THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DEH AND ANOTHER vs. M/S TIDE WATER MARINE INTER AGENT OF HUGHE EVERETT

PDF · subscribers
ITA/25/2006HC UttarakhandUKHC01010569200620 February 2006Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P. C. VERMA7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on February 13, 2001, were indeed issued beyond the period prescribed by Section 149(3) of the Act. This sub-section stipulates that for persons treated as agents of non-residents under Section 163, a notice under Section 148 shall not be issued after the expiry of two years from the end of the relevant assessment year. Since the assessment years were 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99, and the notices were issued in February 2001, they were beyond the two-year limit. Consequently, the Court found that the orders passed by the Assessing Authority were void ab initio. The Tribunal was therefore correct in holding that the penalty imposed under Section 271(1)(C) of the Act was also null and void. The Court concluded that no substantial question of law arose for consideration, and the appeals were devoid of merit.

What were the facts?

The appeals were filed by the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun, against M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc., acting as agent for various non-residents. The assessment years under consideration were 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99. The assessees did not file returns within the prescribed time but filed them in 2000. The Assessing Officer treated these returns as late and issued notices under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on February 13, 2001. Subsequently, notices under Sections 143(2) and 142(1) were issued. The Assessing Officer assessed total income, imposed tax, and initiated penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(C) at 100% of the tax evaded. The Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the assessees' appeals. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) decided these appeals in favor of the assessees, holding the assessment orders and penalties to be void. The High Court is now considering the Revenue's appeals against the ITAT's decision.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on February 13, 2001, for assessment years 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99, were barred by limitation prescribed under Section 149(3) of the Act, considering the assessees acted as agents for non-residents under Section 163 of the Act. Assessee's Contention (as inferred from the judgment's reasoning): The assessees argued, and the Tribunal found, that the notices under Section 148 were issued beyond the two-year period stipulated in Section 149(3) of the Act, rendering the subsequent assessment and penalty proceedings void ab initio. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue appealed the ITAT's decision, implicitly arguing that the notices were validly issued and the assessment and penalty proceedings were not time-barred. The judgment does not explicitly detail the Revenue's specific arguments beyond filing the appeals.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148,Section 149(3),Section 143(2),Section 142(1),Section 271(1)(C),Section 163

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

COURT NO.2 IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARANCHAL AT NAINITAL (1) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.25 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Hughes Everett …………. Respondent

(2) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.26 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Miller Robert …………. Respondent

(3) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.27 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Castro Jorge Valerio

…………. Respondent

(4) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.28 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Beigel Hans Jurgen

(5) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.29 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Johnson Robert …………. Respondent

(6) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.30 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Miller Robert …………. Respondent

(7) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.31 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Diola Noe C.

…………. Respondent

(8) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.32 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Nakrst Franci

…………. Respondent

(9) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.33 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Rose Cooper Charles

…………. Respondent

(10) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.34 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Nagbanua Rogelio

…………. Respondent

(11) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.35 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Davies Jack Elbert

…………. Respondent

(12) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.36 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Marcelino Junio

…………. Respondent

(13) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.37 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Lea Kea Yul

…………. Respondent

(14) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.38 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Garcia Cirilio Escarez …………. Respondent

(15) INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.39 OF 2006

1.

The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun 2. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Circle, Dehradun.

............. Appellants

Versus

M/s Tide Water Marine International Inc. As agent of Mr. Diola Noe C.

…………. Respondent

Sri Pitamber Maulekhi, learned standing counsel for the appellants

Dated: February 20, 2006

Coram: Hon’ble P.C. Verma, J. Hon’ble B.C. Kandpal, J.

Per Hon’ble P.C. Verma, J.

All these bunch of appeals have been preferred by the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun. The relevant income tax assessment years in all these appeals are 1996-97-, 1997-98 and 1998-99. 2.

Brief facts of the case giving rise to all these appeals are that no return was filed by the assesses in the relevant assessment years within the time prescribed for, however the returns were filed in the year 2000. The Assessing Authority found them to be beyond time. Thereafter, a notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter will be referred to as the Act) was issued on 13.02.2001. In response to the notice, the assessee submitted that the return filed may be treated as compliance to the said notice. The notices under Section 143(2) and Section 142(1) of the Act were also issued. In response to these notices, the submissions were filed on various dates. The Assessing Officer assessed the total income and imposed the tax and also passed the order to initiate the penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(C) of the Act. The Assessing Officer levied a penalty at the rate of 100% on tax sought to be evaded by the assessee. The assessee preferred an appeal against the Assessment Order before the Commissioner (Appeals). The Commissioner (Appeals) also dismissed the appeal of the assessee, however the detailed order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) is not available on record. Learned standing counsel for the Revenue also fairly conceded this fact. Against the dismissal order of the Commissioner (Appeals), the assessee filed appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The Tribunal decided all these appeals by one and a common judgment, therefore, all these appeals here are also being disposed of by one and a common judgment.

It is not disputed that the notice under Section 148 of the Act was issued on 13.02.2001. 4.

Sub-section (3) of Section 149 of the Act Prescribes the period for assessment or re-assessment or re-computation to be made in pursuance of the notice under Section 148 of the Act. Sub-section (3) of Section 149 of the Act also prescribes that the notice shall not be issued after the expiry of a period of two years from the end of the relevant assessment year in case a person on whom a notice is to be served as a person treated as the agent of a non-resident under Section 163 of the Act. 5.

In all these appeals the respondents are the agents under Section 163 of the Act and the relevant assessment years are 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 and notices were issued on 13.02.2001 under Section 148 of the Act, therefore the notices were issued beyond the time prescribed by Sub-section (3) of Section 149 of the Act. Thus, the order passed by the Assessing Authority was void ab initio. Hence, the Tribunal has rightly held that the penalty imposed under Section 271(1)(C) of the Act vide the assessment order is also null and void. 6.

In view of the aforesaid facts and in our opinion no substantial question of law arises for consideration in all these appeals. 7.

Therefore, all the appeals are devoid of merit and are dismissed accordingly. No order as to costs.

(B.C. Kandpal, J.) (P.C. Verma, J.)

20.02.2006

20.02.2006

Rajeev Dang

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →