THE COMMISSIONER OF IT, KARNAL vs. M/S ZHILMIL DHABA, GT ROAD, KARNAL
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the ITAT's reasoning was unexceptionable. The mere fact that the partnership deed was not kept with a partner but with the firm's accountant, with the consent of all partners, does not render the assessee an individual rather than a firm. The High Court found that the partnership was evidenced by an instrument in writing. Therefore, the Assessing Officer was not justified in concluding that the firm was not genuine. The High Court concluded that no substantial question of law arose for consideration, and the appeal was dismissed. The ITAT had previously directed that the assessee be assessed as a firm and allowed deductions for salary and interest paid to partners.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s Zhilmil Dhaba, filed its return of income for the assessment year 2000-2001 in the status of a firm, enclosing a certified copy of its partnership deed. The Assessing Officer (AO) noted a violation of Clause 7 of the partnership deed, which stipulated that books of account should be kept on the business premises and not removed without consent. The AO found the books with the firm's accountant, Rajesh Sharma, and therefore assessed the assessee as an Association of Persons (AOP). The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] confirmed the AO's order, holding that the assessee failed to fulfill conditions under Section 184(1) and (2) of the Income Tax Act by not filing a duly certified copy of the partnership deed with the return. The assessee appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT).
What were the issues?
1. Whether the ITAT's order is contrary to Section 184(5) and Section 144 of the Income Tax Act, given the assessee's failure to produce books of account in response to a notice under Section 142(1), leading to assessment under Section 144. - Revenue's contention: The assessee failed to produce books of account as required, thus violating Section 184(5) and necessitating assessment under Section 144. 2. Whether the ITAT was correct in holding that conditions for assessing the firm under Section 184 could be rectified, particularly when Section 185 states that failure to comply with Section 184 conditions results in no deduction for partner salary and interest. - Revenue's contention: The conditions of Section 184 were not met, and Section 185 mandates that no deductions for salary and interest to partners should be allowed. Assessee's contention: The ITAT, in an earlier order concerning similar facts, held that books of account being with the accountant, with the consent of all partners, does not invalidate the firm's existence or its compliance with the partnership deed. The ITAT found the partnership to be evidenced by a written instrument and the AO was not justified in concluding the firm was not genuine.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 184,Section 184(1),Section 184(2),Section 184(5),Section 185,Section 142(1),Section 144,Section 133-A
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH I.T.A. No.6 OF 2006 DATE OF DECISION: October 10,2006 The Commissioner of Income-tax, Karnal
.....Appellant VERSUS M/s Zhilmil Dhaba, G.T.Road, Karnal. ....Respondent CORAM:- HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE J.S.NARANG HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE RANJIT SINGH
PRESENT: Mr. Yogesh Putney, Advocate, for the appellant. ****** RANJIT SINGH, J. This Income-tax appeal has been filed, seeking reference of following substantial questions of law:- “1. Whether the order of the Hon'ble ITAT is contrary to the spirit of Section 184 (5) of the Income Tax Act as the abovesaid assessee failed to produce the books of accounts in response to notice dated 18.6.02 issued under Section 142 (1) of the Act, which resulted in a failure in term of the provisions of Section 144 of the Act? 2. Whether the Hon'ble ITAT was right in law in holding that the conditions specified in Section 184 of the I.T. Act for assessing the firm as such can be rectified, particularly when it is given in Section 185 that if the conditions given in Section 184 are not complied then
I.T.A. No.6 of 2006 :{ 2 }: the firm shall be assessed such as no deduction on account salary and interest to partners shall be allowed?” The assessee in this case is aggrieved against his assessment done in the status of a AOP though the return of income was filed in the status of a firm. The appellant concern is a Dhaba at G.T.Road, Karnal. During a survey of the firm held under Section 133-A of the Income Tax Act (hereinafter referred to as `the Act'), some loose papers and documents were found and on consideration thereof, the assessee offered total income of Rs.7 lacs relating to financial year 1999-2000. During the annual year return 2000-2001, assessee declared an income of Rs.1,96,746/-. While doing so, the concern enclosed a certified copy of the partnership deed, claiming that it should be assessed in the status of a partnership. Assessing Officer, made reference to Clause 7 of the partnership deed which required the firm to keep usual customary books of account in the language and script acceptable to all the partners and that such books of account were not to be removed from the business premises without the consent of the parties. It was found that the said books of account of the firm were lying with one Rajesh Sharma, Accountant of the assessee firm. Finding this to be a violation of Clause 7 of the partnership deed, the Assessing Officer held that the assessee should be taken as AOP. This order was taken in appeal before C.I.T. (A), wherein it was held that the assessee firm did not fulfill the conditions prescribed in Section 184 (1) and (2) of the Act to become eligible for being assessed in the status of a firm. It was further found that the plea of assessee that the original partnership
I.T.A. No.6 of 2006 :{ 3 }: deed had been filed during the course of assessment proceedings, would not make up the deficiency of not filling the copy of the partnership deed duly certified by all the partners alongwith the return of income as prescribed in the Act. Accordingly, dis-allowance of the interest and salary paid to the partners made by the Assessing Officer was confirmed. Aggrieved against this order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Income Tax Tribunal, Delhi (for short, “ITAT”). ITAT referred to an earlier order passed by CIT (A), wherein it has been held that mere fact that the books of account were not available with the assessee at the time of survey in the business premises, it cannot follow that the firm is not a genuine or that it did not exist in conformity with the terms and conditions of the partnership deed. It was also found that partnership is an agreement between the parties and they would be at liberty to have books of account with the Accountant of the firm by consent of all the partners. Noticing that the partnership having been evidenced by an instrument in writing, the Assessing Officer was not justified in concluding that the firm was not genuine on the grounds as stated in the order of assessment. Accordingly, ITAT found that the order of C.I.T. (A) in the earlier case did not call for any interference and the same was confirmed. Taking notice of the position that the C.I.T. (A) had passed a different order in the same set of facts and circumstances, ITAT held that the reasons as afore-mentioned would equally apply to the present case also. Accordingly, ITAT held that status of the assessee is directed to be adopted as that of a firm and the salary and interest paid to the partners is directed to be allowed as deductions. The appeal as such
I.T.A. No.6 of 2006 :{ 4 }: was allowed. The reasons recorded by ITAT are unexceptionable. Merely because the partnership deed was not kept with one of the partners and was with the Accountant of the assessee firm would not make the assessee to be an individual and not a firm. In our considered opinion, no question of law would arise in the case, which would call for interference in the instant appeal. The same is accordingly dismissed. ( RANJIT SINGH ) JUDGE
November 10, 2006 ( J. S. NARANG ) khurmi JUDGE
More judgments on Section 184
- Sree Lakshmi Financiers, Virudhunagar vs ITO, Ward-3, VirudhunagarITA 2737/CHNY/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed4 Aug 2026AY 2017-18
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Chennai vs Olympia Tech Park (Chennai) Private…ITA 3084/CHNY/2025[2015-16]Status: Disposed3 Mar 2026AY 2015-16
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Chennai vs Olympia Tech Park (Chennai) Private…ITA 3081/CHNY/2025[2014-15]Status: Disposed3 Mar 2026AY 2014-15
- Trimurti Steels, Bhubaneswar vs Income Tax Officer, Ward 2(1), BhubaneswarITA 625/CTK/2025[2012-13]Status: Heard19 Feb 2026AY 2012-13
- Vikrant, Shamli vs Income Tax Officer, Ward-3(1)(4), ShamliITA 5129/DEL/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed17 Dec 2025AY 2017-18
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Abdul Majid vs. The Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 5 Nov 2026
- Dipankar Borgohain vs. The Union Of INDIA And 7 OrsGauhati · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Jack And Jill vs. The Union Of INDIA And OrsGauhati · 5 Nov 2026
- Ms Akher Ali vs. The Union Of INDIAGauhati · 5 Nov 2026
- Paonta Hp Centre vs. State Of Hp And OthersHimachal Pradesh · 5 Nov 2026