COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. LATE MISRILAL JAIN

PDF · subscribers
T.A./8/2002HC JharkhandJHHC01014385200207 November 2012Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that while Section 140A(3) deems an assessee in default for non-payment of self-assessed tax or interest, the liability to pay interest under Section 220(2) is specifically linked to the service of a demand notice under Section 156. Section 220(1) requires payment within thirty days of the service of such a notice. The judgment notes that all tax liabilities, except advance tax, require a notice under Section 156, and interest accrues only upon failure to comply with this notice. Undisputedly, the notice under Section 156 was issued to the assessee only after the final assessment order dated March 24, 1992. Therefore, the authorities below were correct in holding that the assessee was liable to pay interest only from the date of the order dated March 24, 1992. The Tribunal answered the questions accordingly. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Late Misrilal Jain, filed self-assessed returns of income. Initially, his income was assessed at Rs. 1,44,74,480, later revised to Rs. 1,45,40,721 under Section 143(3). Proceedings under Section 148 were initiated, leading to an ex-parte order that was later vacated. The assessee then filed a revised return on January 12, 1984, declaring an income of Rs. 1,96,91,399. After multiple appeals, the tax liability was finally determined by an appellate order dated March 24, 1992. The dispute concerns whether interest under Section 220(2) was payable from the date of the revised return (January 12, 1984) or from the date of the final appellate order (March 24, 1992). The facts were not in dispute.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the ITAT was justified in holding that original demands were wiped off by appellate orders between January 1, 1985, and March 24, 1992, leaving no pending demand? (Mixed law and fact, concerning Section 140A and Section 220(2)). 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the ITAT was justified in holding that interest under Section 220(2) could not be charged up to March 24, 1992, when the liability to pay balance self-assessment tax arose on January 12, 1984, upon the assessee filing a revised return and not paying self-assessment tax on the difference? (Mixed law and fact, concerning Section 140A and Section 220(2)). 3. Whether the Income Tax Department should not be compensated by way of interest under Section 220(2) for delayed payment of legitimate government dues, which remained quantified to the extent of the assessee's liability to pay balance self-assessment tax pursuant to the revised return filed on January 12, 1984? (Mixed law and fact, concerning Section 140A and Section 220(2)). Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that interest under Section 220(2) could only be levied after the service of a demand notice under Section 156, and such notice was only issued after the final appellate order dated March 24, 1992, as the liability had not crystallized before that date. They relied on Commissioner of Income Tax-1, Mumbai Vs. Chika Overseas (P) Ltd. ([2012] 23 taxmann.com 315 (Bombay)), Birla Cotton Spg. And Wvg. Mills Ltd. Vs. Income Tax Officer ([1995] 211 ITR 610 (CAL)), and Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Chloride India Ltd. ([1990] 186 ITR 217 (CAL)). Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue contended that Section 140A mandates the assessee to self-assess tax and pay it along with interest. Failure to do so makes the assessee 'in default' under Section 140A(3). They argued that the assessee was liable to pay interest from January 12, 1984, when the revised return was filed, as he did not pay the self-assessed tax and interest on the difference. They also argued that Section 156, requiring a demand notice, applies to tax payable in consequence of an 'order passed', and in self-assessment cases under Section 140A, no such order is required for the initial liability to arise.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 140A,Section 143(3),Section 148,Section 156,Section 220(2),Section 260A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Tax Appeal No.  8   of 2002 In the matter of an appeal under section 260A of Income Tax Act, 1961.

Commissioner of Income Tax, Ranchi Appellant Vs. Late Misrilal Jain through the Executor of Will Shri Gyanchand Jain Respondent ­­­­­ For the Appellant/Petitioner :  M/s.D.Roshan, Sr.S.C(IT), R.Kumari For the Respondent             : M/s.B.Poddar, Snr.Adv.,M.K.Choudhary D.Poddar, P.Poddar, A.Sinha

PRESENT HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY Reportable Dated 7

th    November, 2012

By Court Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. We are not going into the details of facts, in view of the reason that the question of law involved in this Tax Appeal requires no detailed consideration of facts because of the reason that the facts are not in dispute, which are relevant for the purpose of deciding this appeal. 3. The respondent­assessee submitted his self­assessed returns of income,   quantifying   at   Rs.1,44,74,480/­.   Assessee's   income   was assessed Rs.1,45,40,721/­ under section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. On 29th  September,1976, this returns was subjected to proceeding under section 148 and ex parte order was passed on 29.3.1982 which was     vacated on 8.7.1982   and the case was reopened under section 146. Then the assessee submitted another returns of income of Rs.1,96,91,399/­ on 12th January, 1984. After several rounds of appeals etc., ultimately the tax liability of the

assessee was determined by the appellate order dated 24th  March, 1992.   The issue involved in this Tax Appeal is only whether the assessee, who himself submitted revised returns of self­assessment of his income under section 140A of the Act of 1961, was liable to pay interest from the date of his filing revised returns, i.e., from 12th January, 1984, or was liable to pay interest when his tax liability was finally determined by the appellate order dated 24th  March, 1992. The facts are not in dispute and  assessment, appellate and remand orders are not relevant; therefore, we are not going to refer the various orders passed at various stages in this very proceeding. 4. This appeal was admitted on the basis of following questions of law:­ “(A)   Whether   on   the   facts   and   in   the circumstances   of   the   case,   the   ITAT   was   justified   in holding that the original demands had got completely wiped off during the intervening period firstly by way of appellate order dated 29.1.1985 by the Commissioner of Income  Tax (Appeals) and secondly by way  of  setting aside the further orders passed consequent thereto from time to time and no demand was pending during the period from 1.1.1985 to 24.3.1992? (B) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ITAT was justified in holding that interest under section 220(2) could not have been charged upto 24.3.1992 when liability to pay balance self assessment tax arose on 12.1.1984, the date on which the Assessee filed revised return of income showing total income of Rs.1,96,91,399/­(which is equal to the income assessed in   the   final   order   passed   by   the   Assessing   Officer   on 24.3.1992 in pursuance of the order of the ITAT) and did not pay self­assessment tax on the difference of income between revised return of income and original return of income? (C) Whether the income tax Department should not be compensated by way of realising interest under section   220(2)   for   delayed   payment   of   legitimate Government dues which always remained quantified to the   extent   of   Assessee's   liability   to   pay   balance   self­ assessment tax in pursuance of revised return by him on 12.1.1984?

Though   three   questions   of   law   have   been   framed,   in   our opinion, they, in fact, only constitute one question, which we have already referred above and it will answer all three questions. 5. According to the learned counsel for the Revenue, Sri Deepak Roshan, it is clear from Section 140A of the Act of 1961 that it is the duty of the assessee to self­assess the tax and the assessee is liable to pay self­ assessed tax  without any order of any authority and he is further liable to pay interest if he had not paid self­assessed tax in time as fixed by the statutory provision. If the assessee failed to pay self­assessed tax and interest under section 140A, then by virtue of sub­section (3) of section 140A, such assesse is deemed to be  “an assessee in default”  in respect of the tax or interest or both, which remained unpaid. Therefore, it is clear from the facts of the case that the assessee assessed himself to be liable to pay tax and interest on his income to the tune of Rs.1,96,91,399/­ and on 12th January, 1984 as admitted in his revised returns of income,  he did not pay interest over the said amount in view of  his revised returns on 12th January, 1984. Therefore, the assessee was statutorily “an assessee deemed to be an assessee in default” in respect of tax and interest amount which he did not pay. At the cost of repetition, it may be stated that, according to the learned counsel for the appellant, the assessee was defaulter  in view of sub­section (3) of section 140A from the time when he was supposed to pay tax and interest and he did not pay the interest and therefore, automatically without any order of any authority, he was liable to pay the  interest.

6.

Learned counsel for the Revenue, Mr.D.Roshan, also submitted that section 156 of the Act of 1961 provides for issuance of demand notice for the cases wherein any tax, interest, penalty, fine or any other sum is payable in consequence of any “order passed” under the Act of 1961 and then  the assessee is required to be served with a notice   of   demand   in   the   prescribed   form   specifying   the   sum   so payable. In contra, in this case, no such order was required to be passed   by   any   Assessing   Officer   demanding   the   tax   or   interest liability to the assessee, when the assessee was liable to pay tax and interest   by   his   own   assessment   under   section   140A.   Therefore, without there being any notice under section 156 issued on 12th January, 1984, prior to 24th March, 1992, the assessee was liable to pay the tax and interest. However, the assessee since has paid paid the tax amount, he is liable to pay interest only now. 7. Learned counsel, Sri Binod Poddar, Sr. Counsel, submitted that admittedly a notice under section 156 was, in fact, issued and served upon the assessee only after appellate order dated 24th March, 1992, because of the reason that by final order dated 24th March, 1992, the assessee's liability crystallized and before that, assessee's liability had not attained finality and crystallized in quantified form. Therefore, in case of self­assessment, one can assess his income and submit the returns accordingly along with the proof of payment of tax and if there is delay, with proof of payment of interest. It is submitted that in the case  of self­assessment by the assessee but  crystallizing tax liability of the assessee by final order, the interest can be levied

under section 220(2) of the Act of 1961 only after service of demand notice demanding specified amount, which the assessee is required to pay within the stipulated period of 30 days and in default thereof, he  is  liable  to  pay  the  interest.  It  is  further  submitted   that  the appellate authority and the Tribunal rightly held that the assessee is liable to pay interest from the date of final order passed by the appellate authority on 24th  March, 1992. Learned counsel for the respondent relied upon judgment of the Division Bench of Bombay High Court delivered in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax­ 1, Mumbai   Vs.   Chika   Overseas   (P)   Ltd.  reported   in  [2012]   23 taxmann.com 315 (Bombay) and upon judgment of Calcutta High Court delivered in the case of  Birla Cotton Spg. And Wvg. Mills Ltd. Vs. Income Tax Officer reported in [1995] 211 ITR 610 (CAL). Learned counsel for the respondent also relied upon one judgment of Calcutta   High   Court   delivered   in   the   case   of  Commissioner   of Income Tax Vs. Chloride India Ltd.  reported in  [1990] 186 ITR 217 (CAL). 8. We considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and perused the relevant provisions of law. 9. It is clear from section 140A that after taking into account the relevant factors as enumerated in sub­clause (i) to (v) under sub­ section (1) of section 140A, the assessee is liable to assess his income and  to pay tax calculated according to the above provisions together with interest as payable under any of the provisions of the Act of 1961 and is required to pay tax in advance before furnishing returns

and returns shall be accompanied   with   the proof of payment of such tax and interest. Such aggregate of tax and interest as deposited by the assessee is required to be adjusted to reply  against tax and then surplus  against interest as per Explanation appended to section 140A. Sub­section (3) of section 140A provides that,  if assessee fails to pay the whole or any part of such tax or interest or both in accordance with the provisions of sub­section (1) of section 140A, then he will be “deemed to be an assessee in default” in respect of the tax or interest or both, which remained unpaid.  And it has also been provided in sub­section (3) of section 140A that all the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly, obviously treating such assessee to be a defaulter – defaulter  in payment of tax and interest. In spite of declaring such assessee to be a defaulter,  in the same section 140A liability of the interest has not been created on such unpaid amount and Explanation appended to section 140A only provided that the amount so paid by the assessee under section 140A shall be adjusted against tax liability and excess shall be against interest liability. For creating interest liability, a separate provision has been made under the heading “Calculation and Recovery” by section 220. Sub­section (2) of section 220, which is sought to be applied by the Revenue, provides that if the amount as specified in the notice of demand under   section   156,   is   not   paid   within   the   period   limited   under section (1), the assessee shall be liable to pay simple interest at the stipulated rate of interest from the date specified. Sub­section (1) of section 220 provides that any amount,  otherwise than  by way of

advance   tax,   specified   as   payable   in   a   notice   of   demand   under section 156, shall be paid within thirty days of the service of the notice upon the assessee. Therefore, all tax liability,  except advance tax,  have been made liable to be followed by a notice under section 156 and only when the assessee fails to comply with the conditions of the notice under section 156 and fails to pay the due amount, then he is liable to pay interest. No other provision has been shown to us creating any liability for self­assessment default cases and for deemed defaulter under section (3) of section 140A. Undisputedly notice   under   section   156   was   given   to   the   assessee   after   final assessment order dated 24th  March, 1992. The authorities below were,  thus,  right in holding that the assessee in the present case was liable to pay interest from the date of the order dated 24th March, 1992. The question is, therefore, answered accordingly. 10. In view of the above reasons, there is no merit in this appeal, which is dismissed. (Prakash Tatia, C.J.) (Jaya Roy, J.) Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi The 7th November, 2012 NAFR/dey

More judgments on Section 140A

All 155 judgments and leading authorities on Section 140A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →