PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 vs. ST MICRO ELECTRONICS PVT. LTD.
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court found no justification to entertain the appeal. It noted that the issue of excluding the four comparables (M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., VisualSoft Technologies Ltd., and SankhyaInfotech Ltd.) was decided in favour of the respondent-assessee by the CIT(A) and affirmed by the ITAT. The ITAT, in its order, had relied on the judgment of the Delhi High Court and its own decision in the case of Colt Technology Services India Pvt. Ltd. The ITAT found that the CIT(A) had made factual findings regarding the functional comparability of the comparables selected by the TPO, and the Revenue had failed to effectively rebut these findings. The Tribunal also noted that the issue had been examined in the Colt Technology Services India Pvt. Ltd. case by both the Tribunal and the High Court. Consequently, the ITAT saw no reason to interfere with the CIT(A)'s findings and dismissed the Revenue's ground of appeal. The High Court, bearing in mind these findings of fact, dismissed the appeal.
What were the facts?
The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) filed an appeal before the Delhi High Court challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated August 18, 2021. The appeal concerns the assessment year(s) not explicitly stated but implied to be related to transfer pricing adjustments. The core dispute revolves around the ITAT's affirmation of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] decision to exclude certain companies (M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., VisualSoft Technologies Ltd., and SankhyaInfotech Ltd.) as comparables for the respondent-assessee, ST Micro Electronics Pvt. Ltd. The PCIT contends that these companies met the qualitative and quantitative filters set by the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO). The High Court noted a delay of 819 days in refiling the appeal, which was condoned.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the ITAT erred in holding that M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., VisualSoft Technologies Ltd., and SankhyaInfotech Ltd. cannot be considered comparable companies, despite them passing all qualitative and quantitative filters adopted by the TPO? (Question of law and fact, concerning transfer pricing comparability analysis). 2. Whether the ITAT's decision to treat these four companies as non-comparable is perverse, given they satisfied the TPO's filters? 3. Whether the ITAT erred in relying on the judgment in Colt Technology Service Pvt. Ltd. (CTSIPL) when CTSIPL is functionally different from the assessee, which is engaged in Integrated Circuit Design, CAD tools, computer software development, and ITES, whereas CTSIPL is in software development? 4. Whether the ITAT was justified in treating high profit margin companies as non-comparable while considering low profit margin companies as suitable comparables, and whether this approach is perverse when other low-margin companies (Akshay Software Technologies, Lanco Global System Ltd., VJIL Consulting Ltd.) also fail to be acutely similar to the assessee's profile? 5. Whether the ITAT erred in not appreciating that in the TNMM method, broad functional similarity is sufficient, and if strict functional comparison is applied, other low-margin comparables should also be examined and excluded, specifically questioning the comparability of Akshay Software Technologies, VJIL Consulting Ltd. (due to foreign currency expenditure), and Lanco Global System Ltd. (due to size and BPO segment operations)? Assessee's Contentions (implied through the questions framed by the Revenue): - The four excluded companies met the TPO's filters and should have been considered comparable. - The ITAT's reliance on CTSIPL was erroneous due to functional differences. - The ITAT's approach to high vs. low profit margin companies was inconsistent and perverse. - Under TNMM, broad functional similarity is acceptable, and if strictly applied, other low-margin comparables should also be excluded. Revenue's Contentions (implied through the questions framed by the Revenue): - The ITAT's decision to exclude the four comparables was incorrect. - The ITAT erred in relying on the CTSIPL judgment. - The ITAT's treatment of high and low profit margin companies was perverse. - The ITAT failed to appreciate the principle of broad functional similarity under TNMM and should have excluded other low-margin comparables.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
$~60 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 477/2024 PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 .....Appellant Through: Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC, Mr. Anant Mann, JSC, Mr. Abhishek Anand and Mr. Pranjal Singh, Advocates. versus ST MICRO ELECTRONICS PVT. LTD. .....Respondent Through: Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Aditya Vohra and Mr. Shashvat Dhamija, Advocates. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA O R D E R %
03.09.2024 CM APPL. 50805/2024 (819 Days Delay in Refiling) Bearing in the mind the disclosures made, the delay of 819 days in refiling the appeal is condoned. The application shall stand disposed of. ITA 477/2024 1. The Principal Commissioner impugns the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal1 dated 18 August 2021 and posits the following questions of law for our consideration:- “2.1 Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld. ITAT is correct in holding that M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., VisualSoft Technologies LTd.(Seg) and SankhyaInfotech Ltd. cannot be taken as comparable being functionally different when these companies have passed all the 1 Tribunal This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/09/2024 at 14:30:09
qualitative and quantitative filters adopted by the TPO? 2.2 Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld. ITAT's decision with respect of trading M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., VisualSoft Technologies (Seg) and SankhyaInfotech Ltd as non-comparable is not perverse when these comparables satisfy all the qualitative and quantitative filters adopted by the TPO? 2.3 Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case and in law Ld. ITAT has not erred in relying on the Judgment of Hon'ble High Court in the case of Colt Technology Service Pvt. Ltd. (CTSIPL) even through CTSIPL is functionally different compared to Assessee. CTSIPL is in software development while the Assessee is engaged in Integrated Circuit Design, CAD tools and computer software Development service as well as in ITES? 2.4 Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case and in law Ld. ITAT is justified by treating high profit margin companies, M/s Exensys Software Solutions Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., Visnalsoft Teclinologies ( Seg) and SankhyaInfotech Ltd., as non- comparable and considering low profit margin companies as suitable comparables whereas if the decision of the Ld. ITAT is taken into account, these companies are also not acutely similar to the Assessee's functional profile. Thus Ld. ITAT's decision is perverse on the ground that while rejecting comparables of High profit margin low profit margin companies continue to be included in the list of comparables such as Akshay Software Technologies, Lanco Global System Ltd. and VJIL Consulting Ltd, which should also be excluded by itself for proper comparability analysis as these companies are also not exactly similar to the assessee's functional profile? 2.5 Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law Ld. ITAT has erred in not appreciating the facts in TNMM a broad functional similarity is seen. If strict functional comparison is made then other comparableswith low margin also needs to be examined and would fails the test; (a) Akshay Software Technologies can also said to be functionally different as more than 60% of its expenditure is in foreign currency indicating most of the software development work is being done in offshore location indicating a totally different cost base? (b) VJIL Consulting Ltd. can also be said to be functionally different as more than 60% of its expenditure is in foreign currency indicating most of the software development work is being done in offshore location a totally different cost base? This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/09/2024 at 14:30:09
(c) Lanco Global System Ltd. can also be said to be functionally un comparable as with turnover of 6 crores it is very small and start-up company compared to assessee with a turnover of Rs.222 crores. Further Laneo Global is substantially operating in BPO Segment?” 2. We note that the issue of exclusion of the four comparables was one which was answered in favour of the respondent-assessee by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)2 in its order dated 19 May 2017. It was the view expressed by that authority which has ultimately come to be affirmed by the Tribunal in terms of paragraph 9 of the order impugned before us and which is extracted hereinbelow:- “9. We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material available on record. The Revenue is aggrieved by the exclusion of following comparables by the Ld. CIT(A):- [1] Exensys Software Solutions Ltd; [2] Thirdware Solutions Ltd.; [3] Visualsoft Technologies (Seg); and [4] Sankhya Infotech Ltd. By excluding these comparables, Ld.CIT(A) placed reliance upon the judgement of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court and the decision of Tribunal in the case of Colt Technology Services India Pvt.Ltd. (ITA No.609/Del/2011). We find that the Ld.CIT(A) after considering the material placed on records and has given finding on facts in respect of the functional comparability of the comparables selected by the TPO. The Revenue has failed to effectively rebut the finding of Ld.CIT(A). Moreover, this issue has already been examined in the case of Colt Technology Services India Pvt. Ltd.(supra) by the Tribunal as well as Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court. Therefore, we do not see any reason to interfere in the findings of Ld. CIT(A). Thus, order of Ld. CIT(A) is hereby affirmed. The Ground of appeal No.1 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.” 3. Bearing in mind the aforesaid findings of fact, we find no justification to entertain the instant appeal. 2 CIT(A) This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/09/2024 at 14:30:09
The appeal shall accordingly stand dismissed. YASHWANT VARMA, J. RAVINDER DUDEJA, J. SEPTEMBER 3, 2024/ib This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/09/2024 at 14:30:09
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Shiv Ram vs. State Of Hp And OrsHimachal Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Ampl Resources PVT. LTD., Through Sri Om Prakash Pareek, Authorised Signatory vs. The State Of JharkhandJharkhand · 3 Nov 2026
- Saleem vs. The Union Of INDIA And 4 OrsGauhati · 3 Nov 2026
- Ms R Ess Iron And Steel PVT LTD vs. Union Of INDIA And OrsGauhati · 3 Nov 2026
- Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee And Anr vs. Galactic Television And Communications PVT LTD And OrsDelhi · 3 Nov 2026