PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 5 KOLKATA vs. SYAMA PRASAD MOOKERJEE PORT KOLKATA
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the contribution to the Superannuation Fund was made to bridge the gap in actuarial valuation and was an ad hoc interim payment to cover deficiencies. The Court found that the legal nature of a contribution is defined by its purpose, i.e., remedying an actuarial deficit, not by how many years it takes to address the deficit. A persistent deficit due to past funding constraints does not convert ad hoc gap-filling payments into ordinary annual contributions. Imposing the Rule 87 ceiling on necessary, actuarially-backed funding would compromise the fund's solvency and is contrary to Section 36(1)(iv). The ITAT committed no error in upholding the deletion of the disallowance. The Court answered substantial questions of law (1) and (2) in the negative, against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. Regarding the third question, the Court held that the ITAT's order was not perverse or arbitrary as it relied on jurisdictional High Court precedents. The appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata (formerly Kolkata Port Trust), filed its return of income for AY 2020-21 declaring Rs.227,13,00,220/-. The Assessing Officer (AO) completed the assessment at Rs.780,81,75,188/-, making substantial additions including Rs.564,49,19,729/- for disallowance of contribution to Superannuation Fund under Section 37 read with Section 43B. The CIT(A) deleted the disallowance of Superannuation Fund contribution. The revenue appealed to the ITAT, which upheld the deletion, relying on Calcutta High Court decisions. The revenue then filed an appeal before the High Court under Section 260A against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi deleting the disallowance of Rs. 564,49,19,729/- made by the A.O. on account of contributions towards Superannuation Fund in excess of the limit fixed under Rule 87, by considering it as an exceptional one-time payment and failing to consider that such excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and as such was rightly considered by the A.O. as regular contribution? (Section 37, Section 43B, Rule 87) 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi by placing reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court in the case of Exide Industries reported in [2023] 146 taxmann.com 21 (Cal) and failing to appreciate that the facts of the instant case are different from that of Exide Industries as in the case of the assessee, the excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and not a one-time exception? (Section 37, Section 43B, Rule 87) 3. Whether the order of the Learned Tribunal is perverse, arbitrary, and contrary to the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and deserves to be set aside? (General question on perversity) Assessee's Contention (implied from the High Court's reasoning): The contribution was an extraordinary ad hoc interim payment to cover current and past year deficiencies in the Superannuation Fund, necessitated by an actuarial valuation deficit, and thus not subject to the Rule 87 ceiling. Revenue's Contention: The excess contribution was a regular practice over past years, not an exceptional one-time payment, and therefore rightly disallowed by the AO as a regular contribution. The case of Exide Industries Ltd. is distinguishable.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 260A,Section 143(1),Section 143(2),Section 143(3),Section 144B,Section 37,Section 43B,Section 14A(2),Section 41,Section 87,Section 88,Section 36(1)(iv)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (Income Tax) (Original Side)
Coram: THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
Reserved on : 07.08.2026. Pronounced on : 21.08.2026
ITA 47 of 2026 With GA 2 of 2026
Principal Commissioner of Income Tax 5 Kolkata
…Appellant -VS-
Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata.
….Respondent
Present:-
Mr. Soumen Bhattacharjee, Adv. Ms. Shardhya Ghosh, Adv.
…for the appellant
Mr. Arvind P. Datar, Sr. Adv. Mr. Sriram Venkatavaradan, Adv. Mr. Rabindra Kumar Mitra, Adv. Mr. Tamogna Saha, Adv.
….. for the Respondent
Rajarshi Bharadwaj, J:
The appellant has filed this appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act"), challenging the order dated
November 18, 2024 passed by the Learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Kolkata Bench “B”, for the assessment year AY 2020-21, on the substantial questions of law formulated at the time of admission. 2. The facts in a nutshell are that the assessee-respondent, formerly known as the Kolkata Port Trust (KoPT), is an Artificial Juridical Person with a history of providing essential port services for nearly 150 years since its establishment in the year 1870. For the Assessment Year (AY) 2020-21, the assessee filed its Return of Income on March 11, 2022, declaring a total income of Rs.227,13,00,220/-. This return was initially processed under the provisions of Section 143(1) of the Act. Subsequently, the case was selected for scrutiny under the Computer Assisted Scrutiny Selection (CASS) system, and a notice under Section 143(2) of the Act was issued to the assessee on June 29, 2021. The assessment was completed by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B of the Act through an assessment order dated September 28, 2022. In the said assessment order, the AO determined the total assessed income of the assessee to be Rs.780,81,75,188/- after incorporating following substantial additions and disallowances that includes, disallowance of contribution to Superannuation Fund (under Section 37 read with Section 43B): Rs.564,49,19,729/-, disallowance of contribution to Calcutta Port Officers' Club (under Section 37): Rs.1,31,23,083/-, disallowance under Section 14A(2) read with Rule 8D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 of Rs.21,13,100/- and addition deemed profit under Section
Rs.5,35,626/-. 3. Aggrieved by these additions and disallowances, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)], National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC). The Ld. CIT(A), NFAC allowed the assessee's appeal in part. By placing reliance on various case laws, the Ld. CIT(A) deleted the additions and disallowances made by the AO on the issues of the contribution to the Superannuation Fund of Rs.564,49,19,729/- and the
contribution to the Calcutta Port Officers' Club of Rs.1,31,23,083/-. However, the Ld. CIT(A), NFAC dismissed the assessee's appeal and confirmed the additions made on account Section 14A(2) disallowance Rs. 21,13,100/- and the Section 41 deemed profit of Rs.5,35,626/-. Dissatisfied with the deletion of the substantial additions, the revenue preferred a second appeal before the Learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Kolkata, solely on issue contribution to Superannuation Fund Rs.564,49,19,729/-. The revenue accepted the Ld. CIT(A)'s deletion regarding the Calcutta Port Officers' Club contribution and no further appeal was preferred on that ground. The assessee-respondent also filed cross-objections before the ITAT. 4. The ITAT, following the legal principles established by the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court in the cases of PCIT v. Exide Industries Ltd (2023) and Eastern Equipment Sales Ltd. or CIT v. Eastern Equipment & Sales Limited reported in 71 taxmann.com 226(Cal), confirmed the decision of the Ld. CIT(A) and deleted the additions. Regarding the superannuation and gratuity funds, the ITAT observed that the remitted amounts were intended to bridge the gap between actual contributions and actuarial valuations. The Tribunal held that such payments were neither initial contributions nor ordinary annual contributions, meaning the ceilings fixed under the respective rules did not apply. The revenue, thereafter, approached this Court under Section 260A of the Act, asserting that the ITAT was not justified in deleting the aforementioned disallowances of Rs. 564,49,19,729. 5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant raises the issue on the following substantial questions of law that have been admitted: i. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi deleting the disallowance of Rs. 564,49,19,729/- made by the A.O. on account of contributions towards Superannuation Fund in excess of limit fixed under
Rule 87 by considering it as an exceptional onetime payment and failing to consider that such excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and as such was rightly considered by the A.O. as regular contribution? ii. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi by placing reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court in the case of Exide Industries reported in [2023] 146 taxmann.com 21 (Cal) and failing to appreciate that the facts of the instant case are different from that of Exide Industries as in the case of the assessee, the excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and not a onetime exception? iii. Whether the order of the Learned Tribunal is perverse, arbitrary, and contrary to the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and deserves to be set aside? 6. We have heard the appellant-revenue and Learned Senior Counsel for the respondent-assessee at length. Since the issues involved are pure questions of law, this Court proceed to decide the appeal on merits. 7. The Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed Rs.564,49,19,729/- on account of contributions made to the Superannuation Fund in excess of the 27% ceiling fixed under Rule 87 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. The assessee submitted that the contribution was necessitated to meet a severe deficit revealed by an actuarial valuation of the Superannuation Fund. For several preceding years, the assessee could not fully fund the required contribution due to a persistent procedural fund crunch. Consequently, the contribution in the financial year 2020-21 was an extraordinary ad hoc interim payment meant to cover both current and past year deficiencies, aligning the fund's assets with its real actuarial liabilities. The CIT(Appeals) and the ITAT correctly held that since these payments were ad hoc interim contributions made specifically to bridge
the gap in actuarial valuation, they were neither ordinary annual contributions under Rule 87 nor initial contributions under Rule 88. The ITAT relied on the High Court decision in Exide Industries Ltd. (supra), which established that the statutory ceiling of Rule 87 does not apply to extraordinary contributions made to address actuarial deficits. 8. The revenue argued before this Court that the case of Exide Industries Ltd. (supra) is distinguishable because the assessee's practice of funding shortfalls was a regular, recurring method of operation over past years, rather than an exceptional one-time payment. This Court is unable to accept the revenue's contention. The legal nature of a contribution is defined by its purpose i.e., remedying an actuarial deficit and not by how many years the deficit takes to be fully addressed. A persistent deficit caused by past funding constraints cannot convert ad hoc gap-filling payments into ordinary annual contributions. To superimpose the Rule 87 ceiling on necessary, actuarially-backed funding of an approved fund would compromise the solvency of the fund and is contrary to the scheme of Section 36(1)(iv) of the Act. The ITAT committed no error in upholding the deletion of the disallowance. We answer substantial questions of law (1) and (2) in negative, i.e., against the appellant revenue and in favour of the respondent assessee. The deletion of the disallowance of Rs.564,49,19,729/- is hereby upheld. 9. Regarding the overall validity of the ITAT order, herein being question no.3, while the revenue disputes the findings on superannuation and gratuity, the order itself is not perverse or arbitrary in a legal sense. The ITAT reached its conclusions by placing reliance on jurisdictional high court precedents, such as Exide Industries (supra) and Eastern Equipment & Sales Ltd (supra).While the application of those precedents to the specific facts of the superannuation and gratuity issues may be contested, the ITAT’s reliance on existing judicial interpretations ensures the order remains a reasoned legal document rather
than an arbitrary one. We answer substantial question (3) in the negative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 10. The findings of the Tribunal concerning the superannuation fund contributions and the overall non-perversity of the order are upheld. Therefore, the appeal filed by the revenue against the impugned order dated November 18, 2024, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal relating to the Assessment Year 2020-2021 is devoid of any merit. Accordingly, we answer substantial questions (1), (2) and (3) in the negative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 11. There shall be no order as to costs. 12. Urgent certified copy, if applied for, be supplied upon compliance with requisite formalities.
(RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J )
(UDAY KUMAR , J) Kolkata 21.08.2026 PA(BS)
More judgments on Section 144B
- S V D Promoters, Agra vs Income Tax Officer Ward 1(1)(2), AgraITA 325/AGR/2026[2015-16]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2015-16
- Suman Lata, Raipur vs Income Tax Officer-1(1), RaipurITA 800/RPR/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Khambhla Gram Vikas Samiti Trust, Khambla vs ITO Exemption Ward 1, RajkotITA 1136/RJT/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- S G Ram Books Pvt Ltd, Delhi vs ITO Ward 22(1), DelhiITTPA 282/DEL/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Vikas Tyagi, Ghaziabad vs ITO Ward 2(1)(1), GhaziabadITA 8344/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S.Ritika Ispat PVT. LTD.,Balanda, Sundergarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Sai Jagannath, Rourkela, Sundargarh vs. Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Construction, Khordha vs. The Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Pramod Kumar Behera vs. Union Of INDIAOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Santosh Kumar Pradhan (Late Biswabhar Pradhan) vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026