M/S RAJ KUMAR JAIN AND SONSHUF vs. C I T AJMER

PDF · subscribers
ITA/157/2012HC RajasthanRJHC02069693201220 September 20177 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court, in disagreement with the Madras High Court's view, held that the benefit under Section 54EC is intended for one transaction and cannot be availed across different financial years for the same capital gain. The Court reasoned that the object of Section 54EC is to encourage investment in government bonds for long-term capital benefits. The insertion of the proviso on April 1, 2007, providing a benefit of ₹50 lakhs per transaction, was considered by the Tribunal to be just and proper in its interpretation. The Court affirmed the Tribunal's view, stating that the basic connotation of the law supports this interpretation. Therefore, the issue was answered in favour of the department and against the assessee. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The appellant, M/s Raj Kumar Jain & Sons (HUF), challenged an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which had allowed the department's appeal, reversing the decision of the CIT(A) and upholding the Assessing Officer's (AO) order. The case concerns the denial of exemption claimed under Section 54EC of the Income Tax Act. The High Court admitted the appeal on January 2, 2014, framing a substantial question of law. The assessee argued that the investment was made within the stipulated six-month period, even if spread across two financial years, and that the proviso to Section 54EC, introduced on April 1, 2007, should not have retrospective effect. The revenue contended that the benefit of Section 54EC is intended for a single transaction and that the proviso, inserted in the same year, does not alter this.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the findings recorded by the learned ITAT while denying the exemption claimed under Section 54EC of the Act are perverse and contrary to the facts on record and also contrary to the correct interpretation of law? Assessee's Contention: The appellant argued that the investment in long-term specified assets was made within the six-month period after the transfer of the original asset, as stipulated by Section 54EC(1). They further contended that the proviso to Section 54EC, which came into effect from April 1, 2007, should not be applied retrospectively and that the benefit of investment, even if spread across two financial years, should be allowed as long as the total investment falls within the permissible limits and is made within the six-month window. The assessee relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in (2015) 370 ITR 0579. Revenue's Contention: The respondent contended that the intention of Section 54EC is to provide a benefit for a single transaction, and the proviso inserted in the same year does not alter this. They argued that the benefit cannot be claimed across different financial years for the same transaction.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 54EC,Section 45,Section 88,Section 80C

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 157 / 2012 M/s Raj Kumar Jain & Sons (HUF) Through Its Karta Shri Raj Kumar Jain S/o Shri Tikam Chand Jain, Aged About 65 Years, Resident of 47, Anand Nagar, Ajmer. ----Appellant Versus The Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building Jaipur Road, Ajmer ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. Mahendra Gargeiya For Respondent(s) : Ms. Parinitoo Jain _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S.JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR VYAS Judgment / Order 20/09/2017 1. By way of this appeal, the appellant has challenged the judgment and order of the Tribunal whereby Tribunal has allowed the appeal of the department reversing the view taken by the CIT(A) and confirmed the order of AO. 2. This Court while admitting the appeal on 02.01.2014, framed following substantial question of law:- “(i)Whether on facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the findings recorded by ld. ITAT while denying the exemption claimed u/S.54EC of the Act, are perverse and contrary to the facts on record and also contrary to the correct interpretation of law ?” 3. Counsel for the appellant taken us to Section 54EC of

(2 of 7) the Income Tax Act which reads as under:- “Capital gain not to be charged on investment in certain bonds. 54EC. (1) Where the capital gain arises from the transfer of a long-term capital asset (the capital asset so transferred being hereafter in this section referred to as the original asset) and the assessee has, at any time within a period of six months after the date of such transfer, invested the whole or any part of capital gains in the long-term specified asset, the capital gain shall be dealt with in accordance with the following provisions of this section, that is to say,— (a) if the cost of the long-term specified asset is not less than the capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset, the whole of such capital gain shall not be charged under section 45; (b) if the cost of the long-term specified asset is less than the capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset, so much of the capital gain as bears to the whole of the capital gain the same proportion as the cost of acquisition of the long- term specified asset bears to the whole of the capital gain, shall not be charged under section 45 : Provided that the investment made on or after the 1st day of April, 2007 in the long-term specified asset by an assessee during any financial year does not exceed fifty lakh rupees : Provided further that the investment made by an assessee in the long-term specified asset, from capital gains arising from transfer of one or more original assets, during the financial year in which the original asset or assets are transferred and in the subsequent financial year does not exceed fifty lakh rupees. (2) Where the long-term specified asset is transferred or converted (otherwise than by transfer) into money at any time within a period of three years from the date of its acquisition, the amount of capital gains arising from the transfer of the original asset not charged under section 45 on the basis of the cost of such long-term specified asset as provided in clause (a) or, as the case may be, clause (b) of sub-section (1) shall be deemed to

(3 of 7) be the income chargeable under the head "Capital gains" relating to long-term capital asset of the previous year in which the long-term specified asset is transferred or converted (otherwise than by transfer) into money. Explanation.—In a case where the original asset is transferred and the assessee invests the whole or any part of the capital gain received or accrued as a result of transfer of the original asset in any long- term specified asset and such assessee takes any loan or advance on the security of such specified asset, he shall be deemed to have converted (otherwise than by transfer) such specified asset into money on the date on which such loan or advance is taken. (3) Where the cost of the long-term specified asset has been taken into account for the purposes of clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1),— (a) a deduction from the amount of income-tax with reference to such cost shall not be allowed under section 88 for any assessment year ending before the 1st day of April, 2006; (b) a deduction from the income with reference to such cost shall not be allowed under section 80C for any assessment year beginning on or after the 1st day of April, 2006. Explanation.—For the purposes of this section,— (a) "cost", in relation to any long-term specified asset, means the amount invested in such specified asset out of capital gains received or accruing as a result of the transfer of the original asset; (b) "long-term specified asset" for making any investment under this section during the period commencing from the 1st day of April, 2006 and ending with the 31st day of March, 2007, means any bond, redeemable after three years and issued on or after the 1st day of April, 2006, but on or before the 31st day of March, 2007,— (i) by the National Highways Authority of India constituted under section 3 of the National Highways Authority of India Act, 1988 (68 of 1988); or (ii) by the Rural Electrification Corporation Limited, a company formed and registered under the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956),

(4 of 7) and notified by the Central Government in the Official Gazette for the purposes of this section with such conditions (including the condition for providing a limit on the amount of investment by an assessee in such bond) as it thinks fit: Provided that where any bond has been notified before the 1st day of April, 2007, subject to the conditions specified in the notification, by the Central Government in the Official Gazette under the provisions of clause (b) as they stood immediately before their amendment by the Finance Act, 2007, such bond shall be deemed to be a bond notified under this clause; (ba) "long-term specified asset" for making any investment under this section on or after the 1st day of April, 2007 means any bond, redeemable after three years and issued on or after the 1st day of April, 2007 by the National Highways Authority of India constituted under section 3 of the National Highways Authority of India Act, 1988 (68 of 1988) or by the Rural Electrification Corporation Limited, a company formed and registered under the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956)71 72[; or any other bond notified by the Central Government in this behalf].” 4. He contended that it was brought w.e.f. 01.04.2007 and cannot have retrospective effect. 5. He has relied upon the decisions mainly on Madras High court decision reported in (2015) 370 ITR 0579. Madras High Court in paras 5, 6 and 7 has observed as under:- “5. The key issue that arises for consideration is whether the first proviso to section 54EC(1) of the Act would restrict the benefit of investment of capital gains in bonds to that financial year during which the property was sold or it applies to any financial year during the six months period.

(5 of 7) 6. For better understanding of the issue, it would be apposite to refer to section 54EC(1) of the Act, which reads as under: "54EC. Capital gain not to be charged on investment in certain bonds.- (1) Where the capital gain arises from the transfer of a long-term capital asset (the capital asset so transferred being hereafter in this section referred to as the original asset) and the assessee has, at any time within a period of six months after the date of such transfer, invested the whole or any part of capital gains in the long-term specified asset, the capital gain shall be dealt with in accordance with the following provisions of this section, that is to say,-- (a) if the cost of the long-term specified asset is not less than the capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset, the whole of such capital gain shall not be charged under section 45; (b) if the cost of the long-term specified asset is less than the capital gain arising from the transfer of the original asset, so much of the capital gain as bears to the whole of the capital gain the same proportion as the cost of acquisition of the long- term specified asset bears to the whole of the capital gain, shall not be charged under section 45: Provided that the investment made on or after the 1st day of April, 2007 in the long-term specified asset by an assessee during any financial year does not exceed fifty lakh rupees." 7. On a plain reading of the above said provision, we are of the view that section 54EC(1) of the Act restricts the time limit for the period of investment after the property has been sold to six months. There is no cap on the investment to be made in bonds. The first proviso to section 54EC(1) of the Act specifies the quantum of investment and it states that the investment so made on or after April 1, 2007, in the long-term specified asset by an assessee during any financial year does not exceed fifty lakhs rupees. In other words, as per the mandate of section 54EC(1) of the Act, the time

(6 of 7) limit for investment is six months and the benefit that flows from the first proviso is that if the assessee makes the investment of Rs. 50,00,000 in any financial year, it would have the benefit of section 54EC(1) of the Act.” 6. Learned counsel contended that he is entitled for the benefit of the investment which has been made in the subsequent date. In view of the fact that word used is ‘whole’ and the two investments which have been made are within six months and the whole capital gain is invested in two different financial years. 7. Counsel for the respondent contended that the intention of the Section 54EC is to give benefit only qua one transaction and proviso which has been inserted in the same year. Therefore, proviso will not effect in any manner and the view followed by the Tribunal is just and proper. 8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. 9. Taking into account the object of Section 54EC is to give benefit to the assessee to invest in the Government bond and where proviso came for the first time on 01.4.2007 providing benefit of 50 lacs each of the transaction of the property the view taken by the Tribunal is just and proper. 10. We are not in agreement with the view taken by the Madras High Court. The benefit is qua one transaction. It cannot have for different financial years. The purpose is to have investment for benefit of long term capital and once there is interpretation put forward by the basic connotation of law, in that view of the matter, we are affirming the view of the Tribunal.

(7 of 7) 11. The issue is answered in favour of the department and against the assessee. 12. The appeal stands dismissed.

(VIJAY KUMAR VYAS)J. (K.S.JHAVERI)J. Chouhan/177

More judgments on Section 54EC

All 515 judgments and leading authorities on Section 54EC →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →