M/s. Electronics Corporation of India Limited (ECIL) vs. Central Board of Direct Taxes, Ministry of Finance,

PDF · subscribers
WP/14951/2005HC TelanganaHBHC01018735200529 January 2024Author: P.SAM KOSHY,N.TUKARAMJI12 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the writ petition, setting aside the order of rejection by Respondent No. 2 and remitting the matter back to Respondent No. 2 for passing a fresh order. The Court reasoned that the petitioner, being a public sector undertaking, faced genuine administrative and procedural hurdles in obtaining necessary approvals, which led to a delay of approximately 29 days in clearing the outstanding tax liability. The Court noted that there was no apparent mala fide intention or deliberate attempt by the petitioner to avoid tax payment. Crucially, the Court took into consideration the subsequent CBDT order dated June 26, 2006, which empowered the Chief Commissioner and Director General to reconsider applications for waiver of interest, including those previously rejected. The Court directed Respondent No. 2 to provide an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and to pass a decision within four months from the receipt of the order. The issue of whether the petitioner's specific circumstances qualified for waiver under the circulars was left for Respondent No. 2 to decide.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Electronics Corporation of India Limited (ECIL), a Central Public Sector Undertaking under the Department of Atomic Energy, filed a writ petition challenging the rejection of its application for waiver of interest levied under Sections 234B and 234C for Assessment Year 2003-2004. The total interest disputed was Rs. 61,38,142/- under Section 234B and Rs. 1,25,77,012/- under Section 234C. The petitioner's application for waiver was initially rejected by the Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (Respondent No. 2) on October 26, 2004, and subsequently by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (Respondent No. 1) on January 19, 2005, on the grounds that they were not empowered to review the order of Respondent No. 2. The delay in tax payment was attributed to administrative and procedural requirements for obtaining approvals from the administrative ministry, coupled with an unprecedented increase in turnover during the last quarter of the financial year 2002-2003.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the respondents (CBDT and Chief Commissioner of Income Tax) were justified in rejecting the petitioner's application for waiver of interest under Sections 234B and 234C for Assessment Year 2003-2004, considering the administrative and procedural delays faced by the petitioner, a public sector undertaking. Assessee's Arguments: - The petitioner argued that as a public sector undertaking, it must adhere to strict administrative and procedural requirements, including obtaining approvals from its administrative ministry (Department of Atomic Energy) for budget submissions and expenditure. These procedures caused a delay in the payment of advance tax for the last quarter. - The delay in payment of Rs. 10 crores was only for approximately 29 days, from March 31, 2003, to April 29, 2003. - The petitioner relied on CBDT Circular dated January 30, 1997, and a subsequent order dated June 26, 2006, which empowered the Chief Commissioner or Director General to consider applications for reduction or waiver of interest under Section 234C, even for previously rejected cases. Revenue's Arguments: - The revenue, represented by the learned Senior Standing Counsel, contended that the relevant facts were considered by Respondent No. 1 on an earlier occasion when the order dated June 20, 2004, was passed, and therefore, there was no scope for further indulgence in the writ petition.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 234B,Section 234C,Section 119(2)(a)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

t 337e 1 M/s. Electronlcs Corporation of lndia Limited (ECIL 062, Represented by its G.M. Finance Arlr. B. Ashok about 56 years. ), ECIL P.O. Hyderabad - 500 S/o B. Satya Sundar Rao, Aged Between: I HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) IUONDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF JANUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI WRIT PETITION NO.14951 OF 2005 ...PETITIONER

Central Board of Direct Taxes, lrlinistry of Finance, Department of Revenue Government of lndia, North Block, New Delhi Represent6d by its Chairman Chief Commissioner of lncome Tax (1), Aayakar Bhavan, Hyderabad Assistant Commissioner of lncome Tax, Circle 1(3), Aayakar Bhavan, Hyderabad ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a Writ, direction or order especially in the nature of Writ of mandamus directing the Respondents 1 and 2 to reconsider the case of the petitioner for Waiver of interest levied Under Sections 234 B and C in the sum of Rs. 61,38,142l- and Rs. 1,25,77,O121- respectively for the Assessment year 2003- 2004, rt necessary by appropriate special order relaxing the rigor of the said sections to the peculiar class of income as in the case of the petitioner.

l.A. NO: 1 OF 2005(WPMP. NO: 1 9001 0F 2005) Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased stay the impugned demarrd for waiver if interest levied under sections 234 B and c in the sum of Rs.61,38,1421- and Rs. 1,2s,77,o12l- respectively for the assessment year 2003-2004. Counsel for the lretitioner: SRt M. NAGA DEEpAK, REPRESENTING SRI S. RAVI, SENIOR COUNSEL Counsel for the Flespcindents: SRI J. V. PRASAD, . SENIOR STANDING COUNSEL FOR INCOME TAX The Court made the following: ORDER

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI WRIT PETITION No.14951 of 2OO5 ORDER: ber Hoi'bte Si Justrce P.sAltr KosHY) The present writ petition has becn filed seeking the following relief: "...1o issue a writ, direction or order cspecially in the nature of writ of mandamus directing the Respondents 1 and 2 to reconsider the case of the Petitioner for waiver of interest levied under Sections 2348 and 234C irt the sum of Rs.61,38,142/- and Rs. 1,25,77,O12/- respectively for the Assessment Year 2OO3-O4, if necessary by appropriate special order relaxrng the rigor of the said sections to the peculiar class of income as in the case of the Petitioner... " 2. Heard Mr. M. Naga Deepak, learned counsel representing Mr. S. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. J. V. Prasad, learned Senior Standir.rg Counscl for Income Tax appearing lor thc respondents. 3. The necessity for filing of the prescnt writ petition came up after the application hled by the petitioner sceking for waiver of interest stood hrst rejected by the respondent No.2 / Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (1) uide order dated 26.IO.2OO4. 4. Subsequent to the rejection of app'lication for waiver o[ interest by thc responclcnr No.2, the petitioner had approached respondent No. 1/Central Board of Direct Taxcs(for short 'CBDT). Howev-er, the

respondent No.l also uide its order dated 19.01.2005 rejected the matter hold ng that they were not empo\arcred to review an order passed by the respondent No.2 on the issue of ',vaiver of interest. 5. The re levant facts which need to be considered are that the petitioner is a Ccntral Public Sector Undertaking which is under the administrative control of the Department of Alomic Encrgz. The petitioner is engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of electronic gcods and components. For the assessment year 2OO3- 2004, Lhe p,:titioner filed a re turn of income on 01.12.2003. I'he petitioner hal returned a total income of Rs.62,94 ,82,443 /- and the tax thereon v,as determined at Rs.23,13,34,798/-. The pctitioner also had to its crrdit, tax deduction at source under various provisions of the Act, in the gross sum of Rs.83,32,598/-. The petitioner further paid a sum of Rs.IO crores on 30.04.2003 and a further sum of Rs.2,65,2O,1i:9 /- by way of self-assessme nt on 28. 1 1.2OO3. 6. As per the audited accounts, the turnover and profit is Rs.926.88 crcres and Rs.80.58 crores respectively. Thus, thc increase in profit from the revised estimates prepared in AugusL,2002, is more than 10 fold f rom Rs.8 crores to 80.58 crores. The ta-x liability tor the first Lhree ins;tallments was made on the revised budget estimates. However, bcczuse of certain unprecedented transactions that dropped

up in the turnover of the fourth quarter, the payment of interest also has arisen 7 . I t was the contenlion of the learned counsel for the petitioner that since it is a pubiic sector undertaking, it needs to prepare and submit budget to the administralive ministry i.e. the department of atomic energr and upon submission of the said budget, the income and expenditure is made according to the budget approved by the concerned department. The budget is submitted before the commencement of the financial year and the revised budget is also submitted in September for the same financial year. According to the learned counsel for the pelitioner because of the administrative and procedural requirements in the department, where necessary approvals have to be obtained from the concerned administrative ministry, there was some delay that arose in the payment of tax in respect of the turnover that took place in the last quarter. 8. According [o the learned counsel for the petitioner, the tax liability was to be cleared by 31.03.2003, however, because of administrative reasons it could only be cleared by 29.O4.2OO3. Thus, there was a delay of only 29 days in clearing of dues which was primarily because of unprecedented rise in the turnover in the last quarter for the hnancial year 2OO2-O3 and also on account of the procedural requirements that is required to be met before the

payment could bc made so far as the excess tax that was requircd to be paid b1' 31.O3.20O3 which in fact could be paid only by 29.O4.2t]o3. 9. Immerliately, Lhereafter the petitioner had approached respondent No.2 for waiver of interest charged under Section 2348 and 234C for thc assessment year 2OO3-O4. The rcspondcnt No.2 uide its order deted 26.10.2004 considered the same and rejected the application seeking waver of interest. Thereafter, the petitioner approached Lhe respondent No. 1 which again refused to entertain the said application on the ground that it was not empowered to review an order passed by the respondent No.2 which led to filing of the present writ petition. 1O. It has been contended that the pctitioner on an earlicr occasion flled a Writ Petition No.2395 of 2O05 which srood disposed of on 05.04.2005 whereby the petitioner was directed to approach the "Committee rn Disputes" for necessary decision on the samc. The Committee o 1 Disputes uide its order dated 20.O5.2005 disposed the said proceedings giving clearance to the petitioner to pursue the appeal in vierv of the questions of fact of law involved in the matter. 11. Learne,l counsel for the petitioner rcferrcd to t.hc provision of para 2(c) of the CBDT notificarion date d 3O.O 1. 1997 whcreby therc was power :onferrecl upon thc Chief Commissioner or Director

General upon being saLisfied with the facts and circumstances of the case for reduction of waiver of intcrest chargeable under Section 234C of the Income Tax Act. The relevant provision of the said circular is reproduced herein under: "Where any income chargeable to income-tax under aly head of income, other than 'Capital ga.ins' is received or accrues after the due date of payment of the [-r.rst or subsequent installments of advance tax which neither anticipated nor was in the contemplation of the assessee and the advance tax on such income is pard in the remaining insta-llments and the Chief Commissioner or Director General is sarisfied on the facts and circumstances o[ the case that this is a flt case for reduction of waiver of interest chargeable under section 234C of Lhe Income Tax Act-" L2. It was relying upon the said circular by which the respondent No.2 had rejected the same uide order dated 26.1O.20O4. On 26.06.2006 there was yet another order issued by the CBDT whereby the Chief Commissioner of Income Tax or Director General of Income Tax were again empowered to consider the applications lor reduction of waiver of interest under Section 234C of the lncome Tax. CIause (b) of the said order reads as under: "Any income chargeable to income-tax under any head of income, other than "Capital gains" is received or accrued after due date of payment of the first or subsequent instalments of advance tax which was neither anticipated nor was in the contemplation of the assessee, and the advance tax on such income is paid in the remaining insta.lment or instalments, and the Chief Commissioner/Director General is satished on thc facts and circumstances of the case that it is a fit case for

rcduction or waiver ol the intcrest chargcablc undcr scction 234C of the lncome-Tax Act-" 13. Furthtrr, paragraph 4 of the said order would also give an indication tl at the authorities concerned were also given lhe pou'er to even reconsider the matters which stood rejected or decided' For ready refererlce, paragraph 4 is also reproduced herein under: "Eartier Orders under section 119(2)(a) dated 23-5-1996 and 30- I 1997 on the subject stand superseded by this Ordr'r. If any petition in the past has been rejectcd bccause the Board had not issued this direction earlier, such petition may be reconsidered and decided in accordance with this Order. If any petition in the past was allowed in accordance with the Orders under section I l9(2)(a) dated 23-5-1996 and 30-1-1997, such Orders allov.ing waiver should not be reopened / revised as per the g1-ridelines contained in this Order." I4. In the light of the aforesaid revised circular issucd by the CBDT dated 20.O6.2006 emporvering the Chief Commissioner and the Dircctor Ger eral of Income Tax to consider and decide reduction of waiver of int:rest under Section 234A, B and C, what is necessary at this juncturt, to consider is that admittedly the petitioner is a central public sccto - undertaking exclusively owned by the Government ol Inclia r.vhich :omes directly under the ministry of atomic encrgr. From perusal of the order ol rejectior-i of the application for waiver of interest by the respondent No.2, it stands established that the said increase in tr.trnover arose only in the last quarter of tl-re hnancial ycar 2OO2-O3. TL e required tax was to be paid by the petitioner by

31.03.2003. The entire exccss tax liability of Rs. lO crores was to be paid before 31.03.2003 however the remaining tax liability was paid on 29.O4.2OO3 i.e. only with a delay of just around 29 days. 15. The reason assigned by the pctitioner was that since it was directly under the ministry of atomic e ners/, administrativc approvals and sanctions were required to be obtained lrom the concerned ministry. On account of certain administrative reasons, certain delays arose in clearing the balance of payment of Rs. l0 crores which was immediately cleared within a short span of time of less than a month from the last date by which it was to be paid. Apparently there does not seem to be any case of mala fide on the part of the petitioner for not clearing the said outstanding dues, nor is the case of the respondents that the act on the part of the petitioner was with a deliberate intention of avoiding paymcnt of tax or cvasion of tax. 16. Further, admittedly the Chief Commissioncr as also the Dircctor General were empowered to consider the factual aspects of the case which led to delayed payment of tax. The reasons assigned by petitioner does not seem to be in dispute by the Iearned Scnior Standing Counsel for Income Tax. Except for the fact that the learned Senior Standing Counsel submits that these relevant facts were in facr duly considercd by the rcspondcnt No.1 on an earlier occasion

when thc order dated 20.06.2004 was passed and there was as such no scope of ,rny further indulgence in this writ petition. L7. In the factual backdrop narrated in the preceding paragraphs and also tal:ing note of the subsequent order of the CBDT issued on 26.06.2006, r,r,e arc of the considered opinion that particularly taking into consideration thc fact that the petitioner being an public sector undertaking, the reasons assigned by the learned counsel for the petitioner w.rich led to delayed clearing of the outstanding payment of Rs. 1O crores and also considering the fact that payment of Rs.lO crorcs was i e fact made in less than a month's time from the last datc on which it -e11 due. It is a fit case u,here in the opinion of this Bench, the matter necds rcconsideration by the respondent No.2 and the order to the aforesaid extent stands set aside and the matter stands remitted back to the respondent No.2 for passing of fresh order keeping in v.ew the subsequent order of the CBDT dated 20.06.2006. 18, Consirlering the Iong lapse that has lapsed in between, it is expected thzrt rcspondenL No.2 shall give an opportunity of hearing to thc pe tition,:r bcfore passing of a fresh order. Furthcr, taking into consideration that the issuc involves paymcnt of tax liability so lar as the financiel year 2OO2-O3, the respondent No.2 should take an appropriate decision within an outer limit of four (04) months from the date of r:ceipt of a copy of this ordcr.

To, MP GJP Yt' 19. With the above observations, the present writ petition stands allowed. However, there shall no order as to costs. Consequently, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand closed. SD/- C. PRAVEEN KUMAR ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// SECTI N OFFICER 1. The Chairman, r Central Board of Direct Taxes, tr4inistry of Finance, Department of Revenue Government of lndia, North Block, New Delhi. 2. The Chief Commissioner of lncome Tax (1), Aayakar Bhavan, Hyderabad. 3. The Assistant Commissioner of lncome Tax, Circle 1(3), Aayakar Bhavan, Hyderabad 4. One CC to SRI S. RAVI, Senior Counsel [OPUC] 5. One CC to SRI J. V. PRASAD, S.C. for INCOME TAX [OPUC] 6. Two CD Copies

HIGH COURT DATED:291O112024 ORDER WP.No.14951 of 2005 ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS q .d* vY...- -61c{ A.r L e a) c\= a" * 3 H * o ul Fto .\ \ EJ G

More judgments on Section 234B

All 10,750 judgments and leading authorities on Section 234B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →