THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S G T INDUSTRIAL ENTERPRISES

PDF · subscribers
ITA/626/2008HC KarnatakaKAHC01033059200802 August 2014Author: B.MANOHAR,N.KUMAR3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeals were not maintainable. This decision was based on the Court's interpretation of Instruction No. 3/2011 in the case of CIT Vs. RANKA & RANKA. The Court had previously ruled that this instruction is retrospective, meaning that appeals filed by the Revenue with a net tax effect of less than Rs. 10 Lakhs are not maintainable. Consequently, all the present appeals, having a net tax effect below this threshold, were dismissed on grounds of maintainability. The Court granted the Revenue liberty to revive these appeals in the event they succeeded in their pending appeal before the Supreme Court concerning the interpretation of Instruction No. 3/2011. No decision was made on the substantive issues raised in the original appeals.

What were the facts?

The appeals were filed by the Revenue (Commissioner of Income Tax and Income Tax Officer) against the common assessee, M/s. G.T. Industrial Enterprises. The appeals challenged orders passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for various assessment years ranging from 1997-98 to 2002-03. The High Court noted that the net tax effect in these appeals was less than Rs. 10 Lakhs. The Court referred to its previous decision in CIT Vs. RANKA & RANKA, which held that Instruction No. 3/2011 is retrospective, making appeals with a net tax effect below Rs. 10 Lakhs not maintainable. The Revenue acknowledged that an appeal against the Ranka & Ranka decision was pending before the Supreme Court and sought liberty to revive these appeals if successful there.

What were the issues?

1. Whether appeals filed by the Revenue with a net tax effect of less than Rs. 10 Lakhs are maintainable, in light of Instruction No. 3/2011? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee did not present specific arguments on the merits of the ITAT's decision. Their position was implicitly supported by the High Court's reliance on its own precedent regarding the maintainability of appeals based on tax effect. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue challenged the ITAT's orders, seeking to set them aside and confirm the orders of the lower authorities (Appellate Commissioner and Income Tax Officer). However, the primary contention addressed by the High Court related to the maintainability of the appeals themselves, based on the net tax effect. The Revenue acknowledged that an appeal against the High Court's interpretation of Instruction No. 3/2011 was pending before the Supreme Court and sought a conditional dismissal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 2nd DAY OF AUGUST 2014

PRESENT

THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N.KUMAR

AND

THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE B.MANOHAR

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.616 OF 2008 C/W INCOME TAX APPEAL NOS.619 OF 2008, 623 OF 2008, 626 OF 2008, 627 OF 2008, 631 OF 2008, 634 OF 2008, 629 OF 2008 AND 643 OF 2008

BETWEEN :

1.

THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

C.R.BUILDING, QUEENS ROAD

BANGALORE

2.

THE INCOME TAX OFFICER

WARD – 10(2), C.R.BUILDING

QUEENS ROAD, BANGALORE

... APPELLANTS

(COMMON)

(BY SRI.E.I.SANMATHI, ADV.)

AND :

M/s. G.T.INDUSTRIAL ENTERPRISES NO.10/15, SUNKADAKATTE VISWANEEDAM POST BANGALORE – 560 096

... RESPONDENT

(COMMON)

(BY SRI.D.N.MANJUNATH, ADV.) ---

These appeals are filed under Section 260A of I.T.Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 12.12.2007 passed in ITA Nos.423/BNG/2007, 424/BNG/2007, 433/BNG/2007, 425/BNG/2007, 426/BNG/2007, 428/BNG/2007, 433/BNG/2007, 427/BNG/2007 and 435/BNG/2007, respectively for the assessment years 1997-98, 1998-99, 2000-01, 1999-00, 2000-01, 2002-03, 2000-01, 2001-02 and 2002-03, respectively praying to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein, allow the appeals and set aside the order dated 12.12.2007 passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No.423/BNG/2007, 424/BNG/2007, 433/BNG/2007, 425/BNG/2007, 426/BNG/2007, 428/BNG/2007, 433/BNG/2007, 427/BNG/2007 and 435/BNG/2007, respectively confirm orders of Appellate Commissioner and Income Tax Officer, Ward-10(2), Bangalore.

These appeals coming on for Hearing this day, N.KUMAR J., delivered the following:

JUDGMENT

All these appeals are preferred by the revenue challenging the order passed by the Tribunal, where the assessee is common.

2.

The net tax effect in these appeals is less than Rs.10 Lakhs. This Court while interpreting Instruction No.3/2011 in I.T.A. No.3191/2005 disposed of on 02.11.2011 (CIT Vs. RANKA & RANKA), held that it is retrospective in nature and therefore, the appeals filed

where the net tax effect is less than Rs.10 Lakhs are covered under the Notification and as such, it is not maintainable. Accordingly, these appeals are also not maintainable.

3.

It is submitted that against the said order of this Court in case referred supra (I.T.A. No.3191/2005), the Revenue has preferred an appeal before the Supreme Court and it is still pending. In the event of the Revenue succeeding in the Apex Court, they are reserved the liberty to revive these appeals. With said observation, appeals are dismissed.

Sd/- JUDGE

Sd/- JUDGE RV

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →