APR JEWELLERS PRIVATE LIMITED vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)

PDF · subscribers
WP/13926/2022HC TelanganaHBHC01018494202222 April 2022Author: SUREPALLI NANDA,UJJAL BHUYAN10 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court set aside the impugned order dated March 4, 2022, passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). The Court reasoned that the CIT(A), as an appellate authority exercising quasi-judicial powers, is not bound by administrative circulars issued by the CBDT. The CIT(A) must apply their own independent mind to the facts and circumstances of each case. The Court noted that the CIT(A) was guided by the CBDT office memorandum dated July 31, 2017, which stipulated a 20% deposit for stay, and that the Supreme Court in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. L.G. Electronics India Private Ltd. had clarified that a quasi-judicial authority can grant a deposit order of a lesser amount than 20% in individual cases. Therefore, the matter was remanded back to the CIT(A) for a fresh decision on the stay prayer in accordance with law and after complying with the principles of natural justice, to be done within four weeks. Until then, the demand pursuant to the assessment order dated December 21, 2019, shall remain stayed.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, APR Jewellers Private Limited, is an assessee under the Income Tax Act, 1961. For Assessment Year 2017-18, the Assessing Officer passed an assessment order dated December 21, 2019, under Section 143(3), making additions under Section 69A and assessing income at Rs. 1,50,03,952.00 against a returned income of Rs. 1,78,860.00. The petitioner filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)), which was pending. The Assessing Officer issued demand notices followed by garnishee notices. The petitioner filed a stay petition on April 5, 2021, which was not considered. The petitioner then approached the High Court, which directed the CIT(A) to decide the stay petition within six weeks and stayed the demand until then. Subsequently, the CIT(A) passed an order dated March 4, 2022, granting conditional stay, requiring the petitioner to deposit 20% of the outstanding demand of Rs. 1,48,02,444.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the action of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) in disposing of the stay petition by directing the petitioner to deposit 20% of the outstanding demand is illegal, arbitrary, and against the principles of natural justice, violating Articles 14 of the Constitution, relevant CBDT instructions, and High Court judgments? Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that the CIT(A)'s order was illegal, arbitrary, and against natural justice. It was contended that the CIT(A) was guided by a CBDT office memorandum dated July 31, 2017, which mandates a 20% deposit for stay, without applying independent mind to the facts of the case. The assessee relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. L.G. Electronics India Private Ltd., which held that an administrative circular would not bind a quasi-judicial authority and that it is open to grant a lesser deposit amount. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 69A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF APRIL TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA WRIT PETITION NO: 1 3926 0F 2022 Betwee n: APR JEWELLERS PRIVATE LIVITED, (pan No AALCA3233D) Rep. Bv tts It4anaging Director Sri Rama Krshna Rebdy Ambati, Office atll.flo.'a-_O-_2g0, Flat No.3, Qloynd Floor, S_4-Tirumata T5wers, Opp. Hotel Centrif -parf<i Hyderguda' Hyderabad -500029 ...pErroNER 1 . The Commissioner of lncome Ta 2. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward 1( Appeals), Hyderabad-1. I ncome rax Depa rtment, 1[t"JBBi,tr*r, x( 2), Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to pass an order or orders or a writ more particularly one in the nature of writ of Mandamus and declare the action of the Respondent No. 1 in disposing of the stay Petition dt. 0510412021 fited by the writ petitioner against the Assessment Order No. ITB A/AST/S/143 (3)t2019- 2Ol1O22B24Og4 dt. 21-12- 201 9 for the A.Y.201 7-1 8 of the Respondent No. 2 vide orders dt. 04.03.2022 by directing the petitioner herein to deposit a sum equivalent to 20% of the outstanding demand of Rs. 1,48,02,0441- so as to avoid the petitioner being treated as not being default of the above said demand as illegal, arbitrary and against the Principles of Natural Justice and in violation of Article 14 and contrary to the relevant instructions issued by CBDT and contrary to the guidelines issued by the judgements of the Hon'ble High courts and consequently set aside the order dt. 04.03.2022 vide Appeal No CIT(A), Hyderabad-1/1 043012019-20 passed by Respondent No. 2

lA NO: 1 oF 2022 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay of all further recovery proceedings of the Respondent No.2 till the disposal of the present petition Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI SRIRIPURAM KESHAVA, COUNSEL FOR SRI CHALLA GUNARANJAN Counsel for Respondents: SRI K. RAJI REDDY Sr. SC FOR INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT The Court made the following: ORDER // {

W,P.No.13926 of 2022 THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA 1VRIT PETITION No.13926 of 2022 ORDER: (Per Hon'ble Sn Justice UljaL Bhugan) Heard Mr.Siripuram Keshava, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. Challa Gunaranjan, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. K. Raji Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for Income Tax Department for the re spo n dents. 2. Petitioner is aggricved by order dated 04.O3.2022 passed b5, the 1"t respondent to the effect that petitioner u,ould nol be trcated as being in default if the petitioner deposits 2Oo/a of the outstanding demand on or 3. It may be mentioned that petitioner 15 an assessee under the Income Tax Act, 196 i (briefly referred before 20.03.2022.

to hereinalter as 'the Act') assessed to tax n'ithin the jurisdiction of respondent No.2. 4. For the assessment year 2017-18, respondent No.2 passed assessment order dated 21.12.2019 under Section 143(3) of the Act making certain additions under Section 69,,{ of the Act. Against the returned income of the petitioner of Rs.1,78,860'00, by the aforesaid assessment order, income of the petitioner was assessed at Rs. 1,50,03,952.0O. 5. Against the aforesaid order of assessment, petitioner has preferred appeal before the 1"t respondent' It is stated that the appeal is pending. 6. In the meanwhile, 2"d respondent issued demand notices, which were foliowed by garnishee notices' Though petitioner had filed a stay petition before the 1"t respondent on 05.04.202 1, the same was not considered while the petitioner faced demand with garnishee notices.

l, W.P.No. 13926 of 2022 7. It was at that stage that petitioner had approached this Court by filing W.p.No.3 1826 of 2027. The said writ petition r,r,as disposed of on 03.I2.2021 und er: AS "6. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and on due consideration, we are of the view that it would meet the ends of justice if a direction is issued to the Appellate Authority i.e., respondent No. 1 to take up the stay petition of the petitioner dated OS.O4.2O2l and pass appropriate orders thereon in accordalce with law. We are of the further opinion that the said stay petition should be decided within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. Till such time, the demald pursuant to assessment order stayed." dated 21, 12.2019 shall remarn B. Thereafter, lst respondent passed a long order dated 04.03 .2022 grantrng conditionai stay. Relevant portion of the order dated 04.03.2022 reads as under: "lo.l The assessee appeilant will be treated as not bcing in dcfault in respect of the amount ol demand of _Rs.1,48,02,444 outstanding at present, (after payment of

UE, J& SI{, J amount as indicated below), subject to the followrng conditions being fu1fr1led. 1. The appellant deposits a sum equivalent to 2O"/o of the above outstanding demand of Rs.7,48,O2,444 on or before 2O.O3.2O22 a:ncl submits evidence of such payment of demand to the Assessing Offrcer. 2. The appellant must cooperate in the early disposal of its appeal and make its necessary submissions in compliance of notice(s) issued in this regard. The above conditior-rs having been ful{illed : 1. The appeal on merits in the case of the appellant will be taken up, out of turn for early disposal for which notice for hearing is being issued separately' 2. No coercive measures will be taken for recovery of reminder oI outstar-rding demald against the appellant if the appellant complies with Sr'No 1 above. 3. This order will be reviewed after expiry of 3 months from the date of order, or if the appeal order is not passed by such time Period. 4 . This order will not impinge on the right of the Assessing oflicer to adjust refunds arising, if arry against the demand. 5. This order is without prejudice to the proceedings and hna1 outcome the appeal to be decided on the grounds of appeal filed by the appellant."

9.

On a perusal of the impugned order dated O4.O3.2O22, it is seen that 1st respondent was guided by the office memorandum dated 31.07.2017 of the Central Board of Direct Ta-xes (CBDT), as per which stay may be granted in cases where appeals are pending subject to payment o{ 2Oak of the disputed demand. Thus, foilowing the CBDT office memorandum dated 31 .O7 .2077 , the impugned order came to be passed. 10. Supreme Court in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. L.G. Electronics India Private Ltd,r, observed that an administrative circular would not operate as a factor on the Commissioner since it is a quasi-judicial authority. Clarifying further, Supreme Court held that it would be open to the authority on the facts of individual cases to grant deposit orders of a lesser amount than 2Oo/o pending appeal. r (2018) 18 Supreme Court Cases 447

11.

Needless to say, 1"t respondent as the appellate authority exercises quasi-judicial powers' Power to consider prayer lor stay is incidental and anci1lary to the power to hear appeals. As a quasi-judicial authority, Commissioner (Appeals) is not bound by the administrative circulars issued by CBD'I'. He has to apply his olr'n independent mind in the facts and circumstances of each case. 12 . Considering the above , the impugned order dated 04.03.2022 is hereby set aside. The matter is remanded back to the lst respondent for a fresh decision on the prayer for stay of the petitioner in accordance with 1au' after complying with the principles of natural justice' This shal1 be done within a period of four (04) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. Ti1l such time, demand pursuant to the assessment order dated 21 .12.2019 sha1l remain staYed.

\a&*-- 13. This disposes of the Writ Petition. However, there shall be no order as to costs. 14. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications per-rding, if any , in this Writ Petition, sha11 stand closed. //TRUE COPY// SD/-T.SRINIVAS ASSISTANT REGISTRAR SECN#oFFICER oneFair""or,,r..l[[t?]l3i.f ,:?,iH?:i",: jiir^'BHUYAN oneFairc"py.(H.E#?i;?!"=,,'ll1'i,H:rJ3i:jii'"ALLTNANDA To' rf lncome Tax (Appeals)' Hyderabad-l' I Ii3 P.:['TJT:T3-"; ""'"^U;d (2i' iibome raibepartment' Hvderabad i. lljS;&?"?lretary, union or lndia' tr/inistry or Law' Justice and companv t[3 S;]:u,?Hirngrnu Advocates Association Library' Hish court ,3llEE #iif, lli ftffi;:tl:#Y.;:ilsJ33Y3l'u,un'"n'i (oPuc) Two CD Copies One SPare CoPY

6.

7. B. 9. MBC sB1 AJ

HIGH COURT DATED: 2210412022 kiE SiA r€ ( rci t))) 2B?.? MAY

1;F,..7 ...),- t ORDER WP.No.13926 of 2022 DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION

WITHOUT COSTS +'\

More judgments on Section 69A

All 15,970 judgments and leading authorities on Section 69A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →