PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHI - 10 vs. M/S. RADIUS INDUSTRIES

PDF · subscribers
ITA/80/2022HC DelhiDLHC01000046201923 January 2025Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR6 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeal fails to raise any substantial question of law and is consequently dismissed. Regarding the addition of Rs. 8,22,70,000/- for unsecured loans, the Tribunal had found that the assessee had fully substantiated the loans with documentary evidence, including audited financial statements, acknowledgments of returns, lender confirmations, and bank statements. The Tribunal noted that the lenders were corporate entities assessed to tax, and the loans were advanced through banking channels, a fact confirmed by the lenders. The Tribunal concluded that the AO had not led sufficient material to suggest the amounts originated from the assessee's own funds and that the AO's inquiry was lacking. The High Court found no perversity in the Tribunal's findings, acknowledging the Tribunal as the final arbiter of facts. For the addition of Rs. 18,00,000/- on account of remuneration, the Tribunal found it was authorized by the partnership deed and consistent with past practice, deleting the addition. For the addition of Rs. 7,69,097/- on account of TDS, the Tribunal deleted the addition, holding that the assessee was not liable to deduct TDS on interest payments on borrowed loans and that the payees had paid taxes. The High Court did not decide on the merits of these issues but found that the appellant failed to establish perversity in the Tribunal's factual findings.

What were the facts?

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) appealed the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's (ITAT) order dated September 17, 2019. The ITAT had deleted additions made by the Assessing Officer (AO) concerning unsecured loans, disallowance of remuneration, and TDS. The AO had made additions totaling Rs. 8,22,70,000/- for unsecured loans, Rs. 18,00,000/- for remuneration, and Rs. 7,69,097/- for TDS. The ITAT, in its order, found that the assessee had substantiated the unsecured loans with documentary evidence, including audited financial statements and confirmations from lenders. It also noted that the lenders were corporate entities assessed to tax and had advanced loans through banking channels. Regarding remuneration, the ITAT found it was authorized by the partnership deed and consistent with past practice. For TDS, the ITAT held that the assessee was not liable to deduct TDS on interest payments on borrowed loans, and in any case, the payees had paid taxes. The High Court noted that the ITAT was the final arbiter of facts and that the appellant had failed to establish perversity in the ITAT's findings.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal erred in deleting the additions of Rs. 8,22,70,000/- made by the AO, ignoring that the evidence collected showed the respondent failed to prove the genuineness and creditworthiness of parties from whom advance loans were taken (under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961)? - Assessee's contention: The ITAT found that the unsecured loans were fully substantiated by documentary evidence, including audited financial statements, acknowledgments of returns, lender confirmations, and bank statements. The AO failed to lead material to suggest the amounts emanated from the assessee's coffers. The lenders were corporate entities assessed to tax, and loans were made through banking channels, which was confirmed by the lenders. The AO lacked sufficient inquiry. - Revenue's contention: The AO collected evidence showing the respondent failed to prove the genuineness and creditworthiness of the advance loan parties. Notices under Section 133(6) were issued, some returned unserved, and only two parties confirmed transactions but refused to accept they provided unsecured loans. 2. Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal erred by deleting the addition of Rs. 18,00,000/- on account of disallowance of remuneration, contrary to Section 40(b)(ii) of the Act, relying on the judgment in 'Sood Brij & Associates vs CIT'? - Assessee's contention: Remuneration to working partners was authorized by the partnership deed (clauses 7 and 8) and decided mutually from time to time. This disallowance lacked consistency as no such disallowance was made in preceding years. - Revenue's contention: The addition was made because the partnership deed did not specify the amount of remuneration payable to partners, making it not allowable under Section 40(b)(v) of the Act. The expenditure could not be allowed unless the deed specified the amount or the manner of quantifying it. 3. Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal erred by deleting the addition of Rs. 7,69,097/- on account of TDS, in accordance with Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act, which was also confirmed by the CIT(A)? - Assessee's contention: The assessee was not liable to deduct TDS on interest payments on borrowed loans, and the second proviso to Section 40(a)(ia) read with Section 194A was inapplicable. In any case, since the payee had paid taxes, no disallowance was warranted.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 68,Section 40(b)(ii),Section 40(a)(ia),Section 133(6),Section 194A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

ITA 80/2022 Page 1 of 6

$~27 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 80/2022 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHI – 10

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Shlok Chandra, SSC, Ms. Naincy Jain & Ms. Madhavi Shukla, JSCs.

versus

M/S. RADIUS INDUSTRIES

.....Respondent Through: Mr. Gautam Jain and Mr. Manish Yadav, Advs.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR

O R D E R %

23.01.2025

1.

The Commissioner seeks to impugn the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“Tribunal”] dated 17 September 2019 and posits the following questions of law for our consideration: “i) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, in deleting the additions of Rs 8,22,70,000/- made by the Ld. AO by ignoring the fact that the evidence collected by the Ld. AO during the course of assessment proceeding clearly shows that the Respondent failed to prove the genuineness of the transactions and creditworthiness of the advance loan taken from the parties? ii) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by not considering the fact that the notices under Section 133(6) of the Act were issued to the parties from whom unsecured loan was taken by the Respondent, however, some of the notices were returned as unserved. Only two parties confirmed the transactions made with the Respondent but refused to accept that the unsecured loan provided by them to the Respondent? iii) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by deleting the addition made by the Ld. AO amounting Rs. 18,00,000/- on This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

ITA 80/2022 Page 2 of 6

account of disallowance of remuneration which was in accordance under Section 40(b) (ii) of the Act, in view of the fact that the said addition was made by relying upon the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case "Sood Brij & Associates vs CIT"? iv) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by deleting the addition made by Ld. AO amounting Rs. 7,69,097/- on account of TDS which was in accordance with provision of Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act and was also confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A)?” 2. We had on a previous occasion and more particularly on 15 March 2024, after hearing learned counsels for respective sides at some length, passed the following order:- “1. The instant appeal has been filed against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“ITAT”] dated 17 September 2019 on the following questions of law: “i) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, in deleting the additions of Rs 8,22,70,000/- made by the Ld. AO by ignoring the fact that the evidence collected by the Ld. AO during the course of assessment proceeding clearly shows that the Respondent failed to prove the genuineness of the transactions and creditworthiness of the advance loan taken from the parties? ii) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by not considering the fact that the notices under Section 133(6) of the Act were issued to the parties from whom unsecured loan was taken by the Respondent, however, some of the notices were returned as unserved. Only two parties confirmed the transactions made with the Respondent but refused to accept that the unsecured loan provided by them to the Respondent? iii) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by deleting the addition made by the Ld. AO amounting Rs. 18,00,000/- on account of disallowance of remuneration which was in accordance under Section 40(b) (ii) of the Act, in view of the fact that the said addition was made by relying upon the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case "Sood Brij & Associates vs CIT"? iv) Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal has erred on facts and circumstances of the case and prevailing laws, by deleting the addition made by Ld. AO amounting Rs. 7,69,097/- on This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

ITA 80/2022 Page 3 of 6

account of TDS which was in accordance with provision of Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act and was also confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A)?”

2.

Having heard Mr. Chandra, learned counsel appearing for the appellant, we take note of the following particulars in respect of alleged lenders which had come to be captured by the Assessing Officer [“AO”]:

S. No. Name of the lender Returned Income Confirmatio n provided Amount of loan financed Response to notice u/s 133(6) 1 Jiya Bindra No return filed Yes 2,89,20,000 No reply 2 Amrik Singh Chawla 80,82,860 Yes 1,45,00,000 No reply 3 M.S. Bindra (HUF) 31,83,160 Yes 1,55,00,000 No reply 4 Preetinder Kaur Bindra 39,30,430 Yes 1,41,00,000 No reply 5 G.S.T. Corporation Ltd. -2,90,33,609 Yes 30,00,000 No loan provided 6 Multi Bond Trading Corporation No return filed Yes 27,50,000 Unserved 7 JBL Intervention Associates No return filed Yes 30,00,000 No reply 8 Prem Dua No return filed Yes 5,00,000 Unserved

Total

8,22,70,000

3.

Mr. Chandra sought to lay emphasis on the fact that of the aforenoted applicants, at least four were non-filers and consequently there was no means to verify the assertion made by the assessee. 4. However, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“ITAT”] while dealing with the aforesaid has observed as follows: “5. We have heard both the parties and perused the records, especially the impugned order; Synopsis; Paper Book filed by the Assessee‟s counsel and case law relied by both the parties. As regards sustaining of addition of Rs.62,50,000/- on account of sums received as unsecured loan is concerned, we find that the AO has made sum of Rs.8,22,70,000/- on account of sum received from 08 parties as mentioned in the assessment order at page no. 3 and in appeal ld. CIT(A) has partially deleted the addition and sustained the addition of Rs. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

ITA 80/2022 Page 4 of 6

62,50,000/-. We note that the unsecured loan received by the assessee has been fully substantiated not by substantial documentary evidence including copy of audited financial statement, acknowledgement of return of income, confirmation from lender, bank statement of lender, therefore such sum could not in law or fact be held to be unexplained cash credit u/s. 68 of the Act. It is noted that no material has been led by the AO to even allege that such amount representing unsecured loan are emanating from the coffers of the assessee company. It is further noted that the lenders are corporate entities duly assessed to tax and, have made unsecured loans through banking channels, which fact has neither been denied and, nor rebutted in the assessment order, which is also duly confirmed by each of the lender. In view of above, we are of the considered view that assessee has furnished complete details and evidences to discharge the burden in respect of unsecured loan reflecting in the financial statement of the assessee company. This view is supported by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India decision in the case of Earthmetal Electrical (P) Ltd. in Civil Appeal No. 618 of 2010 dated 30.07.2010 wherein the assessee‟s SLP was allowed by holding that if the share application money is received by the assessee company from alleged bogus shareholders, whose names are given to the AO, then the department is free to proceed to reopen their individual assessment in accordance with law, but it cannot be regarded as undisclosed income of the assessee company. Further in the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Orissa Cement Corporation vs. CIT reported in 159 ITR 78 it has been held that it is for the department to pursue a creditor particularly once the assessee had duly furnished the complete particulars of the person from whom monies have been received by the assessee. In absence o such a burden having been discharged, the AO could not have mechanically proceeded to make impugned addition in the instant case. It is a settled law that non-compliance of notice issued u/s. 133(6) of the Act of all the entities giving unsecured loan cannot be a basis to make the addition u/s. 68 of the Act. The nature of income and source of income can be examined only by the AO of the lenders and not by the AO of the assessee. In this case there is lack of inquiry by the AO to rebut the burden discharged by the assessee as no enquiries were made either from corporation entity providing unsecured loan or enquiry from AO of such corporate entity or its banker or Registrar of Companies by issuing notice u/s. 131 of the Act. We further note that the judicial decisions relied upon by the Ld. DR have been duly considered. In our considered view, we do not find any parity in the facts of the decisions relied upon with the peculiar facts of the case in This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

ITA 80/2022 Page 5 of 6

hand. In view of above, we delete the addition of Rs.62,50,000/- on account of sums received as unsecured loan and erroneously held as unexplained cash credit under Section 68 of the Act, which was confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A) and accordingly, we allow the ground no. 1 to 1.1 raised by the assessee. 5.1 Apropos ground no.2 to 2.2 relating to confirmation of addition of Rs. 18,00,000/- on account of alleged excess remuneration paid to the partners and disallowed by invoking clause (v) of section 40(b) of the Act is concerned, we find that this amount was disallowed by holding that, the partnership deed does not specify the amount of the remuneration payable to the partners and as such, the same is not allowable in view of the section 40(b)(v) of the Act. The AO was of the view that the expenditure incurred cannot be allowed as deduction unless the partnership deed either specifies the amount of remuneration payable to each individual working partner or lays down the manner of quantifying such remuneration and similarly, Ld. CIT(A) in appeal has sustained this disallowance. We note that in the instant case, remuneration to the working partners are duly authorized by the partnership deed dated 1.4.2013 (page 1-12 of the Paper Book) and such payment has been made as per clause 7 and 8 of the deed of partnership, „working partners‟ and the amount of remuneration payable and the manner of quantifying such remuneration is to be decided mutually between them from time to time. We further note that this disallowance is contrary to the principle of consistency as no disallowance made in the preceding years i.e. from assessment year 2010-11 to 2014-15 and only from the instant assessment year i.e. AY 2015-16 the addition was made which action is not tenable. This view is fortified by the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in the case of CIT vs Excel Industries Ltd. 358 ITR 295 (SC). Respectfully, following the aforesaid precedent, the addition confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A) is hereby deleted and accordingly, the ground no. 2 to 2.2 raised by the assessee are allowed. 5.2 Apropos ground no.3 to 3.2 relating to confirmation of addition of Rs. 7,69,097/- by invoking Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act is concerned, we note that since assessee is not liable to deduct TDS on in interest payment on borrowed loan and the second proviso to Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act read with Section 194A of the Act were inapplicable and as such, disallowance so made is not in accordance with law. In any case since the payee had paid the taxes on the interest paid by the assessee, no disallowance was warranted in view of second proviso to section 40(a)(ia) of the Act. Accordingly, the addition confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A) is hereby deleted This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

ITA 80/2022 Page 6 of 6

and accordingly, the ground no.3 to 3.2 raised by the assessee are allowed. Accordingly, the appeal filed by the Assessee is allowed.” 5. We however could not proceed further today since Mr. Gautam Jain, learned counsel for the respondent, was unavailable. 6. Consequently, let the appeal be called again on 22.05.2024.”

3.

As we take up the appeal for review today, we find that the Tribunal had categorically found that the twin test of credit worthiness and genuineness of the investing entities had been duly established and the onus discharged by the respondent-assessee. This becomes apparent from a reading of the conclusions which appear in Para 5 and 5.1 of the order of the Tribunal and which have been extracted hereinabove. 4. The appellants have woefully failed to establish that those findings and conclusions suffer from any perversity or that the Tribunal could not have justifiably come to record a finding in favour of the respondent-assessee based on the material which existed on the record. We also bear in mind the indubitable fact of the Tribunal being the final arbiter of facts. 5. In our considered opinion, the appeal fails to raise any substantial question of law. It shall consequently stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J.

HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J. JANUARY 23, 2025/nd

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2025 at 12:02:58

More judgments on Section 68

All 29,931 judgments and leading authorities on Section 68 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →