COMMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. PUSHPA DEVI AGARWAL
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal allowed the appeals, setting aside the conviction. The Tribunal held that while there might have been some departure from circulars by the accused appellants while purchasing butter, mere violation of a circular without dishonest intention cannot be a ground to hold them criminally liable. Citing the principle of 'mens rea' (guilty mind) from K.D. Gaur's Criminal Law and the Apex Court's observations in C.K. Jaffer Sharief vs State, the Tribunal found no evidence to attribute dishonest intention to the accused appellants. The Tribunal also addressed the grievance regarding defective charges, agreeing with the trial court that such defects would not vitiate the trial unless prejudice was caused, which was not shown. The Tribunal relied on the principle that suspicion, however grave, cannot substitute proof, and the explanations offered by the accused could not be brushed aside. The Tribunal concluded that the established circumstances did not establish criminality beyond a reasonable doubt, and the approach of the trial court regarding the requirements of proof was not proper. The Tribunal noted that while the State may have suffered financially due to procedural breaches, these acts did not necessarily establish the commission of criminal offenses. Consequently, the accused appellants were acquitted and set at liberty.
What were the facts?
Three appeals were filed against a judgment dated 29.12.2004 by the Special Judge (CBI), Guwahati, Assam. The judgment convicted Brig. D.A. Chansarkar (A1) and Col. R.K. Khanna (A2) under Section 120B/420 IPC and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Other appellants (A3, A4, A5), army suppliers, were convicted under Section 120B/420/468/471/465 IPC. The prosecution alleged that A1 and A2 colluded with A3, A4, and A5 to defraud the army by purchasing sub-standard butter at exorbitant prices between May 1984 and May 1985, violating existing circulars. A4, Md. Ali, died during the trial. The accused denied conspiracy, claiming adherence to rules and competitive pricing. A1 and A2 stated they followed procedures and competitive pricing due to compelling circumstances. Suppliers denied supplying inferior quality butter, stating they were the lowest bidders.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the accused appellants, Brig. D.A. Chansarkar (A1) and Col. R.K. Khanna (A2), entered into a criminal conspiracy with the other accused (A3, A4, A5) to purchase butter for army units at exorbitant prices, thereby causing loss to the government, as alleged under Section 120B/420 of the IPC and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Assessee's Contention (A1 & A2): A1 continued an existing practice of local purchase of centrally procured items with the consent of DGST, Shillong, and was unaware of A2's procedures, thus denying conspiracy. A2 contended that all rules and procedures were followed, purchases were made at competitive prices after inviting quotations, and orders were placed based on a constituted Board's recommendation. They also argued that the butter was supplied in sealed tins, and they had no knowledge of sub-standard quality, nor did they receive specific complaints. They further argued that the rates were competitive, considering local taxes and other charges, and that a shortage of butter due to the Asian Games necessitated local procurement. Revenue's Contention: The prosecution alleged that the purchase of butter was done in collusion, at exorbitant prices, and that the butter supplied was sub-standard and unfit for human consumption, in total violation of existing circulars for illegal gain.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 120B,Section 13(1)(d),Section 13(2),Section 5(2),Section 5(1)(d),Section 4,Section 215,Section 19(3),Section 294
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Crl.A. 42/2005 BEFORE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PARAN KUMAR PHUKAN JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV) These 3 (three) appeals are preferred against the judgment and order dated 29.12 .2004, passed by the learned Special Judge, (CBI), Guwahati Assam in Special Cas e No.66/2004 convicting the accused appellant Brig. D.A. Chansarkar and Col. R.K . Khanna under Section 120B/420 and under Section 13(1) (d) read with Section 13 (2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, and the other two appellants under Sect ion 120B/420/468/471/465 of the IPC and sentencing them to various terms of impr isonment and fine with default clauses. 2. The case against the accused appellants came to be registered by the Sup erintendent of Police, ACU-1 New Delhi on the basis of source information receiv ed by them to the effect that the accused appellant No. 1 an 2 (A1 and A2) who w ere posted as Deputy Director, Supply and Transport (DDST) 101 Area Headquarter, Shillong and Commanding Officer, Advance Base Supply Depot (ABSD), Guwahati res pectively in collusion with the other appellants (A3, A4 and A5) who were army s uppliers, by corrupt and illegal means, defrauded the army by purchasing/supplyi ng huge quantity of sub-standard butter at exorbitant prices. On completion of i nvestigation CBI submitted charge sheet against the accused appellants A1 and A2 under Section 120B/420 and Section 5(2) read with Section 5(1) (d) of the P.C. Act, 1947 and under Section 420/468/471 of the IPC against the suppliers Mohamma d Ali (since deceased), Md. A. Khalleque and Md. Ayub (A3, A4 and A5 respectivel y) and forwarded them to face trial before the court. 3. Learned Special Judge, CBI framed charges against the appellant A1, A2 u nder Section 120B/420 of the IPC and section 13(2), read with Section 13(1) (d) of the P.C. Act and under Section 120/420/468/465/471 of the IPC against the oth er 3 appellants A3, A4 and A5. The appellants pleaded not guilty to the charges. The appellant Md. Ali (A4) died during the pendency of the trial and the case c ame to be abated against him. 4. The sum and substance of the prosecution case is that during the period from May, 1984 to May 1985 the appellants A1 and A2 entered into a criminal cons piracy with the other accused appellant A3, A4 and A5 to purchase butter for the army units at a very exorbitant price, which they were not authorized to do as it was a centrally procured item. The butter supplied was found to be unfit for human consumption. The entire procedure was done in total violation of the exist ing circulars by the competent authorities for illegal gain. 5. The accused appellant A1 and A2 admitted having purchased the butter fro m the other appellants but denied that it was procured at exorbitant price and a ccording to them they followed all the rules and procedures. They also pleaded t hat under compelling circumstances the purchase was made at competitive price th at too after inviting quotations. The other appellants who were the suppliers de nied having supplied inferior quality butter and according to them since they we re the lowest bidder, orders were placed with them to supply the butter. 6. Heard Mr. J.C. Gaur, learned counsel for the appellant in Crl. A.No.38/2 005, Mr. P. Katakey, learned counsel for the appellant in Crl.A.No.39/2005 and M r. Z. Kamar, learned counsel for the appellants in Crl.A.No.42/2005. Also heard Mr. S. C. Keyal, learned counsel for the CBI. 7. Initiating the argument Mr. Gaur, learned counsel for A1 submits that A1 joined as DGST, 101 Area Headquarter, Shillong on 31.03.1984 and after joining his new assignment he found that though butter and some other articles were cent rally procured articles but those were allowed to be purchased by ABSD, Guwahati for distribution in army units operating in North Eastern Region and this was d one with the consent of DGST, Shillong. After his joining he continued the earli er practice and he was oblivious of the procedures followed by A2 as such there is no question of any criminal conspiracy by him to procure butter at exorbitant price. Mr. Katakey, learned counsel for the appellant A2 contends that there is no violation of the Rules and procedures while purchasing the butter for the ar
my units and as ordered by A1 who was the DGST at the relevant time articles wer e purchased after following due procedures. The orders were placed with the appe llants M/S M.K. Enterprise as per recommendation of the Board constituted for th e purpose and as such no illegality was committed. The learned counsel Mr. Z. Ka mar appearing for the A3 and A5 argued that being food suppliers they supplied t he butter as ordered and they offered to supply best quality of butter (Polson) and quoted lowest prices and as such, their bid was accepted and there is no com plaint from the authorities that butter was sub-standard and they had no mechani sm to know the quality of the butter inside the tins supplied by them. No crimin al liability can be attributed to them for supplying the butter to the army unit as per the terms and conditions of the NIT. 8. Advancing further Mr. Gaur, argued that the lowest rate for butter tin a s disclosed by the prosecution witnesses including the representatives of the ma nufacturer of Amul and Polson butter was at Rs.43.75/kg, 45.45/kg and 47.50/kg a nd if local taxes and other charges are added to these rates and 10% is added to it then the concluding rate will be much higher than the rates at which the but ter tins were purchased by ABSD, Guwahati. Consequently, the accusations of caus ing loss to the Government of India, Ministry of Defence is nothing but a hypoth esis for which criminal liability cannot be attributed to any person. By referri ng to the evidence of representatives of Amul butter it is further argued that i n the year 1984 there was shortage of butter due to Asian Games in Delhi. Inviti ng my attention to the evidence of the representatives of the Amul, learned coun sel contends that the manufacturer has not specified whether the rates of Rs.41. 35/kg and 42.50/kg in 1984 and 47.50/kg and 47.30/kg in 1985 was quoted for pape r packed quality or tinned quality of butter and the difference between the two would be about Rs.10/kg which is apparent from the evidence of the suppliers of Dimapur and Silchar depots. 9. It is argued on behalf of A2 that the butter was supplied in sealed tins and he had no knowledge that those were sub-standard as no specific complaint w as received by him after the tins were sent to different units. The manufacturer of the butter was Polson which is a reputed company and he never doubted the qu ality of the product inside the tins. It is argued on behalf of A3 and A5 that t hey also had no knowledge regarding the quality of butter inside the tins and si nce the company was a reputed one they did not have suspicion regarding the qual ity. When the matter was brought to their notice they expressed their desire to take back the sub-standard butter. Moreover, it is argued that the butters are t o be kept in freezer and if not kept property there is likelihood of deteriorati on of the quality for which they cannot be held liable. 10. The next limb of argument advanced by Mr. Gaur, learned counsel for the appellant A1 is that MGASC Eastern Command Headquarters, Kolkata accorded ex pos t facto approval to the supply orders after going through the documents and lett ers, messages in this regard were issued by MGASC and DDST in its turn issued sa nction letters to other store depots in N.E. Region according sanction and appro val for local purchase of butter tins. However, the purported letters, messages were not produced during the trial of the case and during the pendency of the ap peal an application under Section 294 read with Section 311 of the Code of Crimi nal Procedure was filed before this court. Accordingly court also issued notice to the prosecution but no objection has been filed and this court passed an orde r to the effect that the petition shall be considered at the time of final heari ng of the appeal. Mr. Gaur, learned counsel contends that if the procedural irre gularities occurring while purchasing/procuring butter locally is the criteria o r benchmark then most of the prosecution witnesses and officials of the army hav e committed offence by violating the provisions of ECO-7/66 Exhibit-221. Mr. Gau r, strenuously submits that irregularities perse cannot be a ground to attribute criminal liability to a public servant. Knowingly or unknowingly the officials/ public servants commit genuine mistakes without any ill motive and for such acts they cannot be prosecuted for criminal offences. Butter was essential at that t ime for the army units and since there was scarcity of the same due to Asian Gam es, the appellants decided to procure butter from the local market and even if t here was some procedural irregularities that would not be a ground to attribute
criminal liability to the officers who were otherwise discharging their duties h onestly without any blemish in their service career. 11. It is also contended that ex post facto approval was given by MGASC East ern Command Headquarters, Kolkata to purchase butter after going through all the relevant documents and had there been any illegality committed or the rates wer e exorbitant approval would not have been given. It is also contended by Mr. Gau r that at the instance of PW 56 a court of enquiry was held regarding the accusa tions but the court of enquiry was closed at the behest of some vested interest as A1 was likely to be exonerated during the enquiry. 12. Before adverting the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties it is necessary to have an overview of the Rules and Procedures for pur chasing/procurement of butter and other items as provided under the instructions for local purchases contained in Appendix ’A’ to Eastern Command Order or ECO 7 /66 which takes care of matters from A to Z relating to purchase of ’Central Pur chase Articles’ marked as Exhibit-221. This document, admittedly is the binding procedure to be followed for local purchase by any army unit. The provisions of the Exhibit-221 having a bearing on the matters in dispute in the instant case a re reproduced below:-- 2. The circumstances under which local purchase may be made are as under- (a) Central Purchase Supplies: (i) When ordered by Army H.Q. (j) When the stock of central purchase articles and its substitutes has been exh austed and there is delay in stocks arriving from central sources or in an emerg ency. In such cases minimum requirement will be purchased. Prior sanction of BAS C(DST, if possible) should be obtained. 3.Local purchase of central purchase articles of food stuffs should , as far as possible, be made from CSD(I). If these are not available with CSD(I) as non-ava ilability certificate will be obtained from them before purchases are made direc t from the trade. Items of animal rations are purchased from trade. When purchas es are made from the trade it should be ensured that such purchases are made at competitive rates from authorized dealers, standard firms or individual wholesal e dealers dealing with these items. If the wholesale dealer are reluctant to giv e supplies on credit against supply order (IAFZ-2135) and the services of a midd leman are necessary, every effort will be made to ensure maximum competition. 4. All purchases will be made at the prevailing market rates. When this is not p racticable, purchases may be made at competitive rates which will not exceed the prevailing market rates by more than 10 percent. If due to exceptional circumst ances this also is not possible, purchases may be made at the lowest rate availa ble, provided prior approval of BASC is obtained as to the rates to be paid. In such cases, a certificate to that effect will be furnished by the Officer making the purchases. However, these restrictions will not apply to purchases made, at the risk and expenses of defaulting contractors in accordance with the terms an d conditions. LOCAL MARKET RATES:- 2. In order to ensure that local purchases are effected at most economical and c ompetitive rates and also to ensure that the conditions mentioned in Para 4 abov e are fulfilled. It is essential that local market rates of the item(s) under pu rchase conforming to ASC specification are available with the Officers effecting the purchase. For this purpose the officer making the purchases will request th e OC Station to detail a Board of Officers to obtain the local market rates of t he item(s) conforming to ASC specification. OC Station, if and when possible, wi ll arrange for a representative of Cantonment Executive Authorities to be associ ated with such enquiries. The rates so obtained will be authenticated by the OC Station in the Station Orders and form basis for local purchases. 13. The prosecution to prove the charges examined as many as 58 witnesses ou t of which 24 numbers of witnesses are Army Officials, 8 numbers of witnesses ar e Bank Officials and 9 numbers of witnesses are private individuals. That apart, 8 numbers of witnesses have been examined from the Postal and Sale Tax Departme nt. One government examiner on question documents and one witness of the sanctio ning authority have been examined and 3 numbers of witnesses also examined from
the CBI. 14. In the impugned judgment, the learned Special Judge has elaborately disc ussed the entire evidence of the prosecution witnesses which needs no further pr oliferation and I am only referring those pieces of evidence necessary to decide the questions raised in the appeal. The Army Officials mainly deposed as to the manner in which local purchase of articles like rice, dal, atta, ghee and butte r etc., are made and the evidence of these set of witnesses established that usu ally the above mentioned articles are procured centrally by the central office k nown as CDS. In case of shortage of any item in the Army unit such article can b e purchased locally after obtaining sanction from the DDST. For purchasing of su ch articles locally quotations are floated and those quotations splited up as pe r financial power of the Commandant. In the present case evidence on record reve als that Board was duly constituted for the purpose and quotations were invited and the bid offered by the appellants M/S M.K. Traders were accepted being the l owest. It was sought to be proved by the prosecution that butter was purchased a t exorbitant price of Rs.52/kg though at the relevant time it hovered between Rs .41 - 47. There is evidence on record to show that at the relevant time butter w as easily available in Assam and the market price never exceeded Rs.41 to 47. Th e defence contention is that A3 and A5 purchased butter @ Rs.49/kg at Patna and that too from the manufacturer company itself and as such there is no question o f purchasing butter at a price lower than the price at which they purchased the butter in question. With the addition of 10% which is allowed by the Circular (E xhibit-221) and after inclusion of cost of freight etc., the amount at which A3 and A5 supplied the butter cannot be said to be exorbitant. The learned Trial Ju dge relying on the testimony of Pw-25 and also the other materials placed before him came to the finding that there was no shortage of butter in Assam at the re levant time and all the reputed companies agreed to supply the army butter not o nly on credit but at a very competitive low and concessional price as well. By r eferring to the evidence of Pw-25 the trial court has held that though the appel lants purchased the butter @ Rs.41/kg it was supplied at an exorbitant price of Rs.52/- per kg. 15. On going through the evidence of Pw-25, I have noticed that though he cl aims to have sold the butter to Abdul Khalleque @ Rs.41/kg but he admitted that in response to Exhibit-95 letter written by Headquarter, Army Commandant, Kolkat a he quoted the rate of Polson butter @ Rs.49/kg and if huge quantity is purchas ed they agreed to reduce the price by Rs.4/kg. His evidence also reveals that th ough they had a plan to supply butter sold by them to the purchaser at their doo rstep and the price quoted by him included everything including the cost of frei ght but from his evidence it cannot be discerned that they also decided to suppl y butter at the doorstep in all the States. Admittedly, Pw-25 was the Director o f Polson Private Ltd., of Patna and it cannot be said with certainty, from his e vidence that the company agreed to supply butter in Assam without charging the c ost of freight and other incidental expenses. Obviously, the supplier after purc hasing butter at Patna is to carry the same to Guwahati and after the cost of fr eight and other incidental expenses are added the price of butter supplied in Gu wahati will be much more than in Patna. It also cannot be discerned from the evi dence of Pw-25 as to whether he quoted the price at Rs.49/kg for supplying the s ame at Guwahati or at Patna. 16. The prosecution also made a feeble attempt through the evidence of some other businessmen, to prove that the market price of butter was much lower than the price at which the supplier appellants supplied butter to the army. But it a ppears from the evidence that the price was fluctuating at the relevant time. P w-11, Pw-22 and Pw-34 are Army suppliers. According to Pw-11 he supplied butter to Panitola depot. He quoted price of Rs.50/kg. Pw-22 quoted price of Rs.49/kg f or supplying butter to the army at Silchar. Pw-34 quoted price of Rs.45/kg for s upplying butter at Dimapur. Similarly, from the evidence of Pw-14 who was the De pot Manager of Gujarat Cooperative Society, it appears that rate of butter was f luctuating and though the initial rate was 396.95/ carton in 1994 it was subsequ ently enhanced to 455.70/ carton in February, 1985. 17. What crystallizes from the evidence is that the price of butter was not
fixed and it was fluctuating and the suppliers supplied butter to army at differ ent rates in different places. 18. That apart, admittedly, quotations are invited by the Board constituted for the purpose and those are even opened by the Board members and comparative s tatement are also prepared by the Board. The Board also recommend the price at w hich butter is to be purchased. A1 and A2 had no significant role to play in suc h matters and actions are taken by them as per recommendation of the Board. It w as none of their business to go to the market and verify. The supplier appellant s offered lowest bid and that was accepted by the Board and even if the price wa s on the higher side, criminal liability under such facts and circumstances cann ot be attributed to the appellants A1 and A2. The suppliers are also not expecte d to supply butter to the army at the price at which they purchased butter from the manufacturer and obviously they would quote the price keeping the margin of profit for which they cannot be held criminally liable. 19. The next question which comes for consideration is as to whether the sup plier appellants submitted quotations in the name of fictitious and non-existent firms. The prosecution left no stone unturned to prove that the appellants A3 a nd A5 submitted quotations in the name of fictitious firms. They have examined p ostal peons Pw-2, Pw-3 and Pw-4 to prove that the registered letters were sought to be delivered to the addressees M/s MT Enterprise and M/s MK Traders in Fancy Bazar and Lakhtokia respectively. But the letters could not be delivered as the postal peons could not locate the firms at Fancy Bazar and Lakhtokia. Needless to say that Fancy Bazar and Lakhtokia are big areas having several beats and it is not conclusively established that postal peons visited all the beats in Fancy Bazar and Lakhtokia to deliver the registered letters to the firms. The prosecu tion also examined Pw-5, Pw-6 Tax officials and they also could not find the nam es of M/s MK Traders and M/S Abdul Sattar and Co. in their offence record. Pw-7 Excise Officer testified that the name of the firm M/s Maqbul was not found in t heir office record. However it is admitted by Pw-5 that some firms may deal with business of taxable goods without their knowledge. Pw-7 Excise Officer admitted that he was adducing evidence from his memory and as such it is not conclusive from his evidence that the aforesaid firm is non-existent.Pw-10 army supplier Md . Saifullaha denied his signatures in the various quotations in the name of his firms M/s Md. Saifullaha and he also denied that any of his staff member put sig natures in the quotations. But there is also no conclusive evidence that the acc used appellants put their signatures in those quotations submitted on behalf of M/s Md. Saifullaha. 20. Moreover, a firm is an entity under which business is transacted and it is not compulsory for the firm to have a separate office to prove its physical e xistence. The proprietor of the firm can transact business, in the name of the f irm from his place of abode also. Any individual can open a firm to transact bus iness in the name of a firm and it is not even compulsorily required to be regis tered with the Registrar of Firms or with Tax and Excise authorities. Only trade licence is required to be obtained from the competent authority to transact bus iness in the name of the firm and the licensing authority can take action if the re is any breach thereof. Similarly, for failure of the firm to clear taxes the Taxing department is only competent to proceed against the firm according to the ir own procedure and statutes. In the present case, in all probability the posta l peons were looking for offices of the firms which they were unable to locate w hich cannot be a ground to hold that the firms were non-existent. Similarly, non -availability of the names of the firms with Tax and Excise department cannot be a ground to hold that the firms were not existing. 21. Defence contention is that the appellants suppliers put their own signat ures in the tender document and quotations and no forgery was committed by them and they did not fabricate any document. The questioned documents were sent to t he expert for examination and opinion. The handwriting expert, Pw-42 confirmed t hat handwriting of the appellants were similar to the handwriting found in the q uestioned documents which fortifies the defence version. Moreover, it is for the departmental authorities (here the Board) to verify the credentials of the bidd ers and they should have insisted for production of requisite certificates such
as, income tax clearance certificate, sale tax clearance, trade licence etc. It is not known from the evidence on record, as to whether the aforesaid documents were produced before the Board by the bidders taking part in the bids. The Board was constituted with officers of various ranks drawn from different army units and the Board is responsible for inviting quotations, opening quotations, prepar ing the comparative statement and thereafter recommend the name of the firm or t he individual who is found responsive and quoted the lowest bid. 22. In the instant case, prosecution relied on a number of circumstances to show that the accused appellants committed offence of criminal conspiracy. The c ircumstances relied on are (i) the appellants violated circular vide Exbt.221 wh ich is not only mandatory but also takes care of all from A to Z of the matter r elating to supply of articles to the army; (ii) the accused appellants purchased /supplied butter to the army at a very exorbitant price; (iii) the butter so sup plied was sub-standard and unfit for human consumption; (iv) the appellants A1 a nd A2 purchased butter in huge quantity when there was not necessity for purchas ing such huge quantity; (v) the butter was procured from non-existent firms; (vi ) the supply orders were splitted up so as to bring such order of supply within the official power of A2; (vii) the accused appellants, A1 in particular central ized the process of purchase of centrally purchased articles and authorized only A2 to purchase those articles locally for distributing the same to the army uni ts operating in North Easters Region; (viii) the appellant A2 purchased articles without obtaining non-availability certificate from CDS. 23. Mr. S.C.Keyal, learned Standing counsel for the CBI strenuously contends by referring to the evidence on record that the circumstances from which conclu sion of guilt of the appellants are to be drawn have been fully proved and those are conclusive in nature and only consistent with the hypothesis of the guilt o f the appellants and totally inconsistent with their innocence. The circumstance s taken together have established that the appellants committed the crimes and t he prosecution has been able to prove the charges beyond all reasonable doubt. 24. In controversion, learned counsel appearing for the appellants argued th at though there was some departmental lapses, yet any dishonest intention on the ir part could not be shown and none of the circumstances relied upon by the pros ecution could be construed as incriminating and are of conclusive nature. All th e circumstances put together would not lead to the conclusion that the said circ umstances are compatible only with the hypothesis of guilt of the appellants and wholly incompatible with their innocence. 25. In the backdrop of the aforesaid contentions, I have once again perused the evidence as well as the materials placed before me. 26. Prosecution placed before the court the circular which governs the local purchase of Centrally Purchased Articles which unmistakably evinces that the circular Appendix-’A’ ECO-7/66 marked as Exhibit-221 strictly prohibits the army units from purchasing articles which are procured centrally. However, some rela xation has been provided by the circular itself and in case of emergency army un its are permitted to purchase those items locally on fulfilling certain conditio ns and that too, after obtaining approval from the higher authorities. It is to be ensured that the purchase is made at competitive rates and in any case it wil l not exceed the prevailing market rate of more than 10%. 27. In the present case, it transpires that prior approval was not taken bef ore purchasing the materials but ex-post-facto approval was obtained from MGASC, Eastern Command Headquarters, Kolkata. The appellant A1 who was posted as DGST, Eastern Command, Shillong at the relevant time was an officer in the rank of Br igadier and after receiving requisition from various army units in North Eastern Region instructed the appellant A2 an officer in the rank of Colonel to purchas e butter locally. Evidence also discloses that instead of purchasing minimum qua ntity of butter as provided under Exhibit-221, it was decided to purchase huge q uantity of butter. It was sought to be proved by the prosecution through the evi dence of Pw-21, Pw-26, Pw-29, Pw-30 and Pw-38 that huge quantity of butter was p urchased and sometimes consignment of butter so purchased was so big that surplu s butter from such units was to be transferred to some other units, only to be r ejected, consignee units themselves burdened with huge quantity of surplus butte
r. Defence contention is that butter was purchased only after receiving demands from various army units operating in North Eastern Region and as such, there was no violation of the circular, Exhibit-221. It is found from the record that dur ing the period from May, 1984 to May, 1985 total quantity of butter purchased wa s 31.5 M.T., by A2. What emerges from the evidence is that no prior assessment r egarding requirement was made before placing orders and from a perusal of the ev idence on record it cannot be inferred that the quantity of butter purchased was in conformity with circular, Exhibit-221 which prescribed minimum quantity to b e purchased in case of emergency only. 28. However, evidence reveals that the entire quantity of butter was not pro cured at a time and orders were issued to the supplier from time to time. Accord ing to Pw-1 Gur Kripal Singh, who was the Deputy Commander of ABSD at the releva nt time, if there was shortage of any article, such article can be purchased loc ally and for that purpose quotations are invited and such quotations are split a s per financial power of the Commandant. Notice inviting quotations are displaye d in the notice board and after receipt of the same, quotations are kept in a lo cked box, key of which is retained by Deputy Commandant. From his evidence I do not find any substantial deviation from the circular, Exhibit-221 except the qua ntity His evidence reveals that MGASC, Kolkata is the head office for Eastern Co mmand in the matters of supply of articles and Commandant Eastern Command, DDST, Headquarter, Shillong is under MGASC. Evidence of Pw-19 shows that he was the P residing Officer of the Board constituted for the purpose and from his evidence, it appears that the procedures were duly followed and connected files were duly maintained by the Board and some of the files were even produced during the tri al. 29. When articles are sought to be procured it is the duty of the officers c onnected with the procurement, before placing the orders, to make assessment of the quantity of the article to be purchased. In the present case from the eviden ce on record it cannot be discerned that any prior assessment was made. However, the evidence discloses that requisitions were received by the DDST, Shillong fr om different army units requesting for butter pursuant to which it was decided t o procure butter locally. It also found from the evidence that huge consignment of butter was sent to some units which the units were unable to consume due to w hich excess butter tins were allocated to other units. On an overall assessment of the evidence it can be said with some degree of certainty that the quantity o f butter procured was not in conformity with the Circular Exhibit-221. May be it was an error of judgment or an act of indiscretion, but from that alone dishone st intention cannot be inferred. Reverting back to the evidence I have found tha t A1 joined in his new assignment in Shillong in March, 1984. He being the DDST was the person responsible for maintaining the essential supplies to the various units in the North Eastern Region. Butter which is essential for army was scarc e at that time due to Asian Games in Delhi. Prior to his joining army units used to purchase butter locally according to their requirement. Defence argued that since Guwahati is the only city in NE Region, he thought that butter would be ch eaper in Guwahati and due to this reason he restricted the army units from procu ring butter locally and instead asked A2 to do the job for the entire region. Th ere was no ill motive on his part and his only fault was his inability to assess the actual requirement and decided to procure butter for the entire region. Mor eover, there is no evidence that butter tins were not consumed and destroyed. No doubt complaints were received by the appellants regarding quality and though t he samples of butter was not sent to food analyst of Central Food Laboratory for examination but from the evidence on record particularly, the evidence of Pw-9 Sudhir Kr. Seni, Wing Commander, Pw-21 GPS Mehra, Administrative Officer, Panito la, Pw-30 Major S.Kr. Sarma, Pw-38 A. Nimbulkar, Commanding Officer, supply depo t, Silchar, Pw-51 Arabinda Kr. Rai, Squadron Leader it emerges that the quality of butter received by the units in which they were posted was inferior and unfit for human consumption. There was leakage in some tins of the butter from which foul smell was emanating. When the appellant A2 received complaints regarding th e quality, he even asked to return the tins with a view to return the same to th e suppliers. Pw-51 even calculated the quantity of butter which was found unfit
for human consumption and he worked out the damage at Rs.8065.05 against 194.86 kg of butter. Butter was sought to be tested in the Central Food Laboratory and letter to that effect was also issued in response to which CFL asked for previou s laboratory report, but despite repeated communications made, the composite Foo d Laboratory could not furnish the report. 30. It is argued that since the butter has not been examined in the laborato ry the same cannot be said to be unfit for human consumption but the argument is found to be devoid of any substance. Even a common man can say after consuming the butter and smelling it about the quality of the same, no further testing is necessary. In the present case some of the army officials found the butter unfit for human consumption and there was foul smell emanating from the tins which we re leaking. The evidence of the army officials amply proved that some of the but ter tins supplied were not fit for human consumption. 31. Now the question is whether the appellants knew that the butter was not fit for human consumption. Admittedly, the butter tins were received by ABSD. It is argued that since it was supplied in sealed tins, they had no knowledge that those were sub standard as no specific complain was received by ABSD after the tins were sent to different units. They have no reason to doubt the quality beca use the manufacturer was Polson. The suppliers were also under the impression th at since the butter was supplied by Polson the same would be of good quality. Th ey were totally unaware of the quality inside the tins and they were even willin g to take back the tins which were found leaking. From the evidence on record it cannot be said with certainty that the appellants had knowledge that the butter tins were not fit for human consumption. The appellant A2 even asked the office rs to return the tins found damaged so that the same could be returned to the su ppliers. Moreover, appellants were senior army officials in the rank of Brigadie r and Colonel and it is unbelievable that they would enter into conspiracy with the other appellants to procure rotten butter for the army units for consumption . 32. Another circumstance, relied upon by the prosecution is that the appella nt A2 during that period had sent money to his other family members through dema nd draft. On going through the evidence of Pw-32 Anik Kr. Gupta and Pw-48 H.S. A garwal both bank officials it appears that draft for Rs.8,000/-, Rs.7,000/- and Rs.5000/- and other draft of small denominations were sent from Maligaon branch of the SBI, to the family members of the appellant A2 residing in Delhi. There is no evidence that he was incapable of sending the amounts to his family member s. The amounts involved were also not big enough to raise any doubt regarding hi s financial capacity to send the amounts to his family members including his wif e and children. The officer was posted in Guwahati at the relevant time leaving his family at RK Puram at Delhi and it was not unusual for him to send the money to his family members through drafts. In his statement recorded under Section 3 13 CrPC the accused appellant admitted having sent Rs.7,000/- which was drawn on SBI Silpukhuri branch. Prosecution is unable to connect this amount with the pa yments purportedly made to the supplier appellants for supply of butter tins. Fo r sending of such small amounts to his family members criminal liability cannot be attributed to him unless it is proved affirmatively that such amounts were re ceived by him for placing the supply orders with the suppliers. 33. Learned CBI counsel made strenuous submissions to convince me that split ting of the supply orders were done to bring the orders within the financial pow er of A2. A1 only authorised A 2 to purchase butter locally for the army units i n North Eastern Region which was intentionally done for wrongful gain. He also s ubmits that non availability certificate was not obtained from CDS before purcha sing butter locally. 34. Opposing the contentions learned counsel for the appellants A1 and A2 ar gued that the procedure of splitting supply orders to bring the orders under the financial power of the disbursing officer was done to expedite the process of procurement without causing any pecuniary loss to the ex-chequer and the procedu re is in vogue in the departments. Learned counsel also argued that it was the p rerogative of the DDST to decide to whom the authority is to be given to procure items locally and his decision cannot be called in question. It is also argued
that there was scarcity of the butter due Asian Games which compelled A1 to proc ure butter urgently and therefore, non availability certificate was not obtained from CDS before purchase. 35. It is an admitted position that supply orders for entire quantity was no t placed at a time and different orders were issued for different quantities. In many government departments such procedure is in vogue which is usually followe d to bring the orders within the financial power of the officer concerned, altho ugh, such a procedure cannot be approved, but this is the ground reality which c annot be ignored. Departmental authority should restrict such procedure being fo llowed and issue necessary directions to the officers concerned not to resort to such practice which is likely to open avenues for corruption. 36. In the present case also such a procedure was being followed. In my cons idered view it was a procedural lapse for which no criminal liability could be a ttributed. Moreover, ex post facto approval was given by higher authority to the procurement orders and the bills were also approved. There is no evidence that authorities raised any objection in the matter. The same analogy can also be app lied for inability of A2 to obtain non-availability certificate from CDS before procurement. Scarcity of butter at that time due to Asian Games might have promp ted the officers A1 and A2 to procure butter urgently. 37. On a critical analysis of the entire evidence on record, oral as well as documentary though I have noticed some departure from the usual procedure and t he circular Exhibit-221 but I am of the view that it is impossible to doubt the bonafide of the appellants. The entire charges against the appellants rested on circumstantial evidence and the prosecution has failed to prove that the circums tances were such as can be explained only on one hypothesis, namely, that the ac cused was guilty. Before a presumption against the appellants could be raised, i t must be proved that they knew that other suppliers would have charged lesser a mounts for the butter so purchased. Though the official of the Polson company cl aims to have sold the butter to the appellant suppliers at Rs.41/kg but it appea rs from the correspondence with the army that he was ready to supply butter at R s.49/kg. But there is no evidence that he agreed to supply the butter on credit basis. The suppliers in the instant case were lowest bidders and they were appro ved by the Board constituted for the purpose and it was the duty of the Board me mbers to look into these aspects. For their indiscretion the appellants A1 and A 2 cannot be saddled with criminal liability. 38. Learned counsel for the accused appellants strongly urged that the prose cution has utterly failed to bring home the charges against the accused persons and the trial court has committed manifest illegality by recording their convict ion. It was argued that there was no violation of circular Exhibit-221 by the ar my officials A1 and A2 and even assuming that there was some non-compliance here and there, there was no dishonest intention on the part of the A1 and A2 and th is aspect was totally ignored by the learned Special Judge while recording their conviction. 39. Learned Standing counsel for the CBI on the other hand, submitted that t here was blatant violation of the circular by the army officials and the proved circumstances established that the appellants A1 and A2 intentionally purchased huge quantity of rotten butter unfit for human consumption at an exorbitant pric e for wrongful gain for themselves and for wrongful loss to the Government. 40. Adverting to the facts of the case, it has already been noticed that the allegation against the appellants A1 and A2 is that they had purchased huge qua ntity of butter from the appellants A3 and A5 at an exorbitant price. The appell ants A1 and A2 admitted having purchased the butter, but denied the accusations and according to them the butter was purchased as it was scarce at that time due to Asian Games as per requirement of the army units located in North Eastern Re gion. They had no knowledge that the butter tins were unfit for human consumptio n and they even asked for returning the damaged butter tins which clearly demons trates that they had no dishonest intention to defraud the Government. Board was duly constituted and the official decision was taken by the Board and they foll owed the recommendation of the Board for which they cannot be held liable. For m ere departure from the circular Exhibit-221 they cannot be held to have abused t
heir official position and intentionally caused any pecuniary loss to the State ex-chequer or wrongful gain for themselves. 41. Confronted with a similar situation, The Apex Court, in the case of C. C henga Reddy vs State of A.P. reported in (1996) 10 SCC 193, in paragraph 22 of t he judgment has observed as follows:--- On a careful consideration of the material on the record, we are of the opinion that though the prosecution has established that the appellants have committed not only codal violations but also irregularities by ignoring various circulars and departmental orders issued from time to time in the matter of allotment of w ork of jungle clearance on nomination basis and have committed departmental laps e yet. None of the circumstances relied upon by the prosecution are of any concl usive nature and all the circumstances put together do not lead to the irresisti ble conclusion that the said circumstances are compatible only with the hypothes is of the guilt of the appellant and wholly incompatible with their innocence. I n Abdulla Mohammed Pagarkar v. State (Union Territory of Goa, Daman and Diu), [1 980] 3 SCC 110, under somewhat similar circumstances this Court opined that mere disregard of relevant provisions of the Financial Code as well as ordinary norm s of procedural behaviour of government officials and con-tractors, without conc lusively establishing, beyond a reasonable doubt, the guilt of the concerned off icials and contractors, may give rise to a strong suspicion but that cannot be h eld to establish the guilt of the accused. The established circumstances in this case also do not establish criminality of the appellants beyond the realm of su spicion and, in our opinion, the approach of the trial court and the High Court to the requirements of proof in relation to a criminal charge was not proper. Th at because of the actions of the appellants in breach of codal provisions, instr uctions and procedural safeguards, the Stale may have suffered financially, part icularly by allotment of work on nomination basis without inviting tenders, but those acts of omission and commission by themselves do not establish the commiss ion of criminal offences alleged against them. 42. In the instant case also there might have been some departure from the c ircular by the accused appellants while purchasing butter, but mere violation of the circular without dishonest intention cannot be a ground to hold them crimin ally liable. 43. In C.K. Jaffer Sharief vs State (Through CBI) reported in (2013) 1 SCC 2 05 the Apex Court while handing down the order has observed by referring to crim inal law by K. D. Gaur as follows:--- Criminal guilt would attach to a man for violation of criminal law. However, th e rule is not absolute and is subject to limitations indicated in the Latin maxi m, actus non facit reum, nisi mens sit rea. It signified that there can be no cr ime without a guilty mind. To make a person criminally accountable, it must be p roved that an act, which is forbidden by law, has been caused by his conduct, an d that the conduct was accompanied by a legally blameworthy attitude of mind. Th us, there are two components of every crime, a physical element and a mental ele ment, usually called actus reus and mens rea respectively. 44. Having regard to the above observations and having considered the eviden ce in its entirety I am hesitant to attribute dishonest intention on the part of the accused appellants while purchasing butter. 45. Another grievance of the defence is that the charges framed against the accused appellants were defective. During the trial charges were framed under Se ction 120B/420/468/465/471 of the IPC against the accused appellants A3 and A5 a nd separate charges were framed against the accused appellants Brigadier D.A Cha nsarkar (A1) and Colonel R.K. Khanna (A2) under Section 120B/420 of the IPC and also under Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. It submitted that no charges of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B of the I PC have been framed jointly against all the accused appellants and in the absenc e of joint charges of conspiracy the appellants A3 and A5 could not have been tr ied by the court of Special Judge as envisaged under Section 4 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and the entire trial got vitiated. The learned Trial Ju dge has addressed this contention adequately in his impugned judgment by observi ng that such defects in charge would not cause any harm to the trial of the case
inasmuch as it is a case where public and private persons are jointly tried and the offence which they were tried for were committed in the course of same tran sactions and that the very compartmentalized approach to the allegations levelle d against the accused persons is neither desirable nor permissible. Learned Tria l Judge further observed that provisions of Section 215/464 CrPC as well as Sect ion 19(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act clearly postulates that mere error /defect in the charge would not derail the trial unless such defects/errors has resulted prejudice being caused to the accused. Since no prejudice was shown to have been caused in the present case to the accused appellants, the trial would not vitiate. There is no reason to differ with the opinion rendered by the Trial Judge regarding the defects in the charge. 46. Learned counsel for the appellants also argued by referring to the judgm ent of the Apex court in Vikramjit Singh Alias Vicky vs. State of Punjab (2006) 12 SCC 306, to contend that where two views of a story appear to be probable, th e one that was contended by the accused should be accepted. It is further conten ded that suspicion, however, grave may be, cannot be a substitute for proof. Arg uments cannot be thrown out of consideration. In the present case though the pro secution alleged that the accused appellants violated codal provision but the ap pellants have offered explanation for each of the circumstances appearing agains t them. Although they are suspected to have been involved but it is well settled that suspicion is not a substitute for proof. The explanations offered by them cannot be brushed aside and rejected in limine. 47. From all my discussions above and the reasons aforementioned, I allow th e appeals preferred by the appellants by setting aside the conviction recorded b y the learned Special Judge, CBI, Assam. 48. Consequently, the accused appellants are acquitted and set at liberty fo rthwith. Bail bond, if any, stands discharged. 49. Send down the LCR forthwith.
More judgments on Section 120B
- Dy Director of Income Tax (Inv) vs Mohan India Pvt Ltd and OrsAPPA/377/201410 Mar 2026
- Amit Tak, Jaipur vs Income Tax Officer Ward 7(1), JaipurITA 570/JPR/2025[2017-2018]Status: Disposed26 Sept 2025AY 2017-2018
- Bachhraj Bamalwa vs Assistant Director of Income…CRR/282/20193 Apr 2024
- Narayan @ Narayan Sai @ Mota Bhagwan S/O… vs State of GujaratSCR.A/4640/20238 Jun 2023
- Comnr.of Income Tax vs Suvendu B.BeheraITA/28/201318 Feb 2022
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Sun Shine Metal Works vs. State Of U.P And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Bansal Sanitary Store vs. State Of U.P. And 2 OthersAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Princess Girls Collection vs. State Of U.P. And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- Prabhat Kumar vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- Siddharth Barai (Prop- Siddharth Design Studio) vs. The Superintendent CGST And Central Excise, Balangir RangeOrissa · 4 Nov 2026