COMMISSIONER INCOME TAX vs. SRI. DILBAGH RAI ARORA
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that there was no legal infirmity in the order passed by the ITAT. The Court noted that the assessee had filed its return declaring Rs. 24 Crores and provided evidence for its claims. The addition of Rs. 7 Crores was made by the AO solely on the basis of the statement given during the survey, without any incriminating materials or documents to support it. The assessee's statement on 6.10.2005 clarified that Rs. 18 Crores were for investment in jewellery/precious stones and Rs. 6 Crores were cash shown in books, with details for the remaining Rs. 7 Crores to be provided later. The Court found that assets to the magnitude of Rs. 7 Crores were neither found nor identified, leading to the inference that no such assets existed. The Court reiterated that additions can only be made if there is incriminating material or surrounding circumstances justifying it. It distinguished the cited case laws, noting that in the present case, the addition was made mechanically on the statement alone, unlike in M/S Vertex Chemical Industries where the AO applied his mind and examined documents. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the questions of law were answered in favour of the respondent.
What were the facts?
The Revenue filed an appeal against the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's (ITAT) order dated 27.2.2009 for Assessment Year 2006-2007. The assessee, Sri Dilbagh Rai Arora, was searched on 1.9.2005, during which cash, jewellery, and other valuables were seized. The assessee filed a return on 30.10.2006 declaring an income of Rs. 24,05,86,630/-. On 6.10.2005, the assessee, in a statement under Section 132(4), offered a sum of Rs. 31 Crores for taxation, specifying Rs. 18 Crores for jewellery investment and Rs. 6 Crores as cash shown in books, with details for the remaining Rs. 7 Crores to be provided later. The Assessing Officer (AO) assessed total income at Rs. 31,03,04,332/-, adding back Rs. 7 Crores based on the Section 132(4) statement. The CIT(Appeals) deleted this addition, a decision confirmed by the ITAT.
What were the issues?
1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the order of the Hon'ble ITAT is perverse, as on identical facts and issue, the same bench held a retraction to be void and illegal in the case of Mr. Ravindra Kumar Verma (ITA No. 892/Luc/05 dated 04.02.2009)? (Question of law) 2. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT was right in law in deleting the addition of Rs. 7 crore, despite the surrender being made voluntarily with due care and caution and after necessary consultation? (Question of mixed law and fact, concerning Section 132(4) of the Income Tax Act, 1961) 3. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Hon'ble ITAT was right in law in holding that the addition was not based on any evidence, ignoring that a statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the I.T. Act is itself evidence? (Question of law) Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that concurrent findings of fact were recorded in its favour by the authorities below, and no question of law arises. It was emphasized that while a surrender of Rs. 31 Crores was made, the statement under Section 132(4) immediately clarified that only Rs. 24 Crores could be taxed in the disputed year, with details for the balance to be provided later. The assessee also relied on Circular dated 10.3.2003 (F. No. 286/2/2003-IT(Inv.)) stating that mere confessions during search and seizure cannot be grounds for addition. The assessee provided documents and explanations for Rs. 24 Crores. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue argued that once a statement for surrender of Rs. 31 Crores was given, the ITAT was not justified in confirming the deletion of Rs. 7 Crores. It relied on the judgments in Ravindra Kumar Verma v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Kanpur [2013] 30 taxmann.com 367 (Allahabad) and M/S Vertex Chemical Industries v. Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Lko. (ITA No. 250 of 2000 decided on 27.9.2016).
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Cited by 48 judgments on BharatTax
See all citing judgments →Counted from the text of the judgments hosted here. Most recent first.
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi v. M/S Vestige Marketing Private Limited, DelhiDelhi · 2026-03-20
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi v. M/S Vestige Marketing Private Limited, DelhiDelhi · 2026-03-20
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi v. M/S Vestige Marketing Private Limited, DelhiDelhi · 2026-03-20
- Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi v. M/S Vestige Marketing Private Limited, DelhiDelhi · 2026-03-20
- Vestige Marketing Pvt Ltd, Delhi v. DCIT Central Circle -05, DelhiDelhi · 2026-03-20
Reserved on. 5.3.2019 Delivered on. 15.3.2019 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 304 of 2009 Appellant :- Commissioner Income Tax Respondent :- Sri. Dilbagh Rai Arora Counsel for Appellant :- S.C. Inc. Tax,Gaurav Mahajan,Rk Upadhyay,S.S.C. I.T. Counsel for Respondent :- Ashish Bansal,S.K. Garg Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Piyush Agrawal,J. (Delivered by Hon'ble Piyush Agrawal, J) The present appeal has been filed under Section 260A of Income Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 27.2.2009 passed by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench 'A', Lucknow in ITA No. 658/Luc/2008 for the assessment year 2006- 2007. The aforesaid appeal was admitted by this Court on 6.12.2012 on the following questions of law- "1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the order of the Hon'ble ITAT is perverse in as much as on identical issue and on similar facts in the case of Mr. Ravindra Kumar Verma in ITA No. 892/Luc/05 dated 04.02.2009, the same bench held the
retraction to be void & illegal. 2. Whether on the facts and circumstance of the case the Hon'ble ITAT was right in law in deleting the addition of Rs. 7 crore inspite of the fact that the surrender was made voluntarily with due care and caution and after necessary consultation, with all concerned. 3. Whether on the facts and circumstance of the case the Hon'ble ITAT was right in law in holding that the addition was not based on any evidence. In doing so the ITAT ignored the fact that statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the I.T. Act was itself an evidence." On 1.9.2005, the business premises and residence of the respondent-assessee was searched. During the course of search operation cash, jewellery and other valuables were found and seized. On 30.10.2006, the respondent-assessee filed its return and declared its income of Rs. 24,05,86,630/-. Thereafter, notices under Section 143(2) and 142(1) were issued on 2.7.2007 and 5.11.2007 and questionnaires were issued on 14.12.2007 and 17.12.2007. In response to the notice and questionnaires, the detailed written replies were submitted and case was also discussed in detail with representative of Assessee. On 6.10.2005 the statement on oath of assessee-respondent was recorded under Section 132(4) in which he has offered to surrender a sum of Rs. 31 Crores for taxation for the Assessment Year
2006-07. In the statement, it has been accepted that out of said surrender a sum of Rs. 18 crores were surrendered on account of investment made in the acquisition of jewellery/precious stones and balance Rs. 6 crores were in the form of cash for which necessary entries in his books of account under the head capital accounts were being shown. He further added that details of remaining Rs. 7 crores would be given in due course of time. It was also stated that the income has been earned from trading in commodity exchange. Further on 15.9.2005 the statement of Raj Kumar Arora son of assessee was also recorded who reiterated the surrender of Rs. 31 crores to be taxed. But, seen the return filed by the Assessee disclosing taxable income of Rs. 24 crores (even after surrendering Rs. 31 crores) has retracted from his statement. The assessing authority while framing the assessment order dated 31.12.2007 has assessed the total income at Rs. 31,03,04,332/- and imposed tax accordingly. The assessing authority added back Rs. 7 crores to the income of assessee on the basis of statement given by the assessee-respondent
under Section 132(4) of the Act. Feeling aggrieved by the aforesaid order the assessee preferred appeal before the CIT (Appeals) who by its order dated 18.6.2008 has allowed the appeal and deleted the addition of Rs. 7 crores. Feeling aggrieved by the order of CIT (Appeals), the Revenue filed an appeal before ITAT Lucknow Bench, Lucknow, who by the impugned order has confirmed the order passed by CIT(Appeals) deleting addition of Rs. 7 crores. Heard Mr. Gaurav Mahajan, counsel for the appellant and Mr. Ashish Bansal, counsel for the respondent. On perusal of the record, it reveals that the business premises of the appellant was searched on 1.9.2005 and during the course of search, cash, jewellery and other valuables were found and seized and the statement of the assessee-respondent was recorded. On 6.10.2005, the statement given by the assessee that Rs.18 crores were in the form of investment and Rs. 6 crores were in cash which has been shown in the books of account for the Assessment Year 2006-07 and balance Rs. 7 crores due details would be given in due course of time. The counsel for the revenue has argued that
once a statement has been given for surrender of Rs. 31 crores towards taxation, the Tribunal was not justified inconfirming the deletion of Rs. 7 crores and has relied upon the judgment given in Ravindra Kumar Verma v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Kanpur
[2013]
taxmann.com
(Allahabad),ITA No. 481 of 2009 dated 23 January 2013 and M/S Vertex Chemical Industries v. Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Lko., ITA No. 250 of 2000 decided on 27.9.2016. Counsel for the respondent had argued that the concurrent findings of fact have been recorded by the authorities below in favour of the assessee respondent and no question of law arises in the present appeal. It was further emphasised that though the surrender was made for Rs. 31 crores, immediately thereafter, on 6.10.2005 when the statement was recorded under Section 132(4) the assessee has explained and had given the details that only sum of Rs. 24 crores can be taxed in the year under dispute and balance Rs. 7 crores detail will be given. The Tribunal as well as CIT(Appeals) after recording finding of fact in favour of the assessee has rightly deleted the addition of Rs. 7 crores as
there is no incriminating document or material on record which could be a good ground for addition of seven crores be added in the hand of the assessee. He further emphasized that merely a disclosure of confession cannot be ground for addition of Rs. 7 crores in the hand of assessee. Assesse counsel has further relied upon the circular dated 10.3.2003 F. No. 286/2/2003- IT (Inv). Wherein it has been held that more confession during the course of search and seizure operation cannot be a ground for addition in the income of the Assessee. We have perused the record of the case. The respondent-assessee has filed his return on 30.10.2006 and offered Rs. 24 crores for taxation. Assessee has filed the return and disclosed income from house property, income from other sources and loss on Long Term Capital Gain on the sale of immovable property. The assessee has further disclosed profit from trading in commodity exchange and has also filed evidence in support of his claim. The assessing authority has added back Rs. 7 crores only on the ground that at the time of survey dated 1.9.2005 the assessee had made a disclosure of sum of Rs. 31 crores for taxation in the year under
consideration. But, no incriminating materials and documents had been brought on record for addition of such amount. The CIT(Appeals) while allowing the appeal of the assessee has deleted the said amount, which was being confirmed by the impugned order. The assessee-respondent in the statement given on 6.10.2005, has surrendered Rs. 18 crores on account of investment made in purchase of jewellery/precious stones and Rs. 6 crores were surrendered as cash in hand duly shown in the books of account, balance Rs. 7 crores were surrendered with stipulation that details of the same would be given in due course of time. The assets to the magnitude of Rs. 7 crores were neither found by the authorities below nor such assets were identified or declared by the appellant. In such a situation, it could be inferred that no such assets actually exists. In other words, there is no clinching evidence or material to justify such addition of Rs. 7 crores. The addition can only be made, if there is incriminating material or the surrounding circumstances reveal that there is any material to justify the addition. The person making an admission is not always
mindful of it and some time can get out of its binding purview. If the person can explain exclusive with supportive evidence/material or otherwise that the admission by him earlier is not correct or contain a wrong statement or that a true state of affairs is different from that represented therein and so the same should not be accepted upon forecasting tax liability which should rather be fixed on the basis of correct and true affairs as ascertained from the material on record. The case law cited by the department in the case of Ravinder Kumar Verma (supra) wherein the search was conducted on 14.5.1998 at the business premises in Lucknow and various papers, books of account and cash were seized and later on by letter dated 5.4.2002 the assessee retracted the confessional statement and on that basis the Hon'ble Court came to the conclusion that after almost 4 years the retraction was made and further there was no allegation of coercion or any threat whereupon addition was made, which is afterthought. Paragraph 29 of the judgment in M/S Vertex Chemical Industries (Supra) is quoted herein below:- “29. In our case, the aforesaid judgment has no application. The reason
is that here is not a case of retraction by Assessee but during the course of assessment, documents produced by him have been examined threadbare and thereafter, reasons for addition have been given. This approach is evident from the fact that Assessing Officer has not mechanically made addition of Rs. 9 lacs which was disclosed in the statement under Section 132(4) of Act, 1961 but actual addition is only Rs. 8,12,360/- which shows due application of mind on the part of Assessing Officer, which has been affirmed by Tribunal.”
In the above judgment the Hon'ble Court has come to the. conclusion that the addition was not made merely on the statement made but after looking into the explanation, books of account and other material placed before him and then made the certain addition. The case in hand, the addition have only been made on the basis of statement given on 6.10.2005. Therefore, the case law relied upon by the Appellant is of no help. The case in hand the assessee-respondent has given documents, material and explained threadbare with regard to amount of Rs. 24 crores but the assessing authority has mechanically made the addition of Rs. 7 crores and added back the same amount only on the basis of statement having been made by the assessee which is not permitted. There is no legal infirmity in the order passed by the Tribunal.
The appeal fails and is dismissed. The questions of law are answered in favour of respondent and against the appellant. Order Date :- 15.3.2019 SY
More judgments on Section 132(4)
- Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Jagdish Kumar Dhingra, DelhiITA 5462/DEL/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- ACIT, New Delhi vs Garima Showbiz Pvt Ltd, DelhiITA 4813/DEL/2025[2016-17]Status: Disposed11 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Anil Agarwal, Hyderabad vs DCIT, Central Circle-1(1), HyderabadITA 1064/HYD/2026[2023-24]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2023-24
- Dinesh Singhal, Kishangarh vs Assessment Unit Income Tax Department, AjmerITA 199/JPR/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed5 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Girdhari Lal Swarnkar, Gorakhpur vs Income Tax Officer, Ward - 1(3), GorakhpurITA 233/VNS/2024[2016-2017]Status: Disposed4 Nov 2026AY 2016-2017
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026