COMMISSIONER OF WEALTH TAX, PATIALA vs. RANINDER SINGH TRUST

PDF · subscribers
WTA/3/2010HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01107798201020 January 2020Author: MR. JUSTICE AJAY TEWARI,MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the appeal. The Court noted that the assessee's counsel stated that the tax effect in the case was below the limits prescribed by Circular No. 3/2018 and Circular dated 5/2019. These circulars clarified that the monetary limits for filing appeals in Income Tax cases would apply to Wealth Tax appeals in a 'mutatis mutandis' manner. The revenue's counsel, however, sought more time for this limited purpose. The Court, considering the previous requests to the CBDT to examine the applicability of such circulars to Wealth Tax matters and the subsequent clarification by the CBDT, dismissed the appeal. The dismissal was with liberty to the revenue to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the circular. The Court's reasoning was based on the principle of litigation management and the CBDT's clarification extending the withdrawal policy to Wealth Tax cases, thereby reducing the burden on the courts.

What were the facts?

This case involves appeals filed by the Commissioner of Wealth-tax, Patiala (the revenue) against the Prince Raninder Singh Trust L/H of Late Maharaja Yadvindra Singh of Patiala (the assessee). The appeals were filed under Section 27-A of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957. The High Court had previously, on 18.05.2016 and 23.08.2016, requested the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) to examine whether a circular dated 10.12.2015, which directed withdrawal of appeals in Income Tax cases with a tax effect up to Rs. 20 lacs, would also apply to Wealth Tax and Gift Tax cases, especially given the minimal tax effect in many such pending appeals. The CBDT subsequently issued Circular No. 3/2018 dated 11.07.2018, read with Circular dated 5/2019 dated 05.02.2019, clarifying that the monetary limits for filing appeals in Income Tax cases would apply to Wealth Tax appeals mutatis mutandis.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the circulars issued by the CBDT regarding withdrawal of appeals based on tax effect, originally applicable to Income Tax Act cases, should be extended to Wealth Tax Act cases. (Question of law) Assessee's contention: The assessee argued that the tax effect in this case is below the limit prescribed by the subsequent circulars (Circular No. 3/2018 dated 11.07.2018 read with Circular dated 5/2019 dated 05.02.2019), which clarified that monetary limits for Income Tax appeals would apply to Wealth Tax appeals. The object of these circulars was to reduce litigation. Revenue's contention: The revenue sought further time to obtain instructions regarding the applicability of the circulars to the present case.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 27-A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH WTA No.3 of 2010 (O&M) Date of decision : 20.01.2020 The Commissioner of Wealth-tax, Patiala ...... Appellant versus Prince Raninder Singh Trust L/H of Late Maharaja Yadvindra Singh of Patiala Patiala ...... Respondent CORAM : HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE AJAY TEWARI HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN * Present : Mr. Jitin Kohli, Junior Standing Counsel for Mr. Kunal Sharma, Senior Standing Counsel for the revenue-appellant. Mr. Akshay Bhan, Senior Advocate with Mr. Alok Mittal, Advocate for the respondent. * AJAY TEWARI, J. (Oral)

On 18.05.2016 the following order was passed in WTA No.3 of 2010 and other connected cases :- “This is a bunch of appeals filed by the Department under Section 27-A of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 (for short, 'the Wealth Act'). In the Circular dated 10.12.2015 issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Central Board of Direct Taxes, directing withdrawal of all appeals filed under the Income Tax Act where the tax effect is upto Rs.20 lacs, there is no mention about cases under the Wealth Tax Act and Gift Tax Act and other direct taxes, where the tax effect is quite meagre. The object for issuance of the circular was to reduce litigation.

Keeping that in mind, the matter is required to be examined by the Board as there are number of appeals pending in this Court and may be in other Courts under the aforesaid Acts. Learned counsel for the appellant seeks time to have instructions. Adjourned to 3.8.2016. A copy of this order be placed on the file of each connected case.”

Thereafter on 23.08.2016 the following order was passed in WTA No.3 of 2010 and other connected cases :- “By an order dated 18.05.2016, the Division Bench has requested the Central Board of Direct Taxes to examine whether the circular dated 10.12.2015 would also apply to the cases especially under the Wealth Tax and Gift Tax Act. There are several cases pending in this Court under the Wealth Tax and Gift Tax Act of very minimal amounts. The Board is, therefore, requested once again to issue clarification preferably by the next date. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant is requested to supply the circular dated 10.12.2015 and the order dated 18.05.2016 once again to the authorities concerned. Adjourned to 21.09.2016. A copy of this order be supplied to the counsel for the appellant under the signatures of the Bench Secretary. A photocopy of this order be placed on the files of other connected cases.”

Today again counsel for the assessee-respondent states that tax effect in this case is below the limit prescribed by circular No.3/2018 dated 11.07.2018 read with circular dated 5/2019 dated 05.02.2019 where it has been clarified as under :- “2. There is no charge under Wealth Tax Act, 1957

w.e.f. 1st April, 2016. Therefore, as a step towards litigation management, it has been decided by the Board that monetary limits for filing of appeals in Income tax cases as prescribed in Para 3 of the Circular shall also apply to Wealth Tax appeals through extension of the Circular to Wealth tax matters in a mutatis mutandis manner and with modifications as prescribed hereunder.......”

However, counsel for the appellant is seeking still more time for this limited purpose.

Appeal stands dismissed with liberty to the revenue-appellant to revive the same in case it is not covered by the circular.

Since the main case has been dismissed, the pending C.M. Application, if any, also stands disposed of. ( AJAY TEWARI ) JUDGE ( AVNEESH JHINGAN ) JUDGE 20.01.2020 pooja sharma-I Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable : Yes/No

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →