COOPER CORPORATION PVT. LTD vs. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, SATARA CIRCLE AND ORS

PDF · subscribers
WP/10840/2011HC BombayHCBM01048132201122 December 2011Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE A.A. SAYED,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DR. D.Y. CHANDRACHUD4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the reopening of assessment, though beyond four years, was valid. The Court noted that the assessee's counsel conceded that the AO had not verified the expenditure under Section 40A during the original assessment under Section 143(3). Crucially, a statement recorded from the Director of the assessee during a survey action under Section 133A on March 11, 2011, constituted fresh material. This statement, specifically concerning Query No. 15 and the Director's answer, revealed that the Director was also the sole proprietor of Z.S. Engineers. The Court found that the assessee had not placed all true and material facts necessary for the assessment during the original proceedings. Therefore, the jurisdictional condition for reopening the assessment was duly fulfilled, and no case for interference was made out. The petition was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Cooper Corporation Pvt. Ltd. Satara, filed a writ petition challenging the reopening of its assessment for Assessment Year 2004-05. The Assessing Officer (AO) issued a notice dated March 30, 2011, under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, stating that income had escaped assessment. The reopening was based on two grounds: commission paid to various parties and payments made to persons covered under Section 40A(2)(b) of the Act. The revenue later stated that the first ground was not pressed. The second ground concerned payments to Cooper Metals Private Ltd. and Z.S. Engineers, which were reportedly running into losses. The AO noted that all orders of Z.S. Engineers were furnished only by the assessee and that the Director of the assessee, who is also the sole proprietor of Z.S. Engineers, attributed losses to recession, a reason the AO found vague given the assessee's increasing turnover.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reopening of assessment for AY 2004-05 under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is valid, considering it is beyond a period of four years. Assessee's contention: The assessee, through its counsel, conceded that the Assessing Officer had not verified the genuineness of expenditure pertaining to Section 40A in the original assessment under Section 143(3). Furthermore, a statement of the Director was recorded during survey action under Section 133A on March 11, 2011, which provided fresh material for reopening. The assessee also acknowledged that it had not placed all true and material facts before the AO during the original assessment proceedings. Revenue's contention: The revenue argued that the jurisdictional conditions for reopening were fulfilled due to the emergence of fresh material and the assessee's failure to disclose all material facts during the original assessment.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 143(3),Section 40A(2)(b),Section 133A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

VBC 1 wp10840.11-22.12 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY APPELLATE SIDE WRIT PETITION NO.10840 OF 2011 Cooper Corporation Pvt. Ltd. Satara. ..Petitioner. versus Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Satara Circle & Ors. ..Respondents. ..... Mr.Mihir C.Naniwadekar for the Petitioner. Mr.Tejveer Singh for the Respondents. ..... CORAM :  DR.D.Y.CHANDRACHUD & A. A. SAYED, JJ. December 22, 2011. P.C.  : The   Petitioner   seeks   to   question   the   reopening   of   an assessment for Assessment Year 2004­05.   By a notice dated 30 March 2011, the Assessing Officer stated that there was reason to believe that income chargeable to tax for the Assessment Year  has escaped assessment within the meaning   of Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 2. The reopening of the assessment is sought to be effected on two grounds.  The first ground pertains to commission paid to various parties.  The second relates to the payment covered under

VBC 2 wp10840.11-22.12 Section 40A(2)(b) to various persons. 3. In   so   far   as   the   first   ground   is   concerned,   Counsel appearing on behalf of the Revenue states that the first ground for reopening   is   not   pressed.     Hence,   the   validity   of   the   order   of reopening would have to be tested on the anvil of the second reason mentioned by the Assessing Officer. 4. The second ground for reopening is that the assessee has made payment to persons covered by Section 40A(2)(b), namely (i)   Cooper   Metals   Private   Ltd.   and   (ii)   Z.S.   Engineers.     On verification, according to the Assessing Officer, both these concerns were running into losses for several years.  All the orders of Z.S. Engineers   were   furnished   only   by   the   assessee.       When   the statement of the representative was recorded on 11 March 2011 during the course of the survey action, he stated that the entity was running into losses due to recession.   According to the Assessing Officer, this reason is vague and baseless since the sole  customer of Z.S. Engineers is the assessee.  The business and turn over of the assessee has increased substantially every year, and consistently

VBC 3 wp10840.11-22.12 over several years.   The Assessing Officer, has stated that there is a diversion of the funds by the assessee to Z.S. Engineers with a view to evade the liability to pay tax. 5. The reopening of the assessment in the present case is undoubtedly beyond a period of four years.   However,  Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner concedes that in the original order of assessment under Section 143(3), the Assessing Officer had not verified the genuineness of the expenditure pertaining to Section 40A.  Moreover,  a statement of the Director of the assessee was   recorded   in   the   survey   action   under   Section   133A   of   the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 11 March 2011.  In paragraph 3 of the reasons disclosed to the assessee, the Assessing Officer specifically adverted to Query No.15 and the answer of the Director, who is also stated to be the sole proprietor of M/s.Z.S.Engineers.   Fresh material, therefore, emerged on the basis of which the Assessing Officer has sought to reopen the assessment.   That apart, it is evident   that   during   the   course   of   the   original   assessment proceedings, the assessee had not placed all the true and material facts necessary for the assessment for that assessment year.   The

VBC 4 wp10840.11-22.12 jurisdictional condition for the reopening of the assessment has, therefore, been duly fulfilled.     No case for interference is made out.  The Petition is dismissed. ( Dr.D.Y.Chandrachud, J.) ( A. A. Sayed, J.)

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →