PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 5 KOLKATA vs. SYAMA PRASAD MOOKERJEE PORT KOLKATA
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the ITAT was correct in deleting the disallowances. Regarding the Superannuation Fund, the Court found that the contributions were ad hoc interim payments to bridge actuarial deficits and fund shortfalls, not ordinary annual contributions. Therefore, the ceiling under Rule 87 did not apply, aligning with the precedent in PCIT v. Exide Industries Ltd. For the Gratuity Fund, the Court noted that Section 36(1)(v) allows deductions for contributions to approved gratuity funds without an 8.33% ceiling. Once a fund is approved by the Commissioner, the AO cannot go behind the approval. The ITAT's reliance on Eastern Equipment & Sales Ltd. was upheld, confirming that the AO lacks jurisdiction to disregard the approved status of the fund. For PF/ESI contributions, the Court found that the Kolkata Port Trust regulations do not specify a due date for employee contributions. Consequently, the trigger for disallowance under Section 36(1)(va) did not arise, especially since deposits were made shortly after an artificial deadline. The Court also held that the ITAT's order was not perverse, as it relied on jurisdictional High Court precedents. The appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata (formerly Kolkata Port Trust), filed its return for AY 2018-19. The Assessing Officer (AO) completed the assessment under section 143(3) read with section 144B, determining total income at Rs. 876,16,93,450. This included disallowances of Rs. 710,68,55,297 for Superannuation Fund contributions, Rs. 33,11,01,366 for Gratuity Fund contributions, and Rs. 8,38,35,219 for belated employee contributions to PF/ESI. The CIT(A) allowed the assessee's appeal, deleting these additions. The revenue appealed to the ITAT, which also confirmed the CIT(A)'s order. The revenue has now filed an appeal before the High Court under section 260A.
What were the issues?
The High Court had to decide the following substantial questions of law: 1. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the deletion of Rs. 710,68,55,297 disallowance on account of Superannuation Fund contributions in excess of Rule 87, by considering it an exceptional one-time payment instead of a regular practice to meet a shortfall. 2. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the deletion of Rs. 33,11,01,366 disallowance on account of Gratuity Fund contributions in excess of Rule 103, by considering it an exceptional one-time payment instead of a regular practice to meet a shortfall. 3. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the deletion by placing reliance on the Exide Industries case, failing to appreciate that the facts of the instant case (regular practice of excess contribution) were different. 4. Whether the ITAT was justified in upholding the deletion of Rs. 8,38,35,219 disallowance for belated employee contributions to PF/ESI under section 36(1)(va), based on the Tax Audit Report's delay, ignoring that the AO was merely reiterating a disallowance for computation purposes. 5. Whether the ITAT's order was perverse, arbitrary, and contrary to the Income Tax Act, 1961. Assessee's arguments (as inferred from the ITAT's findings and the High Court's discussion): The contributions were extraordinary ad hoc interim payments to bridge actuarial deficits and fund shortfalls, not regular annual contributions subject to ceilings. For PF/ESI, the applicable regulations for Kolkata Port Trust do not specify a due date, and deposits were made within a couple of days of an artificial due date used by the e-filing software. Revenue's arguments: The excess contributions to Superannuation and Gratuity Funds were a regular practice over several years to meet shortfalls, not exceptional one-time payments, and thus rightly disallowed by the AO. The ITAT erred in applying precedents like Exide Industries and Eastern Equipment to the facts. For PF/ESI, the disallowance was based on the delay specified in the Tax Audit Report.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 260A,Section 143(1),Section 143(2),Section 143(3),Section 144B,Section 37,Section 43B,Section 37(1),Section 36(1)(va),Section 36(1)(v)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (Income Tax) (Original Side)
Coram: THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
Reserved on : 07.08.2026. Pronounced on : 21.08.2026
ITA 49 of 2026 With GA 2 of 2026
..Principal Commissioner of Income Tax 5 Kolkata
…Appellant -VS-
Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata.
….Respondent
Present:-
Mr. Soumen Bhattacharjee, Adv. Ms. Shardhya Ghosh, Adv.
…for the appellant
Mr. Arvind P. Datar, Sr. Adv. Mr. Sriram Venkatavaradan, Adv. Mr. Rabindra Kumar Mitra, Adv. Mr. Tamogna Saha, Adv.
