PR. CIT-9 NEW DELHI vs. M/S. VNG PACKAGING PVT LTD

PDF · subscribers
ITA/693/2019HC DelhiDLHC01031089201926 July 2019Bench: HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TALWANT SINGH4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the interpretation placed by the ITAT on Section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, its reasoning, and conclusions in the impugned order were consistent with the legal position and did not suffer from any legal infirmity. The ITAT had correctly identified that the Assessee had received investments in the form of equity shares of various companies in lieu of allotment of its own shares, which constituted an exchange rather than a receipt of money. The ITAT reasoned that for Section 68 to apply, the credit appearing in the books of account must be with reference to any sum received by the assessee. If no sum in terms of money (cash or cheque) was received, the deeming provisions of Section 68 would not apply. The ITAT also found that the AO had conducted a detailed inquiry, and the identities and genuineness of the transaction were established. Therefore, the ITAT was justified in setting aside the PCIT's order under Section 263. No substantial question of law arose from the ITAT's order.

What were the facts?

The Revenue appealed an order dated April 8, 2019, by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) concerning Assessment Year 2010-11. The ITAT had set aside an order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The PCIT had invoked Section 263 to direct the Assessing Officer (AO) to revisit the assessment of the Assessee, M/s. VNG Packaging Pvt Ltd. The PCIT's concern was the investments made in the Assessee company, which it believed had not received sufficient attention in the original assessment. The original assessment order noted that the Assessee company was engaged in the business of investment in shares and had not conducted any other business during the year. The ITAT found that the invocation of Section 263 was not warranted.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT was justified in setting aside the order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, requiring the Assessing Officer (AO) to revisit the assessment made earlier of the Assessee. This is a question of mixed law and fact, turning on the interpretation and application of Section 263. Assessee's Contentions (as inferred from ITAT's findings): The Assessee argued that the PCIT's invocation of Section 263 was not warranted. The ITAT found that the Assessee had received investments in the form of equity shares held by other companies for a long time, which were duly disclosed. Crucially, the Assessee had not received any money in cash or cheque in lieu of share application or premium, but rather an exchange of investments for equity shares. The ITAT also noted that the AO had undertaken detailed inquiries and obtained records from 15 companies, and the identities of the parties were not in dispute. The genuineness of the transaction was proven by the exchange of shares, and there was no need to examine creditworthiness as no sum was received. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue contended that the PCIT was justified in invoking Section 263 because the investments made in the Assessee company had not merited enough attention in the original assessment order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 263,Section 68,Section 147,Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

ITA 693/2019

Page 1 of 4

$~32 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI +

ITA 693/2019

PR. CIT-9 NEW DELHI

..... Appellant Through: Mr. Ajit Sharma and Ms. Adeeba Mujahid, Advocates

versus

M/S. VNG PACKAGING PVT LTD

..... Respondent

Through: None

CORAM: JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR JUSTICE TALWANT SINGH

O R D E R %

26.07.2019 1. The Revenue is in appeal against an order dated 8th April, 2019 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in ITA No. 2742/Del/2017 in the Assessment Year (AY) 2010-11.

2.

The issue sought to be urged by the Revenue is whether the ITAT is justified in setting aside the order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act) requiring the Assessing Officer (AO) to revisit the assessment made earlier of the Assessee by the order dated 29th March, 2015 under Section 147/143 (3) of the Act?

3.

The PCIT decided to evoke the jurisdiction under Section 263 of the Act specific to the issue of the investments made in the Assessee company which

ITA 693/2019

Page 2 of 4

according to the PCIT had not merited enough attention in the original assessment order. It was noted by the AO in para 2 of the original assessment order as under: “2. The assessee company has been engaged in the business of investment in shares. During the year under consideration the assessee company has not done any business.”

4.

The Assessee then appealed to the ITAT which has by the impugned order come to the conclusion that the invocation of Section 263 of the Act was not warranted.

5.

With the assistance of the learned counsel for the Revenue, the Court has examined carefully the impugned orders of the PCIT as well as the ITAT. An outstanding factor, which according to the ITAT, clinched the issue was discussed by it in para 8 of the impugned order which reads as under: “8. One more important fact which clinches the entire issue and separates the case of the assessee from all other cases of share capital and share premium is that, here it is not the case where the assessee has received any money in form of cash or cheque in lieu of share application or share premium; rather the assessee had received investments in form of equity shares held by these companies in their balance sheet for a long time and duly disclosed in their income tax particulars. This fact is undisputed and is clearly borne out from various replies filed by the assessee before the Assessing Officer and also before the Ld. PCIT. The details of investments purchased by the assessee company in lieu of share allotment for the F.Y. 2009-10 is reproduced hereunder:”

6.

The ITAT then proceeded to discuss in detail, the figures in the accounts pertaining to each of the companies whose shares had been transferred to the

ITA 693/2019

Page 3 of 4

Assessee in lieu of allotment of its shares at face value of shares. This was in a sense an exchange. The ITAT interpreted Section 68 of the Act in the light of the above facts and observed in para 10 of the impugned order as under: “10. Ergo, when assessee in lieu of allotment of shares including face value of shares as well as premium amount, has received investments in the form of equity shares of various companies, then whether these companies had availability of cash or not may not be very relevant factor. The creditworthiness which is required to be examined u/s. 68 can be with regard to the transaction in form of any money either in cash or cheque. To invoke the deeming provisions of section 68, it is axiomatic that the credit appearing in the books of account maintained by the assessee should be with reference to any .sum received by the assessee. If the assessee has not received any sum in terms of any money, i.e., in cash or cheque, then deeming provision of section 68 will not apply.”

7.

The impugned order of the ITAT noted that the AO did undertake a detailed inquiry and got the entire records from the 15 companies and therefore, it could not be said that he failed to investigate the genuineness and creditworthiness of the source of funds. The identities of the parties were not in dispute. The genuineness of the transaction was held to have been fully proven by the fact the companies had given shares to the Assessee in lieu of the shares allotted to them. And lastly, there was no requirement to examine the creditworthiness of any sum advanced or invested because in fact, there was no transaction in terms of cash/money.

8.

Having examined the impugned orders of the PCIT and the ITAT, and having considered the submissions of learned counsel for the Revenue, this Court is of the view that in the facts and circumstances of the case on hand,

ITA 693/2019

Page 4 of 4

the interpretation placed by the ITAT on Section 68 of the Act, its reasoning and conclusions in the impugned order are consistent with the legal position and cannot be said to be suffering from any legal infirmity.

9.

No substantial question of law arises from the impugned order.

10.

The appeal is dismissed.

S. MURALIDHAR, J.

TALWANT SINGH, J. JULY 26, 2019 PB

More judgments on Section 263

All 13,616 judgments and leading authorities on Section 263 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →