ENSCO MARITIME LTD. MR MANGATAS SIHOMBING vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DEHRADUN
What did the High Court hold?
Regarding the first question, the High Court held that it had already been decided by a Division Bench of the same Court in the case of "Sedco Forex International Inc. Vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax and another" (decided on July 22, 2005, in Income Tax Appeal No. 165 of 2001). In that judgment, the question was answered in favour of the Revenue. For the second question, the High Court noted that it had been decided by the Hon'ble Apex Court in "Sedco Forex International Drill Inc. and Others Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun and Another" (JT 2005(9) SC 639). In view of the Apex Court's decision, this question was answered in favour of the assessee. The appeal was disposed of accordingly.
What were the facts?
The appellant, Ensco Maritime Ltd. (earlier Dual Offshore Ltd.), acting as agent for Mr. Mangatas Sihombing, filed an appeal against an order dated July 26, 2004, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Bench 'F', New Delhi. The appeal pertains to the assessment year 1997-98. The High Court of Uttaranchal at Nainital was seized of this appeal. Both parties were ready to argue the matter. The appeal was preferred against the ITAT's order. The parties agreed that only two specific questions of law were to be determined, and the rest were not pressed.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the learned ITAT erred in law by holding that the appellant failed to satisfy the condition that 'the remuneration is not deductible in computing the profits of an enterprise chargeable to tax in that other state'? This question turns on the interpretation of provisions related to the deductibility of remuneration in foreign states. The appellant's contention is that the ITAT's finding was erroneous. The revenue's contention is not recorded. 2. Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that off-period salary was not taxable under Section 9(1)(ii) read with the Explanation as it stood at the relevant time? This question concerns the taxability of salary earned during periods when the employee was not actively working. The appellant's contention is that the Tribunal's holding was correct. The revenue's contention is not recorded.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
COURT NO. 2
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARANCHAL AT NAINITAL
Income Tax Appeal No. 187 of 2004
Ensco Maritime Ltd. (earlier known as Dual Offshore Ltd.) as agent of Mr. Mangatas Sihombing C/o Nangia & Company, Chartered Accountants, 75/7 Rajpur Road, Dehradun ..............Appellant
Versus
The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun
.............. Respondents
Ms. Krishi Shukla, Advocate for the appellant.
Dated: February 20, 2006
Coram: Hon. P.C. Verma, J. Hon. B.C. Kandpal, J.
Both the parties are ready to argue the matter today.
This appeal has been preferred against the order dated 26.07.2004 for the assessment year 1997-98, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, (Bench 'F' New Delhi).
The learned counsel for the parties agree that the following only two questions of law arise in this appeal for the determination. They do not press the rest of the questions framed in the appeal: -
Whether the learned I.T.A.T. has erred in law in holding that the appellant has failed to satisfy the condition that 'the remuneration is not deductible in computing the profits of an enterprise chargeable to tax in that other state'?
Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that off period salary was not taxable under section 9(1)(ii) read with the Explanation as it stood at the relevant time?
So far as the question No. 1 is concerned, this question has already been decided by a Division Bench of this Court {in which one of us (P.C. Verma, J.) was a member} in case of "Sedco Forex International Inc. Vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax and another", which was decided on 22.07.2005 in Income Tax Appeal No. 165 of 2001. In the said judgment, the question framed in the said appeal was answered in favour of the Revenue.
The aforementioned second question has also been decided by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal Nos.351-355 of 2005 "Sedco Forex International Drill Inc. and Others Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun and Another, JT 2005(9) SC 639". In view of the aforesaid decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court, this question is answered in favour of the assessee.
In view of the above, we dispose of the appeal accordingly.
(B.C. Kandpal, J.)
(P.C. Verma, J.)
Rajeev Dang
More judgments on Section 9(1)(ii)
- Mr. Rajesh R Hemrajani, Mumbai vs ITO Int. Tax Ward 2(2)(1), MumbaiITA 1284/MUM/2025[2019-20]Status: Disposed31 Jul 2026AY 2019-20
- Mrigesh Gaurav, Bangalore vs ITO Ward 42(2)(4), MumbaiITA 7988/MUM/2025[2018-19]Status: Disposed5 Mar 2026AY 2018-19
- Commissioner of Income Tax, (International… vs M/S Exl Service.Com Inc (Presently Known As…ITA/749/202517 Dec 2025
- Commissioner of Income Tax (International… vs Exl Service.Com Inc (Presently Known As Exl…ITA/748/202517 Dec 2025
- Commissioner of Income Tax (International… vs Exl Service.Com Inc (Presently Known As Exl…ITA/752/202517 Dec 2025
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Mrs. Sharma Glass And Plywoods vs. The Commercial Tax OfficerKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Sri Mohanraj vs. Assistant Commissioner Of Commercial TaxesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Kavita vs. The Assistant Commissioner Of State TaxAndhra Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- Kavita vs. The Assistant Commissioner Of State TaxAndhra Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- Shobha Kumari vs. State Of Bihar And AnrPatna · 3 Nov 2026