COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. SHIV KUMAR BHAKAT

PDF · subscribers
T.A./17/2010HC JharkhandJHHC01000194201013 January 2016Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D. N. PATEL,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMITAV K. GUPTA1 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeal should be dismissed based on the CBDT Circular No. 21/2015 dated December 10, 2015. The court noted that the monetary limit involved in the present case was less than the enhanced limit of Rs. 20 Lakhs for filing appeals before the High Courts. Furthermore, the court found that the facts of this particular case did not fall within the exceptions enumerated in paragraph 8 of the aforementioned circular. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. Any interim relief previously granted was also vacated. The ratio decidendi is that pending appeals that do not meet the revised monetary threshold for appeal, and do not fall under the specified exceptions, should be dismissed in light of the retrospective application of the CBDT circular.

What were the facts?

This case involves an appeal filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur (the Revenue) against Shiv Kumar Bhakat, Proprietor of M/s Highway Transport Service (the Assessee). The appeal was filed before the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. The core of the matter revolves around the monetary limits for filing appeals by the Income Tax Department. The parties brought to the court's attention CBDT Circular No. 21/2015, dated December 10, 2015, which revised these monetary limits. The circular enhanced the limit for filing appeals before the High Courts to Rs. 20 Lakhs and was stated to be applicable retrospectively to pending appeals.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the revised monetary limit for filing appeals before the High Court, as stipulated in CBDT Circular No. 21/2015 dated December 10, 2015, is applicable to the present appeal, which was pending at the time of the circular's issuance? (Question of law) Assessee's Contentions: The assessee's counsel, along with the revenue's counsel, submitted that the latest circular issued by the CBDT, Circular No. 21/2015, provides revised monetary limits for filing appeals. They highlighted that the monetary limit for High Courts has been enhanced to Rs. 20 Lakhs and that the circular's instructions are to be applied retrospectively to pending appeals. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue's counsel concurred with the assessee's submission regarding the applicability of the CBDT circular and its retrospective effect on pending appeals.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Tax Appeal No.17 of 2010 The Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur … Appellant Versus Shiv Kumar Bhakat, Proprietor: M/s Highway Transprot Service, NH-33, Baliguma, Ghatshila … … ... … ... ... Respondent ------ CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D. N. PATEL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMITAV K. GUPTA ----- For the Appellant: M/s. Deepak Roshan For the Respondent: M/s. K.P. Choudhary, A.R. Choudhary ------ 07/Dated: 13th January, 2016 Per D.N. Patel, J. 1) Counsels appearing for the parties submitted that the latest circular issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes, i.e. CBDT Circular 21/2015 dated 10th December, 2015, gives revised monetary limits for filing appeals by the Income Tax Department before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunals and the High Courts and for filing S.L.P. before Hon'ble the Supreme Court. 2) As per the aforesaid circular, monetary limit with respect to High Courts has been enhanced to Rs.20 Lakhs. This circular provides for some exceptions enumerated in Paragraph No.10 thereof and looking to Paragraph No.10 thereof, it appears that aforesaid instructions contained in the Circular is to be applied retrospectively to the pending appeals before the High Courts. Photocopy of the aforesaid circular is taken on record. 3) Having heard counsels for both sides and looking to the Circular dated 10th December, 2015 and also looking to the facts that monetary limit involved in the present case is less than Rs.20 lakhs and that the facts of this case do not fall within the purview of the exceptions pointed out at paragraph no.8 of the aforesaid circular, this appeal is dismissed. 4) Interim relief, if any, stands vacated. (D. N. Patel, J) Manoj/

(Amitav K. Gupta, J)

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →