THE PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 vs. OSN INFRASTRUCTURE & PROJECTS PVT. LTD.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/1206/2018HC DelhiDLHC01318432201830 August 2024Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA5 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that no substantial question of law arose from the ITAT's order. The Court noted that the CIT(A) had considered the detailed explanation provided by the assessee regarding the payments and the write-off. Crucially, the CIT(A) found that the write-off was based on validly executed deeds of settlement, which are legally enforceable documents. The CIT(A) concluded that since these deeds were executed, the assessee had given up its claim on these amounts, and therefore, the loss was an allowable business loss or expense. The ITAT affirmed this view. The High Court found that the consideration given by the CIT(A) and affirmed by the ITAT was sufficient, leading to the dismissal of the appeal. The operative direction from the CIT(A) was to direct the AO to furnish information to the assessing officers of the three parties to tax these amounts in their hands and to examine a specific journal entry adjustment. The High Court did not disturb these directions but focused on the allowability of the loss.

What were the facts?

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax appealed an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated April 20, 2018. The ITAT had deleted a disallowance of business loss amounting to Rs. 14,49,33,613/- claimed by the assessee, OSN Infrastructure & Projects Pvt. Ltd. The assessee, involved in land acquisition and construction for the Educomp group, had written off advances given to three parties (M/s Salasar Corporation, M/s Shri Ganpati Trading Company, and M/s Sumit Trading Company) for land consolidation. The Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed this loss, viewing it as a capital loss from unmaterialized land purchases and questioning the assessee's onus to prove the loss was revenue in nature. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] had also disallowed the claim, noting that the settlement deeds were executed after a search and the parties did not respond to Section 133(6) notices. The assessee disputed this lack of opportunity.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT was legally justified in deleting the disallowance of business loss by ignoring the assessee's failure to discharge the initial onus that the loss was actually incurred and was of a revenue nature? (Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961) 2. Whether the ITAT was legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs. 14,49,33,613/- on revenue account by ignoring that the amount represented a write-off of advances given for land purchase, which was in the nature of a capital loss? (Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961) 3. Whether the ITAT was legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs. 14,49,33,613/- on revenue account solely on the basis of the assessee's self-serving claim that advances for unmaterialized land purchases were revenue in nature because the purchases were for stock-in-trade? 4. Whether the ITAT was legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs. 14,49,33,613/- on revenue account even when the claim of advances for unmaterialized land purchase for stock-in-trade was not proved by the assessee? Assessee's Contentions (as inferred from the CIT(A)'s order and the High Court's discussion): The assessee contended that the amounts written off were due to unmaterialized land purchases for stock-in-trade, making the loss revenue in nature. The assessee also argued that it was not confronted with the fact that the parties had not responded to notices and was denied a proper opportunity to present its case despite filing all documents. The assessee's business involved land acquisition and consolidation on behalf of its principals. Revenue's Contentions (as inferred from the CIT(A)'s order and the High Court's discussion): The revenue contended that the loss was capital in nature, not revenue, as it related to advances for land purchase. It also argued that the assessee had not discharged its initial onus to prove the loss was revenue and that the claim was not proved, especially since the settlement deeds were executed after a search and the parties did not respond to notices.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 37

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

ITA 1206/2018 Page 1 of 5 $~24 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 1206/2018 THE PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 .....Appellant Through: Mr. Sanjay Kumar and Ms. Easha, Advocates. versus OSN INFRASTRUCTURE & PROJECTS PVT. LTD. .....Respondent Through: Mr. P. Roychaudhuri, Advocate. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA O R D E R %

30.08.2024 1. The Principal Commissioner impugns the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [‘Tribunal’] dated 20 April 2018 and posits the following questions of law for our consideration: - “2.1 Whether Id. ITAT is legally justified in deleting disallowance of business loss by ignoring a fact that the Assessee had not discharged its initial onus that the loss was actually incurred and it was in the nature of revenue loss? 2.2 Whether the ld. ITAT is legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs.14,49,33,613/- on revenue account by ignoring a fact that the amount represented write off of advances given for purchase of lands which was in nature of capital loss? 2.3 Whether the ld. ITAT is legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs.14,49,33,613/- on revenue account solely on the basis of self- serving claim. of the Assessee that advances were given for purchase of lands was revenue in nature for the reasons that un- materialized purchase of lands were for stock in trade? 2.4 Whether Id. ITAT is legally justified in allowing the loss of Rs.14,49,33,613/- on revenue account even when the claim of advances for unmaterialized purchase of land for stock in trade was This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/09/2024 at 12:21:21

ITA 1206/2018 Page 2 of 5 not proved by the assessee?” 2. We, however, find that while dealing with the explanation which was proffered with respect to the suspect payments as well as the claim for write off, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [‘CIT (A)’] had in its order observed as follows:- “6.1. I have considered the assessment order, the submissions made, the documents filed and also the assessment records (called from the AO). The relevant documents filed before me were also filed before the AO. Facts are that the appellant company is involved in the business of land acquisition and consolidation on behalf of, and also undertaking construction activities, mainly for its principal M/s Educomp Infrastructure and School Management Ltd. (EISM) of the Educomp group. During the year and a year earlier, the appellant company also helped M/s Edusmart Services Pvt. Ltd. (ESS), another company of the Educomp group, in recovery of debt from various trade debtors through the process of debt syndication involving 6 intermediary parties/agents. During the search and surveys conducted on the Educomp group, in which the appellant was also covered, evidence was gathered that the appellant was involved in generation of cash through over- invoicing of works /purchases, as also generation of unaccounted income from the loan syndication business conducted for and on behalf of the Educomp group. When confronted with the evidence collected, director of the appellant company admitted to having earned unaccounted income of Rs.75 crore in two years, out of which income of Rs.59.25 crore was admitted as undisclosed income of the appellant company in AY s 2011-12 and 2012-13 (current AY). The amount of Rs.33.60 crore was offered to tax by the appellant in AY 2011-12 and has been taxed as such. In the current AY (2012-13) the appellant has offered the remaining amount of Rs.25.65 crore to tax. However, in the current A Y, the appellant has also claimed loss in the land acquisition and consolidation business amounting to Rs.14,49,33,613/-, being amounts remaining irrecoverable from three parties, M/s Salasar Corporation, M/s Shri Ganpati Trading Company and M/s Sumit Trading Company, with whom the appellant company had entered into deeds of settlement on 21.03.2012. The agreements for engaging these entities as agents for land consolidation were entered into by the appellant earlier on 17.09.2010, 10.09.2010 and 09.09.2010 respectively. The fact that the deeds of settlement were entered after the date of search perhaps cast a suspicion on the claim, The claim was disallowed as the said 3 parties did not respond to letters issued u/s 133(6) by the revenue, and the claim of This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/09/2024 at 12:21:21

ITA 1206/2018 Page 3 of 5 loss was held to be excessive. Appellant's case is that it was never confronted with the fact that the parties had not responded and, thus, not allowed necessary opportunity despite having filed all documents and evidence which have never been doubted. It is rejection of the claim of loss without proper opportunity which has been disputed by the appellant in this appeal. 6.2 The details of payments made I recovered to I from the three parties are as under: M/s Salasar Corporation, Sirsa PAYMENTS RECEIPTS Date Amount (Rs.) Date Amount (Rs.) 14.09.2010 30000000 05.05.2011 2500000 16.09.2010 50000000 09.05.2011 7250000 23.09.2010 25000000 10.05.2011 15400000 24.09.2010 9000000 11.05.2011 16000000 12.05.2011 17500000 23.05.2011 1747887 02.06.2011 1400000 03.06.2011 2050000 06.06.2011 1000000 07.06.2011 2300000 09.06.2011 918500 03.08.2011 1000000 TOTAL 114000000 TOTAL 69066387 Balance written off 44933613 M/s Shri Ganpati Trading Company, Sirsa PAYMENTS RECEIPTS Date Amount (Rs.) Date Amount (Rs.) 09.09.2010 50000000 TOTAL 50000000 TOTAL 0 Balance written off 50000000 M/s Sumit Trading, Sirsa PAYMENTS RECEIPTS Date Amount (Rs.) Date Amount (Rs.) 21.09.2010 25000000 22.11.2010 25000000 TOTAL 50000000 TOTAL 0 Balance written off 50000000 6.3 The amounts were paid to the three parties from the HDFC This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/09/2024 at 12:21:21

ITA 1206/2018 Page 4 of 5 Bank account of the appellant and amounts returned by M/s Salasar Corporation was from its Axis Bank account. I find that the appellant made these payments from an amount of Rs.50 crore received from EISM on 06.09.2010 and also appellant's own funds and amounts realized on sale of Birla Sun Life Mutual Funds owned by the appellant. The land acquisition account of EISM has been squared up in the books of the appellant by adjustment of Rs.42,50,00,000/- and Rs.50,92,84,600/- (totaling Rs.93,42,84,600/-) transferred by journal entry and debited on 30.03.2011 in the name of one 'Babu Lal', and also against payments for construction activities and service tax account of EISM. The balances in these two accounts as on 31.03.2012 amounting to Rs.6,99,32,078/- (land acquisition account) and Rs.5,97,900/- (construction activities and service tax account), totaling Rs.7,05,29,978/-, have been converted to unsecured loan from EISM, which is duly reflected in the appellant's balance sheet. Thus, except for this amount of unsecured loan, there is nothing to be paid by the appellant to EISM as on 31.03.2012. In the books of the appellant, amounts paid to the three parties are not credited to the account of EISM, implying that these amounts have not been charged to EISM but remained the risk and responsibility of the appellant company. I further find that the appellant company or its directors are not directly or indirectly related to or linked with the entities of the Educomp group. Their relationship is purely business-based. 6.4 The facts of the case are not in dispute. From the above facts, it cannot be concluded that claim of the appellant is incorrect. The only dispute is whether the loss claimed by the appellant company in writing off the amounts due from the land consolidators is an allowable business loss I expense. I have carefully considered the matter. There is no evidence to establish that the amounts written off have been received back in any form by the appellant or its principals. The amounts have actually been written off by way of valid deeds of settlement which are legally enforceable documents. Even if it is assumed that the amounts written off are some sort of compensation paid to some parties through the appellant company, it would still be expenditure in the hands of the appellant company or its principals. I hold accordingly. 6.5 Since the amounts have been written off after executing valid deeds of settlement, legally enforceable documents, the appellant has given up the claim on these amounts. Thus, these amounts partake the character of income in the hands of those persons. I find that no effort has been made to bring to tax the amounts written off as income in the hands of the persons to whom the money was advanced. I, accordingly, direct the AO to furnish the relevant information and documents to the assessing officers of M/s Sumit This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/09/2024 at 12:21:21

ITA 1206/2018 Page 5 of 5 Trading Company, M/s Salasar Corporation and M/s Shree Ganpati Trading Company to initiate necessary action to tax these amounts in their hands in accordance with the law. In case it is found that this money was transferred back by these parties to the appellant or its principals in any form, the amounts so transferred shall be taxable as income of the appellant company or its principals, as the case may be. I also direct the AO to examine the matter relating to adjustment of Rs.93,42,84,600/- by way journal entry on 30.03.2011 debited to Babu Lal during the assessment proceedings for the next A Y 2013-14. 6.6. I also find that the initial submissions of the appellant based ,on the assumption that the amount written off was against monies advanced for acquiring land as stock-in-trade is incorrect to the extent that the appellant is not involved in the business of purchase and sale of land but only acquired and consolidates land on behalf of its principals in the Educomp group.” 3. As is manifest from the above, the payments which were made to various parties were duly explained by the respondent/assessee in detail as would be evident from what stands recorded in paragraph 6.3. 4. Similarly, and insofar as the issue of write off is concerned, the CIT(A) had found that the same was based on validly executed deeds of settlement. It is this view which has ultimately come to be affirmed by the Tribunal. 5. Bearing in mind the consideration accorded by the CIT(A) which came to be affirmed by the Tribunal, we are of the opinion that no substantial question of law arises. 6. The appeal fails and shall stand dismissed. YASHWANT VARMA, J. RAVINDER DUDEJA, J. AUGUST 30, 2024/vp This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/09/2024 at 12:21:21

More judgments on Section 37

All 4,334 judgments and leading authorities on Section 37 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →