Commissioner Of Income Tax, Dehradun vs. Snjay Ghai

PDF · subscribers
ITA/35/2013HC UttarakhandUKHC01007377201319 March 2014Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE2 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the appeal preferred by the Commissioner of Income Tax. The Court found no ground to admit the appeal. The Tribunal had initially allowed the Department's rectification application based on a purported concession from the assessee's counsel. However, upon the assessee's subsequent application, the Tribunal recalled its earlier order, noting that no such concession was ever given by the assessee's counsel and there was nothing on record to support it. The Tribunal's second order effectively corrected its own erroneous decision which was not based on rectifying a mistake but on a false premise of a concession. The Court rejected the revenue's contention that the power of rectification applies only to original orders and not miscellaneous orders, stating that if the order, which was rectified, were left unchanged, it would become the original order. Therefore, the Tribunal's action of recalling its order was upheld.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Sanjay Ghai, appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal) against an order of the Commissioner of Appeals and succeeded. Subsequently, the Department filed an application before the Tribunal for rectification, questioning the service of a notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal allowed the Department's rectification application based on a purported concession made by the assessee's counsel. The assessee then filed another rectification application, arguing that no such concession was given and that the Tribunal's earlier order allowing the Department's application was incorrect. The Tribunal accepted the assessee's second application, recalled its order, and noted that no concession was ever given by the assessee's counsel and there was no record to support it. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun, has preferred this appeal against the Tribunal's order recalling its earlier rectification order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in recalling its earlier order allowing the Department's rectification application, which was based on a purported concession from the assessee's counsel, when no such concession was actually given and there was no mistake in the original order to rectify under Section 154 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that the Tribunal's order allowing the Department's rectification application was based on a non-existent concession by the assessee's counsel. The assessee further contended that the Tribunal, in its subsequent order, correctly identified that no concession was given and that its earlier order was not for rectifying a mistake but was based on a false premise. The assessee's counsel argued that the Tribunal had the power to recall its order when it was passed erroneously. Revenue's contentions: The revenue contended that the power of rectification under Section 154 is applicable to original orders and not to miscellaneous orders. The revenue argued that the Tribunal's order allowing the Department's rectification application was a miscellaneous order and thus not subject to recall on the grounds presented.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148,Section 154

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL Income Tax Appeal No. 35 of 2013

Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun

……….. Appellant

Versus

Sanjay Ghai, 81-D, Rajpur Road,, Dehradun

……….. Respondent

Present: Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, Advocate for the appellant.

Mr. Arv

ind Vashistha, Advocate for the respondent.

Coram: Hon’ble Barin Ghosh, C.J.

Hon’ble V.K. Bist, J.

BARIN GHOSH, C.J. (Oral)

The Tribunal was approached by the assessee against the order of the Commissioner of Appeals. It succeeded. Thereafter, an application was filed by the Department before the Tribunal for rectification. The issue was, whether the service of the notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 has been served or not? It did not indicate, in its rectification application, that any mistake crept in the order of the Tribunal as, in fact, there was none. The Tribunal allowed the said application not recording that in its earlier order, there was any mistake, but on the basis of a purported concession said to have been given by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the assessee. Having had seen that order, the assessee re-approached the Tribunal seeking for rectification of its order, by which the Tribunal allowed the rectification application of the Department on the basis of the purported concession given by the counsel for the assessee. The Tribunal accepted the application of the assessee and recalled its earlier order, which was passed not for the purpose of rectifying a mistake, but on the basis of a purported concession said to have been given by the counsel for the assessee after having had noticed specifically that no such concession was ever given by the learned counsel for the assessee and there is nothing on record to show that any such concession

2 was given. Aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been preferred.

The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant is contending that the power of rectification is of original orders and not of miscellaneous orders. The fact remains that the order, which stands rectified, if left unchanged, would become the original order. We are, accordingly, unable to accede to the contention on finding no ground to admit the appeal. The same is dismissed.

(V.K. Bist, J.) (Barin Ghosh, C.J.) 19.03.2014 19.03.2014

P. Singh

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →