Vijeta Projects And Infrastructure Limited Through Its Director Shri Parma Singh vs. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax And Ors
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court dismissed Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 and Civil Review No. 13 of 2016 for non-prosecution. The Court noted that the review petitions had been listed for hearing numerous times, with the petitioners frequently seeking adjournments. The Court emphasized that the power of review is limited to correcting "mistakes apparent on the face of the record" and cannot be used as an appellate power to re-examine merits. The judgment cited "Meera Bhanja v. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury" and "Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Mallikarjun Bhavanappa Tirumale" to define "error apparent on the face of the record" as an error that is self-evident and does not require extensive reasoning. Given the lack of appearance by the review petitioners and the history of adjournments, the Court found no basis to proceed with the review on merits. The interim order dated August 5, 2015, was consequently vacated.
What were the facts?
The judgment concerns Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 filed by Alchemist Infra Reality Limited and Civil Review No. 13 of 2016 filed by Care Vision Mutual Benefit Limited. Both petitions sought review of an order dated May 11, 2015, passed in W.P.(PIL) No. 1635 of 2014. The review petitioners argued that the original order, which directed an investigation by the CBI, was passed without adhering to principles of natural justice as they were not heard. They also contended that the case did not fall within the parameters laid down by Supreme Court judgments. The respondents argued that there is no legal requirement to hear proposed accused before ordering a CBI investigation. The review petitions faced numerous adjournments, and an interim order staying the original order was in place. Ultimately, the matters were dismissed for non-prosecution.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the review petitions are maintainable on the ground of "error apparent on the face of the record" and breach of natural justice, specifically concerning the direction for CBI investigation without hearing the review petitioners? Assessee's Contention: The review petitioners argued that the order dated May 11, 2015, suffered from "errors apparent on the face of the record" and was passed in violation of natural justice principles because they were not heard before the direction for CBI investigation was issued. They relied on "State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar", "Rajender Singh Pathania v. State (NCT of Delhi)", and "K.V. Rajendran v. CBCID" to argue that their case did not fit the criteria for such an investigation. Revenue's Contention: The respondents contended that there is no legal requirement to hear proposed accused individuals before a court orders an investigation by the CBI. They cited "E. Sivakumar v. Union of India" to counter the plea of breach of natural justice.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Civil Review No. 92 of 2015
Alchemist Infra Reality Limited, a company registered under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, through its Director Shri Chatrasal Singh son of Narendra Singh Ranawat having its registered office at 723, DLF Tower 'A', Jasola District Centre, PO Sarita Vihar, PS Sarita Vihar, New Delhi- 110044 (NCR of Delhi)
... Petitioner Versus 1. Jharkhand Against Corruption, through its Vice President Santosh Kumar Singh, son of Sri S.N. Singh, resident of Nai Basti, PO: Ashok Nagar, PS: Argora, District: Ranchi; 2. The State of Jharkhand; 3. The Home Secretary, Govt. of Jharkhand, Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi; 4. The Director General of Police, Jharkhand, Police Headquarter, Dhurwa, Ranchi; 5. The Union of India through Secretary, Department of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, New Delhi; 6. The Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India, North Block, New Delhi; 7. The Central Bureau of Investigation, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 8. The Director, the Central Bureau of Investigation, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 9. The Director, Enforcement Directorate, Shivaji Park, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 10. The Director (Investigation), Income Tax, Income Tax Building, 7 Main Road, Chutia, Ranchi.
… Respondents with Civil Review No. 13 of 2016
Care Vision Mutual Benefit Limited, through its Director, Beni Shankar Jha, son of Late Bal Kuntha Jha, having its registered office at Mangal Tower, First Floor, 103, Kantatoli Chowk, Lower Bazar, Ranchi (Jharkhand).
... Petitioner Versus 1. Jharkhand Against Corruption, through its Vice President Santosh Kumar Singh, son of Sri S.N. Singh, resident of Nai Basti, PO Ashok Nagar, PS Argora & District Ranchi (Jharkhand); 2. The State of Jharkhand through Home Secretary, Department of Home, Govt. of Jharkhand, having its office at Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi; 3. Director General of Police, Jharkhand, Police Headquarters, having its office at Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi; 4. The Union of India, through the Secretary, Department of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, New Delhi; 5. Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India North Block, New Delhi; 6. Central Bureau of Investigation, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 7. Director, Central Bureau of Investigation, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 8. Director, Enforcement Directorate, Shivaji Park, Lodhi Road, New Delhi; 9. Director (Investigation), Income Tax, Income Tax Building, 7 Main Road, Chutia, Ranchi.
… Respondents
-2- Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & analogous cases
with W.P.(Cr.) No. 220 of 2018 Nishi Kumari, wife of Shri Ashwani Kumar, resident of Sharma House, Matwari Colony, PO Hazaribagh, PS Korra (Sadar), District Hazaribagh.
…..Petitioner Versus 1. The State of Jharkhand through the Superintendent of Police, Central Bureau of Investigation, Ranchi, PO GPO, PS Kotwali, District Ranchi; 2. The Executive Magistrate, Hazaribagh Collectorate, Hazaribagh; 3. The Sub Divisional Officer, Sadar, Hazaribagh.
…....Respondents ------
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RATNAKER BHENGRA ----- For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate; Mr. Arpan Mishra, Advocate; Ms. Sonal Jaiswal, Advocate (in Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & Civil Review No. 13 of 2016) None (in W.P.(Cr.) No. 220 of 2018) For the Respondents : Mr. Ravi Kerkettta, SC-VI; Ms. Deepika Jajower, AC to SC-VI (in W.P.(Cr.) No. 220 of 2018)
-----
Order No. 35/ Dated: 22nd November 2023
Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & Civil Review No. 13 of 2016
Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 was filed on 22nd July 2015 and today is the thirty-fifth date of hearing of this petition. 2.
Civil Review No. 13 of 2016 was filed on 20th April 2016 and today is the twenty-eighth date of hearing of this petition. 3.
These civil review petitions have been filed seeking review of the order dated 11th May 2015 passed in W.P.(PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 primarily on the ground that in view of the judgments in “State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar” (2011) 14 SCC 770, “Rajender Singh Pathania v. State (NCT of Delhi)” (2011) 13 SCC 329 and “K.V. Rajendran v. CBCID” (2013) 12 SCC 480 the case against the review petitioners does not fall within the parameters laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid cases. The review petitioners have further pleaded that the order passed in W.P.(PIL) No.1635 of 2014 suffers from errors apparent on the face of the record and the said order has been passed without following the rules of natural justice
-3- Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & analogous cases
inasmuch as the review petitioners were not heard before a direction was issued by the Court for investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (in short, CBI). 4.
On the other hand, the respondents have taken a plea that there is no requirement in law to hear the proposed accused before an order for investigation by the CBI is passed by the Court. As it would appear from the order dated 13th February 2020, the learned counsel for the CBI referred to “E. Sivakumar v. Union of India” (2018) 7 SCC 365 to controvert the plea of breach of natural justice raised by the review petitioner(s). 5.
The proceedings in Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 would indicate that by an order dated 5th August 2015, the order dated 11th May 2015 passed in W.P.(PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 was stayed by this Court but, thereafter, final hearing of this civil review could not take place on the next more than thirty occasions because for the one or the other reasons the parties sought adjournments. The proceedings in Civil Review No. 13 of 2016 also tells a similar story. One of the reasons why final hearings in these matters could not take place was that relevant materials including the pleadings in W.P.(PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 were not brought on record. This also appears from the order dated 19th December 2019 that on 19th December 2019 when these matters were listed for the first time before this Bench the attempt by the review petitioners to seek adjournment was declined and the applications filed by the intervenors were disposed of. It further appears from the proceeding dated 19th December 2019 that by that time the respondents had not filed their response to these civil review petitions. It also does not appear from the proceedings in these civil review petitions that the review petitioners ever made a grievance regarding not filing of the counter-affidavit and it seems that they were quite happy with the adjournments because they are enjoying an interim order by this Court. 6.
The order dated 13th February 2020 reads as under: “[ I.A. No. 1015 of 2020 in Civil Review No. 92 of 2015] 33/13.02.2020: This application has been filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation (hereinafter referred to as CBI) raising a preliminary objection to maintainability of the review petition. In this application, the applicant has referred to the decision of the Supreme Court in “State of Punjab Vs. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar and others” reported in (2011) 14 SCC 770 and “E. Shivakumar Vs. Union of India and others” reported in (2018) 7 SCC 365. 2. Mr. Rajiv Sinha, the learned counsel for the CBI submits that
-4- Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & analogous cases
an accused has no right of hearing and he cannot maintain a review petition on the ground that before an order was passed which may adversely affect him he must be heard. The learned counsel submits that in compliance of the order passed by this Court in WP (PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 and in WP (PIL) No. 642 of 2016, the First Information Reports registered at various police stations in Jharkhand, such as, FIR No. 543 of 2013 dated 06.09.2013 of Deoghar Police Station, FIR No. 69 of 2013 of Tilaiya Police Station and FIR No. 573 of 2016 of Town Police Station, Hazaribagh were re-registered by CBI as RC 08 (A)/2015-D, RC 07(S)/2015-D and RC 27 (S)/ 2017-EOW (R) respectively. 3. During the course of hearing, it has transpired that the pleadings in WP (PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 and the order passed in WP (PIL) No.642 of 2016 have not been placed on record. 4. Accordingly, the review petitioner is directed to complete
the records in so far as WP (PIL) No. 1635 of 2014 is concerned. 5. Mr. Rajiv Sinha, the learned counsel for the CBI shall place on record the orders passed in WP (PIL) No.642 of 2016 and other materials. 6. Post these matters under the heading “Final Disposal” on 26.03.2020. 7. Let a copy of the order be given to the learned counsels for the parties.”
The concern of the Court is indicated in the order dated 17th October 2023 which reads as under: “Order No. 34 /Dated: 17th October 2023
Today is the 34th date of listing of these matters. 2. Still, Mr. Arpan Mishra, the learned counsel for the petitioner(s) is seeking adjournment. 3. Post these matters on 10th November 2023 at 1:15 PM. 4. In the meantime, the learned assisting counsel to Mr. Anil Kumar, the learned ASGI shall seek instructions in these matters and ensure compliance of the order dated 19th December 2019 passed by this Court.”
The power of review can be exercised for correction of a mistake apparent on the face of record. The expression “error apparent on the face of record” is distinct from an erroneous decision. The error apparent on record refers to such an error which does not require a process of reasoning to arrive at a conclusion and which is self evident. In “Meera Bhanja v. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury” (1995) 1 SCC 170 the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the review proceedings are not by way of an appeal and must strictly remain confined to the scope and ambit of Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In “Meera Bhanja”, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under: “8. It is well settled that the review proceedings are not by way of an appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order 47, Rule 1, CPC. In connection with the limitation of the powers of the court under Order 47, Rule 1, while dealing with
-5- Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & analogous cases
similar jurisdiction available to the High Court while seeking to review the orders under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court, in the case of Aribam Tuleshwar Sharma v. Aribam Pishak Sharma, speaking through Chinnappa Reddy, J., has made the following pertinent observations: (SCC p. 390, para 3) “It is true as observed by this Court in Shivdeo Singh v. State of Punjab, there is nothing in Article 226 of the Constitution to preclude the High Court from exercising the power of review which inheres in every Court of plenary jurisdiction to prevent miscarriage of justice or to correct grave and palpable errors committed by it. But, there are definitive limits to the exercise of the power of review. The power of review may be exercised on the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence was not within the knowledge of the person seeking the review or could not be produced by him at the time when the order was made; it may be exercised where some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record is found; it may also be exercised on any analogous ground. But, it may not be exercised on the ground that the decision was erroneous on merits. That would be the province of a court of appeal. A power of review is not to be confused with appellate power which may enable an appellate court to correct all manner of errors committed by the subordinate court.” 9. Now it is also to be kept in view that in the impugned judgment, the Division Bench of the High Court has clearly observed that they were entertaining the review petition only on the ground of error apparent on the face of the record and not on any other ground. So far as that aspect is concerned, it has to be kept in view that an error apparent on the face of record must be such an error which must strike one on mere looking at the record and would not require any long-drawn process of reasoning on points where there may conceivably be two opinions. We may usefully refer to the observations of this Court in the case of Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Mallikarjun Bhavanappa Tirumale wherein, K.C. Das Gupta, J., speaking for the Court has made the following observations in connection with an error apparent on the face of the record: An error which has to be established by a long-drawn process of reasoning on points where there may conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of the record. Where an alleged error is far from self-evident and if it can be established, it has to be established, by lengthy and complicated arguments, such an error cannot be cured by a writ of certiorari according to the rule governing the powers of the superior court to issue such a writ.”
Mr. Indrajit Sinha, the learned counsel has tendered an e-mail copy of the letter dated 21st November 2023 written by the Resolution Professional. 10.
Taken on record. 11. According to this e-mail, the Resolution Professional wants to engage another counsel. 12.
But no one appears for the review petitioner(s). 13.
Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & Civil Review No. 13 of 2016 are dismissed for non-prosecution.
-6- Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 & analogous cases 14.
Interim order dated 5th August 2015 passed in Civil Review No. 92 of 2015 stands vacated.
W.P.(Cr.) No. 220 of 2018 15.
No one appears on behalf of the petitioner. 16.
W.P.(Cr.) No. 220 of 2018 is dismissed for non-prosecution.
(Shree Chandrashekhar, J.)
(Ratnaker Bhengra, J.) S.B./Nibha
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Multitech Agro INDIA (Opc) PVT LTD vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 5 Nov 2026
- Gopa Satya Madhava Subbarao vs. The State Of Andhra PradeshAndhra Pradesh · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Kallu Cable vs. The Commissioner State Goods And Service TaxUttarakhand · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Dream Home Interiors vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial TaxesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Jishu Suklabaidya vs. The Union Of INDIA And 16 Ors.Gauhati · 4 Nov 2026