COMMISSIONER(IT) vs. MS RUCHIRA PAPERS
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that when an assessment has been made under Section 143(3) and there has been a full and true disclosure of all material facts, the proviso to Section 147 clearly stipulates that no action can be taken under Section 147 after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year. The duty of the assessee is to disclose facts, not to draw inferences or guide the Assessing Officer on entitlement to exemptions. If full facts are disclosed, but an incorrect exemption is claimed, the Assessing Officer can reopen the assessment only within the four-year period. Section 149 governs the field not covered by the proviso to Section 147. The proviso to Section 147 is a specific provision with a special limitation for scrutiny assessments with full disclosure. Therefore, if there is a full and true disclosure of material facts, the limitation is strictly four years. The question was answered in favour of the assessee. The appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s Ruchira Papers Ltd., had two industrial units in Himachal Pradesh. Profits from newly established industrial establishments were eligible for exemption under Sections 80-HH and 80-I of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee disclosed profits in one unit and losses in another but claimed exemption on the entire profits of the profitable unit without adjusting the losses. The Revenue contended that this led to income escaping assessment. The assessment proceedings were conducted under Section 143(3) (scrutiny assessment). The Revenue issued a notice under Section 148 for reassessment after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year. The dispute centers on whether this reassessment notice was validly issued, considering the assessee's disclosure of facts and the time limits prescribed by Sections 147 and 149 of the Act.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, in a case falling under the proviso to Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, if there has been a true and full disclosure of all material facts, a notice under Section 148 for reassessment can be issued after the expiry of four years, taking benefit of the provisions of Section 149 of the Act? Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that since it had made a full and true disclosure of all material facts necessary for assessment, and the assessment was a scrutiny assessment under Section 143(3), the proviso to Section 147 limits the reassessment period to four years from the end of the relevant assessment year. Therefore, a notice issued after this period is invalid. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue contended that the assessee had wrongly claimed deduction, leading to income escaping assessment. They argued that Section 147 is subject to Sections 148 and 153, and therefore must be read subject to Section 149. They further argued that since the income escaping assessment exceeded Rs. 1,00,000, the limitation period under Section 149 could extend to six years.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 147,Section 148,Section 149,Section 143(3),Section 80-HH,Section 80-I
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
ITA No. 22 of 2007
Date of Decision: 18.6.2012
Commissioner of Income Tax Shimla
…Appellant
Versus.
M/s Ruchira Papers Ltd. Kala Amb, Distt. Sirmour through its
Managing Director.
…Respondent
Appeal under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta, Judge. The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sharma, Judge. Whether approved for Reporting? Yes
For the appellant:
Mr. Vinay Kuthiala Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Vandana Kuthiala, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. K.D. Sood, Sr. Advocate with M/s Abhishek Jhamba and Sanjeev Sood, Advocates.
Per Deepak Gupta, J (oral)
Though this appeal by the Revenue was admitted on a different question of law but in our opinion the following question of law arises in this case:-
Whether in a case falling under proviso to Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, if there has been true disclosure of all material facts, can notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act for reassessment be issued after an expiry of period of four years taking benefit of provisions of Section 149 of the Income Tax Act?
2 2.
The undisputed fact is that the assessee had two Units within the State of Himachal Pradesh. As per the Industrial Policy and the incentives given, profits in these newly established industrial establishment were entitled for exemption of tax under Sections 80-HH and 80-I of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’). 3.
Before this Court, it has not been disputed that for the purposes of computing profit which was to be exempted under these provisions losses of the Units have also to be taken into consideration and combined together and then the exemption claimed. Admittedly this was not done. However, the assessee did disclose to the Assessing Officer that it had incurred losses in one Unit and made profits in the other Unit. Instead of adjusting the losses o of one Unit against the profits of the other it claimed deduction of the entire profits of the second Unit. It is claimed on behalf of the revenue that the assessee was not entitled to deduction of the entire profits and could have only claimed deduction of the profits after making deduction of the losses of the other Unit of the assessee. The whole dispute revolves around the interpretation to be given to Section 147 of the Act, which reads as follows:-
“147. If the Assessing Officer has reason to believe that any income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for any assessment year, he may, subject to the provisions of sections 148 to 153, assess or reassess such income and also any other income chargeable to tax which has escaped assessment and which comes to
3 his notice subsequently in the course of the proceedings under this Section, or recomputed the loss or the depreciation allowance or any other allowance, as the case may be, for the assessment year concerned (hereafter in this section and in sections 148 to 153 referred to as the relevant assessment year):
Provided that where an assessment under sub- section (3) of or this section has been made for the relevant assessment year, no action shall be taken under this section after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year, unless any income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for such assessment year by reason of the failure on the part of the assessee to make a return under or in response to a notice issued under sub-section (1) of or to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for his assessment, for that assessment year
Explanation 1.- Production before the Assessing Officer of account books or other evidence from which material evidence could with due diligence have been discovered by the Assessing Officer will not necessarily amount to disclosure within the meaning of the foregoing proviso.
Explanation 2. - For the purposes of this section, the following shall also be deemed to be cases where income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment, namely:- (a) where no return of income has been furnished by the assessee although his total income or the total income of any other person in respect of which he is assessable under this Act during the previous year exceeded the maximum amount which is not chargeable to income-tax; (b) where a return of income has been furnished by the assessee but no assessment has been made and it is noticed by the Assessing Officer that the assessee has understated the income or has claimed excessive loss, deduction, allowance or relief in the return; (c) Where an assessment has been made, but- (i) income chargeable to tax has been under assessed; or (ii) such income has been assessed at too low a rate; or (iii) such income has been made the subject of excessive relief under this Act; or
4 (iv) excessive loss or depreciation allowance or any other allowance under this Act has been computed.”
In addition thereto, reference has been made by Shri Vinay Kuthiala, learned senior standing counsel for the Revenue to the provisions of Section 149 of the Act, which prescribe the time limit for issuance of notice and reads as under:-
“149. (1) No notice under Section 148 shall be issued for the relevant assessment year,-
(a) if four years have escaped from the end of the relevant assessment year, unless the case falls under clause (b);
(b) if four years, but not more than six years, have escaped from the end of the relevant assessment year unless the income chargeable to tax which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to one lakh rupees or more for that year.
Explanation.- In determining income chargeable to tax which has escaped assessment for the purposes of this sub-section, the provisions of Explanation 2 of Section 147 shall apply as they apply for the purposes of that section.
(2) The provisions of sub-section (1) as to the issue of notice shall be subject to the provisions of section 151.
(3) If the persons on whom a notice under section 148 is to be served is a person treated as the agent of a non-resident under section 163 and the assessment, reassessment or recomputation to be made in pursuance of the notice is to be made on him as the agent of such non-resident, the notice shall not be issued after the expiry of a period of two years from the end of the relevant assessment year.”
The contention raised on behalf of the Revenue is that in this case though the assessee may have disclosed all facts but it had wrongly claimed the deduction and
5 therefore, it amounts to income escaping from assessment. There can be no dispute with regard to this proposition. In case the assessee has claimed some benefits wrongly then this would definitely be a case of income escaping assessment. The moot point what is the time limit for issuing reassessment notice in such cases. 5.
Another admitted fact is that the assessment proceedings in this case were conducted in accordance with the provisions of Section 143 of the Act i.e. scrutiny proceedings, which definitely entail a greater amount of scrutiny by the Assessing Officer as the term scrutiny itself postulates. 6.
It has been contended on behalf of the Revenue that Section 147 of the Act itself starts with a clause that it is subject to provisions of Sections 148 and 153 of the Act and therefore, must be read subject to Section 149 of the Act. This argument may, at first blush, seem to be attractive but the words of the Statute have to be given a proper interpretation keeping in view the language of all the relevant provisions. 7.
When we read Section 147 of the Act, especially the proviso thereto, it clearly postulates that where assessment has been made under sub-section (3) of Section 143 of the Act no action can be taken after the expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year unless the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment by reason of or failure on the part of the assessee to either make a return under or in response
6 to a notice or to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for the assessment. We are only concerned with the second part of the proviso which deals with disclosing fully and truly all material facts necessary for the assessment. The duty of the assessee is to disclose the facts. It is not his duty to disclose what is the inference to be drawn from the facts. It is not his duty to guide the Income Tax Officer as to whether he is entitled to any exemption or not. This is the role or the duty cast upon the Assessing Officer. If the assessee has placed full and true facts before the Assessing Officer but has taken the benefit of an exemption to which he was not legally entitled to then the Assessing Officer can reopen the assessment only within the period of four years as provided for under this proviso. It is not as if the assessment has become final. It is not as if the mistake cannot be rectified. However, the Legislature has laid down the condition that the limitation for reopening the matter will be four years and no more if there has been full, true and complete disclosure of all the material facts. 8.
Finality has to be given to assessment proceedings. These cannot be reopened at the whims and fancy of the Revenue even when mistakes may have taken place. The law provides a procedure and also prescribes the limitation for taking such action. To take benefit of a power, which essentially is very wide power of virtually reopening the assessment, the Revenue must act within the time prescribed by the Act.
7 9.
It has been contended on behalf of the Revenue that Section 149 of the Act lays down the limitation and since the income, which has escaped assessment in the present case, is more than Rs.1,00,000/- the limitation would be six years and in fact under the un-amended provision of Section 149, the limitation would be seven years even in the case where the income escaping assessment was more than Rs.50,000/-. 10.
We are of the considered view that Section 149 of the Act governs that field which is not covered by the proviso to Section 147 of the Act. The proviso to Section 147 of the Act is a specific provision laying down a special limitation in cases of assessment made on scrutiny where there has been full and complete disclosure of material facts. In such cases, the limitation is four years. Section 149 of the Act also lays down a limitation of four years even in cases where the income has escaped assessment due to non-disclosure of material facts. However, in case the income escaping assessment is more than Rs.1,00,000/- (Rs.50,000/- earlier) then the limitation would be six years. Therefore, even under Section 149 of the Act, the notice cannot be issued after four years of the end of the relevant assessment year unless the income escaping assessment is more than Rs.1,00,000/- in which case the limitation would be six years. After six years obviously no notice could be issued. 11.
It is clear that: (a) when there is full, complete and true disclosure of all material facts, the limitation is only
8 four years from the end of the assessment year concerned; (b) when there is non disclosure of facts the limitation is four years in case the income escaping assessment is less than Rs.1,00,000/-; and (c) in case there is non-disclosure of facts and the income escaping assessment is more than Rs.1,00,000/- the limitation is six years. This is the only interpretation which can be given to Sections 147 to 149. 12.
While taking this view we are fortified by the judgment of the Allahabad High Court in Vikram Kothari (HUF) vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., (2011) 242 CTR Reports, wherein the Allahabad High Court after considering the provisions of Sections 147,148 and 149 of the Act held as follows:-
“13. Thus, on the plain reading of s. 147 and s. 149 legal position in respect of limitation emerges as follows:-
(i) In view of proviso to s. 147 no action can be taken under s.147 beyond the period of four years if the case does not fall within the exception of the proviso mentioned in the proviso itself namely, if there is no case of failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts which are necessary for assessment for the year of assessment etc.
(ii) If the case falls under the exception mentioned in the proviso to s. 147, namely there is failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts which are necessary for assessment for the year of assessment etc., then action can be taken beyond four years subject to the issue of notice under s. 148 of the Act within the limitation provided under s. 149 of the Act.
(iii) Where case falls under the exception to proviso to s. 147 and escaped income exceed
9 rupees one lac. the notice under s. 148 can be issued beyond the period of 4 years but within 6 years under s. 149(1)(b).
(iv) In case when the escaped income is less than rupees one lac the limitation to issue the notice under s. 148 is only four years, even if the case falls under the exception of proviso to s. 147.”
13.
In view of the above discussion, we answer the question in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue and therefore, we find no merit in this appeal, which is accordingly dismissed. No costs.
( Deepak Gupta )
Judge.
June 18, 2012
( Rajiv Sharma )
(vt)
Judge.
More judgments on Section 147
- S V D Promoters, Agra vs Income Tax Officer Ward 1(1)(2), AgraITA 325/AGR/2026[2015-16]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2015-16
- Suman Lata, Raipur vs Income Tax Officer-1(1), RaipurITA 800/RPR/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Naynaben Rasiklal Cholera, Rajkot vs ITO, Ward-1(2)(1), RajkotITA 1124/RJT/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Pakman International, Delhi vs ITO Ward 34(5), DelhiITA 7952/DEL/2026[2014-2015]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2014-2015
- Crystal Business System Limited (Earlier… vs DCIT, Circle 22(2), DelhiITA 6979/DEL/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Sanjurani Giri vs. The Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Deepankar Mohanty vs. Union Of INDIAOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Dinabandhu Majhi vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax, CT And GST, KoraputOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Makardhwaj Kaudi vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahoo Supply Agency, Balasore vs. Central Board Of Indirect Taxes And CustomsOrissa · 17 Nov 2026