PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-5,KOLKATA vs. M/S. FOUNTAIN VANIJYA PVT.LIMITED(NOW MERGED WITH M/S.ASHIANA GOODS PVT. LTD.
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that there was no substantial question of law arising for consideration in the appeal. The Court noted that the ITAT was convinced that the reason for reopening was bad in law, as the assessee had not shown any income from capital gains or business loss, making the premise of escaped income factually incorrect. The Tribunal also observed that the alleged transaction had already been brought into the books of accounts and disclosed in the Income Tax Return filed under Section 139(1), which rendered the very foundation of the reopening proceedings bad in law. The Court took note of the ITAT's reliance on the decision of this Court in CIT-vs.-Infinity Infotech Parks Limited (ITAT No. 60 of 2024) and also referred to CIT-vs.-Jet Airways India Limited Ltd. (331 ITR 236) and Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited-vs.-CIT (336 ITR 136). Consequently, the appeal filed by the revenue was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The appeal was filed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-5, Kolkata (revenue) against an order dated September 12, 2023, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) "A" Bench, Kolkata, for the assessment year 2012-13. The ITAT had quashed the reopening proceedings initiated by the Assessing Officer. The revenue's primary contention was that the assessee had suo moto added back long-term capital gain/loss, but the gain of Rs. 88,73,135/- on the sale of penny stock of Aagam Capital Limited was not genuine and the Assessing Officer had correctly reopened the assessment to treat the entire sale proceeds as bogus. The assessee argued that the reasons for reopening were factually incorrect as no income from long-term capital gain, short-term capital gain, or business loss was shown, and the alleged transaction was already disclosed in the return.
What were the issues?
1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ITAT was justified in law in quashing the reopening proceedings on the ground that the assessee had suo moto added back long-term capital gain/loss, despite the revenue's contention that the long-term capital gain of Rs. 88,73,135/- on the sale of penny stock of Aagam Capital Limited could not be treated as genuine and the Assessing Officer had correctly reopened and added the entire sale proceeds as bogus? (Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961) 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ITAT was justified in law and on facts by deleting the additions made by the Assessing Officer, even though the decision of the jurisdictional High Court in Pr. CIT –vs-Smt. Swati Bajaj squarely covers the issue of bogus Long Term Capital Gain from sale of penny stocks and is also covered by exceptions laid in respect of Circular No. 23 of 2019 issued by the CBDT? (Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961) Assessee's Contentions: The assessee contended that the reasons for reopening were factually incorrect because they had not shown any income from long-term capital gain/short-term capital gain/business loss. The alleged transaction was already brought into the books of accounts and disclosed in the Income Tax Return filed under Section 139(1). Revenue's Contentions: The revenue contended that the ITAT was not justified in quashing the reopening proceedings, as the long-term capital gain of Rs. 88,73,135/- on the sale of penny stock of Aagam Capital Limited could not be treated as genuine. They argued that the Assessing Officer had correctly reopened the assessment and added the entire sale proceeds as bogus. They also argued that the decision in Pr. CIT –vs-Smt. Swati Bajaj and CBDT Circular No. 23 of 2019 covered the issue of bogus long-term capital gains from penny stocks.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
OD-30 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION [INCOME TAX] ORIGINAL SIDE
ITAT/143/2024 IA NO: GA/2/2024 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX5, KOLKATA VS M/S. FOUNTAIN VANIJYA PVT.LIMITED(NOW MERGED WITH M/S.ASHIANA GOODS PVT. LTD.
BEFORE : THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE T.S SIVAGNANAM -A N D- HON'BLE JUSTICE HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA DATE : 16th August, 2024. Appearance : Mr. Prithu Dudhoria, Adv. …for appellant
The Court :- This appeal filed by the revenue under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act) is directed against the order dated September 12, 2023 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal “A” Bench , Kolkata in I.T.A. No. 400/Kol/2023 for the assessment year 2012-13. The revenue has raised the following substantial questions of law for consideration :- (i) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon’ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal is justified in law in quashing the reopening proceedings on the ground that the assessee had suo moto added back long term capital gain/loss incurred during the year without considering the fact that long term capital gain of Rs.88, 73, 135/- on the sale of Penny Stock of Aagam Capital Limited cannot be treated as genuine and that the Assessing Officer has correctly reopened and added
the entire sale proceeds of Rs.88,73,135/- from sale of penny stock of Aagam Capital Limited holding the same as bogus ? (ii) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon’ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal is justified in law and on facts by deleting the additions made by the Assessing Officer even though the decision of the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the lead case of Pr. CIT –vs-Smt. Swati Bajaj squarely covers the issue of bogus Long Term Capital Gain from sale of penny stocks and also covered by exceptions laid in respect of Circular No. 23 of 2019 issued by the CBDT vide F. No. 279/Misc/M- 93/2018-ITJ(Pt.) dated 06.09.2019? We have heard Mr. Dudhoria, learned standing Counsel for the appellant. The respondent has been served and affidavit of service has been filed but none appears for the respondent. Though the department contends that the matter relates to penny stock, the issue which was decided by the Tribunal was whether the reopening of the assessment was valid. The assessee’s contention was that the reasons for reopening of the assessment was that the income of Rs.88,73,135/- had escaped assessment which is generated by the assessee from sale of penny stocks, which reasons was found to be factually incorrect since the assessee had not shown any income from long term capital gain/short term capital gain/business loss and, therefore, the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the reason to believe is bad and consequently the reopening is illegal. The learned Tribunal took note of the decision of this Court in CIT-vs.-Infinity Infotech Parks Limited in ITAT No. 60 of 2024. Thus, we find that on facts the Tribunal was convinced the reason for reopening was bad in law. Apart from that the Tribunal has noted that the alleged transaction has already been brought into books of accounts and has been disclosed in Income
Tax Return filed under Section 139(1) of the Act and, therefore, the very foundation of reopening of proceedings becomes bad in law. Reference was also made in the decision CIT-vs.-Jet Airways India Limited Ltd. (331 ITR 236) and Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited-vs.-CIT (336 ITR 136). Thus, we find there is no question of law much less substantial questions of law arising for consideration in this appeal. Thus, the appeal fails and dismissed. Consequently, the application also stands dismissed.
. (T.S. SIVAGNANAM) CHIEF JUSTICE
(HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA, J.) pkd/GH.
More judgments on Section 139(1)
- Suman Lata, Raipur vs Income Tax Officer-1(1), RaipurITA 800/RPR/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6556/DEL/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6555/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- DCIT Central Circle 32, Delhi vs M/S Triveni Tv Networks Private Limited…ITA 5661/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Delhi Hardware Stores, Delhi vs ITO Ward -46 (4), New DelhiITA 3623/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Arun Aloysius Barnes vs. Commercial Tax OfficerKarnataka · 11 Nov 2026
- Sandhyarani Das vs. The Superintendent Of CGST And Central ExciseOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Pitabas Jena,Pokharigaon, Cuttack vs. Supernitendent, Cuttack-Iii, Range, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Sudarshan Behera vs. Superintendent Angul Circle, AngulOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Gayatri Priyadarshini Bisoi vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax, CT And GST, Cuttack-Ii,Cuttack, OdishaOrissa · 11 Nov 2026