Sri Rajendra Prasad Bansiwal vs. The Income Tax Officer

PDF · subscribers
WP/8421/2024HC TelanganaHBHC01016375202402 April 2024Author: SUJOY PAUL,N.TUKARAMJI10 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court, in a common order, allowed all the writ petitions. The Court noted that it is common ground that the reassessment process was modified by the Finance Act, 2021, and the respondents had not taken this into account, rendering the notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, unsustainable. The Court referred to its previous common order dated September 14, 2023, in W.P. No. 25903 of 2022 and connected matters. In that order, the Court had held that the procedure adopted by the respondent department was in contravention of the Finance Act, 2021, and the directives of the Supreme Court in Ashish Agarwal. Consequently, the impugned notices and proceedings were set aside and quashed. The Court further held that as a consequence, all consequential orders passed by the respondent department pursuant to the notices would also be quashed. The Court reserved liberty for both parties to take respective stands and proceed in accordance with law as per paragraph 38 of the aforementioned Supreme Court order in Ashish Agarwal. No costs were awarded.

What were the facts?

The petitioners, including Aruna Devi Vancha, Sri Rajendra Prasad Bansiwal, Sri Mahesh Reddy Allola, Smt. Swapna Yalala, and S. Kamala B Boinwad, filed writ petitions before the High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad. They challenged orders passed by the Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, and Income Tax Officers under Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessment years involved were 2015-16, 2019-20, 2018-19, and 2015-16. The petitioners argued that the reassessment notices and subsequent orders were illegal, arbitrary, and violative of Sections 148A, 149, and 151A of the Act, as well as CBDT circulars, due to non-compliance with the modified reassessment process introduced by the Finance Act, 2021. The respondents are the Income Tax Department authorities.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the subsequent proceedings are illegal and liable to be quashed for non-compliance with the modified reassessment procedure introduced by the Finance Act, 2021? (Question of law) 2. Whether the reassessment orders passed under Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Act are bad in law, arbitrary, and void ab initio due to procedural irregularities? Assessee's Contentions: The petitioners argued that the respondents failed to follow the reassessment procedure as modified by the Finance Act, 2021. They contended that the notices issued under Section 148 of the Act were bad in law, and consequently, the consequential orders were also bad in law. They relied on the principle that if the initiation of proceedings is procedurally flawed, subsequent orders are automatically nullified. They also cited the Supreme Court's decision in Ashish Agarwal. Revenue's Contentions: The judgment does not explicitly record the revenue's contentions. However, it notes a consensus between the parties.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 144B,Section 148A,Section 149,Section 151A,Section 148

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

[ 3403 I HIGH COURT FOR TH€ STATEOF TELAI.IGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY,THE SECOND DAY OF APRIL TWO THOUSAND ANID TWENW FOUR PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUJOY PAUL THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI WRIT PETITION NOS:841 8. 8421.8443.8458 .8a90 ANO 85'l 10F2024 W.P.NO: 8418 OF 2021

Aruna Devi Vancha, D/o. Sri M. Veera Reddy, aged about 66 yeac, Occ Agriculture, North Avenue 29, Near Apollo Readh Fbspital' Saraswathi Nagar, Karimnagar -5o50o1' ...pETrroNER Assessment Unit, Natiorral Faceless Assessment Centre, lncome Tax Department, Miniltry of Finance, Room No. 1O1, 2nd Floor, E-Ramp, Jairaharlal Nehru Stadium, Delhi - 110 0O3. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward - 2, Myakar Bhavan, Near Natraj Theatre' Karimnagar - 505001' ...RES'oNDENTS Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1"t Respondent u/s. 147 r'w's 144E of the Act, d1.14tO312O24 with DIN No lTBNASTlSl147lzO23- 2411062620742(1) for{he Ay.2015-16, as arbitrary, i{legal, bad in law, void ab initio, apart from being violative of provisions of section 148 A and sectioo 149 of the Act and also contrary to the circular issued by GBDT and provisions of section 151A of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1st Respondent uls. 147 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dt.141O3.2O24 with DIN No lTStuAST/S 114712023' 24t'1O6262O7 42(1 ) for the Ay.2O15-16 and all consequential proceedings pursuant thereto I

lA NO: 1 OF 2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased lo stay all. further proceedings, including an)r recovery, pursuant to the order passed by the 1"t Respondent uls. 147 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dl.14to3t2o24 with DIN No:lTBA"/AST/S I 1 47 12023-241 10626207 42(1) for the Ay.201 5-1 6 W.P. NO: a421 0F 2024 AtlD

Sri Rajendra Prasad Bansiwal, S/o. Sri Chunnilal, aged about 48 years, Occ. Business, MIG 110, Attapur Mushk Mahal, Hyderabad - 500048. ...PETINONER The Income Tax Officer, Ward - 8(1), Signature Towers, Opp. Botanical Gardens, Kondapur. Hyderabad - 500084. Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, lncome Tax Department, Ministry of Finance, Room No. 401, 2nd Floor, E-Ramp, Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium. Delhi -110 003- ...RES'ONOENTS Petition under Ad.icle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Courl may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1st Respondent u/s. 147 r.w.s. 144 of the Act, dt.27.O2.2O24 with DIN No.ITBAIAST/S114712023- 2411061579072( 1 ) for the Ay.2O19-2o, as arbitrary, illegal, bad in law, void ab initio, apart from being violative of provisions of section 148A and section 149 of section 1514 of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1St Respondent u/s. 147 r.w.s. 144 of the Act, dt.27 .O2.2O24 with DIN No.ITBA/AST/S114712023-2411061579072(1) for the Ay.2019-20 and all

A NO: 1 OF 2024 Petition under Sec{ion 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased {o passedbythelstRespondentU/s.147r.w.s.144oftheAcl,dt.27.o2.2o24wilh D I N No. I TBA/A ST lS t 1 47 t2O23 -24t 1 061 57 9O7 2( 1 ) for the Av'2O 1 I -2O w.P NO: 8443 OF 2024 Sri Mahesh Reddv Allola, Aged about 44 years, 5-11-5117 H, NTR Marg' Priyadarshini Nag6r, Nirmal - 504106 ...PETITIONER

Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessrnent Centre' lncome Tax o"oirt ent. Miniitrv of Finan@, Roorn No. 401, 2nd Floor, E-Ramp' Jawaharlal Nehru Siadium, Delhi - 110 003. ih.in-.. Tax Officer, Ward 1, Nirmal, Ward 1' Nirmal-504101 ..RESPONDENTS Petition under Arlicle 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1'r Respondent u/s' 147 r'w s 1448 of the Act, dl.28lo2l2L24 with DIN No-ITBA/AST/S/14- 2023' 2411061701322(1)fortheAy.2018-'l9,asawry,illegal'badinlaw'voidabinitio apart from being violative of provisions of section 148A and section 149 of the Act and also contrary to the circular issued by GEDT and provisions of section 151A of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1"t Respondent u/s' 147r.w.S1448oftheAct,dt.28lo2l2o24withDlNNo{TBfuAST/S114712023- 2411061701322(1) for the Ay.2018-19 and all consequential proceedings pursuant thereto IA NO: 1 OF 2021 PetitionunderSectionlslCPCprayingthatk]theckcumstanc€sstatedin the affidavit filed in support of the petitiofl, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings, including any r@very, pursuanl to the order passed by

the 1sr Respondent u/s. 147 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dl.28l12l2i24 with DIN No- ITBAJAST/S/1 47 t2o23-24t 1061701322(1) for the Av.201 8-1 I w.P.NO:8158OF 2O24 Smt. Swapna Yalala, Wo. Sri Sreeram Reddy Yalla' aqed qbou! ^4-4- ygars' Occ. Uouie Wite, 1-2, Gollurguda, Shabad Mandal, R. R. District - 501217' ...PETITIONER 1. Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Cenlre, lncome Tax " ij6orrt."^i, t'linilt.v of Finance. Room No. 4o1 ' 2nd Floor, E-Ramp, Jariyahadat Nehru Stadium, Delhi - 1 10 003. z. itre-incohe Tax Officer, Ward - 8(1), Signature Towers, Opp' Botanical ...RES'ONOENTS PetitionunderArticle226oftheConstitutionoflndiaprayingthatin.the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1 st Respondent u/s' 147 r'w's 1448 of the Act, dt.O4.O3.2024 with DIN No'ITBtuAST/S l1'4712023- 24/fi61g74134(1)fortheAy.2015-l6,asarbitrary,illegal,badinlaw,voidab initio, apart from being violative of provisions of section l4SA and section 149 of the Act and also contrary to the circular issued by GBDT and provisions of section 1514 of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1st Respondent uls. 147 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dl'o4 '03 '2024 with DtN No.ITBtuAST/S t147t2}23-24t1061974134(1) for the Ay.2015-16 and all !A NO: 1 OF 2024 PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased' to passedbythelstRespondentu/s.147r.w.s144B-oftheAct,dt.04.03.2o24with DIN No. ITBA/AST tS t 1 47 12023-24t1O61 97 41 34( 1 ) for the Ay 20 1 5-1 6

W.P. NO: A19OOF m24 S. Kamala B Boinwad, W/o. Sri Dafta Boinwad, aged about z16 Business, 5-5-1OB|2/8, Manikyanima Colony, Rajendranagar, R. 500030, y€afs, occ. R. District - ...PETINONER 1 . Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, lncome Tax Department, Ministry of Finance, Room l,&c. 4O1, 2il Floor, ERamp, Jawahadal Nehru Stadium, Delhi -1 10 003. 2. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward - 8(1), Signature Towers, Opp. Botanical ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1st Respondent u/s. 147 r.w.s. 144 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dt.2310312024 with DIN No.ITBNAST/S114712O23- 2411O63249a29(1) for the Ay.2O19-2O, as arbitrary, illegal, bad in law, void ab initio, apart from being violative of provisions of section 148A afld section 149 of section 151A of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1St Respondent uls. 147 r.w.s. 144 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dt.23lo3l2o24 with DIN No.ITBA"/AST/S 114712O23-2411O632a9829('l ) for the Ay.2019-20 and all consequenlial proceedings pursuant thereto lA NO: 1 OF 2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstanc€s stated in the affi<Javit filed in support of the petition, lhe High Court may be pleased to passed by the 1st Respondent uts. 147 t.w.s. 144 r.w.s 144E} of the Act, dt.23lo3l2o24 with DIN No.|TBA/AST/S114712023-2411O63249829(1) for the Ay.2O19-2o

w.P. NO a511 0F 2024 Sri Nagaiah Yaski, S;ro. Sri Y. Manaiah, aged about 72 years' Occ. Retired empbyee, 4-5-169. Old Guni. Vikarabad - 501101 ...PET|TiONER AND1. Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, lncom€ Tax Department, Ministryof Finance,.. Room No. 401' 2nd Floor' E*amp, Jar,vahadal Nehru Stadium, Delhi 1 10 003. 2. The lncome Tax Officer, Wa,rd 1.4-2-1041, Ramaiahguda, Vikarabad 501101' ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith' the High Court may be MANDAMUS holding that the order passed by 1sl Respondent uls. 147 Fw's 't 44 r.w.s 1448 of the AcL dt.o2.o3.2o24 with DIN No. ITBtuAST/S.114712O23- 24t1O61879477 ('l ) for the Ay.2015-16, as arbitrary. illegal. bad in law, void ab initio, apart from being violative of provisions of section 148A and section 149 of section 1514 of the Act, and consequently set aside the order passed by 1St Respondent uts. 147 r.w.s 144 r.w.s 1448 of the Act- dl.O2.O3 -2024 with DIN No' ITBtuAST/S/147 t2023-24t1}61879477(11 for the Av.2015-16 and all [A NO: 1 OF 2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings, including any recovery. pursuant to the order passed by the 1st Respondent uls. 147 r-w.s 144 r.w.s 1448 of the Act, dt.O2-O3.2O24 with DIN Ne . |TBAJASTlsl14712023-24/1061879477(1) for the Ay.2015-16 Counsel for the Petitioner in all the W.P"s: SRI A V. RAGHU RAM Counsel for the Respondents in all the tJ.P.'s: M/s. SUNITI{A REP M/s. SUNDARI R PISUPAT(SC FOR INCOME TAX) The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER

TTII HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUJOY PAUL THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N. TUKARAMJI WRIT PEIITION NOS.8418 a421.8443. 8458. 8490 AND 8511 0F 2024 COMMON ORDER (per Hon'ble SP,J) Heard Sri A.V.Raghu Ram, learned counsel for the petitioner(s) and Ms.Sunitha, representing Ms.Sundari R Pisupati, learned Standing Counsel for Income Tax appearing on behalf of the respondents in all the writ petitions. 2. Regard being had to the similarity of the question involved, on the joint request of the parties, the matters a-re analogously heard and decided by this common order- 3. It is common ground taken by the learned counsel for the petitioner(s) that in furtherance of Finance '\ct, 2O2L, re- assessment process stobd modified but the respondents have not taken care of it and thei'efore notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 cannot sustain judicial scrutiny. Since notices are bad in lanr,, the consequential orders are also bad in law.

z 4. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the parties agreed that curtains on this issue are linally drawn by this Court in a batch of writ petitions, W.p.No.259O3 of 2022 and other connected matters, decided by common order dated I4.O9.2023. The parties agreed that this matter may be disposed of in terms of tlre Common Order d,ated, 14.O9.2023. 5. This Court in the said order dated 14.09.2023 in W.P.No.259O3 of 2022, held as under: "35. ln view of the afor€said discussions, it is by now very clear that the procedure to be followed by the respondent_Oepartment upon trcating the notic€s bsued for reassessment being under Section 1rEA, the subsequent proceedings was mandatorily required to be under(aken under the substituted provisions as laid down under the finance Act, 2021. ln the absence of which, we ar€ constrained to hold that the procedure adopted by the respondent_Department is in contrayenti,on to the statute i-e. the Finance Act,2021, at the first inst:nce. Secondly, it is also in direct contravention to the directives issued by the Hon'bte Supreme Court in the case of Ashish Agarwat, suPla. 36. For all the aforesak! reasons, the impugned notices issued and the proc€edings drawn by the respondentoepartment is neither tenable, nor sustainable. The notices so issued and the procedure adopted being per se illegal, deserves to be and a.e accordingly set aside&uashed. As a consequence, all the impugned orders gettang Atas$d, {he consequential o.ders passed by ure respondent Depafonent pursuant to the notices issued under Section 147 and irrS would also get quashed and it is ordered accordingly. The reason we are quashing the consequential order is on the principles that when the initiation of the proceedings itsetf was procedurally wrong, the subseguent orders also gets nullified automatically. 37. The preliminary objection raised by the petitioner is sustained and all these writ petitions stands allowed on this yery ,urisdictional issue.

Since the impugned notices and orde.s are getting quash€d on tfte point of jurisdiction, we are not inclined do proceed fudher and decide tfte other issues raised by the petitioner whkh stands reserved to be raised and contended in an appropriateoroceedings. 38. Since the Hon'bb Supreme Court had, in th€ cas€ of Ashish Agarwal, supra, as a one{ime measure exercising the povrr€rs under Article 142 of the Constitution of lndia, permitted the Revenue to proceed under the substituted provisions, and this Court altowing the petitions only on the p.ocedural f{aw, the right conferred on the Revenue would remain reserved to proceed further if they so want from the stage of the order of the Supreme Court in the case of Ashish Agarwal, supra. 39. No order as to costs." 6. In view of ttre consensus arrived, the impugned Show Cause notices and consequential orders passed in this batch of writ petitions are set aside. Liberty is reserved to both tJle parties to take respective stald and to proceed in accordance with law as per paragraph No.38 of the order dated 14.09.2023 in W.P.No.259O3 of 2022. 7 . The writ petitions are allowed. No costs. Interlocutory applications, if any pending, shall also stand closed. SD/-K. AII'IMA'I ASSISTANT REGISTRAR l'l^--"'" SECTIO}y'OFFtCER 1. The Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, lncorne Tax Deoartment, Ministry of Finance, Room No. 4O1,2M Floor, E-Rarnp, Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium, Dethi - 110 0O3. 2. The lncome Tax Officer, \Nard - 2, Aayakar Bhavan, Near Natraj Theatre, Karimnagar - 5O5OO1. 3. The lnco-me Tax Officer, Ward - 8(1), Signature Towers, Opp. Botanical 4. The lncoine Tax'Ofticei, Ward 1, Nirmal, Ward 1, Nirmal-504101 5. Tne lncome Tax Officer, Ward 1 , 4-2-1O41, Ramaiahguda, Vikarabad 501 101. 6. One CC to SRI A. V. RAGHU RAM, Advocate [OPUCI 7. One CC to M/s. SUNDARI R PISUPATI, ( SC FOR INCoME TAX) loPUCl L Two CD Copies //TRUE COPY// I To, ,%. BM

HIGH COURT DATED:0210412024 =-,i tt t : 2[2i [1 ,:. * .,-,/ , ,-- r.,|).-',.- ;/ COMMON ORDER WP.No's.8418, 6421,8443,8458,8490 AND BSf f oF 2024 ALLOWING ALL THE WRITPETINONS WITHOUT COSTS ,('- L\d'' t-- :lT,\ ra\\.-. \

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →