PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS)- 1 vs. HINDUSTAN COCA COLA BEVERAGES PVT. LTD.
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that penalty proceedings should be initiated within a reasonable timeframe. It noted that Section 275(1)(c) of the Act does not fix a date for the commencement of the limitation period, creating a legislative gap that can disadvantage the assessee. The Court found that in this case, more than eleven years had passed since the assessment order and fourteen years since the return was filed, constituting a significant delay. The Court disagreed with the revenue's submission that the six-month period should commence from the date of the show cause notice, stating that this would allow the Assessing Officer to trigger penalty proceedings at their convenience. The Court held that the initiation of penalty proceedings is triggered by the proposal for penalty, which was made on 27.03.2019. The penalty order was passed on 31.10.2019, which was beyond the six-month period that expired on 30.09.2019. Therefore, the penalty proceedings were time-barred. The appeal was closed as no substantial question of law arose.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Hindustan Coca Cola Beverages Pvt. Ltd., filed its return of income for Assessment Year 2005-06 on 30.10.2004, declaring a loss. The assessment order under Section 143(3) was passed on 17.12.2008, pegging the loss at Rs.383,96,56,832/-. The assessee had suo motu disallowed expenses of Rs.39,80,73,391/- under Section 40(a)(ia) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. More than a decade later, the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax proposed initiating penalty proceedings against the assessee for failure to deduct tax at source on these disallowed expenses. The tax allegedly not deducted under Section 194C was Rs.1,05,36,376/-. The proposal for penalty was made on 27.03.2019, and a show cause notice under Section 271C was issued on 23.04.2019, nearly eleven years after the assessment order and fourteen years after filing the return.
What were the issues?
1. Whether penalty proceedings initiated after a significant delay, specifically more than eleven years after the assessment order and fourteen years after filing the return, are valid? 2. Whether the period of limitation for passing a penalty order under Section 275(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, commences from the date of the proposal for penalty initiation or the date of the show cause notice? Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that penalty proceedings initiated after such a long delay are not permissible. The Tribunal ruled in favour of the assessee. Revenue's contentions: The revenue, through its senior standing counsel, argued that since Section 275(1)(c) does not provide a specific commencement date for the limitation period, the six-month period for passing the penalty order should commence from the date the show cause notice is issued. The revenue relied on the second limb of Section 275(1)(c).
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 40(a)(ia),Section 194C,Section 271C,Section 275(1)(c),Section 143(3),Section 274,Section 275
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ITA 408/2023 Page 1 of 6
$~95 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI %
Date of Decision: 27.07.2023 + ITA 408/2023
PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS)- 1..... Appellant Through: Mr Puneet Rai, Sr Standing Counsel with Mr Ashvini Kumar and Ms Madhavi Shukla, Advs.
versus
HINDUSTAN COCA COLA BEVERAGES PVT. LTD.
..... Respondent
Through: Mr Sachit Jolly, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GIRISH KATHPALIA
[Physical Hearing/Hybrid Hearing (as per request)] RAJIV SHAKDHER, J.: (ORAL)
CM Appl.37857/2023 1. Allowed, subject to just exceptions. ITA 408/2023 2. This appeal concerns Assessment Year (AY) 2005-06. 3. Via this appeal, the appellant/revenue seeks to assail the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [in short, “Tribunal”] dated 17.01.2023. 4. The broad facts, which are required to be noticed in order to adjudicate the instant appeal, are the following: 4.1 On 30.10.2004, the respondent/assessee had filed its return of income (ROI), declaring a loss amounting to Rs.439,67,64,096/-. Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
ITA 408/2023 Page 2 of 6
4.2 The respondent/assessee’s case was selected for scrutiny, and ultimately, an order dated 17.12.2008 was passed under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [in short, “Act”]. 4.3 The Assessing Officer (AO) scaled down the loss declared by the respondent/assessee and thus, pegged it at Rs.383,96,56,832/-. 5. It is relevant to note that in the return, the respondent/assessee had suo motu sought disallowance of expenses incurred towards certain transactions, amounting to Rs. 39,80,73,391/-, having regard to the provisions of Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act. 5.1 The record shows that more than a decade later, the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (JCIT) proposed initiation of penalty against the respondent/assessee for failing to deduct tax at source, with regard to the sou motu disallowance which stood embedded in the return of the respondent/assessee. The value of the transactions qua which disallowance was entered in the return filed by the respondent/assessee was Rs.39,80,73,391/-. 5.2 Tax at source, which according to the AO, ought to have been deducted under Section 194C of the Act, was pegged at Rs.1,05,36,376/-. It is this amount which was ultimately handed down as penalty. 5.3 Importantly, the proposal for initiation of penalty was made on 27.03.2019. 5.4 The show cause notice under Section 271C of the Act was issued on 23.04.2019, which was nearly eleven (11) years after the assessment order was passed, and fourteen (14) years from the time when the return was filed. 6. The moot question which arose before the statutory authorities was Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
ITA 408/2023 Page 3 of 6
whether penalty could have been levied, under the aforementioned circumstances. 7. The Tribunal ruled in favour of the respondent/assessee. 8. According to us, apart from anything else, the issue raised in the present appeal stands covered by the judgment of a coordinate Bench of this court rendered in Clix Capital Services Pvt. Ltd. vs. DCIT, 2023/DHC/0017031. 9. The sum of the ratio of the said decision is that penalty ought to be levied within a reasonable timeframe. This attains criticality, as Section 275(1)(c) of the Act does not fix a date for the commencement of the period of limitation. This legislative gap in the provision works to the disadvantage of the assessee, as often, the AO takes his own sweet time in making a proposal for the initiation of penalty proceedings. 9.1 In this case, as noticed above, more than 11 years have passed since the time the assessment order was passed, and if the date of filing of the return is taken into account, there is a yawning 14 years of time gap. 10. Mr Puneet Rai, learned senior standing counsel, who appears on
1 “…17.2 It is apparent, that while a timeframe has been provided for the conclusion of penalty proceedings once initiated, there is no indication, as to when the period of six months ought to commence. In other words, can initiation of penalty proceeding be left to the whims and fancies of the revenue or it should be hitched to the dicta of “reasonable period” adopted by Courts in such situations, in the absence of a statutory provision? 18. (x) 19. (x) 20. However, we are inclined to agree with the submission made on behalf of the petitioner, i.e., the assessee, and the reason for that is quite simple. If we were to accept the respondent/revenue’s stand, then it could end up [as it has in this case] in a situation, where the revenue could decide the date when it could trigger a SCN to fulfil, as a mere formality, the principles of natural justice, which are engrafted under Section 274 of the Act. Section 274 of the Act, inter alia, mandates that no order imposing a penalty under the Chapter i.e., Chapter XXI shall be made unless the assessee has been heard, or has been given a reasonable opportunity of being heard…” [Emphasis is ours] Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
ITA 408/2023 Page 4 of 6
behalf of the appellant/revenue, however, says that since there no date is provided for the commencement of limitation in Section 275 (1) (c) of the Act, the appellant/revenue should have the benefit of the second limb of the said provision and six months provided for passing the penalty order should commence from the date when show cause notice is issued. For the sake of convenience, the relevant part of Section 275 is extracted hereafter: “275. (1) No order imposing a penalty under this Chapter shall be passed - (a) in a case where the relevant assessment or other order is the subject matter of an appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) under section 246 or section 246A or an appeal to the Appellate Tribunal under section 253. after the expiry of the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for the imposition of penalty has been initiated, are completed, or six months from the end of the month in which the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) or, as the case may be, the Appellate Tribunal is received by the Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, whichever period expires later : Provided that in a case where the relevant assessment or other order is the subject-matter of an appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) under section 246 or section 246A and the Commissioner (Appeals) passes the order on or after the 1st day of June, 2003 disposing of such appeal, an order imposing penalty shall be passed before the expiry of the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for imposition of penalty has been initiated, are completed, or within one year from the end of the financial year in which the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) is received by the Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, whichever is later; (b) in a case where the relevant assessment or other order is the subject matter of revision under section 263 or section 264, after the expiry of six months from the end of the month in which such order of revision is passed; (c) in any other case, after the expiry of the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for the imposition of penalty has been initiated, are completed, or six months from the end of the month in which action for imposition of penalty is initiated, whichever period expires later.”
Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
ITA 408/2023 Page 5 of 6
[Emphasis is ours] 11. A careful perusal of the second limb would show that the legislature has provided a limitation of six months, from the end of the month in which the action for imposition of penalty is initiated. 12. Even according to Mr Rai, the first limb of Section 275(1)(c) is not applicable. 13. Therefore if the dates and events, (which obtain in the matter and are not in dispute), are taken into account, even then, the proceedings would be time-barred as initiation of penalty proceedings commences with the proposal being submitted for triggering penalty proceedings. 14. In this case, the proposal, as noticed above, for commencing of penalty proceedings was submitted by the JCIT on 27.03.2019. 15. The record shows that the order under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act was passed only on 31.10.2019, which is a date well beyond six months, that expired on 30.09.2019. 15.1 Although it is Mr Rai’s argument that six month period should commence from the date when show cause notice is issued, in our view, once again, this is a submission which cannot be accepted, as it would provide a scope to the AO to trigger the penalty proceedings at the date of his choosing, as is palpably evident in this case. 15.2 The word used in the provision is “initiated” which according to us, is an act which would get triggered on the date when the proposal is made. This rationale ties in with our view, as noted hereinabove, that penalty proceedings should be initiated within a reasonable period. 16. We are, thus, not in agreement with the submission made by Mr Rai. Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
ITA 408/2023 Page 6 of 6
Accordingly, the appeal is closed, since no substantial question of law arises for consideration.
RAJIV SHAKDHER, J
GIRISH KATHPALIA, J
JULY 27, 2023/pmc
Digitally Signed By:TARUN RANA Signing Date:05.08.2023 19:57:08 Signature Not Verified
More judgments on Section 40(a)(ia)
- Dineshkumar and Co., Junagadh vs The Income Tax Officer, VeravalITA 1196/RJT/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed17 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
- Dineshkumar and Co., Junagadh vs The Income Tax Officer, VeravalITA 1195/RJT/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed17 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
- M/S Country Liquar Shop, Nandgaon Peth vs Income Tax Officer Ward-2 Amravati, AmravatiITA 250/NAG/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
- Neovantage Innovation Parks Private Limited… vs ITO, Ward -16(3), HyderabadITA 675/HYD/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Ainthapali… vs The Koraput Central Cooperative Bank Ltd…ITA 475/CTK/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Rapaka Govinda Rao vs. Assistant Commissioner CT And GST, Koraput, JeyporeOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- M/S Life Care Emporium vs. Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And GST,CuttackOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Prafulla Mohapatra vs. The Principal Commissioner CGST And Central Excise, BbsrOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- M/S A. K. Infrastructure vs. Additional Commissioner, Bhubaneswar CBICOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- M/S.Arun Kumar Sunani, Sundergarh vs. Commissioner(Appeal), GST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 18 Nov 2026