….. for the Respondent
Rajarshi Bharadwaj, J:
The appellant has filed this appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act"), challenging the order dated November 18, 2024 passed by the Learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
(ITAT), Kolkata Bench “B”, for the assessment year AY 2018-19, on the substantial questions of law formulated at the time of admission. 2. The facts in a nutshell are that the assessee herein the respondent, formerly known as the Kolkata Port Trust (KoPT), is an Artificial Juridical Person with a history of providing essential port services since its establishment in the year 1870. For the assessment year 2018-19, the assessee filed its original return of income on September 27, 2018 and a revised return on March 28, 2019. This return was initially processed under the provisions of section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Subsequently, the case was scrutinised under the Computer Assisted Scrutiny Selection (CASS) system, leading to the issuance of a notice under section 143(2) on September 22, 2019. The assessment was eventually completed by the Assessing Officer (A.O.) under section 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act through an order dated September 24, 2021. In the said assessment order, the A.O. determined the total income to be Rs. 876,16,93,450, having incorporated substantial additions and disallowances. These included a disallowance of Rs.710,68,55,297/- regarding contributions to the Superannuation Fund under section 37 read with section 43B. A disallowance of Rs.33,11,01,366/- for contributions to the approved Gratuity Fund under section 37(1) read with Rule 87 and a disallowance of Rs.8,38,35,219/- for belated credit of employees’ contributions to PF/ESI under section 36(1)(va). 3. Aggrieved by these disallowances, the assessee respondent preferred an appeal before the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)], National Faceless Appeal Centre. The Ld. CIT(A) allowed the assessee's appeal and deleted all the disallowances and additions made by the A.O. by placing reliance on various case laws. Dissatisfied with the decision, the revenue herein the appellant preferred a second appeal before the Learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Kolkata. In considering the matter, the ITAT followed the legal principles established by the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court in the cases of PCIT v. Exide Industries Ltd (2023) and Eastern Equipment Sales Ltd. or
CIT v. Eastern Equipment & Sales Limited reported in 71 taxmann.com 226(Cal), confirmed decision of Ld. CIT(A). Regarding Superannuation and Gratuity funds, the ITAT observed that the remitted amounts were intended to bridge the gap between actual contributions and actuarial valuations. The Tribunal held that such payments were neither initial contributions nor ordinary annual contributions, meaning the ceilings fixed under the respective rules did not apply. On the issue of PF/ESI, the ITAT noted that the relevant regulations for the Kolkata Port Trust do not specify a due date for such credits and that the deposit was made within a couple of days of the artificial due date used by the e-filing software. 4. The revenue, thereafter, approached this Court under section 260A, asserting that the ITAT was not justified in deleting the aforementioned disallowances. 5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant raises the issue on the following substantial questions of law that have been admitted: i. erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi deleting the disallowance of Rs.710,68,55, 297/- made by the A.O. on account of contributions towards Superannuation Fund in excess of limit fixed under Rule 87 by considering it as an exceptional onetime payment and failing to consider that such excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and as such was rightly considered by the A.O. as regular contribution? ii. erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi deleting the disallowance of Rs. 33,11,01,366/ made by the A.O. on account of contributions towards Gratuity Fund in excess of limit fixed under Rule 103 by considering it as an exceptional onetime payment and failing to consider that such excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a
regular practice over past several years and as such was rightly considered by the Α.Ο. as regular contribution? iii. erred in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(Appeals), NFAC, Delhi by placing reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court in the case of Exide Industries reported in [2023] 146 taxmann.com 21 (Cal) and failing to appreciate that the facts of the instant case are different from that of Exide Industries as in the case of the assessee, the excess contribution to meet shortfall in fund balance was a regular practice over past several years and not a onetime exception? iv. was justified in upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(A) deleting the disallowance of Rs.8,38,35,219/- made on account of belated credit of Employees' contribution to Provident Fund or Superannuation Fund as per 36(1)(va) in order u/s. 143(1) based on the delay specified by the Auditor in the Tax Audit Report and ignoring the fact that since no appeal was filed against the order u/s. 143(1) challenging the said disallowance, the A.O. was merely reiterating the disallowance for computation purposes only? v. Whether the order of the Learned Tribunal is perverse, arbitrary, and contrary to the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and deserves to be set aside? 6. We have heard the appellant-revenue and Learned Senior Counsel for the respondent-assessee at length. Since the issues involved are pure questions of law, this Court proceed to decide the appeal on merits. 7. First, the Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed Rs.710,68,55,297/- on account of contributions made to the Superannuation Fund in excess of the 27% ceiling fixed under Rule 87 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. During the relevant year, the actual salary for the purpose of Superannuation Fund
determination was Rs. 446,33,18,867 (salaries and wages of Rs.500,60,83,433/- minus overtime of Rs.54,27,64,566/-). The AO calculated that the permissible 27% contribution under Rule 87 was Rs.120,50,96,094/-, whereas the assessee debited Rs.831,20,51,391/- to the Profit & Loss account, prompting the AO to disallow the excess. The assessee submitted that the contribution was necessitated to meet a severe deficit revealed by an actuarial valuation of the Superannuation Fund. For several preceding years, the assessee could not fully fund the required contribution due to a persistent procedural fund crunch. Consequently, the contribution in the financial year 2017-18 was an extraordinary ad hoc interim payment meant to cover both current and past year deficiencies, aligning the fund's assets with its real actuarial liabilities. The CIT(Appeals) and the ITAT correctly held that since these payments were ad hoc interim contributions made specifically to bridge the gap in actuarial valuation, they were neither ordinary annual contributions under Rule 87 nor initial contributions under Rule 88. The ITAT relied on the High Court decision in Exide Industries Ltd. (supra), which established that the statutory ceiling of Rule 87 does not apply to extraordinary contributions made to address actuarial deficits. 8. The revenue argued before this Court that the case of Exide Industries Ltd. (supra) is distinguishable because the assessee's practice of funding shortfalls was a regular, recurring method of operation over past years, rather than an exceptional one-time payment. This Court is unable to accept the revenue's contention. The legal nature of a contribution is defined by its purpose i.e., remedying an actuarial deficit and not by how many years the deficit takes to be fully addressed. A persistent deficit caused by past funding constraints cannot convert ad hoc gap-filling payments into ordinary annual contributions. To superimpose the Rule 87 ceiling on necessary, actuarially-backed funding of an approved fund would compromise the solvency of the fund and is contrary to the scheme of Section 36(1)(iv) of the Act. The ITAT committed no error in
upholding the deletion of the disallowance. We answer substantial questions of law (1) and (3) in negative, i.e., against the appellant revenue and in favour of the respondent assessee. The deletion of the disallowance of Rs.710,68,55,297/- is hereby upheld. 9. Second, ITAT’s decision to uphold deletion of Rs.33,11,01,366/- disallowance related to the Gratuity Fund is legally sound and merits no interference. The primary contention of the revenue was that the contribution exceeded the 8.33% limit prescribed by Rule 103. However, a fundamental distinction must be made between ordinary annual contributions and payments made to bridge a gap in actuarial valuation. The assessee’s contribution was specifically made to address a shortfall in actuarial valuation specifically to bridge the gap between actuarial liability and actual fund availability to ensure that the approved Gratuity Fund, which is maintained with the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), remained capable of discharging its lawful obligations. As such, it does not fall under the restrictive definition of an ordinary annual contribution as contemplated by Rule 103. 10. Furthermore, Section 36(1)(v) of the Income Tax Act, which governs deductions for contributions to approved gratuity funds, does not per se impose the 8.33% restriction found in the Rules. Section 36(1)(v) allows deduction of any sum paid by the employer by way of contribution towards an approved gratuity fund created for the exclusive benefit of employees under an irrevocable trust, without imposing any 8.33% ceiling. As the assessee’s Gratuity Fund remains an approved fund recognised by the Commissioner, the taxing authority must proceed on the basis that the fund satisfies all conditions for recognition unless that recognition is formally withdrawn. The ITAT correctly placed reliance on the High Court’s precedent in Eastern Equipment & Sales Ltd.(supra), which supports the view that such contributions are fully allowable. As established in Eastern Equipment (supra), once the Commissioner accords approval, it is binding on the assessing authority and the AO is entirely devoid
of power and jurisdiction to go behind the permission to find out whether the contribution is in conformity with the rules or in excess thereof. The AO simply cannot sit in judgment over the Commissioner's approval. Consequently, the revenue’s contention that the excess was part of a regular practice does not assist its position, even assuming such a factual claim, the AO possesses no jurisdiction in assessment proceedings to disregard the approved status of the fund and to superimpose Rule 103 as a deduction-disallowance mechanism contrary to as held in Eastern Equipment (supra). Restricting the deduction to 8.33% when the statutory provision does not envisage such a cap especially for payments intended to maintain the solvency of the fund based on actuarial requirements would be contrary to the intent of the Act. Therefore, the ITAT correctly appreciated that the ceiling fixed under the rules does not apply to this specific type of contribution. We answer substantial question (2) in the negative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 11. Third, the ITAT’s decision to delete the Rs.8,38,35,219/- disallowance regarding belated employee contributions to PF and ESI is legally sound. The A.O. had initially made this addition under Section 36(1)(va), relying on the Tax Audit Report which flagged the deposits as "delayed" based on an artificial deadline being 15th of the month. However, Section 36(1)(va), read with its Explanation, makes it clear that a disallowance can only arise where the employees' contribution is not credited by the 'due date' that is defined as the date prescribed under the applicable Act, rule, order, notification, standing order, award, contract of service or otherwise. In the present case, the assessee is governed by the Kolkata Port Trust (Non-contributory Provident Fund) Regulations 1988, approved and notified under the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963. Crucially, these specific regulations do not specify a due date for depositing the employee’s share of contributions. 12. Since there is no prescribed statutory deadline in the specific regulations applicable to the assessee, the general 15th of the month deadline found in the Employee's Provident Fund Scheme does not apply. The artificial due date of the
15th of the following month mentioned under Serial No. 20(b) of the Form 3CD Tax Audit Report was entered by the Tax Auditor solely due to the technical limitations of the concerned e-filing software, which compulsorily mandates entering a date in that column. Therefore, the standard due date of the 15th of the next month as specified under Clause 38 of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme, framed under the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, is not applicable to the respondent. In the absence of a legally prescribed due date under the applicable regulatory regime, the statutory trigger for disallowance under Section 36(1)(va) does not arise. Without a legally defined due date, there can be no delay to trigger a disallowance under Section 36(1)(va). Furthermore, the A.O. admitted that the deposits were actually made within a couple of days of the artificial software-generated deadline. Therefore, we answer substantial question (4) in the affirmative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 13. Regarding the overall validity of the ITAT order, herein being question no.5, while the revenue disputes the findings on superannuation and gratuity, the order itself is not perverse or arbitrary in a legal sense. The ITAT reached its conclusions by placing reliance on jurisdictional high court precedents, such as Exide Industries (supra) and Eastern Equipment & Sales Ltd (supra).While the application of those precedents to the specific facts of the superannuation and gratuity issues may be contested, the ITAT’s reliance on existing judicial interpretations ensures the order remains a reasoned legal document rather than an arbitrary one. We answer substantial question (5) in the negative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 14. The findings of the Tribunal concerning the Gratuity Fund, PF/ESI contributions and the overall non-perversity of the order are upheld. Therefore, the appeal filed by the revenue against the impugned order dated November 18, 2024, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal relating to the Assessment Year 2018-2019 is devoid of any merit. Accordingly, we answer substantial
questions (1), (2), (3) and (5) in the negative and question (4) in the affirmative, i.e., against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. 15. There shall be no order as to costs. 16. Urgent certified copy, if applied for, be supplied upon compliance with requisite formalities.
(RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J )
(UDAY KUMAR , J) Kolkata 21.08.2026 PA(BS)
More judgments on Section 144B
- S V D Promoters, Agra vs Income Tax Officer Ward 1(1)(2), AgraITA 325/AGR/2026[2015-16]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2015-16
- Suman Lata, Raipur vs Income Tax Officer-1(1), RaipurITA 800/RPR/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Khambhla Gram Vikas Samiti Trust, Khambla vs ITO Exemption Ward 1, RajkotITA 1136/RJT/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- S G Ram Books Pvt Ltd, Delhi vs ITO Ward 22(1), DelhiITTPA 282/DEL/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Vikas Tyagi, Ghaziabad vs ITO Ward 2(1)(1), GhaziabadITA 8344/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Basant Ballabh Punetha vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Satyavan vs. Commissioner Central Goods And Services Tax CommissionerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Deepak Kumar Daiya vs. State Of West Bengal And Ors.Calcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Pawan Kumar Rajgaria vs. State Of West BengalCalcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Mohammed Fazil vs. State Of ChhattisgarhChhattisgarh · 4 Nov 2026