BENTLY NEVADA LLC vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION), DELHI -I

PDF · subscribers
ITA/1040/2018HC DelhiDLHC01153126201816 January 2023Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER,HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the Supreme Court's decision in Honda Motor Company Ltd. would not be applicable to the present case. The reasoning was based on the facts ascertained by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, which indicated that the arm's length principle had not been satisfied in this instance. Consequently, the Tribunal found that the decision rendered by the Supreme Court in DIT v. Morgan Stanley & Co. would be applicable. This, the court noted, was likely the reason why the review petition in the related GE Energy Parts Inc. case was dismissed. As a result, the appeals were closed, and pending applications were also disposed of. The operative direction was to close the appeals.

What were the facts?

The appeals were filed by Bentley Nevada LLC (the assessee) against the Commissioner of Income Tax (International Taxation), Delhi-I, for Assessment Years 2002-2003 to 2006-2007. The assessee's counsel conceded that the issues were covered by a coordinate bench judgment in GE Energy Parts Inc. v. CIT. However, the assessee sought to rely on a Supreme Court order in Honda Motor Company Ltd. v. Assistant Director of Income Tax, which held that once the arm's length principle is satisfied, no further profit can be attributed even with a permanent establishment in India. The revenue's counsel did not have complete instructions regarding the factual position. The Tribunal noted that the Supreme Court order in Honda Motor Company Ltd. arose from a judgment concerning LG Electronics Inc., where a Section 148 notice was issued. The Tribunal also noted that the facts ascertained by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in the present case suggested that the arm's length principle had not been satisfied.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Supreme Court's decision in Honda Motor Company Ltd. v. Assistant Director of Income Tax, which states that no further profit can be attributed once the arm's length principle is satisfied, is applicable to the present appeals, notwithstanding the existence of a permanent establishment in India? (Question of law) Assessee's contentions: - The assessee argued that the Supreme Court's decision in Honda Motor Company Ltd. is relevant and should be considered. This decision held that if the arm's length principle is satisfied, no profit can be attributed to a person even if they have a permanent establishment in India. The assessee pointed out that the coordinate bench judgment in GE Energy Parts Inc. had noticed the Supreme Court's judgment in DIT(International Taxation) v. Morgan Stanley & Co. The assessee also noted that a review petition in GE Energy Parts Inc. referring to the Honda Motor Company Ltd. order was dismissed. Revenue's contentions: - The revenue's counsel stated that they did not have complete instructions regarding the factual position. The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue regarding the applicability of the Honda Motor Company Ltd. judgment or any other contention.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~22 to 25 & 9 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 1034/2018 and CM APPL. 39266/2018

ITA 1035/2018 and CM APPL. 39268/2018

ITA 1040/2018 and CM APPL. 39278/2018

ITA 1045/2018 and CM APPL. 39287/2018

ITA 1037/2018 and CM APPL. 39272/2018

BENTLY NEVADA LLC

......Appellant

Through: Mr Sachit Jolly, Advocate.

versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION), DELHI –I

.....Respondent Through: Mr Ruchir Bhatia, Sr. Standing Counsel.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER

HON'BLE MS JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

O R D E R %

16.01.2023 [Physical Hearing/Hybrid Hearing (as per request)] 1. These are appeals filed by the appellant/assessee concerning Assessment Years (AYs) 2002–2003 to 2006–2007. 2. Mr Sachit Jolly, who appears on behalf of the appellant/assessee, does concede, that the issue raised in the instant appeals stands covered by a coordinate bench judgment dated 21.12.2018 rendered in a bunch of appeals, the lead appeal being ITA 621/2017, titled GE Energy Parts Inc. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (International Taxation), Delhi-I. 2.1 Mr Jolly, however, says that there is one aspect of the matter which requires to be considered, which is the order passed by the Supreme Court on 14.03.2018 in Honda Motor Company Ltd., Japan v. Assistant Director of Income Tax, Noida and Ors. (2018) 6 SCC 70. ITA 1034/2018

page 1 of 3 This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/05/2026 at 15:33:50

3.

The order of the Supreme Court reads as follows: “1. Leave granted. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. In the judgment of this Court dated 24.10.2017 in CIT v. E-Funds IT Solution Inc., it has been held that once arm’s length principle has been satisfied, there can be no further profit attributable to a person even if it has a permanent establishment in India. 2. Since the impugned notice for the reassessment is based only on the allegation that the appellant(s) has permanent establishment in India, the notice cannot be sustained once arm’s length price procedure has been followed. Accordingly, the impugned order(s) is set aside and the appeals are allowed. 3. The learned counsel for the Revenue states that he does not have complete instructions. If the Revenue disputes the above factual position, it will be at liberty to move this Court.”

4.

It is Mr Jolly’s contention, that the aforementioned judgment of the coordinate bench of this Court had noticed the judgment of the Supreme Court rendered in DIT(International Taxation) v. Morgan Stanley & Co.

(2007) 292 ITR 416. 4.1 Mr Jolly also does not dispute the fact, that a review petition was filed in GE Energy Parts Inc. in which inter alia a reference was made to the order passed by the Supreme Court in Honda Motor Company Ltd. 4.2 Mr Jolly states that the review petition was dismissed. 5. We are also informed by Mr Jolly, that although a Special Leave Petition was filed concerning the judgment rendered by the coordinate bench in GE Energy Parts Inc., the same was ultimately not carried forward, as assessees in those cases had taken recourse to the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020. ITA 1034/2018

page 2 of 3 This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/05/2026 at 15:33:50

6.

We have heard Mr Jolly as well as Mr Ruchir Bhatia. 7. A perusal of the order/judgment of the Supreme Court rendered in Honda Motor Company Ltd. case is suggestive of the fact, that once arm’s length principle has been satisfied, no profit can be attributed to a person even if the said person has a permanent establishment in India. This judgment, we are told by Mr Jolly, arose out of a judgment of the Allahabad High Court rendered in Principal Officer, LG Electronics Inc. v. Asstt. Director of Income Tax, International Taxation and Others 2014 SCC OnLine ALL 12718: (2014) 68 ITR 401. 7.1 In LG Electronic Inc., concededly, a notice under Section 148 of the Act had been issued. 8. Insofar as this case is concerned, the facts ascertained by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [in short, “Tribunal”] suggest, that the arm’s length principle has not been satisfied. Therefore, according to us, the decision rendered by the Supreme Court in DIT v. Morgan Standing Company Inc. would be applicable, which is also perhaps the reason why the review petition was dismissed. 9. This being the position, these appeals are closed. 10. Consequently, pending applications shall also stand closed.

RAJIV SHAKDHER, J

TARA VITASTA GANJU, J

JANUARY 16, 2023 / tr

Click here to check corrigendum, if any ITA 1034/2018

page 3 of 3 This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/05/2026 at 15:33:50

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →