STATE BANK OF INDIA, CAG BRANCH vs. ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/342/2024HC DelhiDLHC01039630202411 July 2024Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the issue sought to be canvassed by the appellant, State Bank of India, stands conclusively settled against the appellant in light of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 8181/2022. Consequently, the High Court dismissed the appeals along with pending applications. The reasoning is that the Supreme Court's decision in the cited appeal governs the present matter, rendering further adjudication on the points raised by the appellant unnecessary. The principle established is that where the Supreme Court has conclusively ruled on an issue, subsequent appeals on the same issue will be dismissed. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeals.

What were the facts?

The appellant, State Bank of India (SBI), is challenging an order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) on January 25, 2024. The appeals pertain to assessment years not explicitly stated in the provided text. The core of the dispute involves the SBI being held as an assessee in default under Section 201(1) of the Income Tax Act for non-deduction of tax (TDS) on its employees' Leave Travel Concession (LTC) claims. The bank argues that its non-deduction was in compliance with orders from the Madras High Court and a pending Special Leave Petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court, which provided interim protection against recovery from employees. The revenue, represented by the Assistant CIT, Circle 77(1), and another respondent, is the opposing party. The High Court is considering multiple appeals filed by SBI.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide the following questions of law posed by the appellant, State Bank of India: 1. Whether the ITAT erred in not appreciating orders of the Madras High Court and the Supreme Court directing the appellant bank not to make recoveries from employees regarding tax on LTC claims, including the TDS component (Section 201(1) of the Income Tax Act). 2. Whether the ITAT erred in holding the appellant bank as an assessee in default under Section 201(1) for non-deduction of tax on LTC/HTC claims, given that such non-deduction was in compliance with court orders (Madras High Court and Supreme Court). 3. Whether the ITAT erred in deeming the appellant bank as an assessee in default, especially when an SLP concerning employees' right to claim LTC for overseas travel was pending before the Supreme Court with interim protection against tax recovery. 4. Whether the demand for TDS (principal and interest) from the appellant for LTC/HTC claims is legal and justified post-finalization of individual returns under Section 139, considering the non-deduction was due to a court order and reflected in employee disclosures, and whether the responsibility for tax lies with employees or the bank. 5. Whether the ITAT erred by not deciding the matter on merits and solely relying on one Supreme Court judgment (SBI Vs ACIT Civil Appeal No. 8181/2022) while ignoring another relevant Supreme Court order (SLP No. 16734/2023) concerning substantial issues pending adjudication. 6. Whether the ITAT's order was perverse and based on incorrect appreciation of facts and legal principles. 7. Whether the ACIT's approach in ignoring the law and disregarding merits and facts was correct. Assessee's Contentions: The appellant argued that its non-deduction of tax was in compliance with judicial pronouncements from the Madras High Court and the Supreme Court, and that an SLP with interim protection was pending before the Supreme Court. They contended that the responsibility for tax should lie with the employees if not deducted at source due to court orders. They also argued that the ITAT failed to decide on merits and ignored relevant Supreme Court orders. Revenue's Contentions: The judgment does not explicitly record the revenue's contentions.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 201(1),Section 139

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~68 to 72, 89 & 90 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 342/2024 & CM APPL. 38547/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38548/2024 (Ex.) & CM APPL. 38549/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA, CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents

Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1.

Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2.

69 + ITA 343/2024 & CM APPL. 38551/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38552/2024 (Ex.) & CM APPL. 38553/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA, CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1.

Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2. 70 + ITA 344/2024 & CM APPL. 38575/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38576/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38577/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents

Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1.

Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2.

71 + ITA 345/2024 & CM APPL. 38579/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38580/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38581/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA

.....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1.

Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2.

72 + ITA 346/2024 & CM APPL. 38582/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38583/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38584/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1.

Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2.

89 + ITA 347/2024 & CM APPL. 38673/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38674/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38675/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1. Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2. 90 + ITA 348/2024 & CM APPL. 38680/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.

38681/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38682/2024 (Impleadment)

STATE BANK OF INDIA CAG BRANCH .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjeev Sagar, SC along with Ms. Nazia Parveen, Mr. Rishabh Malik, Mr. Vidyut Dwivedi and Mr. Nitin, Advs.

versus

ASSISTANT CIT, CIRCLE 77(1) & ANR. .....Respondents

Through: Mr. Debesh Panda, Ms. Zehra Khan, Mr. Vikram Aditya Singh, Mr. Ojaswa Pathak, Mr. Vineet Gupta and Ms. Anauntta Shankar, Advs. for R-1. Mr. Gautam Narayan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. K.V. Prasad and Mr. Anirudh Anand, Advs. for R-2.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

O R D E R %

11.07.2024

CM APPL. 38550/2024 (20 Days Delay) in ITA 342/2024 CM APPL. 38554/2024 (20 Days Delay) in ITA 343/2024 CM APPL. 38585/2024 (20 Days Delay) in ITA 346/2024

1.

Bearing in the mind the disclosures made, the delay of 20 days in filing the appeals is condoned. 2. Applications shall stand disposed of. ITA 342/2024 & CM APPL. 38547/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38548/2024 (Ex.) & CM APPL. 38549/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 343/2024 & CM APPL. 38551/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38552/2024 (Ex.) & CM APPL. 38553/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 344/2024 & CM APPL. 38575/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38576/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38577/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 345/2024 & CM APPL. 38579/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38580/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38581/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 346/2024 & CM APPL. 38582/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38583/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38584/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 347/2024 & CM APPL. 38673/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38674/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38675/2024 (Impleadment)

ITA 348/2024 & CM APPL. 38680/2024 (Stay), CM APPL. 38681/2024 (Ex.), CM APPL. 38682/2024 (Impleadment)

3.

The State Bank of India seeks to assail the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [„Tribunal‟] dated 25 January 2024 and poses the following questions of law for our consideration: “A. Whether the Ld. ITAT on facts failed to appreciate the judgment dated 25.04.2014 and 16.02.2015 in W.P. No. 11991/2014 and order dated 08.06.2023 in W.A No.1653/2022 all passed by Hon‟ble Madras High Court and order dated 28.08.2023 passed by Hon‟ble Apex Court in SLP (C) No.16734/2023 whereby the Hon‟ble Apex court has directed the Appellant Bank to not make any recoveries from its employees in respect of tax on their LTC claims including TDS component?

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

B. Whether the Ld. ITAT erred in holding the Appellant Bank as an assessee in default in terms of section 201(1) of the Income Tax Act, for non-deduction of tax on the reimbursement of LTC/HTC claim of its employees, in view of the fact that any and all non-deduction of tax was in compliance of orders of the Hon‟ble Madras High Court dated 25.04.2014 & 16.02.2015 passed in WP No. 11991/2014 and WANo.1653 & Supreme Court in SLP (C) 16734/2023 dated 28.08.2023?

C. Whether the Ld. ITAT has erred in law and fact in deeming the Appellant Bank as an assessee in default, particularly in view of the fact that a Special Leave Petition No. 16734/2023 on the issue of right of the employees of the Appellant Bank, to claim LTC to visit overseas countries is still pending adjudication and when an interim protection is awarded to employees of the Appellant from any recovery of tax in the said SLP?

D. Whether the demand of the respondent no.1 from the appellant for TDS claim (principal and interest) in respect of LTC/HTC claim of its employees is legal and justified post finalization of individual returns U/s 139 of the Income Tax Act, in view of the fact that where Income Tax was not deducted, the reason for the same was an order of Hon‟ble Madras High Court and the said fact was reflected in Form No. 12BA (as enclosure to Form 16) of the employees? Whether the claim of such amount if any, is to be made from the employees or from the appellant Bank in view of the fact that the responsibility to pay tax on any income vests on the employees as the same was not deducted at source owing to order of Court of Law? E. Whether the Ld. ITAT has erred by not deciding the matter on merits and simply relying on one of the judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case of “ SBI Vs ACIT Civil Appeal No. 8181/2022” and ignoring the order of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in another case i.e. SLP No. 16734/2023, thereby ignoring the fact that once again substantial issues qua the employees of the appellant in relation to LTC claim are pending in SLP no.16734/2023 before the Hon‟ble Apex Court, wherein the respondents are party?

F. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, order passed by the Ld. ITAT was perverse and based on incorrect appreciation of facts and legal principles?

G. Whether the approach of the ACIT in ignoring the law on the subject and disregarding the merits and facts of the matter was correct?”

4.

Undisputedly, the issue which is sought to be canvassed stands conclusively settled against the appellant in light of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 8181/2022. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

5.

Consequently, and in light of the aforesaid, the appeals along with pending applications, fail and shall stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J.

RAVINDER DUDEJA, J. JULY 11, 2024/RW This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/07/2024 at 14:28:27

More judgments on Section 201(1)

All 3,835 judgments and leading authorities on Section 201(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →