C I T JAIPUR vs. SMT VARSHA SINGH
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the issue was squarely covered by its own previous decision in D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 25/2009 (CIT, Jaipur-II vs. M/s Manglam Arts) decided on 14.02.2017. In that case, the Court had observed that the word 'production' has a wider meaning than 'manufacture'. The Court noted the detailed process undertaken by the assessee, which included assembling, shaping, punching, fitting, filling, filing, sanding, carving, and polishing wooden items to create artistic and antique articles for export. Citing the Supreme Court's judgment in ITO vs. Arihant Tiles and Marbles (P) Ltd. (2010) 320 ITR 79, which clarified that 'production' is wider in ambit than 'manufacture' and that while every manufacture is production, not every production is manufacture, the High Court found that the assessee's activities constituted 'manufacture or production' under Section 10BA. The Court also referred to its decision in CIT vs. M/s State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur (D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 177/2011) regarding the issue of ESI and PF payments, confirming that disallowance under Section 43B or 36(1)(va) is not applicable if payments are made before the filing of the return under Section 139(1). Therefore, the issue was answered in favour of the assessee. All appeals were dismissed.
What were the facts?
The appellant, Commissioner of Income Tax (now Principal Commissioner), challenged the orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which had dismissed the department's appeals. The ITAT had allowed deductions under Section 10BA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to the respondent assessee, Smt. Varsha Singh, for assessment years not explicitly stated but implied by the appeal numbers and dates. The core dispute revolved around whether the assessee fulfilled the mandatory conditions for claiming deduction under Section 10BA, specifically concerning the 'eligible article or thing' and the nature of the activities undertaken by the assessee. The amounts in dispute for the three appeals were Rs. 77,59,185/-, Rs. 74,10,291/-, and Rs. 1,82,27,594/-.
What were the issues?
The High Court had to decide the following substantial questions of law: 1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs. 77,59,185/- when the assessee did not fulfill the mandatory conditions of an 'eligible article or thing' as prescribed in Section 10BA? 2. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs. 74,10,291/- when the assessee did not fulfill the mandatory conditions of an 'eligible article or thing' as prescribed in Section 10BA? 3. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs. 1,82,27,594/- when the assessee did not fulfill the mandatory conditions of an 'eligible article or thing' as prescribed in Section 10BA? The Revenue's contention was that the assessee did not meet the mandatory conditions for the deduction under Section 10BA, arguing that the term 'manufacturing or process' should be construed strictly, drawing parallels with Section 80I and citing the Supreme Court's decision in CIT vs. Gem India Manufacturing Co. (2001) 249 ITR 307. The Assessee, through their counsel, highlighted the detailed process undertaken by them, which involved assembling, shaping, punching, fitting, filling, filing, sanding, carving, and polishing wooden items to give them artistic and antique value for export. They relied on the Supreme Court's observations in ITO vs. Arihant Tiles and Marbles (P) Ltd. (2010) 320 ITR 79, which emphasized the wider meaning of 'production' compared to 'manufacture'.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 10BA,Section 80I,Section 80IA,Section 43B,Section 36(1)(va),Section 139(1)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 56 / 2011 Commissioner of Income Tax-I, New Central Revenue Building, Statue Circle, Jaipur (Raj.) ----Appellant Versus Smt.Varsha Singh, Thaltara, Sirsi Road, Khatipura, Jaipur ----Respondent Connected With D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 219 / 2012 Commissioner of Income Tax-I, New Central Revenue Building, Statue Circle, Jaipur (Raj.) ----Appellant Versus Smt.Varsha Singh, Thaltara, Sirsi Road, Khatipura, Jaipur ----Respondent/Assessee D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 181 / 2015 Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-I, New Central Revenue Building, Statue Circle, Jaipur (Raj.) ----Appellant Versus Smt.Varsha Singh, Thaltara, Sirsi Road, Khatipura, Jaipur ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. Anuroop Singhi with Mr. Aditya Vijay For Respondent(s) : Mr. Sandeep Taneja _____________________________________________________
(2 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH Judgment 22/08/2017 1. By way of these appeals, the appellant has challenged the judgment and order of the tribunal whereby the tribunal has dismissed the appeal of the department. 2. This court while admitted the matter has framed following substantial questions of law:- D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.56/2011 admitted on 04.05.2011 “Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the learned Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs.77,59,185/- even when the assessee does not fulfil the mandatory conditions of eligible article or thing as prescribed in Section 10BA?” D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.219/2012 admitted on 31.07.2012 “Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs.74,10,291/- even when the assessee does not fulfill the mandatory conditions of ‘eligible article or thing as prescribed in Section 10BA?” D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.181/2015 admitted on 19.09.2016 “Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in allowing the assessee deduction under Section 10BA of Rs.1,82,27,594/- even when the assessee does not fulfill the mandatory conditions of ‘eligible
(3 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
article or thing as prescribed in Section 10BA?” 3. The issue is now squarely covered by the decision of this Court in D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.25/2009 (Commissioner of Income Tax, Jaipur-II, Jaipur Vs. M/s Manglam Arts, Govind Nagar, Amber Palace Road, Jaipur) decided on 14.02.2017 and other connected matters whereby this court has observed as under:- 4. He has contended that the word which has been used in the section ‘manufacturing or process’ is to be construed very strictly and since it is an exemption, it should be equated with the provisions of Section 80I which has been interpreted by the Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Income-Tax Vs. Gem India Manufacturing Co.- (2001) 249 ITR 307, wherein it has been held as under: 4. The Tribunal took the view that it did because in "common parlance and commercial sense raw diamonds are not the same thing as polished and cut diamonds. The two are different entities in the commercial world. Though the chemical composition remains the same the physical characteristics of shape and class, etc., are substantially different". It would appear that no material had been placed on the record before the Tribunal upon which it could have reached the conclusions that, either in common or in commercial parlance, raw diamonds were not the same thing as polished and cut diamonds, and that they were different entities in the commercial world. An ipse dixit of the Tribunal is not the best foundation for a decision. “5. The High Court, as aforestated, concluded that the case was covered by its decision in the case of CIT v. London Star Diamond
Co.
(I.)
Ltd.: [1995]213ITR517(Bom) . It was not pointed out to the High Court that the question in that case was whether the assessee was an industrial company within the meaning of Section 2(8) of the Finance
(4 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
Act, 1975, and that, in answering that question, the High Court had held that raw diamonds and cut and polished diamonds were different and distinct marketable commodities having different uses; therefore, a company engaged in cutting and polishing raw diamonds for the purpose of export was engaged in the "processing of goods" to convert them into marketable form. The question that the High Court and we are here concerned with is whether, in cutting and polishing diamonds, the assessee manufactures or produces articles or things. 6. There can be little difficulty in holding that the raw and uncut diamond is subjected to a process of cutting and polishing which yields the polished diamond, but that is not to say that the polished diamond is a new article or thing which is the result of manufacture or production. There is no material on the record upon which such a conclusion can be reached. 7. The appeal is, therefore, allowed. The order under challenge is sot aside. The question quoted above is answered in the negative and in favour of the Revenue. The assessee shall pay to the Revenue the costs of the appeal.” 5. He has contended that the view taken by the Tribunal is required to be reversed in view of the observations made by the Supreme Court. 6. Mr. Jhanwar, counsel for the respondent has taken us to the judgment of the Tribunal and contended that while considering the process which has been undertaken by the assessee, the Tribunal has observed as under: “The various activities carried out by the appellant, are as under:- (i) Firstly, the appellant purchases wood, semi finished material which requires further wood and other work of beautification and of artistic value. There apart, the other raw material, the wooden out of which is the main, and others i.e. grass, nails etc. are purchased. (ii) Thereafter various other items are added depending upon the designs, size, quality of the subjected item to be
(5 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
exported, (iii) After purchasing the semi finished goods and raw material, as stated above, the very first step is to assemble the same, if so required. Some time the semi finished furniture is required to be given further shape as per the desired exportable designs. (iv) Thereafter, punching is done by hammering nails by hand. It is pure labour work which can be done by experts only. It may be noted that the nails are of special type having artistic and antique look. (v) Fitting of brass and iron items again with a view to give artistic and antique look. (vi) Filling and filing with a view to smoothen the surface. (vii) Sanding (viii) Carving with a view to bring the artistic value and to show that these are antique items. (ix) And lastly polishing (x) Thereafter, various wooden items are fitted according to the need and design of the exportable wooden article, i.e. wooden moulding is fitted Inlay is done.” 7. He contended that taking into consideration the observations made by the Supreme Court in the case of Income Tax Officer, Udaipur Vs. Arihant Tiles and Marbles (P) Ltd.- (2010) 320 ITR 79 (SC), the Supreme Court has observed as under: “16. In the case of Aman Marble Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Collector of Central
Excise
reported
in MANU/SC/0858/2003 : 157 ELT 393(SC), the question that arose for consideration was whether cutting of marble blocks into marble slabs amounted to manufacture for the purposes of Central Excise Act. At the outset, we may point out that in the present case, we are not only concerned
with
the
word "manufacture", but we are also concerned with the connotation of the word "production" in Section 80IA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which, as stated herein-above, has a wider meaning as compared to the word
(6 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
"manufacture". Further, when one refers to the word "production", it means manufacture plus something in addition thereto. The word "production" was not under consideration before this Court in the case of Aman Marble Industries Pvt. Ltd. (supra). Be that as it may, in that case, it was held that "cutting" of marble blocks into slabs per se did not amount to "manufacture". This conclusion was based on the observations made by this Court in the case of Rajasthan State Electricity Board (supra). In our view, the judgment of this Court in Aman Marble Industries Pvt. Ltd. (supra) also has no application to the facts of the present case. One of the most important reasons for saying so is that in all such cases, particularly under the Excise law, the Court has to go by the facts of each case. In each case one has to examine the nature of the activity undertaken by an assessee. Mere extraction of stones may not constitute manufacture. Similarly, after extraction, if marble blocks are cut into slabs per se will not amount to the activity of manufacture. 17. In the present case, we have extracted in detail the process undertaken by each of the respondents before us. In the present case, we are not concerned only with cutting of marble blocks into slabs. In the present case we are also concerned with the activity of polishing and ultimate conversion of blocks into polished slabs and tiles. What we find from the process indicated herein-above is that there are various stages through which the blocks have to go through before they become polished slabs and tiles. In the circumstances, we are of the view that on (ITA-25/2009] the facts of the cases in hand, there is certainly an activity which will come in the category of "manufacture" or "production" under Section 80IA of the Income Tax Act. As stated herein- above, the judgment of this Court in Aman Marble Industries Pvt. Ltd. was not required to construe the word "production" in addition to the
(7 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
word "manufacture". One has to examine the scheme of the Act also while deciding the question as to whether the activity constitutes manufacture or production. Therefore, looking to the nature of the activity stepwise, we are of the view that the subject activity certainly constitutes "manufacture or production" in terms of Section 80IA. In this connection, our view is also fortified by the following judgments of this Court which have been fairly pointed out to us by learned Counsel appearing for the Department. 18. In the case of Commissioner of Income Tax v. Sesa Goa Ltd. reported in MANU/SC/1123/2004 : 271 ITR 331 (SC), the meaning of the word "production" came up for consideration. The question which came before this Court was whether the ITAT was justified in holding that the assessee was entitled to deduction under Section 32A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, in respect of machinery used in mining activity ignoring the fact that the assessee was engaged in extraction and processing of iron ore, not amounting to manufacture or production of any article or thing. The High Court in that case, while dismissing the appeal preferred by the Revenue, held that extraction and processing of iron ore did not amount to "manufacture". However, it came to the conclusion that extraction of iron ore and the various processes would involve "production" within the meaning of Section 32A(2) (b)(iii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and consequently, the assessee was entitled to the benefit of investment allowance under Section 32A of the Income Tax Act. In that matter, it was argued on behalf of the Revenue that extraction and processing of iron ore did not produce any new product whereas it was argued on behalf of the assessee that it did produce a distinct new product. The view expressed by the High Court that the activity in question constituted "production" has been affirmed by this Court in Sesa Goa's
(8 of 8) [ITA-56/2011]
case saying that the High Court's opinion was unimpeachable. It was held by this Court that the word "production" is wider in ambit and it has a wider connotation
than
the
word "manufacture". It was held that while every manufacture can constitute production, every production did not amount to manufacture.” 8. He has contended that the word ‘production’ is to be construed as a wider meaning than ‘manufacture’ and in view of the observations made by the Supreme Court, the view taken by the Tribunal is just and proper. 9. Mr. Mathur has also contended that regarding second issue with regard to ESI and PF, however, the same is covered by the decision of this Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. M/s State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur-
D.B.
Income
Tax
Appeal No.177/2011 decided on 06.01.2014 wherein it has been held as under: “Thus, we are of the view that where the PF and/or EPF, CPF, GPF etc., if paid after the due date under respective Act but before filing of the return of income under Section 139(1), cannot be disallowed under Section 43B or under Section 36(1)(va) of the IT Act.” 4. In that view of the matter, the issue is answered in favour of the assessee and against the department.” 5. All the appeals stand dismissed. (INDERJEET SINGH),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J. Jyoti Item No.70-72
More judgments on Section 10BA
- Bhagwan Precision, Rohtak vs Asstt. Commissioner of Income Tax, RohtakITA 5174/DEL/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Aug 2025AY 2017-18
- The Chandarlapdu Large Size Cooperative… vs Income Tax Officer, Ward 1(3), VijayawadaITA 11/VIZ/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Jun 2025AY 2017-18
- Kuntamukkala Premary Agriculture… vs Income Tax Officer, Ward 1(3), VijayawadaITA 247/VIZ/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed10 Jun 2025AY 2017-18
- Indian Institute of Management Sirmaur… vs The CIT(Exemptions), ChandigarhITA 1122/CHANDI/2024[2024-2025]Status: Disposed1 May 2025AY 2024-2025
- Eramalloor Service Co-Perative Bank Ltds… vs ITO, Ward-1, AlappuzhaITA 820/COCH/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed27 Mar 2025AY 2017-18
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S. Ashok Panda, Dhenkanal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax , CT And GST Circle, DhenkanalOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahadev Malik vs. Additional Commissioner, BhubaneswarOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Dillip Kumar Sethy vs. The Deputy Commissioner, CGST And Central ExciseOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- K Pushkara Rao vs. The State Of ApAndhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026
- M/S. Jayasundar Engg Works vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Andhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026