Bhandaru Srikanth Rao vs. The National Faceless Assessment Center

PDF · subscribers
WP/25118/2024HC TelanganaHBHC01048576202412 September 2024Author: SUJOY PAUL,NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO6 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the writ petition, setting aside the impugned show cause notice and consequential orders. The Court relied on its previous common order dated September 14, 2023, in W.P.No.25903 of 2022 and connected matters. In that order, the Court had held that the procedure adopted by the respondent department was in contravention of the Finance Act, 2021, and the directives of the Supreme Court in Ashish Agrawal. The Court found the notices and proceedings to be illegal and quashed them. The consequential orders were also quashed on the principle that if the initiation of proceedings is procedurally wrong, subsequent orders automatically become invalid. The Court explicitly stated that other issues raised by the petitioner were not decided and stood reserved for appropriate proceedings. Liberty was reserved to both parties to proceed in accordance with law as per paragraph 38 of the aforementioned Supreme Court order in Ashish Agrawal, which allowed the revenue, as a one-time measure, to proceed under the substituted provisions from the stage of the Supreme Court's order.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Bhandaru Srikanth Rao, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated March 18, 2023, passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, a consequent notice dated March 18, 2023, under Section 148, and a reassessment order dated January 31, 2024. The petitioner contended that the reassessment process was not conducted in accordance with the modifications introduced by the Finance Act, 2021. The respondents are the National Faceless Assessment Center, Income Tax Officer, Ward 14(1), Hyderabad, and the Assessment Unit, Income Tax Department. The petitioner sought to declare the said orders and notices void, illegal, arbitrary, and without jurisdiction. An interim application was also filed seeking a stay on further proceedings, including the collection of tax.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reassessment proceedings initiated by the respondents are invalid due to non-compliance with the procedure prescribed under the Finance Act, 2021, thereby violating Section 148A and Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961? (Question of law and fact) Assessee's Contention: The petitioner argued that the respondents failed to follow the modified reassessment procedure introduced by the Finance Act, 2021. Consequently, the notice issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is bad in law, rendering all subsequent consequential orders also bad in law. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue. However, the parties agreed that the issue had been conclusively decided by this Court in a batch of writ petitions, specifically W.P.No.25903 of 2022 and connected matters, decided by a common order dated September 14, 2023.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148A,Section 148,Section 147

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) THURSDAY,THE TWELFTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUJOY PAUL THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO Department 134111 Ministry . of Finance ..:RESPONDEN'TS Between: Bhandaru Srikanth Rao, S/o. Bhandaru Prabhaker Rao Aged about 48 years, Blg H No- 3-4-52617, F-'l .03 Kaveri Enclave, Barkatpur:a, Hyderabad, Telangana 500027. ...PETITIONER 1. The National Faceless Assessment Center, lncome-tax Department, New Delhi, lndia 2. lncome Tax Officer, Ward 14 '1 Hyderabad 3; The Assessment Unit, lncome Tax Governinent of lndia New,Delhi . Petition under Article 226 of th'e Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction, more particularly in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring order dated 18-03-2023 under Section 148A(d) bearing DIN and Notice No. ITBA/ASTlFl141Al2022-23l'1050949089(1), the consequent notice dated 18-03-2023 u/s. 148 bearing |TBA/AST/S/14B_1t2022- 2311050949170(1)and the reassessment order dated 31-01-2024 bearing ITBA/AST/S/147 12023-2411 060334080(1 ), as being void, illegat, arbitrary, without jurisdiction, violate of Article 14 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently set aside the same WRIT PETITION NO: 25118 OF 2024 il

IANO:1O F 2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that rn the circumsternces stated in the affidavit filed in s rpport of the petition' the High Court may be Srleased to stay all further proceedingts including collection of tax pursuant to reassessment order dated 31 -01 -2024 bearing ITBA/AST/Si1 47 12023-241 1060334080(1 ) Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI' M' NAGA DEEPAK Counsel for the Respondent Nos' 1&2: Ms' BOKARO SAPNA REDDY (Jr' SC FOR INCOME TAX) counselfor the Respondent No'3: sRlGAD| i,ttr%=-tt[HS^t oF tNDtA The Court made the following: ORDER

TIIE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICD SUJOY PAI'L THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAIUAVARAPU RAJESHIVAR RAO WRIT PETITION No.25118 OF 2o24 ORDER: (per Hon'ble Justice Sujog Paul) Heard Sri M. Naga Deepak, learned counsel for the petitioner(s), Ms. B. Sapna Reddy, learned Junior Standing Counsel for Income Tax Department, for the respondent(s)- Income Tax Department and Sri B. Mukherjee, learned counsel representing Sri Gadi Praveen Kumar, learned Deputy Solicitor Genera,l of India, for the respondent(s)- Central Government. 2. The ground taken by the learned counsel for the petitioner(s) is tha[ in furtherarce of Finance Act, 2021, re- assessment process stood modilted but the respondents have not taken care of it and therefore, notice issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 cannot sustain judicial scrutiny. Since notice is bad in law, the consequential orders are a-1so bad in law. 3. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the parties agreed that curtains on this issue are ltnally drawn by this Court in a batch of writ petitions, W.P.No.259O3 of 2022 :

and other c,)nnected matters, decided by common crder dated 14.09.i1O23. The parties agreed that this mattcr meqy be disposecl of ir terms of the Common Order dated 14 09'2)23' 4. This Crurt in the said order dated 14 09 2023 \n W.P.No.2590I of 2022, held as under: "35- :n view of the afotesaid aliscussions, it is by now very clear that the Procedute to be fouowed by t_hc respoldent_ Dcpartmcot upou treatidg the aotrces issued for reassessmeat being under section 148A, the subsequent Proceediags was mandatorily required to be undertakes uader the subsututed provisiorls as laid doEn undet the Finalce Act, 2021' Itr the abseDce of which, we are coostrai.aed to hold that the procedure adopted by the resPondent_DepartEent is in contraveotion to the statute i.e. the Fillalce Act,2O21, at the frrst iDstance. Seco[dly, it ls also ln direct co[travention to the directives issued by the Hoa'ble SuPreme coult in the case ,f Ashish Atarqral, suPra. 36. For aU the aforesald reasotrs, the iEpugEed Eouces issued atrd the proceedlEgs dres! by thc resPondert-DepartEent is Eeitber telrable, nor sustaiaable. The lotrces so issued aEd the procedure adoPted beiBg per se lllegal' deserses to be and are accordingly set aslde/quashed. As a consequencc' all the idpugEed ordets getung quashed, the co[sequential olders passed by the resPordent DeParb[ent pursuallt to the notices issued under Sectioo 147 and 148 eould also get quashed and it is ordered accotdingly. The rcasoE we are quashi[g the consequential otder is o[ the princiPles tlat whcn tie iditiatioD of the Proceediats itself was ptocedurally wrotrg' thc subsequent orders also Sets qlrllified autooatrcally. 37. The pretiElnary objection raised by tlle Petitioner is sustaiaed and all these ![rit petiuotrs sta.Eds allowed on tlis very jurisdictlonal issue' Since the i.Epug[ed notices ard orde6 are getting quashed oa the Polnt ofiurisdiction, we are not incliaed to Proceed further aod declde thG other issues mised by the petltlonet which staads re6erved to be raised aqd conteuded ia a.a apPropriate proceediags.

38.

Since thc llo!'ble SuPrede Court had' ia the cese of Ashish Aganral' suPra, as a one-tiEe Eeasure exercisirA tlle powets uader Arttcle 142 of the CoastitutioE of Irdia' perEitted the Reveauc to Proceed under the substituted provisiors, arrd this Court alloqdng the Petitions only or the procedural llaw, tie right coderted oa ttre Reveoue would reEai! aeserved to proceed firrther if they so want froE the stage of the order of the Supreme Court ill the case of Ashish Agatsal, supra. 39. No order as to costs." 5. In view of the consensus arrived, the impugned Show Cause notice and consequential orders passed in this writ petition are set aside. Liberty is reserved to both the parties to take respective stand and to proceed in accordalce u'ith 1aw as per paragraph No.38 of the order dated 14.09.2O23 in W.P.No.259O3 of 2022. 6. The Writ Petition is allowed. No costs. Interlocutory applications, if .any pelQ13s, :lf4t4:g_Cte4.9lo:9d, ., - SD/- P. PADMANABHA R ASSISTANT REGIS DY RAR //TRUE COPY// SECTION FICER 1. The National Faceless Assessment Center, lncome-tax Department, New Delhi, lndia 2. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward 14 'l Hyderabad 3. The Assessment Unit, lncome Tax Department Ministry of Finance Government of India New Delhi 4. lncome Tax Officer, Ward 14(1), Hyderabad 5. The Assessment Unit, lncome Tax Department [r4inistry of Finance, Government of lndia, New Delhi 6. One CC to SRl. M. NAGA DEEPAK, Advocate [OPUC] T One CC to Ms BOKARO SAPNA REDDY (Jr SC FOR INCOIVE TAX)[OPUC] 8. One CC to SRl. GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR, DY. SOLICITOR GENERAL OF rNDtA [OPUC] 9. Two CD Copies To, BM GJP

HIGH COURT DATED:1210912024 ORDER WP.No.2S118 ot 2024 ALLOWING THE WRITPETITION WITHOUT COSTS . ,. :\ ),[ { \ \r !.

More judgments on Section 148A

All 9,462 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →