COMMR.OF I.T.A.P.III HYD vs. SRINIVASA HATCHERIS(P)LTD HYD
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the Commissioner erred in exercising his suo motu powers under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act. The Tribunal had correctly noted that the power under Section 263 can be exercised only if the Assessing Officer's order is patently illegal or if there is no possibility of two views. The Tribunal found that neither of these conditions was met. The High Court further observed that the revenue's counsel could not demonstrate how the Tribunal's order was erroneous. Crucially, the Court stated that the question of whether a particular unit can be used independently or in tandem with similar units is a pure question of fact. Such factual matters cannot be dealt with in an appeal under Section 260A of the Act. Therefore, the appeal filed by the Department was dismissed. No order as to costs was made.
What were the facts?
The assessee, a hatchery, claimed 100% depreciation on cages purchased for the assessment year 1992-93. The Assessing Officer allowed the claim. However, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) invoked Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and disallowed depreciation. The Commissioner reasoned that although the cost of individual cages was below Rs. 5,000, they were used collectively as a larger compartment with common facilities, implying their cumulative cost should be considered. The assessee appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which allowed the appeal. The Department then filed the present appeal before the High Court under Section 260A.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Commissioner erred in exercising his suo motu powers under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to revise the assessment order allowing depreciation on cages. The assessee contended that the Assessing Officer's order was not erroneous or prejudicial to the revenue, and the Commissioner could not revise the order merely because another view was possible. The assessee argued that the ITAT correctly applied the principle that revision under Section 263 is permissible only when the order is patently illegal or where no two views are possible. The assessee also argued that the question of whether cages could be used independently or in tandem was a question of fact, not suitable for appeal under Section 260A. The revenue, through the Commissioner, argued that the cages, though individually costing less than Rs. 5,000, were used in fabrication of a bigger compartment with common facilities, and therefore, the cumulative cost should be considered for depreciation, citing the Karnataka High Court's decision in Pathangey Poultry Forms v. Commissioner of Income Tax.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM
I.T.T.A.No.16 of 2002
JUDGMENT: (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice L.Narasimha Reddy)
The respondent is a Hatchery and is an assessee under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘the Act’). For the assessment year 1992-93, it claimed 100% depreciation on cages purchased by it. In the order of assessment, dated 19.04.1993, the Assessing Authority allowed the depreciation by taking into account certain precedents. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), however, exercised powers of suo motu under Section 263 of the Act and passed an order, dated 30.10.1995. He took the view that though the cost of each cage is less than Rs.5,000/-, they can be put to proper use only when they are attached to each other. Therefore, he disallowed the depreciation. Aggrieved by that, the respondent filed I.T.A.No.437/Hyd/1996 before the Hyderabad Bench ‘A’ of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal allowed the appeal through its order, dated 16.10.2001. Hence, this appeal by the Department, under Section 260A of the Act.
Heard Sri J.V.Prasad, learned counsel for the appellant, and Sri Y.Ratnakar, learned counsel for the respondent.
On his part, the Assessing Officer was satisfied with the claim of the respondent for depreciation on the cages, to carry birds that are produced in the hatchery. The Commissioner, however, reopened the matter by issuing a notice under Section 263 of the Act. According to him, the situation is covered by the judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Pathangey Poultry Forms v.
Commissioner of Income Tax[1]. The purport of that judgment was that if an item on which the depreciation is claimed, can be put to use only in tandem for other similar units, the cumulative cost must be taken into account in the context of allowing depreciation. The Commissioner took the view that though the cost of each cage purchased by the respondent during the concerned assessment year, was less than Rs.5,000/-, the cages were not put to use independently and they were utilized in fabrication of a bigger compartment with common facilities of lighting, feeding, watering etc. Accordingly, the depreciation was denied.
In the appeal, before it, by the respondent, the Tribunal discussed the matter at length with reference to the relevant precedents. The principle governing the exercise of power in a revision was taken note of. The principle is to the effect that where two views of a particular aspect are possible, for an Income Tax Officer, and he has chosen one, the Commissioner cannot reopen the matter on the ground that another view is possible. The second ground where the power can be exercised is that the order passed by the Assessing Authority is patently illegal. The Tribunal found that none of the grounds exist in the instant case. Learned counsel for the Department is not able to demonstrate as to how the order passed by the Tribunal is erroneous. At any rate, the question as to whether a particular unit can be used independently or in tandem with similar units, is a pure question of fact and the same cannot be dealt with in an appeal under Section 260-A of the Act.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
The miscellaneous petition filed in this writ appeal shall also
stand disposed of.
____________________ L.NARASIMHA REDDY, J.
_____________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM, J.
Date:16.07.2014
[1] 210 ITR 668
More judgments on Section 263
- G.S. Pharmaceutical Pvt Ltd, Muzaffarnagar vs Pr, CIT, DehradunITA 4167/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Kaushalkumar Rajendrakumar Patel, Ahmedabad vs Principal Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1161/AHD/2026[2013-14]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2013-14
- M/S the Educationalsociety St. Marys… vs DCIT Exemption Circle, GhaziabadITA 5861/DEL/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- M/S Nao Spirits & Beverages Private… vs Assessment Unit, C. R. BuildingITA 3318/DEL/2025[2021-22]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- Waseem Ahmad, Muzaffarnagar vs ITO, Ward-3(2)(4), MuzaffarnagarITA 568/DEL/2022[2012-13]Status: Disposed10 Nov 2026AY 2012-13
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- B.S. Automobiles vs. The State Of Meghalaya And Ors.Meghalaya · 17 Nov 2026
- Jingso Tayang vs. The Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 15 Nov 2026
- The Assistant Commissioner Of Central Tax vs. M/S Volvo Group INDIA Private LimitedKarnataka · 13 Nov 2026
- Sri Bheema Setu Munivrunda Mutt vs. Government Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 12 Nov 2026
- Sri. Bhimasethu Munivrunda Matha vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 12 Nov 2026