THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. DR KHALID FOUNDATION

PDF · subscribers
T.A./12/2014HC JharkhandJHHC01013912201430 September 2016Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D. N. PATEL,HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S. N. PATHAK4 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court quashed and set aside the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in ITA No.117/Ran/2010 dated July 11, 2011. The Court found that the ITAT had passed a common order for multiple matters, mixing up facts and failing to appreciate the specific factual aspects of the present case. The ITAT's reasoning that the application was for renewal and that registration was previously granted under Section 12AA was found to be factually incorrect for this case. The High Court observed that the previous application for registration under Section 12A had been dismissed by the CIT on December 31, 2007, and this order had attained finality. The subsequent application was also dismissed. The High Court held that the ITAT's order was perverse and lacked proper appreciation of facts. Therefore, the matter was remanded to the ITAT for a fresh decision on merits, allowing the respondent an opportunity to be heard and to adduce evidence if required. The substantial questions of law were answered accordingly for the purpose of remand.

What were the facts?

The Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT), Ranchi (Appellant) has filed this Tax Appeal against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ranchi Bench. The ITAT had allowed an application by Dr. Khalid Foundation (Respondent) in ITA No.117/Ran/2010, quashing the order passed by the CIT. The Appellant contends that the ITAT's order was passed without proper appreciation of facts, mixing up facts from other cases, and without assigning valid reasons. The Respondent had applied for registration under Section 12A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. An earlier application on June 22, 2007, was dismissed by the CIT on December 31, 2007, and this order attained finality. A subsequent application on September 30, 2009, was also dismissed by the CIT on March 25, 2010. The ITAT allowed the appeal against the latter dismissal.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide the following substantial questions of law: 1. Whether the ITAT was justified in quashing the order passed by the CIT under Section 12AA(1)(b)(ii) without deeply examining the basis of rejection by the CIT? 2. Whether the ITAT was correct in directing the CIT to grant registration under Section 12AA without appreciating that the Trust failed to establish its charitable purpose and public benefit? 3. Whether the ITAT was correct in directing the CIT to grant registration under Section 12AA without verifying the independent existence of the Trust? 4. Whether the ITAT was correct in directing the CIT to grant registration under Section 12AA without appreciating that the Settlor reserved all rights, which is against the spirit of a charitable trust? 5. Whether the ITAT was correct in directing the CIT to grant registration under Section 12AA without appreciating that the Trust failed to establish the genuineness of its activities vis-à-vis its stated objects? 6. Whether the ITAT was correct in passing a common order involving other assessees with different issues? 7. Whether the impugned order is perverse? Assessee's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions made by the Respondent (Dr. Khalid Foundation) before the High Court. However, the ITAT's reasoning, as quoted in the judgment, suggests that the assessee's material was not incorrect, and previous registrations/renewals under Section 12AA and 80G supported their claim. The ITAT found the CIT's orders not in accordance with law. Revenue's Contentions: The Appellant (CIT) argued that the ITAT's order was passed without assigning any reason, mixed up facts from other cases, and that the factual aspects were wrongly appreciated. The Appellant raised the substantial questions of law listed above.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 12A,Section 12AA,Section 12AA(1)(b)(ii),Section 80G

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Tax Appeal No.12 of 2014 The Commissioner of Income Tax, Ranchi, Aaykar Bhawan, Luby Circular Road, P.O. & P.S. - Dhanbad, District – Dhanbad … ... … Appellant Versus Dr. Khalid Foundation, Govindpur, P.O. & P.S. - Govindpur, District – Dhanbad … ... ... Respondent ------ CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D. N. PATEL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DR. SHIVA NAND PATHAK ----- For the Appellant: M/s. Deepak Roshan, Advocate For the Respondent: M/s. Darshana Poddar Mishra, Advcoate ------ 11/Dated: 30th September, 2016 Per D.N. Patel, J. 1) This Tax Appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order delivered by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi in ITA No.117/Ran/2010, whereby the application preferred by the respondent was allowed without assigning any reason and whatever factual aspects have been mentioned are absolutely false and wrong, as more than half a dozen cases have been decided at a time and the facts of other cases have been mixed up with the facts of the present case and wrongly the application has been allowed, as submitted by the counsel for the appellant. Substantial questions of law have been raised which are as under: - i. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the learned ITAT was justified in law in quashing the order u/s 12AA(1)(b)(ii) of the I.T. Act, 1961 passed by the CIT without going in depth the basis of rejection taken by CIT? ii. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the learned ITAT was correct in law in directing the CIT to grant registration u/s 12AA of the Act without appreciating the fact that the Trust failed to establish that it has been created for charitable purpose and for the benefit of the Public? iii. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the learned ITAT was correct in law in directing the CIT to grant registration u/s 12AA of the Act without verifying the independent existence of the Trust?

-2- iv. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the learned ITAT was correct in law in directing the CIT to grant registration u/s 12AA of the Act without appreciating the fact that the Settler reserves all rights with him which is totally against the spirit of Charitable Trust? v. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the learned ITAT was correct in law in directing the CIT to grant registration u/s 12AA of the Act without appreciating the fact that the Trust failed to establish genuineness of its actual activities vis-a-vis its stated objects which is essential condition to be fulfilled for grant of registration u/s 12AA of the I.T. Act, 1961? vi. whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the ld. ITAT is correct in passing a common order involving other Assessee(s) having difference issues? vii.Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the impugned order is perverse? 2) Having heard learned counsels for both sides and looking to the facts and circumstances of the case, combined and joint reasons given by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in para-6 for half a dozen matters which are as under: - “6. On careful analysis of the order(s) passed by the ld. CIT(s) and the rival submissions of all the parties, it is found that the assessee-society(s) was/were given registration under section 12AA and renewal was granted under section 80G for earlier years, therefore, it cannot be said that the material filed by the assessee(s) is incorrect. In this background, we are of the considered view that these are the fit cases to renew the registration of the Trusts and the impugned orders passed by the ld. CIT are not in accordance with law. Hence, the same are hereby set aside by directing the CIT(s) to renew the registration under section 80G and also grant of registration under section 12A/AA of the I.T. Act, 1961 as prayed for by the assessee(s) in different application(s), by allowing appeals of the assessee(s).”

-3- 3) The aforesaid reasons have been given jointly for every matter by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi including in ITA No.117/Ran/2010. 4) It appears that the facts of the present case have not been appreciated at all. Earlier this respondent-Trust had preferred an application under Section 12A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 22nd June, 2007 for its registration. This application was dismissed and the registration was refused by the Commissioner of Income Tax by an order dated 31st December, 2007. No appeal was preferred by the respondent and the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax was accepted. The said order had attained its finality. 5) It appears from the facts of the case that the respondent again preferred an application under Section 12A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 30th September, 2009 for registration and again the application was dismissed by an order dated 25th March, 2010 by the Commissioner of Income Tax. 6) Being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax dated 25th March, 2010, the respondent preferred appeal being ITA No.117/Ran/2010 which has been allowed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi by an order dated 11th July, 2011, with the only reason given in para-6 as quoted herein above. 7) Looking to the reasons given by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench,Ranchi in allowing the aforesaid ITA No.117/Ran/2010, it appears that factually wrong aspects have been appreciated and wrongly this appeal has been allowed of the respondent. It has been observed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal that there was an application for renewal of the registration. It is factually a wrong aspect of the matter. Moreover, previously the registration was granted under Section 12AA is also not a fact of this case. 8) It ought to be kept in mind by the Income Tax Appellate Tribuna

l that whenever they decide more than one matter, all care should have been taken for factual aspects of each & every case, otherwise, this type of error is bound to occur. 9) In view of these facts, we, hereby, quash and set aside the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi in

-4- ITA No.117/Ran/2010 judgment and order dated 11th July, 2011 and we hereby remand the matter to Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi for its afresh decision. ITA No.117/Ran/2010 is revived to its original file. The same will be decided on merit of the case and on the basis of the evidences on record. Substantial questions of law raised in this appeal are accordingly answered which are necessary for remand of the matter. 10) It is needles to say that Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench, Ranchi will afford an opportunity of being heard to the respondent, who is appellant before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, in ITA NO.117/Ran/2010. The respondent will also be permitted to adduce evidence if so required. 11) This Tax Appeal is allowed and disposed of. (D. N. Patel, J) Manoj/

(Shiva Nand Pathak, J)

More judgments on Section 12A

All 6,672 judgments and leading authorities on Section 12A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →