Joji Reddy Yeruva vs. Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax and 4 Others
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court, considering the drastic nature of attachment of bank accounts and properties, directed the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal to expeditiously hear the pending appeals of the revenue and cross-objections of the petitioner within six months. The petitioner was directed to deposit 20% of the tax dues as per the first appellate authority's order dated March 31, 2018. Upon such deposit, the attachment of the petitioner's bank accounts and stock-in-trade would be withdrawn. The court further clarified that after the withdrawal of attachment, if the petitioner deposited any amount into his bank accounts, 50% of such deposit should be maintained in the accounts until deemed necessary. The court found that the appeals and cross-objections should be heard expeditiously, and the attachment of stock-in-trade was withdrawn to enable the petitioner to meet tax dues, aligning with the first proviso to Section 254(A) of the Act. The attachment of bank accounts was also to be withdrawn, given that not much money had been recovered from them.
What were the facts?
The petitioner, Joji Reddy Yeruva, filed a writ petition before the High Court challenging the action of the Tax Recovery Officer (Respondent No. 5) in issuing notices under Section 226(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated December 12, 2019, to attach nine of his bank accounts. He also challenged a prior notice dated March 18, 2014, by the same officer, which attached his properties, including stock-in-trade. The petitioner sought directions to operate his bank accounts and release his attached properties. The impugned actions stemmed from assessment orders passed for assessment years 2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10, following a search and seizure action. Appeals against the first appellate authority's orders were pending before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the action of the Tax Recovery Officer in issuing notices under Section 226(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated December 12, 2019, to attach the petitioner's bank accounts is illegal and void? 2. Whether the notice dated March 18, 2014, issued by the Tax Recovery Officer attaching the petitioner's properties, including stock-in-trade, is illegal and void? Assessee's Contentions: The petitioner argued that the attachment of his bank accounts and properties, including stock-in-trade, was a drastic measure that jeopardized his business activities, making it impossible to generate revenue to meet tax dues. He sought permission to operate his bank accounts and release his attached properties. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue's primary contention, as inferred from the context of the proceedings and the subsequent directions, was to ensure recovery of tax dues. While not explicitly detailed in the provided text, their actions of attachment indicate a stance to secure the outstanding demand.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 226(3),Section 132,Section 153(c),Section 143(3),Section 254(A)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) IVONDAY ,THE FIRST DAY OF NOVEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA Between: Joji Reddy Yeruva, S/o. Balreddy Yeruva, aged about 50 years, 7-2-176C1 19A, CZECH Colony 2nd Floor, Ananda Nilayam Sanath Nagar, HYDERABAD- 500081 Telangana State ...PETITIONER 1. Principal Chief Commissioner of lncome Tax, 1Oth Floor, A- Block, l.T Towers, AC Guards Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 500028, Telangana State 3. The Commissioner of lncome Tax (Appeals)-3, Visakhapatnam, Direct Taxes Building, Opp. Raitu Bazaar, Double road, M.V.P.Colony, Visakhapatnam. 4. Deputy Commissioner of lncome Tax Circle- 6(1), 6th Floor, A- Block l. T Towers, AC Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 500028, Telangana State 5. Tax Recovery Officer, O/o. the PCIT-6, 6th Floor, A- Block, l. T Towers, AC Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 500028, Telangana State ...RESPONDENTS WRIT PETITION NO: 2413 OF 2020 2. Principal Commissioner of lncome Tax-6, 6th Floor, A- Block LT Towers, AC Guards Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 500028, Telangana State
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High 'court may be pleased to issue writ order or direction one in the nature of mindam us decliring the action the sth Respondent in issuing the impugned proceedings Notice U/s. 226 (3) of the lncome Tax Act, 1961 dated 1211212019 to the following banks to freeze the petitioners account T :i Nir Name of the Bank lnclLls Ind Ban k tlr ilndian AccoLrnt Ncr 480 r ooso I oooo46 Letr er No. s ITBA / COM/ F/ t7 /20 t9_ 20/to22,2t137211) '2-20,,9 ITBA/ COM / F Dateci: l2- I I 17 I 201() 20 / ro2,22t6307( 1) Date(l: l2-12-20r9 ITBA/ COM/ F/t7 I 20t9- 20 / 1O2,22t 4936( l) l0't8 r 02000006033 ITBA/ COM/ 1000 I 402252 I Uanjara I Iyderabad Hills, b5l053000000 I I6r 652073000000027 652653000003430 6567530000o3741 6526530000037.1 12 Serilingampall ,.] 8a)5 30o0( )5-1,7.1. t llvderarbad 548653000054734 5486530000547.3s s48653000054736 4t3655000000071 ITBA 20/ 1 12-201q lt I 17 I '2O 1t) 20 / 1o222O.2 {)88( I I '2019 Dared: l2 l2- I'niA (l | 20 / 1o,) oMlF/t7/20ts '2'20377 Bll) _ _tls!.1li l2- I 2,2019 |r'trA, col\4/ rr/l72taq. 20 I la22) IoO 1iJ(l) I)irtr'( I lf l-l 2tJl() Sr.rrrr h Inrliirl llank Lt<l,, l'l Ir.,\, ( ()\1 1.. t7:-t(tt (/ l0i t ( )l2l tl.J 1,s( r ) Datct l: ll Lt.l () I rl /coM ,/17/,2ot<_l o22 2138O61t l Dated: 12- l2- 20 t9 And proceedings F No TRCss/DCrr/c c.1tvspt13-14 dated. 18103/2014 attaching the properties consisting "r .i""ii""tr""ae of the petitioner ", iirlgrr ili{fri:;l,,l'Ji J:,T:',i!;"i, "x n: ;i" l,?, .xii rr. . "t. " ; ;;, ; ;' .1i u' " no Dcrl cc. i , vspr rs--ia bur.J o+;;;;;;J,;h;r",,t111r"n,. since the rRcss/ Section 225 of the lncome-tax Act' lsof ;;; i;;;l'':-::"ttarv' to the provisions and arso the attachment or petitioner p..ri,*ti", .r,iil;1"i,::JT,f;;i accounts IA NO: 10F 2020 Branch
Axis Bank MVP Colony, 91102OO1209776r 55700 r 0200o02493
Karnataka Banl< ShantipLlram, 798200o r ooosozo i HDFC Bank Seetham madhara 101835000 20
lDBl Bank eethammadhara ammadhara VisakhaPatnam S Seetl) South lndian Banl( Ltd., Point, Diamoncl
V4aya Bank Visakha patnam Extension LIC Counter, ) TBA CoM F 0 9
'2 I 4 D ted
1 9 Petitton under Secti n tne a ri Ja u i j,"u' "- II,3l:J.i,i:!.,iri: ifl J^;[ i Ax ffiil,J:T,3."Jji :s suspend the proceeding oat"o tz-li_[ilr;ii# 5; Respondenr L f Per.:l-]Z
n/,, ''t- S, NO Axis IJank 9 t1020012097765 55700 10200002493 MVP Colony, lShantipuram, lVisakhapatnanr Sr't lh:rtu r r t:rtllr; r r a \/isal(lla patna lll lnd Seel ha nrnrad ha ra 7982000 t ooo502o I trBAlcoMlFllT 12019- 20 / tO222\ t372ltl Dated: 12 12 2019 ITBAICOM/t; /17 12019- 201 102221630711l, Datcd: 12 l2-2O19 rtrsercoxt ti lti/zotq- 20 I ro222)_4936{.t]. DaLed: 12-12-2019 ITBA / COII./, /F / 17 I 20 t9 20 I 102220268811l' Dated: I2- 12-2019 ITRA I COM /ta / t7 /2Ot9- 20 I tO2220377 Sltl
Karnataka Bar.rk lll)1.( l].rrrl. IO I83i:,0o02066.100 10 181 02000006033 Indus I lan l< 100014022521 Visa k h;r pir tn a nr a) South lndian Banjara tlills, 6520530000001 16 652073000000027 652653000003430 656753000003741 6526530000037412 and permit the petttioner to operate the bank accounts, pending disposal of writ petition. Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the proceeding No. F. No. TRCSS/DCIT/CC.1/VSP/13-14 dated. 1810312014 of the sth Respondent by releasing the attachment of the petitioners properties, pending disposal of writ petition. Namc of the IJank Branch Account No Letter No.s ITBA1COM/Fl17/2019- 20 I t0222l0or8lrl
South Indian Serilingampally, s48653000054733 548653000054734 5486s3000054735 5486530000s4736 rTBA/COM/F/ 1712019- 20 I to222r23t8ltl E $outh Indian Ilank Ltd. , Point, Diamond Llydcrabad 4 I 365500000007 i rrBA/coM/F/ i7l2019- 20 / 10222 r3996ltl Dated: l2-L2-2Q19
Vijaya Bank LIC Extension Counter, ITBAICOM/F lt7 l2Ol9- 20 I 1022224194\rl Dated 12-12-2019 [+. I rour u-.r, Seetlrammadhara Visakhapatnanl t lA NO: 2 OF 2020 Counsel for the Petitionerg:SRl. N PURNACHANDRA RAO Counsel for the Respondents:SRl. K RAJI REDDY, SC FOR lT The Court made the following: 4 80 r 0030 r 000046
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN HONOURABLE DR.JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMAI.ATHA W.P.No.2413 of 2020 ORDER: (>er llctrt b/t 5i .latri.e t-l1a/ tsbuyan) Fleard Mr. N.Pumachandra Rao, leamed counsel for the petitioner, and N{r. K. R .ii Reddy, leamed Senior Standing C-ounsel for Income Tax Department appearing for the respondenm. 2. This lVrit Petition has been filed under Anicte 226 of the Constitution of India for declaring the action of respondent No.5/Tax Recovery Officer in issuing norices under Section 226(3) of the Income Tax Acr, 1961 (briefly'the Act' hereinatter) dxed 12.12.2a19, as illegal and nonest in the ep of iaw. 2.1. Be it stated, by the notice dated 12.12.2019, nine bank accounts of the petitioner have been attached. 3. Petitioner further seeks a declaration that notice dated 18.03.2014 of respondent No.5/Tax RecoveryOfficer is illegal and void. 3.1. Be it stated, by the said notice, properties of the petitioner including stock in rrade were attached. 4. Petitioner further seels a direction to respondenr No.5 to allow him to operate the bank accounts and also to release the propenies including stock- in- trade from attachmenr. 5. From the marerials on record, including the counter-affidavit of the respondents, it is seen that a search and seizure action under Section 132 of the Acr was initiated against M/s Sailakshmi rownship private
Limited, Visakhapatnaru or22.08.2008. During the search and seizure action, incriminating materials relating to the petitioner were recovered' Thereafter, three assessment orders dated 31.12.2010 were passed in respect of the petitioner under Section 1a3(3) read with Section 153(c) oi the Act for the assessment years 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10 raising variou demands. The assessr.tten$ were made by the then Deputy C-omn.rissioner of Income Tax, C-entral Grcle-1, Visakhapatnarn. 6. C-onsequent thereto, Tax Recovery Gnificates were drawn up by respondent No.5 for the three assessment years on 04.11'2afi for various amounts totaling Rs.10,60,65,780.00. Since the assessed taxes were not paid by the petitioner despite notice of demand, immovable properties of the petitioner were aftached. Additionally, bank accounts of the petitionerwere also attached. 7. Against the three orders of assessment, Petitioner prefer-red three appeals before the C-on.rmissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-3, Visakhapatnam (briefly 'first appellate authority' hereinafter). By its orders dated 31.03.2018, the first appellate authority panly allowed those appeals. Follou,ing the said orders, the outstanding demand against the petitioner stood revised to Rs.8,59,96,946.A0. 8. Against the orders passed by the first appellate authority, the revenue preferred further appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Visakhapatnam (for shon 'the Tribunal), which are registered as LT.ANos.32S, 326, and 327 of 2018. Petitioner has also filed
b--
cross-objections in those apPeals. It is stated that those appeals are pending before the Tribunal. Since petitioner did not paythe dues, his bank accounts were atuched. Ftrowever, only an amount of Rs.25,128.00 has been recovered from his account maintained with the South Indian Bank, Diamond Point Branch, Secunderabad. g. \)fle find that during pendencyof the appeals and cross-ob,iections before the Tribunal, petitioner has filed stay application before the Principal C.ommissioner of Income Tax-6, Hyderabad and the said authority passed an order on 05.02.2020, directing the petitioner to pay 5Oo/o of the demand on or before 28.02.2020 for considering his stay till disposal of the appeals. However, dll date, petitioner has not complied with the order dated 05.02.202A. 10. We have given due consideration to the submissions made by leamed counsel for the panies. l. Attachment of bank account as well as property of a penon is a drastic measure. Of course, such provisions are provided in the statute to ensure recovery of the dues. Nonetheless, in the given facs and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that the appeals filed by the revenue and cross-objections filed bythe petitioner should be heard expeditiotu ly bi, the Tribunal. 12. Our attention has also been drawn to the provisions of Section 254Q.A) of the Act, more paniculariy, to the first proviso thereto, as per which, the Tribunal can pass an order of stay subject to
the condition that the essessee deposits not less rhan 2ao/o of the amount of tax, interest etr., or furnishes security of equal amount. 13. At this stage, leamed counsel for the petitioner submits that as his properties including the stock-in-trade have been anached, his business activities have been complerely jeopardirc.d, for which reason he is unable to generate any revenue lor pal,rnent of the tax dues. 14. In the light o[ the contentions made and taking an o\rer all view of the matter, we feel that it would meet the ends of justice, if the attachment of tl-re stock-in-trade of the petitioner is withdrawn to enable him to meer the tax dues in terms of the first proviso to Section 254 QA) of the Act. In view of the statement made by the revenue itself that not much money could be appropriated through attachment of bank accounts, attachment of the bank accounts may be withdrawn. 15. Accordingly, and in the light of rhe above, we pass the following orders: (1) Tribunal is directed to expeditiously hear the three appeals of the fuvenue and corresponding Cross Objections of the petitioner, preferably within a period of six months from today. (2) Petitioner shall deposit 2Oo/o of the tax dues following the ordcr p,used by rhe first .rppcilatc aurhodry on I 1.01.2018. (l) On such deposit, atrachment of the petitioner's bank accouns as well a-s the stock-in-tradc shall stand withdrawn fonhwirh. (4) However, we clarify that post-withdrawal of attachment, if the petitioner deposits any amounr into the bank accoilnts, the bank authorities shall ensure that 5Oo/o of such
deposit is maintained in the accounts till such time as is considered necessary. 16. With the above direaions, Vrir petition is disposed of. Related Interlocutory Applications are also disposed of. 17. No costs. \ //TRUE COPY// SD/.N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO ASSISTANT REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER To, P[/ 1. Principal Chief Commissioner of lncome Tax, 1Oth Floor, A- Block, LT Towers, AC Guards Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 5OOO2S, Telangana'State 2. Principal commissioner of rncome Tax-6, 6th Froor, A- Btock iT Towers, AC - Guards Masab Tank, Hyderabad- S0OO28, Telangana State 3. The commissioner of rncome Tax (Appears)-3, Visakhapatnam, Direct Taxes Building, Opp. Raitu Bazaar, Double road, M.V.p.Colony, Visaknapatn"m. -- 4. Deputy Commissioner of lncome Tax Circle_ 6(1), 6th Floor, A_ glock f. i _ Towers, AC Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad_'sii002g, Telangana State 5. Tax Recovery Officer, O/o. the pClT:6, 6th Ftoor, A_ Btock, f . f ior"i., nC ^ Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad- 5OOO28, Telangana State 6. One CC to Sri. N purnachandra Rao, Advocate tdpucl I. 9n" !! !o sri K Raji Reddy, SC for tT topucl 8. Two CD Copies. 9. One Spare Copy.
HIGH COURT DATED:01/1 1/2021 ORDER WP.No.2413 ot 2020 Disposing of the WP Without costs. t 11 Nw?ii?l rA7't: E
c)l) e Co l4 to ( \ \:
More judgments on Section 226(3)
- Begur Srinivasashetty Naveenkumar… vs Income Tax Officer, Ward 1, ChamarajanagarITA 1039/BANG/2026[2020-2021]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-2021
- Begur Srinivasashetty Naveenkumar… vs Income Tax Officer, Ward 1, ChamarajanagarITA 1039/BANG/2026[2020-2021]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-2021
- Shaik Rahmathulla, Bengaluru vs Income Tax Officer, Ward - 1(2)(5)…ITA 170/BANG/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed29 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- Thoti Sankaraiah, Chittoor vs Income Tax Officer, Ward-1, ChittoorITA 2094/HYD/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed16 Oct 2026AY 2016-17
- Abhaykumar Bansilal Sancheti vs Principal Commissioner of Income Tax 3 PuneWP/7165/20269 Oct 2026
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Kamdhenu Udyog Private Limited And Anr vs. The Assistant Commissioner Of Revenue Office Of The Charge Office, CT, Bhabanipur Charge And OrsCalcutta · 12 Nov 2026
- Keshab Joshi vs. State Of West Bengal And Ors.Calcutta · 12 Nov 2026
- Binayak Nayak vs. The Assistant Commissioner, GST And Central Excise, BbsrOrissa · 12 Nov 2026
- M/S Sunil Kumar Agrawal LLP, Raipur vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 12 Nov 2026
- Life Insurance Corporation Of INDIA vs. The Insurance Ombudsman And 2 OrsGauhati · 11 Nov 2026