Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-5 vs. Shri P.Narasimha Reddy

PDF · subscribers
ITTA/97/2019HC TelanganaHBHC01000754201915 March 2019Author: P.KESHAVA RAO,V RAMASUBRAMANIAN4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the Revenue's appeal. The Court noted that the ITAT had found as a fact that the AO had conducted an enquiry after reopening the proceedings and applied his mind. Once there was an application of mind by the AO, the CIT could not invoke jurisdiction under Section 263 to re-appreciate the facts. The Court observed that the assessment was reopened under Section 148/147 and completed under Section 143(3). In such circumstances, the CIT's attempt to re-appreciate facts under Section 263 was not permissible. Therefore, the appeal did not give rise to any substantial question of law. The Court did not decide the merits of the capital gains computation or the applicability of Section 50C, as the primary issue was the validity of the Section 263 revision.

What were the facts?

The assessee purchased an immovable property on 17.11.2007 and sold it on 18.11.2008 for Rs. 1.5 crores. The Revenue contended the market value was Rs. 3,27,70,000. As the assessee did not offer capital gains for Assessment Year 2009-10, the Assessing Officer (AO) reopened the assessment under Section 148 read with Section 147. The assessment was completed under Section 143(3) read with Section 147. Subsequently, the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) initiated proceedings under Section 263, alleging the assessment order was erroneous and prejudicial to revenue due to under-assessment of short-term capital gains and non-consideration of Section 50C. The CIT directed the AO to consider Section 50C. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) allowed the assessee's appeal against the CIT's order. The Revenue appealed to the High Court.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT's order holding that the initial assessment order was not erroneous and that the CIT's exercise of jurisdiction under Section 263 was bad in law, perverse, illegal, and liable to be set aside, is legally sustainable, considering the reasons in the Section 263 order? (Section 263) 2. Whether the ITAT was justified in not appreciating the AO's omission to tax short-term capital gains on the sale of immovable property within three years of purchase, despite full sale consideration being received? (Section 2(47)(v) and capital gains provisions) 3. Whether the ITAT was justified in not considering that the transaction was squarely covered by Section 2(47)(v) of the Income Tax Act? 4. Whether the ITAT was justified in holding that Section 263 cannot be invoked even when the AO arrived at a wrong conclusion, when the facts indicated capital gains should be taxed as short-term capital gains for AY 2009-10, with due application of Section 50C? (Section 263, Section 50C) Assessee's contentions: Not recorded. Revenue's contentions: The initial assessment order was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue. The AO failed to tax short-term capital gains and did not consider Section 50C. The transaction fell under Section 2(47)(v). The ITAT erred in allowing the appeal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 263,Section 148,Section 147,Section 143(3),Section 2(47)(v),Section 50C

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN AND HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE P.KESHAVA RAO I.T.T.A.No.97 of 2019

JUDGMENT: (per V. Ramasubramanian, J)

The Revenue has come up with the above appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short ‘the Act’), raising the following substantial questions of law: 1) In the facts and circumstances of the case, whether the order of the Hon'ble Tribunal (ITAT) in holding that the initial assessment order was not erroneous and exercise of jurisdiction by the learned Commissioner of Income Tax under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is bad in law, without due appreciation of relevant material facts and reasons mentioned in the order under Section 263 of the Act is not perverse, illegal and liable to be set aside? 2) In the facts and circumstances of the case, whether the Hon'ble Tribunal (ITAT) is justified in not appreciating the omission on the part of the Assessing Officer in not bringing the short term capital gains to tax in the event to sale of immovable property within three years from the date of purchase and that the sale consideration was received by the assessee in full? 3) In the facts and circumstances of the case, whether the Hon'ble Tribunal (ITAT) is justified in not considering that the transaction entered into by the assessee is squarely covered by Section 2(47)(v) of the Income Tax Act? 4) In the facts and circumstances of the case, whether the Hon'ble Tribunal (ITAT) is justified in holding that the provisions of Section 263 cannot be invoked even

when the Assessing Officer arrived at a wrong conclusion though the facts of the case clearly indicate that the Capital gain has to be taxed as Short Term Capital Gain for the AY 2009-10 with due application of Section 50C of the Income Tax Act, 1961? 2. Heard Mr.B.Narasimha Sarma, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Department. 3. The respondent/assessee purchased an immovable property along with another person on 17.11.2007. Thereafter, he sold the same to a realtor under a sale deed, dated 18.11.2008, for a sale consideration of Rs.1.5 crores. According to the Revenue, the market value of the property was Rs.3,27,70,000/- 4. Since the assessee did not offer capital gains arising out of the sale of the property, in the return of income for the assessment year 2009-10, the case was re-opened by the Assessing Officer under Section 148 of the Act, after issuing notice under Section 147 of the Act. 5. The assessment proceedings were completed under Section 143(3) read with Section 147 of the Act 6. However, the jurisdictional Commissioner of Income Tax issued a show cause notice under Section 263 of the Act, dated 06.02.2017, claiming that the assessment order was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue and that it had resulted in an under-assessment of short term capital gains. 7. The assessee submitted a reply to the show cause notice. Thereafter, the Commissioner passed an order, dated 27.03.2017,

holding that the order of assessment, dated 27.03.2015, passed under Section 143(3) of the Act was erroneous and that since the same was prejudicial to the interest of the Revenue, the Assessing Officer would consider the applicability of the provisions of Section 50C of the Act while computing the capital gains. 8. As against the said order, the assessee filed an appeal to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal, by an order, dated 20.07.2018, allowed the appeal. It is against the said Order that the Revenue has come up with the above appeal. 9. It is seen from paragraph No.10 of the impugned Order of the Tribunal that the Tribunal recorded findings of fact to the effect that the Assessing Officer actually carried out an enquiry after the reopening of the proceedings and that once there was an application of mind, on the part of the Assessing Officer, it was not open to the Commissioner to invoke the jurisdiction under Section 263 of the Act. The said finding of fact does not give rise to any substantial question of law before us. 10. It is seen from the Order of the Commissioner under Section 263 of the Act that the Assessment was actually reopened on the ground that the assessee did not offer capital gains. The reopening was under Section 148 of the Act after issuing notice under Section 147 of the Act. Thereafter, the assessment was completed under Section 143(3) of the Act. In such circumstances, what the Commissioner attempted to do by invoking Section 263 of the Act was only to re-appreciate the facts. Since it is not permissible, the appeal does not give rise to any substantial question of law. Hence, it is dismissed.

Consequently, miscellaneous petitions if ay pending in the writ petition shall stand dismissed. No order as to costs.

____________________________ V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, J

_____________________ P. KESHAVA RAO, J

March 15, 2019 smr

More judgments on Section 263

All 14,704 judgments and leading authorities on Section 263 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →