PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 7 DELHI vs. M/S SCORPIO RESEARCH AND CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/423/2024HC DelhiDLHC01048138202407 August 2024Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeal fails to raise any substantial question of law. The Court noted that the source of the cash seized during the search was explained by the assessee and accepted by both the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal. The Tribunal, in its order, observed that the AO relied on email communications suggesting a total consideration of Rs. 150 crores for land sale, implying Rs. 45 crores was received in cash. However, the Tribunal found no other corroborative evidence beyond the emails to prove actual cash payment. The emails were considered discussions and proposals, not a clear agreement. The Commissioner (Appeals) had factually found that no seized materials conclusively established cash payment or adjustment against sale consideration. The Tribunal concluded that the Revenue failed to controvert these findings and that suspicion, however strong, cannot replace evidence. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Appellant) is challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated April 20, 2023. The ITAT had deleted an addition of Rs. 15,00,00,000/- made by the Assessing Officer (AO) on account of alleged cash payments. The AO's addition was based on seized documents, specifically email communications, which suggested that the total consideration for the sale of land was Rs. 150 crores, implying Rs. 45 crores was paid in cash outside the books. The assessee is M/s Scorpio Research and Consultants Pvt. Ltd. (Respondent). The appeal was filed with a delay of 214 days, which was condoned by the High Court.

What were the issues?

1. Whether on the facts, circumstances, and in law, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 15,00,00,000/- on account of cash payments, based on seized documents, without appreciating the AO's findings that these documents were corroborated with the assessee's books of accounts. 2. Whether on the facts, circumstances, and in law, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in holding that while emails relied upon by the AO might give rise to suspicion of cash payments, such suspicion, however strong, cannot substitute for evidence, despite the AO corroborating the emails and seized documents with the assessee's books of accounts. Assessee's contentions: Not recorded in the judgment. Revenue's contentions: The ITAT erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 15,00,00,000/-. The AO's findings, based on seized documents (emails) and corroborated with the assessee's books of accounts, established cash payments. Suspicion arising from these documents, even if strong, should have been considered sufficient evidence.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~68 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 423/2024

PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 7 DELHI

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Sunil Agarwal, SSC with Mr. Shivansh B. Pandya, Mr. Viplav Acharya, JScs & Mr. Utkarsh Tiwari, Adv.

versus

M/S SCORPIO RESEARCH AND CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.

.....Respondent

Through: None

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA

O R D E R %

07.08.2024

CM APPL. 44891/2024 (Ex.)

Allowed subject to all just exceptions.

Application stands disposed of. CM APPL. 44890/2024 (214 Days Delay)

Bearing in mind the disclosures made, the delay of 214 days in filing the appeal is condoned.

Application stands disposed of. ITA 423/2024 1. The Principal Commissioner impugns the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“Tribunal”] dated 20 April 2023 and posits the following questions of law for our consideration: “3.1 Whether on the facts, circumstances and in law, the Hon’ble ITAT erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 15,00,00,000/- on account of cash payments on the basis of seized documents and not appreciating the findings of the AO who has corroborated these This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 14/08/2024 at 11:35:47

documents with books of accounts of the assessee company? 3.2 Whether on the facts, circumstances and in law, the Hon’ble ITAT erred in holding that email relied upon by the AO may give rise to suspicion that there may be cash payment in addition to the recorded sale consideration, however, such suspicion, however, strong, cannot take place of evidence although AO has corroborated the email and seized documents with books of accounts of the assessee company?”

2.

We, however, find that the source of cash which was seized during the course of the search appears to have been duly explained by the assessee and which position came to be accepted both by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) as well as the Tribunal. This is evident from a reading of paras 68 & 69 of the order impugned before us:- “68. We have considered rival submissions and perused materials on record. From the observations of the Assessing Officer in the assessment order, it is clearly evident, relying upon certain email communications between some persons related to the assessee company and other entities, the Assessing Officer has concluded that in addition to the amount recorded in the agreement towards consideration for sale of land in Sector 84 and 85 of Gurgaon, the assessee received money in cash, as, the information in the email suggests that the total consideration paid towards purchase of land by different entities was to the tune of Rs.150 crores and not the recorded amount of Rs.105 crores. Accordingly, he has inferred that the assessee has received an amount of Rs.45 crores in cash outside the books towards sale consideration of land, which was added back to the income of the assessee. It is observed from the materials on record, except the email communications, the Assessing Officer has no other corroborative evidence to conclusively prove that money in cash had actually changed hands. Except the email communications, no other documents have been seized, either from the assessee or from other entities to indicate that cash payment was actually made. Apart from relying upon the email communication, the Assessing Officer has not made proper inquiry to establish on record that cash payments were actually made to the assessee. As rightly observed by learned Commissioner (Appeals), the emails on which the Assessing Officer placed reliance, essentially, do not patently show any agreement or discernible consent arrived at between the buyer and seller regarding the land to be purchased or the rate per sq. yards. The emails are in the nature of discussions and proposals to a planned This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 14/08/2024 at 11:35:47

purchase transaction. It has been factually found by learned Commissioner (Appeals) that the figures relating to the alleged total deal vary in different emails. Learned Commissioner (Appeals) has also given a factual finding that no seized materials were found conclusively establishing that any amount in cash was actually paid or any such sum was adjusted against the final sale consideration. 69. We must say, the Revenue has failed to controvert any of the factual findings recorded by learned Commissioner (Appeals). Though, email relied upon by the Assessing Officer may give rise to suspicion that there may be cash payment in addition to the recorded sale consideration, however, such suspicion, howsoever strong, cannot take place of evidence. It is a fact on record that the Assessing Officer has not brought any evidence to establish that cash payments were actually made to the assessee.”

3.

In view of the above, we find that the appeal fails to raise any substantial question of law. 4. The appeal shall, consequently, stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J.

RAVINDER DUDEJA, J. AUGUST 7, 2024/kk This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 14/08/2024 at 11:35:47

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →