THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. Ms Gulab Wire Products Pvt Ltd

PDF · subscribers
T.A./8/2013HC JharkhandJHHC01027859201306 December 2013Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(R. BANUMATHI),HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH5 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the Tax Appeal filed by the Revenue on the grounds of maintainability. The Court noted that the learned counsel for the Revenue fairly submitted that the tax effect involved in the addition of Rs. 36,78,410 regarding the payment made to the creditor would be less than Rs. 10,00,000 and would be governed by Instruction No. 3 of 2011. This instruction specifies that appeals under Section 260A before the High Court shall not be filed where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 10,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was less than Rs. 10,00,000, the Court held that the Tax Appeal filed by the Revenue was not maintainable and accordingly dismissed it. The ITAT's decision on the merits of the addition was not adjudicated upon by the High Court.

What were the facts?

The Revenue appealed against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated October 8, 2012, which deleted an addition of Rs. 36,78,410 made by the Assessing Officer (AO) for Assessment Year 2008-09. The assessee, M/s Gulab Wire Products Pvt. Ltd., had filed a return declaring a loss. The AO had made additions including Rs. 1,00,716 for outstanding VAT, Rs. 69,347 for depreciation, and Rs. 36,78,410 for payments to sundry creditors, treating the latter as undisclosed income. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) confirmed the AO's order. The ITAT, however, deleted the addition of Rs. 36,78,410.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT erred in ignoring the facts and circumstances available before it as emerged from the finding of the decision of the CIT(A)? (Question of law/mixed law and fact) 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT is justified in accepting fictitious debtors of Rs. 36,78,410 from 7 parties for which no details were furnished and the same were held as non-existent by the AO & CIT(A)? (Question of law/mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contention: The assessee raised a preliminary objection regarding the maintainability of the appeal, citing CBDT Instruction No. 3 of 2011, which mandates a monetary limit of Rs. 10,00,000 for filing appeals before the High Court. The assessee argued that the tax effect in this appeal was less than Rs. 10,00,000, making the appeal not maintainable. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue argued that the ITAT erred in deleting the entire addition of Rs. 36,78,410, as the assessee failed to discharge the onus regarding the creditors and the ITAT accepted fictitious debtors. The Revenue prayed for the appeal to be allowed.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(1),Section 260A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Tax Appeal No. 8 of 2013 The Commissioner of Income Tax .... Appellant ­Versus­ M/s Gulab Wire Products Pvt. Ltd. Jamshedpur .....Respondent CORAM :        HON’BLE THE  CHIEF JUSTICE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH .... For the  Appellant: M/s Deepak Roshan, Sr.S.C.(IT) & Rupa Kumari,Adv.

For the Respondent: M/s B.Poddar, Sr.Adv., M.Choudhary,Amrita Sinha, Darshal Poddar Mishra & Piyush Poddar,Advs.

Dated 6

th   December , 2013

By Court­ This Tax Appeal is preferred against the order of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi dated 08.10.2012 passed  in   I.T.A.   No.   20/Ran/12   deleting   the   entire   addition   of Rs.36,78,410/­ made by the Assessment Officer for the Assessment Year 2008­09 raising the following questions of law: ­ (I)  Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the Case the learned ITAT has not erred in ignoring the facts and circumstances available before it as emerged from the finding of the decision of the CIT(A)? (II) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the  Case the learned ITAT  is  justified accepting the fictitious debtors of Rs.36,78,410/­ from 7 parties for which no details were furnished and the same were held as non­existence by the AO & CIT(A)? 2. The Assessee filed its Return of Income for the Assessment Year 2008­09 on 29.03.2008 declaring loss of income of Rs.9,00,374/­. The return was processed under Section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. (i)   The   outstanding   liability   of   VAT   Rs.1,00,716/­   was disallowed and added back to the total income; (ii)Depreciation of Plant & Machineries are disallowed and the actual   cost   of   Plant   &   Machineries   was   treated   as   NIL

2.

and   depreciation   claimed   by   the   Assessee   amounting   to Rs.69,347/­   was   disallowed   and   added   back   to   the   total income; (iii)The claim of payment to sundry creditors of Rs.36,78,410/­ was   disallowed   and   the   Assessing   Officer   opined   that   it   is taxable in the hands of the Assessee Company and the same was added back to the total income. 3. Being aggrieved by the order of the Assessing Officer, the Assessee preferred appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). Before the CIT(Appeals), the Assessee did not press the outstanding liability   of   VAT   of   Rs.1,00,716/­.   However,   Ground   No.(ii)   i.e., disallowance   of   depreciation   on   Plant   &   Machinery   amounting   to Rs.69,347/­   and   Ground   No.(iii)   &   (iv)­   against   the   addition   of Rs.36,78,410/­   in   respect   of   payment   to   M/s.   Sandeep   Industries, Sundry   Creditors   of   the   Assessee   Company   were   pressed.   The   CIT (Appeals) confirmed the order of the Assessing Officer holding that the amount   of   Rs.36,78,410/­   is   treated   as   undisclosed   income   of   the Assessee Company and the action of the Assessing Officer in taxing the said amount was confirmed. 4. Being aggrieved by the order of the CIT(Appeals), the Assessee preferred appeal before the ITAT. The ITAT allowed the appeal deleting the addition of Rs.36,78,410/­. ITAT held as under: ­ “On careful analysis of the impugned orders passed by both the   lower   authorities,   we   find   that   both   the   lower authorities   have   not   disputed   the   entries   made   by   the assessee in the respective ledger accounts of sundry creditors as well as sundry debtors, to whom the amounts were paid for supply of machinery. Both the amounts are equal. Apart from that it is undisputed that the sundry creditors as well as sundry debtors both are regular parties dealing with assessee. It   is   a   running   account   with   the   assess.   The   assessee   is purchasing   the   materials   from   the   said   M/s.   Sandeep

Industries, sundry creditors and it is also undertaking the order from M/s. Sandeep Industries. The sale proceeds out of this   order   is   entered   in   the   account   of   M/s.   Sandeep Industries and the same fact is also found that the assessee has made advances for supplying of machineries to various concerns   during   the   period   under   consideration   and   the aggregate of such advances are of equal amount that were paid   to   M/s.   Sandeep   Industries   towards   the   account. Therefore, in the light of not finding fault of this account by the departmental authorities the contention of the assessee that amount being equal and that were not disclosed in the balance sheet separately is to be accepted. In the remand report submitted by the AO no where it was mentioned that the   advances   given   by   the   assessee   to   the   suppliers   for machinery is not correct. In this view of the matter, the contention of the assessee is to be accepted. Hence, we are of the conclusion that the reasons given by the departmental authorities are not sustainable for legal scrutiny. Hence, the same   is   hereby   set   aside   by   allowing   the   appeal   of   the assessee”. 5. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that ITAT was not justified in deleting the entire addition of Rs.36,78,410/­ made by the Assessing Officer inspite of the fact that the Assessee has failed to discharge the onus regarding the creditors. It was submitted that the ITAT was not justified in accepting the fictitious debtors of Rs.36,78,410/­ from 7 (seven) parties for which no details were furnished and the same was held as non­existent and prayed for allowing of the appeal. 6. The learned  Senior Counsel  for the Assessee raised preliminary objection   relating   to   the   maintainability   of   the   appeal   and submitted that Instruction No.3 of 2011 dated 09.02.2011 specifies the   mandatory   limit   of   Rs.10,00,000/­   (Rupees   Ten   Lakh)   for maintainability of appeal before the High Court. CBDT directed the

4.

Revenue not to raise substantial question of law where the tax effect is less than the amount prescribed in the instructions issued by it. The tax effect in revenue appeals is less than Rs.10,00,000/­ (Rupees Ten Lakh), which was filed even prior. 7. Learned   counsel   for   the   respondent­assessee   has   drawn   our attention   to   the   Instruction   No.3/2011   dated   9.2.2011   and submitted that the tax effect involved in this Tax Appeal is less than Rs.10.00   lacs   and,   therefore,   the   instant   Tax   Appeal   is   not maintainable. 8. We have heard Mr.Deepak Roshan, learned counsel, appearing for the Revenue, who fairly submitted that the tax effect involved in respect of addition of Rs.36,78,410 regarding the payment made to the creditor would be less than Rs.10.00 lacs and, therefore would be governed under Instruction No.3 of 2011. 9. The Instruction No.3/2011 [F. No. 279/  Misc.142 /2007  / ITJ] dated  9.2.2011 reads as follows : Instruction No.3/2011[F.No.279/Misc.142/2007/ITJ]Dated 9.2.2011. “Reference   is   invited   to   Board's   instruction   No.5/2008   dated 15­5­2008 wherein monetary limits and other conditions for filing departmental   appeals(In   Income­tax   matters)   before   Appellate Tribunal, High Courts and Supreme Court were specified. 2. In supersession of the above instruction, it has been decided by the Board that departmental appeals may be filed on merits before Appellate Tribunal, High Courts and Supreme Court keeping in view the monetary limits and conditions specified below. Henceforth appeals shall not be filed in cases where the tax effect does not exceed the monetary limits given hereunder:­ S.No. Appeals in Income Tax matters Monetary Limit (in Rs.) 1. Appeal before Appellate Tribunal 3,00,000 2. Appeal u/s 260A before High Court 10,00,000 Appeal before Supreme Court 25,00,000

5.

It is clarified that an appeal should not be filed merely because the tax effect in a case exceeds the monetary limits prescribed above. Filing of appeal in such cases is to be decided on merits of the case.” 10. Since the tax effect involved in the present appeal is less than   Rs.10.00   lacs,   in   view   of   Instruction   No.   3/2011   dated 9.2.2011, the Tax Appeal filed by the Revenue is not maintainable and the same is dismissed.

( R.Banumathi, C.J. )

( Aparesh Kumar Singh, J.) G.Jha/Aditya

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →