COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S.MITHILA MOTORS LTD.

PDF · subscribers
T.A./7/2002HC JharkhandJHHC01010390200206 November 2012Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY1 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi dismissed the Tax Appeal filed by the Revenue. The Court found that the issue raised by the Revenue regarding the allowability of depreciation on moulds, treated as containers, was already decided by various High Courts. Specifically, the Court referred to the judgment of the Patna High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Steel City Beverages (P) Ltd. (1996) 222 ITR 744 (Pat.), the Madras High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Upasna Finance Ltd. (2006) 286 ITR 179 (Mad.), and the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Margdarshi Chit Fund (P) Ltd. These decisions, according to the High Court, held that an assessee is entitled to depreciation on new purchases of containers, and by analogy, on moulds. The High Court concluded that the appeal was covered by these precedents and therefore dismissed it. No issues were left undecided.

What were the facts?

This case involves an appeal by the Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur (the Revenue) against an order concerning M/s Mithila Motors Limited (the assessee). The assessment year(s) are not explicitly stated in the provided text. The appeal challenges a decision on the allowability of depreciation on new purchases of 'moulds', which the assessee contends are akin to 'containers'. The procedural history indicates that the Revenue filed this Tax Appeal No. 07 of 2002 before the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. The amount in dispute is not mentioned.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the assessee is entitled to depreciation on new purchases of moulds, which are argued to be analogous to containers, under the relevant provisions of the Income Tax Act (the specific provision is not named but relates to depreciation). The assessee contends that the issue is settled by pronouncements of various High Courts. They cite the judgment of the Patna High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Steel City Beverages (P) Ltd. reported in (1996) 222 ITR 744 (Pat.). Furthermore, they refer to decisions of the Madras High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Upasna Finance Ltd. reported in (2006) 286 ITR 179 (Mad.) and the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Margdarshi Chit Fund (P) Ltd. These judgments, according to the assessee, hold that an assessee is entitled to depreciation on new purchases of containers, and moulds should be treated similarly. The Revenue's specific arguments are not recorded in the provided text.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI ----- Tax Appeal No. 07 of 2002 ----- Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur .... Appellant

Versus M/s Mithila Motors Limited .... .... .... Respondent

----- CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY

For the Appellant : Mr. Deepak Roshan, Sr. S.C. (I.T.) Ms. Rupa Kumari, Advocate For the Respondent : Mr. Binod Poddar, Sr. Advocate Mr. M.K. Choudhary, Advocate Mr. Darshan Poddar, Advocate Mr. Piyush Poddar, Advocate Ms. Anita Sinha, Advocate

----- Order No. 10 Dated 6

th November, 2012

Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the issue raised by the appellant in this appeal as question of law in fact stands answered, in view of the judgment of Patna High Court delivered in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Steel City Beverages (P) Ltd. reported in (1996) 222 ITR 744 (Pat.). It is also submitted that the same issue has been considered by the Madras High Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Upasna Finance Ltd. reported in (2006) 286 ITR 179 (Mad.) and Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Margdarshi Chit Fund (P) Ltd. and has been answered against the Revenue and it has been held that “ the assessee would be entitled to depreciation on new purchases of the containers' and in present case also they are on the articles of Moulds which are also the containers. In view of the above decisions, we are of the considered opinion that the issue is covered by the judgment referred above and the Tax Appeal, therefore, is dismissed in the light of the reasons given in the above judgments. (Prakash Tatia, C. J.)

(Jaya Roy , J.) SI/Anit

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →