COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION) -1 vs. ESS ADVERTISING (MAURITIUS) SNC ET COMPAGNIE (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ESPN STAR SPORTS MAURITIUS SNC ET

PDF · subscribers
ITA/399/2024HC DelhiDLHC01048661202118 September 2024Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeals filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax. The Court found that the issues raised in these appeals had been conclusively answered by its previous judgment in the case of The Commissioner of Income Tax-International Taxation 1 vs. ESPN Star Sports Mauritius S.N.C.ET Compagnie (ITA 333/2023, decided on February 13, 2024). Specifically addressing the Permanent Establishment (PE) issue, the Court reiterated its finding that there was no fixed place PE. Regarding the DAPE aspect, the Court noted that the contract stipulations indicated an absence of authority for the subsidiary to conclude contracts in the name of the foreign company. The ITAT had found that the Indian entities had an independent right to enter into contracts with cable operators, and the foreign company was not privy to these agreements. The Court also affirmed that since there was no PE, the issue of profit attribution did not arise, referencing the Supreme Court's decision in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. E-Funds IT Solution Inc. Consequently, the High Court found no grounds to interfere with the impugned orders and dismissed the appeals.

What were the facts?

The appeals were filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (International Taxation) -1 against the orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The respondent assessee is Ess Advertising (Mauritius) SNC et Compagnie, formerly known as ESPN Star Sports Mauritius SNC et Compagnie. The appeals challenge the ITAT's findings regarding the attribution of profits to a foreign company and the existence of a Dependent Agent Permanent Establishment (DAPE). The High Court noted that the appeals involved significant delays in refiling, which were condoned. The core of the dispute revolves around whether the ITAT correctly held that no further profit attribution was necessary for the foreign company if its subsidiary operated at arm's length, and whether the subsidiary's activities constituted a DAPE.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was correct in holding that if remuneration is on an arm's length basis as a subsidiary company, no further attribution of profit should be made to the foreign company, considering the subsidiary company as a dependent agent PE? (Section 9(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and Article 12(4)(i) of the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA)). 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was correct in holding that no further attribution of profit should be made to the foreign company even if the transfer pricing analysis did not adequately reflect the functions, assets, and risks (FAR) performed by it as a DAPE? 3. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was correct in holding that the subsidiary company was earning profit through its agency activity only and not through its activity in the form of a DAPE of the foreign company? Assessee's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions made by the assessee's counsel, Mr. Porus F. Kaka, Sr. Adv. However, the High Court's decision implies that the assessee's position aligned with the ITAT's findings, which were upheld. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue, represented by Mr. Anant Mann, argued that the ITAT erred in its conclusions regarding profit attribution and the classification of the subsidiary's activities. The revenue sought to question the ITAT's findings on the existence of a DAPE and the subsequent profit attribution.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 9(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~5 to 7 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 399/2024

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION) -1

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Anant Mann, JSC, Mr. Abhishek Anand and Mr. Pranjal Singh, Advs. for Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC.

versus

ESS ADVERTISING (MAURITIUS) SNC ET COMPAGNIE (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ESPN STAR SPORTS MAURITIUS SNC ET COMPAGNIE) .....Respondent Through: Mr. Porus F. Kaka, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Divesh Chawla, Mr. Ashok Mathur, Mr. Saurabh Jain and Ms. Sandy Sharma, Advs. 6 + ITA 400/2024

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION) -1

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Anant Mann, JSC, Mr. Abhishek Anand and Mr. Pranjal Singh, Advs. for Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC.

versus

ESS ADVERTISING (MAURITIUS) SNC ET COMPAGNIE (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ESPN STAR SPORTS MAURITIUS SNC ET COMPAGNIE) .....Respondent Through: Mr. Porus F. Kaka, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Divesh Chawla, Mr. Ashok Mathur, Mr. Saurabh Jain and Ms. Sandy Sharma, Advs.

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:18:05

7 + ITA 402/2024

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - INTERNATIONAL TAXATION -1

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Anant Mann, JSC, Mr. Abhishek Anand and Mr. Pranjal Singh, Advs. for Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC.

versus

ESPN STAR SPORTS (MAURITIUS) SNC ET COMPAGNIE NOW KNOWN AS ESS ADVERTISING (MAURITIUS) S.N.C. ET COMPAGNIE

.....Respondent Through: Mr. Porus F. Kaka, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Divesh Chawla, Mr. Ashok Mathur, Mr. Saurabh Jain and Ms. Sandy Sharma, Advs.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA

O R D E R %

18.09.2024

CM APPL. 42831/2024 (759 Days Delay in Refiling) in ITA 399/2024

Bearing in the mind the disclosures made, the delay of 759 days in re-filing the appeal is condoned. The application shall stand disposed of. CM APPL. 42838/2024 (759 Days Delay in Refiling) in ITA 400/2024

Bearing in the mind the disclosures made, the delay of 759 days in re-filing the appeal is condoned. The application shall stand disposed of.

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:18:05

CM APPL. 42944/2024 (720 Days Delay in Refiling) in ITA 402/2024

Bearing in the mind the disclosures made, the delay of 720 days in re-filing the appeal is condoned. The application shall stand disposed of.

ITA 399/2024, ITA 400/2024 & ITA 402/2024

1.

The Principal Commissioner has in the main appeal posited the following questions for our consideration:- “2.1 Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. ITAT is correct in holding that the purported PE if remuneration on arm's length as subsidiary company, no further attribution of profit be made on foreign company, considering subsidiary company as dependent agent PE?

2.2 Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. ITAT is correct in holding that no further attribution of profit be made on foreign company even if the TP analysis did not adequately reflect the FAR home by the enterprise, for additional functions/risks performed by it as DAPE?

2.3Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. ITAT is correct in holding that subsidiary company is earning profit through its agency activity only and not through its activity in the form of DAPE of Foreign Company? ”

2.

Having heard Mr. Mann, learned counsel who appears in support of these appeals and Mr. Kaka, learned senior counsel who represents the respondent assessee, we find that the issues which are sought to be canvassed in these appeals stand conclusively answered in light of the judgment rendered by us in The Commissioner of Income Tax-International Taxation 1 vs. ESPN Star Sports Mauritius S.N.C.ET Compagnie [ITA 333/2023 decided on 13 February 2024].

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:18:05

3.

In connected ITA 402/2024, the additional questions which are sought to be canvassed pertain to business connection and taxability under Section 9(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [„Act‟]. Dealing with the aspect of Permanent Establishment and whether any further attribution could be made once it was found that the remittances were accounted for, we had while disposing of ESPN Star Sports held as follows:- “14. Insofar as the issue of fixed place PE is concerned, the same clearly stands concluded against the appellants by virtue of the findings of fact returned by the ITAT. The case of a DAPE appears to have been raised in the backdrop of Article 12(4)(i) of the India Mauritius DTAA. However, the contract stipulations would unerringly point towards a manifest absence of a right having been conferred or an authority granted to conclude contracts in the name of ESS Distribution (Mauritius). The ITAT has found that the Indian entities stood conferred with an independent right to enter into contracts with cable operators for channel distribution and that ESS Distribution (Mauritius) was not privy to those agreements. In terms of those agreements, it is the Indian entities which bear associated distribution costs and expenses. The agreements unequivocally establish that ESS Distribution (Mauritius) is in no manner connected with the contracts executed by the Indian entities with cable operators and other intermediaries. Even the right to initiate legal action by the latter is available to be exercised only against the Indian entities.

15.

As far as the additional issue of profit attribution is concerned, we note that since there is no PE, the issue of profit attribution would clearly not arise. This issue, in any case, stands concluded in light of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. E-Funds IT Solution Inc.”

4.

We consequently find no ground to interfere with the orders impugned. The appeals fail and shall stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J

RAVINDER DUDEJA, J SEPTEMBER 18, 2024/RW This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:18:05

More judgments on Section 9(1)

All 168 judgments and leading authorities on Section 9(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →