COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S SIDHI VINAYAK METCON LTD
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that there was no reason to entertain the Tax Appeal. The addition made by the Assessing Officer should not have been made because the amounts received towards share applications were by way of cheque. The assessee had furnished all the details regarding the applicants, and the Department could have issued notices to such applicants. Therefore, there was no need for the Assessing Officer to make the addition of Rs. 95,15,000/-. The Court noted that a prayer for issuing notices to share applicants could have been made before the CIT(A), but no such application was preferred by the appellant. Consequently, the Court saw no reason at that stage to remand the matter to the Assessing Officer for further verification. The Court found no error committed by the ITAT or the CIT(A) and concluded that no substantial question of law was involved. The appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Sidhi Vinayak Metcon Ltd., is in appeal against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The assessment year in question is 2005-06. The Assessing Officer (AO) made an addition of Rs. 95,15,000/- on account of share applications, stating that the identity of the applicants remained unverified and the assessee could not provide a satisfactory reply. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] allowed the assessee's appeal, quashing the addition, as the amounts were received by cheque and the assessee had provided detailed explanations. The Department appealed to the ITAT, which dismissed the appeal, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Lovely Exports (Pvt.) Ltd. The High Court is now hearing a Tax Appeal preferred by the Department against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT was justified in confirming the order of the CIT(A) who deleted the entire addition, failing to appreciate that the identity of 5 share applicants remained unidentified and the genuineness of the transaction of 2 persons was not verified? (Question of law) 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT was justified in confirming the order of the CIT(A) who deleted the entire addition and failed to remand the case to the AO for thorough investigation, despite findings regarding the unidentified identity of five share applicants and unverified genuineness of transactions of two persons? (Question of mixed law and fact) 3. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, the order passed by the ITAT is perverse? (Question of law) Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that the amounts were received by cheque, and the Department could have followed up on bank entries. Detailed explanations were provided to the CIT(A). The ITAT rightly relied on the decision in Lovely Exports (Pvt.) Ltd. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue contended that the identity of 5 share applicants remained unidentified and the genuineness of transactions for 2 persons was not verified. They argued that the ITAT should have remanded the case to the AO for further investigation.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
206A
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2009
The Commissioner of Income Tax, 47-Circuit House Area, P.O. & P.S. Mango, Jamshedpur, District East Singhbhum … … Appellant
Versus Sidhi Vinayak Metcon Ltd. I J, Shanti Hari Inner Circle Road, P.O. & P.S. Bistupur, Jamshedpur, Dist :- East Singhbhum ... ... Respondent
------
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D.N. PATEL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR
-----
For the Appellant: Deepak Roshan
For the Respondents: Darshana Poddar Mishra
----- 20/Dated 5th April, 2018 Per D.N.Patel,J.
This Tax Appeal has been preferred by the Department under Section 206 A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 raising the following substantial question of law: “a) “Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the Case the learned ITAT was justified in confirming the Order of CIT (A) who has deleted the entire addition and had failed to appreciate that the Identity of 5 Share Applicants remained unidentified and genuineness of the transaction of 2 persons were not verified?” b) “Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the Case the learned ITAT was justified in confirming the Order of CIT (A) who has deleted the entire addition and had failed to remand the Case to AO for thorough investigation in spite of his clear finding with respect to the existence and identity of the five share applicants remained unidentified and genuineness of the transaction of regarding 2 persons remained unverified?” c) “Whether on the fact and circumstances of the case the order passed by the ITAT is perverse?” 2. Having heard counsels appearing for both sides and looking to the facts and circumstances of the case, it appears that this case is pertaining to Assessment Year 2005-06. Looking to the Assessment Order dated 27th December, 2007, it appears that an addition of Rs.95,15,000/- has been made mainly for the reason that though this amount pertained to share
-2- applications, but, the identity of the applicants remained unverified and the assessee could not give reply in this regard. Order dated 27th December, 2007 is at Annexure 1 to the memo of this Tax Appeal. 3. Thereafter, being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the Assessment Order for the assessment year 2005-06, appeal was preferred before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) in which a detailed explanation was given by the assessee as to from where the amount was received. The amount was received by way of cheque and hence, the Department could have followed up the bank entries etc. which was not done. Therefore, said appeal, being Appeal No. 416/JSR/2007-08, was allowed on 20th November, 2008 and the addition made by the Assessing Officer was quashed and set aside. The said order is at Annexure 2 to the memo of this Tax Appeal. 4. Being aggrieved and feeling dissatisfied by the said order, appeal was preferred before the Income Tax appellate Tribunal , Ranchi Circuit Bench, Ranchi by the Department. The learned I.T.A.T. dismissed the appeal preferred by the Department mainly on the ground that Assessee has not only disclosed, relevant particulars with respect to the shareholders, but, the amount received by the Assessee towards share application was also by way of cheque and the Department could have also followed the bank entries because all the share amount was received by the assessee by way of cheques from the applicants. The learned I.T.A.T. has dismissed the appeal rightly relying upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Lovely Exports (Pvt.) Ltd. reported in 216 CTR 195 (Para 5) 5. Having heard counsels appearing for both sides and looking to the facts and circumstances of the case, we see no reason to entertain this Tax Appeal mainly for the reason that the addition made by the Assessing Officer should not have been made by him because amount received towards the share applications was by way of cheque. All the details regarding applicants were furnished by the assessee and Department could have issued notices to such applicants. Hence, there was no need for the Assessing Officer to make addition of Rs. 95,15,000/-. 6. It appears that before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) also such prayer could have been made by the Department for issuance of Notices upon share applicants. No such application was preferred before C.I.T. (Appeals) by this appellant. Hence, we see no reason at this stage to remand the matter to the Assessing Officer for further verification of share applications.
-3- 7. It appears that similar type of cases are coming to this court often and most of the time same type of error is committed by the Assessing Officers, either deliberately or due to “induced ignorance”. This is not the first time such type of matter has been taken up by this Court
It is now high time for the Commissioner, Income Tax to have orientation courses or induction courses conducted for the Assessing Officers to make them understand that whenever assessee receives any amount by cheque, there is a need for the Assessing Officer to give notice to the drawers of those cheques. 8. In view of the aforesaid facts and reasons, there is no substance in this Tax Appeal as no error has been committed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal while passing Order dated 10th July, 2009 in I.T.A. No. 18/Ran/2009 (Annexure 3 to the memo of this appeal) and the Commissioner of Income Tax has also not committed any error while passing Order dated 20th November, 2008 in Appeal No. 416/JSR/07-08 (Annexure 2 to the memo of this Tax Appeal) and as there is no substantial question of law involved in this Tax Appeal, this Tax Appeal is, hereby, dismissed.
(D.N.Patel, J.)
(Rajesh Kumar, J.)
s.m.
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Kbb Nuts PVT. Limited vs. Mr. Suresh Chand & Ors.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Amritsar Haveli Cuisines Private Limited & Anr. vs. Amarbir Singh & Ors.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Abd Maestro Private Limited vs. Great Galleon Ventures LTDDelhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Jangeer Singh Trading As Jangeer Singh Kabulshah Agriculture Works vs. Yogesh Jangid Trading As Jangid Agro Engineering & Anr.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Rabindranath Behera vs. The Chief Commissioner, CT And GST, OdishaOrissa · 3 Nov 2026