PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. INDRANI PATTNAIK

PDF · subscribers
ITA/55/2015HC OrissaODHC01024007201515 November 2018Author: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE K.R.MOHAPATRA40 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that all three essentials of a valid gift under Mohammedan Law – declaration of the gift by the donor, acceptance by the donee, and delivery of possession – were established. The court found that the donor, Syed Khizer Ahmed, had declared the oral gift, it was accepted by Mohd. Abdul Zia Baig on behalf of his minor son (Mohd. Irfan Baig) as natural guardian, and possession was delivered. Documentary evidence, including Ex. B1 to B33, supported the oral gift, its declaration in income tax returns, payment of gift tax, and subsequent property tax payments by the donee. The court found no infirmity in the trial court's appreciation of the evidence. Therefore, the partition suit filed by Syed Iftikhar Ahmed was dismissed, and the suit for possession filed by Mohd. Irfan Baig was decreed, confirming the trial court's common judgment and decree. No order as to costs was made due to the relationship between the parties.

What were the facts?

These appeals arose from a common judgment and decree dated January 19, 2015, by the I Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Secunderabad. O.S. No. 27 of 2005 was a suit for partition filed by Syed Iftikhar Ahmed (appellant in CCCA No. 72 of 2015, defendant in O.S. No. 77 of 2005) seeking a 7/20th share in a plot of land and the house constructed thereon. He claimed the property was purchased by his late father, Syed Khizer Ahmed, and inherited by him and his mother (defendant No. 1) and sisters (defendants Nos. 2-4). O.S. No. 77 of 2005 was filed by Mohd. Irfan Baig (respondent in CCCA No. 72 of 2015, plaintiff in O.S. No. 77 of 2005) for recovery of possession and mesne profits, claiming the property was gifted to him by his grandfather, Syed Khizer Ahmed. The trial court dismissed the partition suit (O.S. No. 27 of 2005) and decreed the suit for possession (O.S. No. 77 of 2005).

What were the issues?

1. Whether the suit schedule property was validly gifted by the deceased Syed Khizer Ahmed to his grandson, Mohd. Irfan Baig (plaintiff in O.S. No. 77 of 2005), thereby divesting any claim of partition by Syed Iftikhar Ahmed (plaintiff in O.S. No. 27 of 2005)? (Question of law and fact, concerning the validity of a gift under Mohammedan Law). Assessee (Syed Iftikhar Ahmed) argued that the property was purchased by his father and was ancestral, thus liable for partition. He contended that the alleged gift was not valid and that he was deprived of his rightful share. Revenue (Mohd. Irfan Baig) argued that the property was validly gifted to him by his grandfather, Syed Khizer Ahmed, through an oral gift accompanied by delivery of possession and acceptance. He relied on documentary evidence, including the donor's income tax returns declaring the gift and payment of gift tax, and permission obtained for construction in his name. He also argued that the possession of the original defendants was permissive.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

[ 3218 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF MARCH TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.VENKATESHWARA REDDY C.C.C.A. NOS: 55 AND 72 OF 2015 Appeal under Section 96 of CPC against the common order and decree dated 1910112015 made in OS No.27 &77 of 2005 on the file of the Court of the I Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Secunderabad. cccA No.55 QF 2015: Syed lftekhar Ahmed, S/o. Syed Khizar Ahmed Occ: Business Ri/o. Plot No.6, H.No.2/20189, Maharaja Colony, Secunderabad. ...APPELLANT/ DEFENDANT lvlohammed lrfan Baig, S/o. Mohd. Zia Baig, Rep. by his General Power of Attorney Holder, Mohd. Zia Baig @ Abdul Zia Baig, S/o. (Late) Abdul Sattar Baig, Ryo. 1-7- 68/8' ll Floor' sarojini Devi Road' secunderabad ..RES'.NDENT/ 'LATNTTFF cccA NO.72 0F 2015: Syed lftekhar Ahmed, Sio. Syed Khizar Ahmed Occ: Business R/o. Plot No.6, H'No'2/20l89'Maharajacolonv'secunderabad' ...AppELLANT/'LATNTTFF 1. Smt Begum Jani, Wo.late Syed Khizar Ahmed, Occ: Housewife, Rl/o.Plot No.12, Gulshan-e-lqbal, Sanjeevaiah Cooperative Society, Sikh Village, 2. Smt Shaeda Begum, Wo.Abdul Zia Baig, Occ: Housewife, R/o.'1-7-68, Mis.Saftar Sons Packaging Pri,t. Ltd., S.D.Road, Secunderabad. 3. Smt Ruksana Begum, Wo.Dr. Mohd. Raeesuddin, Occ: Housewife, Rl/o.Beside Pariwar Hotel, Station Road, Gulbarga, Karnataka State. 4. Smt Rizwana Begum, Wo.Raees lqbalk Occ: Housewife, Ryo.Plot No.12, Gulshan-e-lqbal, Sanjeevaiah Cooperative So0iety, Sikh Village, Secunderabad ...RES'.NDENT/ RES'.NDENT' For the Appellant : SRI K.K.WAGHRAY, Advocate For the Respondents : SRI RAVINDER REDDY MUPPU, Advocate The Court delivered the following : JUDGMENT

THE HON,BI,I i SRI JUSTICE A. VENKATESHWARTT IIE])DY C:CCA Nos.55 and 72 of 2O15 COMMON JU[I( |,MENT Thes;e tu,r appeals are arising out of the l:ontmon judgrnent arr(l c.ecree dated 19.01.2015 ir O.S.l'lo.'i7 of 2005 and C.S,lro.27 of 2005 on the fiie cf tht, lezLrned I Additional {)l- iel Judge, City Civil Court at SecurL j erabad 2. Tee plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2005 tra:r tile,1 the suit fbr parti:rc 11 in respect of the plot bearing No.(i - house bearing n*o.11 i 0 89 in Survey No.10 (part), si_rrate.d at Maharaja C,)l( ny, Sick Vi1lage, Secunderirbad ,.:laiming 7 /2O'], shrare I rr himsell', 1/Brn share for defenrl:.nt No.1 arrd 7 /4oti\ sha -e each to the defendant Nos.1l to 4. 3. The suit for recovr property and f per month fr,r n delivery of pc s;r defendant, r.," h, respect of thr: r plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 200r; tras iile<l the n, of possession in respect of ...t: :;ame )r mesne profits at the rate of Rs 3 5,000/- , t.he date of filing of the suit till tlL: da.te of ,:r;sion. This suit was filed agains: r.he sole is the plaintiff in O.S.No.2.Z of 1,'005 in rrly same suit schedule propert]. - p -enrises

Page 2 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &, 72 ot2Ol5 bearing No.2-20-89 plot No.6 in Survey No.10 (part) consisting of a residential house (ground floor) at Maharaja Colony, Sick Village, Secunderabad, admeasuring 322.22 square yards with precise boundaries as mentioned in the schedule of property 4. After full length trial, the suit in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 filed for partition was dismissed by the trial Court Whereas, in O.S.No.77 of 20O5 for recovery of possession was decreed, through common judgment and decree dated 19.01.2015. Feeling aggrieved by the common judgment dated 19.01.2015, the plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2005, suit for partition has filed CCCA No.72 of 2015 and the sole defendalt in O.S.No.77 of 2005, who is none other than the plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2005, has filed CCCA No.55 of 2015. Therefore, it is proposed to dispose of both the appeal suits together as under: PleadinEs in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5: 5. The plaintiff has frled the suit against the defendant Nos.l to 4 for partition 4nd separate possession of his 7 l2Oth share in the suit schedule property alleging

Page 3 of 35 : .\ R.J CCC\ N)s.'i ,t 7: of 2015 that his fatl- r:r, late Syed Khizer Ahmed, rvtL:r is the husband of <i,:fr:ndant No.1 and father of ciefenrl:,nt Nos.2 to 4, has purc tiLsed the plot No.6 admeasur-ins i,2 2 square yards, throuill . {t registered sale deed docunrerrt ,r r,.2(j 12 of 1979, datc<i 06.11.1979 before the Sub F,egrstrar, Marredpally a'rc[ constructed a house therein, .\'.-ric1r was assigned hrnr;e No.2-20-89 by the Cantonmerrl Eioard, Secu.nderabaC He died leaving behind the plrintiff and defer-rdalr- Ncs 1 to 4 as the only legal heirs and r; _ cce ssors to inherent :h , above said property. The defenc rt rt Nos.2 to 4 aJte r tlLt ir marriage started living at their in 1arn,s place. The Ir,;t defendant, mother of the 1;1ain1jf:' sl arted 'living u'ith the s:cond defendant, in view of the <liifer:nces with the 1;lahr if:. Subsequently, the plaintiff has colne to know tha., th: defendalt Nos.2 to 4 being the D.-r:ctors of M/s. Sattar li :,r: s Packaging Private Limite,l are :rying to mortgage th e strit schedule property claiming i: as their exclusive prop r:r ty. Thereupon, he addressed a ;etter to APSFC asserli :.9 his right of share over thr suit r,ch,:dule ,property. T.te c:efendants are depriving the rigltt s of the

Page 4 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 & 72 ot 2015 plaintiff in respect of suit schedule property. Hence, the suit for partition. 6. The defendant No.1, mother of the plaintiff has filed a detailed written statement and the same is adopted by the defendant Nos.2 to 4 who are the daughters of defendant No.1 and sisters of the piaintiff. 7 . The main averments of the written statement filed by the first defendant are that the relationship between the pa,rties inter se is admitted. The defendant No.2 is ma-rried to one Mohd. Abdul Zia Batg, who is looking after the defendant No.1 and her husband. The defendant No.1 was able to make savings, due to which her husband-Syed Khizer Ahmed has purchased the house site wherein the suit schedule property was constructed. Thereafter, since the defendant No.2 and her husband were looking after the plaintiff and her husband-late Syed l(hizer Ahmed, the suit schedule property was gifted to his grandson by name Mohd. Irfan Baig (plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005), who was minor at that time arrd represented by father-Mohd. Abdul Zia Batg. The said gift was

Page 5 of 35 r\ \'R,.J CC( ,\ N os. ; ) \, 7 .'. of 2()l; accepted b] I son as natlt|i deed, otl-rer property we s; Ahmed beirrll his gift in tre has issur:d ;ls also pard construcl.ed t obtaining pt::'r Baig in f)ecer Zia Batg thr husbald'Syec occupied the there un<ler 1.. late Syed Klr.z the plainl iff eJ schedule ho : s the purpose r Khizer Al-Lmr:rl 'lchd. Abdul Zia Batg on beha-lf ol I is minor I guardia:r and acted upon, t he o -L1,1inrr1 title e.evant documents and the sr-ri: sclredule handed over at that time. L.;.te St r d .(hizer a -r income tax assessee has de clitr,:d abotir 1 ear 1983 and the Income 'i'ax C r:lrartmenl iessment order to that effect ancl gift lax was 'h ereafter, Mohd. Abdul Ziz, l: aig has :e house i.e., the suit schedule prr:pe.-ty b1, .rission as a natural guardian ol- Iv ; rd. Irfan :ter 1985. At the instance of Mclrl. Abdr-rl t-rrst defendant along with her rleceased Khizer Ahmed and other srzrnrl children :;r.rit schedule residential house arrrl s tayed ;e permissive possession. In thc ',',, ar 1997 l:r Ahmed fell sick, during thr: relevr Lnt time, .rc shifted along with his fam:ly in.I th: suit :: by repenting about his past misc:r duct for 'rieruing his father. Even though lrrte Syed was against joining of the plaintili with the family in the s.rit house at the instance of Mohcl. .l.bdrrl Zia \-..-

Page 6 of 35 Baig, the hrst defendalt permitted the plaintiff to stay in the suit house on a condition that he should ieave the house whenever the real owners demand him. But on expiry of Syed Khizer Ahmed in the year 1997 in spite of repeated requests, the plaintiff failed to leave the suit house, on ttre other hand, in the year 1999 forcibly thrown out the defendant No.l from the suit house. Having no other shelter, she started Iiving with her daughters and at present she is depending on her daughters for all her requirements. Subsequently, when the hrst defendant refused to part with her property bearing No.21 at Bowenpally, Secunderabad in favour of the plaintiff, he came up with false allegations and filed the present suit knowingfully well that the suit schedule house was constructed with the monies of Mohd. Abdul Zia Baig and it stands on the name of his son-Irfan Baig, who is the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005 by virtue of gift of land given by Syed Khrzer Ahmed, accordingly, prayed for dismissal of the suit.

Page 7 of 35 ,\\,R,J CC(A\os.)r&7lof2015 Pleadinss irL( .S-NS.ZZ-gj ZQQE: B. It,: plaintiff has filed this suit agnirr;l tLLe sole defendant, rv rc, is the plaintiff in O.S.No.27 o' 12005, for eviction al,l ecovery of possession. The 'nain :,vel ments of the p lead i Lg s in the plaint are that th e su property - 1>.< t No.6 admeasuring 322.22 s(luilr( gifted to hirr r1 maternal grandfather in ar: ot'al 01.O3.19,83 a rrl it was zrccepted on his beh.ilf b1 ' scl-redule .. arrls was - iba dated l is lather. The relevar: t rlocuments along with posse ss 'l -t :f the property wr::, rlelivered. ThereaJter, he has cotts;tructed a residential h .,t se in the suit plot on obr-airlir : required permission 1r rre the Secunderabad Cantonmc'r-rt l:ioard and they u,ere ir teaceful possession and enjoymt:nt. While so, in or arotur:. the year 1997 the defen,laut r,'as given permissir,e pr s,session to join the suit schedule l).'operty to look aftt:r I.a e Mohd. Syed Khizer Ahmed, tl-rt maternal grandfathe.- r ,he plaintiff. In fact, the plaintifl tr as paying the proper',.'r t:rx, electricity consumption char:t:s tmd all other s':atrt.,ry liabilities in respect ol suiL schedule property as; t r( same stands on his name. After the death of late S,vecl l'.hizer Ahmed, the defendant refi-rst': to vacate

Page 8 of 35 the suit house, the plaintiff has come to know that the defendant has also Iiled a partition suit in O.S.No.27 of 2005. The plaintiff got issued a legal notice dated 07.06.2005 calling upon him to vacate the suit house and also to pay Rs.35,0OO/- per month towards damages, but no reply was issued to the said notice. Hence, the suit for eviction of the defendant and also for mesne profits at the rate of Rs.35,000/- per month from the date of filing of the suit. 9. The sole defendant has filed a detailed written statement mainly contending that the plaintiff was not in possession of the suit house at any point of time. The alleged memorandum of past transaction said to have been executed by Syed Khizer Ahmed is not a valid document. The father of the plaintiff is instrumental for all the family disputes. Late Syed I{hizer Ahmed himself constructed the suit house with his own funds and the defendant was residing in the suit house along with his father. Hence, the question of the defendant staying in the suit house as a permissive possessor does not aris6. In fact, the defendant

Page 9 of 35 , \ I.R,.J CCCA \os..i; \ 7.1 of20t; has obtaint rl passport of 29.08.1989 with the ruldress of suit schedtLle house as his residential address ,rnc after the death o his father-Syed Khizer Ahmed, he hlect O.S.No.2 7 cf ,)005 for partition of the suit sctLedule property, as i;rrch the present suit is nr,t mtri.:rta.nable without seeki 1g deciaratory relief and the suit ri liable to be dismissc<i on this ground alone, the plain1r.T is not entitled for rr, sre profits (r! Rs.35,000 /-, the suit is t,arred by limrtatiorL )rayed for dismissal of the suit. I 0. [] ,r , ing on the above pleadings, t.h e bll twing issues we re s( r.tled by the trial Court in O.S.Nos..t ,, a.,td, Z7 of 2005: Issues in O.Si.I o,27 of 2OO5: 1. V/he th .:r the plaint schedule properties, are r lr,: sr.lf_ acqurr 'd properties of [he father of the p1a-in _ 1? 2. Srhetb ,r the plaintiff is entitled to a share n the pLain,chedule properties? .-t fc' r? 4. T,r wtLr : -elieP If so, 1 .r what share each of the parties are :r.titled

PaBe 10 of 35 Issues in O.S.No.77 of 2OO5: CCCA Nos.55 &,72 ol2Ol5 is entitled for recovery of schedule property from the 1. Whether the possession of defendant? plaintiff the suit 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for future mesne profits @ Rs.35,0OO/- per month as prayed for? 3. Whether the plaintiff is liable to pay Advocate Court fee on the relief of future mesne proltts under Section 41 of APCF and SV Act? 4. To what relieP Evidence and findings ofthe trial Court: 11. During trial, evidence was adduced in the lead suit in O.S.No.27 of 2005, suit for partition. On behalf of the plaintiff, he himself got examined as PW.1. Exs.A. 1 to A. 16 documents were marked. After closure of plaintiffs erridence on behalf of defendants, DWs.l to 5 were examined. DW. 1 is the defendant No.1 in O.S.No.27 of 2005. DW.2 is the defendant No.4 in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5. DW.3 is the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005. DW.4 is the father of DW.3, whereas DW.S is al independent witness for oral hiba on 01.03.1983 and the memorandum of hiba dated O4.03.1983 along with Moinuddin Ali Khan. In all.--

PaBe 11 of 35 , l \,R,J CC(A \os..; i I 7-l of20l5 Exs.B.1 to il 3.J documents r,vere marked. Hcrr.:ve r, the issue No 1 .rlf .S.No.27 of 2OO5 was re-casted r rrrsilering the pleaclin,gs and the rraterial available on r.ecr,r d bv the trial Cou:t ru; rrnder: Wht:th:r' ,f e plaint schedule property is subsrsr irrg as the prop, rty rlf ths Iatl'rer of the plaintiff rLs r>n tire date of his r1,.: .tir or covered by HIBA in favour of 1>l,rintif: in O.S Nc.7;' of 2005 pronounced by the fathe- rf the plainti.I, iyed Khizer Ahmed and covert:d by Meraora r ,lrrni of pasL Gift date 04.03. 1983? 12. Or <:areful appreciation of the entirr material on record, t. re learned Judge of the tr.ial (,r.ur_ has answered tl.t: jssue No.1 in O.S.No.27 of 2005 alliLinst the plaintiff r-here n holding that the suit schedul: property was not sut,r rsting as the self-acquired ltropert rr of the father of th,: :,lirintiff as on the date of his deatt: i.rt., on 23.10.1997 ,r as on the date of liling of th: suit for pa-rtition b-u-. ,l-r,, platntiff and it is coverr:d b.r hiba as claimed by t r : first defendant by Syed Khrz<:r 1\l1med ir-r favour of the l)laintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2OOS :Lnd that memoranCurr of past gift was also exc()Lltec. on 04.03.1963. Srnrilarly, issue Nos.2 & 3 in O.S l',1o.:27 of

Page 12 of 35 2005 were answered against the plaintiff therein, accordingly, the suit of the plaintiff was dismissed with costs. 13. Similarly, the issue No.1 in O.S.No.77 of 2005 was answered in favour of the plaintiff holding that the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of possession of the suit schedule property from the defendant. Issue Nos.2 to 4 were answered, holding that the suit of the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2OO5 shall be decreed with costs and the defendant therein was directed to vacate the suit schedule property u'ithin three months from the date of judgment and till the vacant possession of the same to the plaintiff and in default the plaintiff is entitled for eviction of the defendant through process of the Court and that the plaintiff is at liberty to file a separate petition under Order- XX Rule 12 of CPC to ascertain the qualtum of mesne profits for occupation of suit schedule property from the date of notice dated 07.06.2005 till the date of delivery of vacant possession of the same to him subject to payment of court fee on such ascertained sum.

PaBe 13 of 35 14 l'l us, the plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2C{),> and the sole defenczr:rt in O.S.No.77 of 2005 has filed :he,;e tri,o appeal suits n CCCA No.72 of 2005 arid CCCtr Nc,.55 of 1995 respe,::i ,'eIy. I /R,.I CC(IA llos.: I; & 72 ol 2(r t 5 15. Flt a:-d learncd counsel on bcll,, sides. 16. ln t.-re lighL of the rival contentions axd the Submiss ons made on either side havc r.e< r:ive<l due considerattion rl' this Court materlal avzul rble on re<;ord the following points :Lrat woulci arise for r--orLl;i .k:ration are 11, I e ,her PW. 1 is entitled for partiti: r.L and srol ,aiate possession of the slrit sr:Lredrrle prr p :rty as prayed for? \Vt,:l.her the suit for recovery o[ pos:t:ssion 'r,-r, ltLe plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005 jn the abr ence of declaration of ti:.. t: is nra ntainablc? iii) V/l:::ther the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 1)()05 is at,l ,, to establish the essentials of valirl pift dee rl under Mohammedan !aw? :rncl

Page 14 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &,72 of 2015 i") Whether the impugned common judgment and decree dated 19.01.2015 is sustainable? 17. The learned counsel on behalf of the appellant in both the suits strenuously contends that the trial Court has failed to appreciate the material available on record and erroneously dismissed the suit in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 and decreed the suit in O.S.No.77 of 2005. The crux of the entire case is that whether the grandfather of DW.3 has executed oral hiba on 01.03.1983 and the memorandum of past hiba on 04.03.1983 as pleaded by DW.3. It is furtfrer argued that the case of DW.3 is that in 1997 PW. 1 was allowed to enter into the suit schedule house and he is continuing as permissive possessor which has no basis. It is only in order to grab the suit house, the father of DW.3 has played fraud on DW. 1 and her husband. There is ample evidence on record to show that even in the year 1989 itself PW.1 has obtained passport and got his name entered in the voter list with the suit house as his residential address. Subsequenfly, his children were also admitted with the same address in the school. The suit \ frled by DW.3 for recovery of possession in the absdfd of

Page 15 of 35 1., R,J CCCA Nos.i,l; \ 7tl ol2Ol5 declaration t title, in the above circumstancoii, :s not maintainable : 'rLd it is 1iab1e to be dismissed. 18. 'ln .: learned counsel for the appellant reijed on the principfu:s :aid in the following decisions: iva rir Mohammed. Vs. J. Kamqla and. othetst 1/,e r.k'.ataramq.nq. olio,s Venkappa AntlauAa )7e7de (since deceased bg L.R,) Vs. Gonpathi un :l others2 , iir) t;.ll I; Usman Ali and another Vs. O.B.V. Kt,.'tendra lla. and. anothef; irr) lf,a'be.za Bibi and others Vs" Sho:ikh Fari:t (dlea) ltgl '.,fi'.s ond. otherd'; v) Ittrh . Taher Ali Khan Vs" Chairtnan, llt using Ilor LnI through Competent Authortfu and tlhers5; vi) l[.s. .Noor Ja.ho.n Begum Vs. MuJtkhar Dcd,. Kh:an cttu I others6; vii) Iitt wal Abdul Hakeem Sab (died} bg I,.F!s 7s. trkL'V.tm Sufiga and. othersT; , viii) Inc te Noriah Binte Mohamed. Tahir Vs. Sft<rik A,ll e bin Omar bin Abdutlah Bo,ho.shuan9; ' AIR 2o2o sc 432 . 2 AIR 200+ Karnal {€. 433 I AIR 1973 lv{adr.z.s 2ti0 a AIR 20 1l sc 159: s-oeopl ALD 1tc.i o AtR 1970 Altahat d l7o 'zoro 1r; ALD 8c2 8 AIR 1929 priv-w {} uncil 3

Page 16 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 & 72 ol2Ol5 ix) Most. Bibi Sageed.a Khatoon and. others Vs. Most. Bindtl Fatma and othersg; 19. Per cofttra, the learned counsel for the respondents strenuously contends that the learned judge of the trial Court on careful appreciation of the available evidence on record has rightly dismissed the suit filed for partition by the plaintiff therein and decreed the suit filed by DW.3 for recovery of possession. DW.3 is able to establish all the essentials of valid gift under Mohammedan Law. There is no ground for interference with the findings recorded by the trial Court. The suit schedule property was not subsisting as self-acquired property of late Syed Klizer Ahmed as on the date of his death or on the date of filing the partition suit, and it was orally gifted in favour of DW.3, who was a minor at that time under the gua-rdianship of his natural father on 01.03.1983 and the memorandum of past gift was also executed on 04.03.1983 as in Ex.B.1, all the essentials for valid gift are established. On behalf of DW.3, his father has accepted the grft, e zooo lzl FJCc 348

Page 17 of 35 AvR.J CCC{ Nos.s.' lt 72 ol2Ol5 possession '^; s also delivered and in fact perm i;:jior1 was obtained b1' he father of DW.3 from the Cirrrtonment Board, Se'curLr erabad for construction of the suit l;ouse. It is only wher-r a-e Syed Khizer Ahmed was sick rl rder the guise of lool<ir Lg after him, PW.1 has entered inr rl th: suit house as a I)e rr.issive possessor, with a mda fidr: intr:ntion fiIed the suit or partition in O.S.No.27 of 2005. 'lhr: trial Court has riq ltly dismissed the said suit. Tht: -r: are no merits in botb the appeals filed by the appellant ;tnd relied on the princip ,:r; iaid in the following decisions: llltt l-dasani Sarojana Vs. Mud.daso,ni lt enlcat Itktt tsctirl,h and othersra tktu'ee'za Bibi and. others Vs. Shaikh Faric,. ldead) bg . ,.Rs and otherst 1; Point No.(iil: Wherth:r [he suit for recovery of possession by the plaintill n O.S.No.77 of 2005 and in the alx;ence of declirr r.t:on of title is maintainable? 'o AIR 2oo7 lip s c t'1zott1 5 scc ri;

Page 18 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &,72 ol 2Ol5 20. DW.3 has filed the suit in O.S.No.77 of 2OO5 for recovery of possession alleging that PW. 1 was only permitted as permissive possessor in the suit house, but therea-fter he failed to vacate the suit house with mala Iide intention and filed the suit for partition in O.S.No.27 of 2005. The learned counsel for the appellant has seriously disputed the construction of the suit in O.S.No.77 of 2005 for recovery of possession in the absence of decla-ration of title, since the defendant therein, who is PW. 1, has been disputing title of DW.3 and relied on the following decisions: 2I. ln Nazir Mohammed's case (cited supra), in a second appeal, the Apex Court considering the plea of adverse possession raised by the defendant in para-46 held as under: "46. A decree of possession does not automatically follow a decree of declaration of title and ownership over propert5r. It is weil settled that, where a Plaintiff wants to establish that the Defendant's original possession was permissive, it is for the Plaintiff to prove this allegation and if he fails to do so, it may be presumed tliat possession was adverse, unless there is evidence to the contrarJr." l-r

Page 19 of 35 A y'R,.I CC(IA Nos.: :; &, 72 of 2015 22 In 9 enkataramo,na's case (cited suprr) in a suit filed un,ler iiection 34 of the Specilic Relief rt.ct, 1963 <iealing wit b permissive possession held th iir. in the absence of examination of independent ri i:ness to corrobor.ate t Le said plea, the plaintiff has misererbly failed to prove the .heory of permissive possessicn, asi su^h the plea of defenr att for adverse possession was uplrt:ld. 23. fl ,: learned counsel for the responde nis r-elying on the prrirx:: 1t1es laid in Muddasani Scrojr'cza's <:i,tse (cited supra) argtur, I ihat DW.3 is entitled for filing tlL:: sirit for mere recover ,' of possession, merely because I:W.1 has denied t,re r.i k:, the plaintiff in OS No.77 of l(.r5 is not expected to a rtr:nd the pleadings or to seek the .:r:claration of title. in pr:.rir-12 of the above judgment. thrs (.ourt has held as unde r "72 Tte suit was fited for the relief of recov,rr,r o[ possessir n of the suit schedule property and rtr:sne proJits t.l ,:reof. Obviously, it is based upon tr t tle Such a uit can be maintained, when l.here is. nc, disput,: i s to the title in the plaint" The acim; lr:rior of title ir r(tspect of the suit scheduie property : eec not be ,,j ,;- r-vis the plaintiff alone. If the plair tilf is,

Page 20 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &,72 of2Ol5 able to disclose the title, beyond any pale of doubt, even in respect of his predecessors, or transferors, then he does not have the necessit5r to pray for the relief of declaration of title. Where, however, there is serious dispute as to the existence of title in the plaintiff and the same doubt exists as to the title of the predecessors and transferors, the necessity to seek declaration of title exists." 24. Be it stated that in the present case, on behalf of the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2OO5, in all five witnesses are examined. DW. 1 is the defendant No.1 in O.S.No.27 of 2015. In her evidence in chief examination, she has categorically stated that her late husband has gifted the suit plot in favour of DW.3, who was the minor at that time on 01.03.1983 under the guardianship of his father-DW.4 and the memorandum of said oral hiba was drafted on 04.03.1983 as in Ex.B.1. This evidence of DW. I is also supported by DW.2, who is the defendant No.4 in O.S.No.27 of 2005. Though these witnesses were cross- examined at length, I do not find any reason to disbelieve their version.

25 1l exarnined i1l The inderperLt and the mern Ex.B.1 aJorr;g There is nc Ahmed ir-i res are only cla.r Syed Khizer I the plairLtiff ; title beyrnrl predecessor -i, hiba on 01. ll and anol-her. hiba on behrl including, thr-' the case, ll-r necessity tc I because the rt that effect. A' existence of I Page 21 of 35 I,VR,,I CC\IA Nos : Ii & 72 of 2015 iat apart, the pialntiff in O.S.\o.7i' :rf 21005 is IrW.3 and his father is examinerl as DW.4. e rt witness for the oral hibet on - I .O:1.1983 :randum of past hiba dated t)4.C3 19811 as in r,r'ith another witness is examinerl as DW.S. ,l spute as to the title of late 51 r-.d Khizer :r<:ct of the suit plot. In fact, both rhe parties ring the suit schedule property th:rrug;h late hmed" With the oral evidence of I)\r/s. I to 5, n O.S.No.77 of 2005 is able tc dis,close the iury pale of doubt, even in resJ',r,)t of his rtr: Syed Khizer Ahmed, who execult::l the oral 1983 in the presence of two rvitne:s;es, DW-5 'Ihe father of DW.3 has also acrt:pted the i of DW.3, as per his oral evidenct: as DW.4 rr:citals of Ex.B. 1. In such lact sit ration of 'r plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2OO-, has nc er:k the relief of declaration of ti. r:', rnerely \iras a pleading in the written stirtr:ment to rsclutely there is no serious disputr as to the rl,: in favour of the plaintiff rn O.it No.77 of

Page 22 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &,72 ot 2015 2005 or his predecessor-in-title. The principles laid in Nazir Mohammed and Venkataro;mo;na's cases (cited supra) are distinguishable on facts. In fact, in a different context, the Apex Court has held that in the absence of any whisper in the plaint as to on which date the appellant or his predecessor-in-title took possession of the property found such plea as artificial one, but in the instant case, the evidence clinches the issue that late Syed Khizer Atrmed was the original owner of the suit plot, he orally gifted the same in favour of DW.3 under the guardianship of DW.4 on 01.03.1983 and also executed the memorandum of past gift on 04.03.1983. 26. In that view of the matter, relying on the principles laid in Muddaso;ni Saro.;cna's case (cited supra), I hold that the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005 is able to disclose his title and that of his predecessor beyond any pale of doubt and there is no necessity for the plaintiff to seek declaration of his title. The point is accordingly answered against the appellant and in favour of the --respondents.

Page 23 of 35 A./R,. CC(IA Nos.:: & 72 of20l5 Points - { il. [ii if & (ivl: 27 . S i Lc e the Point Nos. (i), (iii) & (ir ) are interconnec te :1, as the common evidence is let-i in both the suits;, fcr the sake of convenience they art: ,rns;wered together as -.r. id er: 28, P\ 2005 for pa.rt the suit i;ch e r< got exarninec rnar:ked in tl: s belonged tr; husbanri of t registere<l se.l PW.1 that residential h contributed fc /. i nas filed the original suit in O ! Nc,.27 of tion arld separate possession of his sh are in ule house. in support of his :ase, :,e himself irs PW. 1, Exs.A. 1 to A. 16 docurn ents are evidence. Admittedly, the suit plot ,rri1$nal11, iate Syed Khizer Ahmed, father ,rf pW. l, tr'.1 and he purchased the same _lrrough a :, deed dated 06.17.1979" It is as.r,'er1ed by :ir; father has constructecl tl-r,: e>:isting ru se in the suit plot and tha: he also :' '-he same. 29. Irr Lh e cross-examination, pW. t has rr,:Lterl that he was €rssiril ing his father in electronic allied r. or1>orate business till tr9'/6, trater with the business of M7 ; Trocom Combines u1r tc 1986. Therea_fter, he starte<[ his, or,r,,n

Page 24 of 35 partnership business with his father-in-law called as M/s. Golconda Packaging Industry. He further stated that he was not an income tax assessee in his individual capacity, except for M/s. Golkonda Packaging Industry, he admitted that Exs.A.7 to A. 10 are in his own handrtriting, which are the application form in respect of his children, showing his address at Door No.1-7-28, Zamisthanpur and the name of his father is shown as guardian of the suit schedule property. PW.1 has explained that the construction of suit house started in the year 1985 and he took about lYz year for completion, but he cannot say how much amount he contributed for the construction. He further stated that he has not seen the permission salctioned by the Secunderabad Cantonment Board 30. Be it stated that among the Exs.A. 1 to A. 16 f,tled on behalf of PW. 1 there is no document with details about the availability of funds with PW. 1 to contribute with his father for construction of the house in the suit schedule property.

a1 Jt. examinzLtic 1r improveme rr does no: rr:rr saw the p Secundera b a income :ax r the version constructic'11 was doing j,r 1985. Page 25 of 35 ,rVR J C(CANor.:;& 72 of2015 n a careful evaluation of tl:e cross- c f PW. 1 , there are certain om. r;:;iorts and ri beyond the pleadings. He has st:t:d that he ernt)er hou, much cash he has givr,:, he never ':rmission proceedings sanctionr:: try the ri Cantonment Board and he carn)t file his :ttrrns. Al1 these aspects are raisinl4 ir dcubt in of PW. 1 that he has contr l:,ut,:d for ,:l'the house along with his father rc.rd that he e- Lrusiness along with his father till the year 32. It is pertinent to note that no i - r tependent witness is e; anineci on behalf of PW. 1 in sulr: crt of his clajm fo;- par ition of the suit schedule property. Whereas, on behaif oj' he defendants in O.S.No.27 cf 2COlj refuting the claim nra 1e by the ptaintiff therein, in all fivr witnesses are exarnine r. DW.l, who is the mother of pW,1, she has categorically :;tated that her husband-SyeC I(hi:zr:r .{hmed has orally p ifled the suit plot in .favour ol Drdr.3 on 01.03.19t83, ;itrce DW.3 was minor the grft u'r: _r accepted : i i t r-r-" n-

PaBe 26 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 & 72 of 2015 by his father-Dw.4 arrd also original title deed was handed over along with the relevant documents pertaining to the suit plot in the year 1983 itself. She has further stated that the gift was confirmed by memorandum of past transaction dated 04.03.1983 as in Ex'B'1' Late Syed I(hizer Ahmed in his income tax returns has a-lso declared about the same and he has paid gift tax' Subsequently, DW.4 has obtained building permission from Secunderabad Cantonment Board in the year 1984 and constructed a residential house, which is the suit schedule property. 33. The learned counsel for the appellant contends that nothing is mentioned as to the acceptance of Hiba either in Ex.B.1 or in the oral evidence of DWs' 1 to 5' Be it stated that in par:a-2 of Ex.B.l in clear terms, it is mentioned that the hiba was made by Syed Khizer Ahmed and accepted by donee's father-DW.4 in the presence of the witnesses. Thus, the contention of the learned counsel for PW.1 that there is no acceptance has no legs to stand'

Page 27 of 35 34. 'Ii e,. :rpart as per the recitals in Il>:.8.1, the possessir>n ol suit schedule property was deiiv,)r:d to the donee's lath,: -l)W.4 and the title deeds were a i() handed over to ein-r. Apart from Ex.B.1, Ex.B.8-origir rri gift ta-x assessmonr r rrler, Ex.B.9 challan of gifr ta,x, Ex.B.10 original corr 1 utation of wealth tax, Exs. B. 1 1 r:nd B. l2 original rveelt L iax challans and Ex.B.13 brrildir 1l sanction pian filed on l ,enalf of the defendants in O.S.No..'i' ol' 20O5 and the plairrl iff in O.S.No.77 of 2OO5 are filed. 35" Ir' :rddition to the above docurr,:.rts, the del'endant N o. t herself got examined as DW.2. li -re is the sister of P\,r'. J s;upported the evidence of I)W. I D\V.3 is the plaintiff i L O.S.No.77 of 2005, whereas D\trI 4 .s the father of DVr'., i. DW.5 is the independent witnes.r, for or:r1 hiba and all;,r fc,r Ex.B.1. DW.2 has clearl_v statc:l that in view of oral i rta, none of the family members l'.av: any right in respe.:t of the suit schedule proportv. \Vhr:reas, DW.3 has srle,e d that all false allegations are ina<le bv PW. 1. Ttre cr g nal sale deed and other docum lr:ts as in 1,/R,. CC(lA Nos. a: &,72of2Ol5 Exs.B.7, B.'7 r-c 8.31 ',vere handed over to L Jr,.4. The

PaBe 28 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 &72 ot2Ol5 property tax was assessed and he has been paying the tax for the year 1989-90 onwards. DW.4 has supported the evidence of DWs. 1 to 3 and a-lso further stated that he has accepted the oral hiba on behalf of his minor son-DW'3 and also obtained permission from the Secunderabad Cantonmerrt Board in the name of DW.3 for construction of the house. 36. DW.5 clearly stated that he is related to both the parties to the suit as his mother is the sister of mother of late Syed Khizer Ahmed, husband of DW. 1 ald that it was on 01.03.1983 late Syed Khizer Ahmed called him and one Syed Moinuddin Ali Khan to his house at Picket on two occasions i.e., on 01.03.1983 as well as on 04'03' 1983' DW.5 further stated that in their presence on 01'03'1983 late Syed Khizer Ahmed has pronounced oral hiba and later he signed on the memorandum on 04'03'1981 in respect of the suit plot bearing No.6 situated at Maharaj a Colony. On behalf of DW.3, his father-DW.4 has accepted the gift and possession was also delivered' DW'5 further

Page 29 of 35 l.'. R,.I CCCA Nos.l r \ 7a: ol2Al5 stated that I ubsequently late Syed Khizer Atrrne,l has notarizecj E;<.1 i. l. 37 . iirnr r_he evidence discussed abovt:, _1 rs <:rysta1 clear that D\!:;.1 to 3 are not eye witnesses to thr: orzLl hiba dated O l .0:t . '1 33 in respect of the suit pk>t an _ q,hatever they hav,: sta e,l as to the execution of hibar, merr.or:ndum of past :rar s ar:tion as in Ex.B. 1 is on the brlsiis of tire informatLon I rnished to them by late Syeci Khi:re r Ahmed, husband o:- li\V. 1. DWs.1 to 3 are the iamil.r members they were zr'',r rre of a1l these developments. Sirrrilarly, t1-re evidence of I ,$/.4, who is the father of DW.3- i:n<:e and DW.5, r,l ho 1 i lne of the attestors of Ex. B. i rL: d z so in whose pl-eser,:<: oral hiba was made on O1.03. I !)!;3 is quite consistet'rt th rcughout the cross-examination. , )W.4 has clearly stalt:r that on 01.03.1993 itself his fetl,rer in_law ora-lly inforr:l rc him about the hiba, gave the ,.r. it plot in favour ol D\!,3 and also on the same day handt::l o.rer the documents. 'llrereafter-, he has obtained yrerml;:;ion letter '1from thr: sc ( jety, the r.l,itness denied the strg6 r:r;ticn that

PaBe 30 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 & 72 of 2Ol5 PW. t has contributed for construction of the house artd that late Syed Khizer Ahmed built the suit house. 38. It is the specific case of defendants in O.S.No.27 of 2005 and the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005 in or around the year 1997 only PW. 1 was permitted to occupy the suit house as permissive possessor since he intended to attend his ailing father. But, the voter ID card, PAN card and Passport disclose that much prior to 1997 in or around the year 1989 itself with the address of suit house PW.t has obtained such documents. Thus the fact remains that the oral evidence of DWs. 1 to 5 and the documents filed on behalf of plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005 are quite cogent and consistent. There is ample evidence to show that on 01.03.1983 oral hiba was made in favour of DW.3 under the guardianship of DW.4 and thereafter, a memorandum was executed as in Ex.B.l by late Syed Khizer Ahmed- Later, it was specifically notarized, as such as on the date of death ol late Syed Khizer Ahmed on 23.01.1997 or on the date of filing O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 the suit schedule ;propertl was not subsisting as his self-acquired property -- -,

Page 31 of 35 /.., R,.' CCCA Nos.l., l:71 of 20lir and as sucfr t t€ plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2O()S canrlot claim any right fo- I a:tition in respect of the sam(). 39. rn srrch circumstances, it is imnraterirl u,ltether PW"l has ,rn tered into the suit schedule pro:r,rty as a permissi.re pc ris;essor either in or around ti-re 1,6i,. 1997 or during tJre li r: time of his father along wrth o - ^ er family members. '[L ,: evidence wouid establish that , ate Syed Khizer A.lrme.r treing the absolute owner has sett ,:rl the suit plot througr )ral hiba rn favour of DW.3 dirted rl 1.OIt.1983 and merno:-i1 icum of ltast transaction as in Ii>t.B.1 was executed in he presence of DW.S and anoth:r. witness. The ora; evi, lence of DW.4 and the contenrs :rf lx.B.1 would estatrl s t that as guardiaa of the cior r:r: L,e has accepteri th e p if1 and also received title deecl i: nd other documents. F e has obtained permission :'rorr the Secunderab,l 1 Cantonment Board for construc r.i tn of the suit house.

'1'l rir; being the factual situation. tlrr: l34ne6 counsel for .l re appellant relied on the above strl de:isions $ ln S.llt Usmo,.t AIi. Hafeeza. Bibt, Mir. Taher Ati l{hc:it. M:;t. Noor

Page 32 of 35 CCCA Nos.55 & 72 of 2Ol5 Jahan Begum, Katual Abdul Hakeem Sab, Inche Norio,h blnte Mohamed Tahir, and Most. Bibl Sageeda Khrl:toon (cited supra) and argued that the essentia-ls of valid gift are not disclosed with the evidence available on record. 41. The essentials of valid gift were explained by the Apex Court and other High Courts including our High Court. The law is well settled that three essentials of the gift under Mohammedan Law are iii) declaration of the gift by the donor; accepta-nce of the gift by the donee; and delivery of possession. 42. The recitals of Mohammedan Law do not make writing essential to the valid gift. Oral gift fulfilling all the three essentials make the gift complete and irrevocable. Right from 1929 Privy Council in Inche Norlah Binte Mohamed. Tahi/s case (cited supra), the Courts in India have consistently laid down the essentials for valid gift under Mohammedan Law. 43. In the instant case, the gift was made by the donor on 01.03.1983 orally in the presence of DW.S and

Page 33 of 35 I \,R,J CCC { Nrs..'i ,n7a ot 2ali; another \\,itn( srr. At that time, DW.4 w:rs al j(, p:esent being guar(li ,rn of DW.3, Later, on 04.03 I )Bll the memorandu.tr cf past gift was executed in the 1r-csence of very sarne r;il irr:ss. A conjoint reading of the or,rl evjdence of DWs.zi €r 'i along rvith the contents of Ex.il I r.l,oulcl estabiish tL.ir' the donor-Syed Khizer Ahmed hz:; declared the oral gift c s;uit plot and it was accepteci by I)\i/.4 being the guar,liar rf DW.3 in the presence of DW.S ar,, I al-rother witness. pc,s;l ,:r;sion was delivered, title cieeds ..,rere a_lso handed over. The subsequent conduct of DWs.3 ii, 4 rvould disclose th r t permission was obtained ..-orr. the Secunderatra, I Cantonment Board for construction of the house on th.) name of DW.3 and that therr: is ample documentarf evidence to show that the doncr has also disclose<l tl-re o ra_l gift rn his income tax retlrrr ; eLn d also paid gift ta:<r/.vt:alth ta-x, subsequently the i)roper.r.y [r1x r,r',as being paid b1 trW.3 continuously.

J'l .r-rs, r.l,ith the evidence of DWs.1 t(, i; and the contents ol' l lxs.B.1 to B.33, the plaintiff in O.Si.No.77 of 2005 is ,a.ble o establish a1l the three essentizrls ot'va1id gift

Page 34 of 35 under Moharnmedan Law i.e., declaration of the gift by the donor, acceptance of the gift by the donee and delivery of possesslon. 45. Therefore, for all the reasons stated above, I hold that the principles taid in the above referred decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant will not be of no assistance to the appellant. Whereas, in accordance with the principles laid in those decisions only, all the essentials of valid gift under Mohammedan Law are established by the defendalts in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 and the plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of 2005. I do not Iind any infirmity or perversity in appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence available on record, the impugned common judgment and decree dated 19.01.2015 in O.S.Nos.27 and 77 of 2OO5 does not warrant any interference by this Court. Accordingly, the point Nos.(i), (iii) & (iv) are arswered against the appellant/ plaintiff in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 and sole defendant in O.S.No.77 of 2005 and in favour of the respondents i.e., defendants in O.S.No.27 of 2OO5 and the sole plaintiff in O.S.No.77 of

Page 35 of 35 T\ R,J CCCc. N,rs.SI ,i. 72 of 2OiS 2005 on th: ile of the learned I Addition,al Cf t, f . udge. City Civil Corlt at Secunderabad. 46. IrL llre result, both the appeal suits :n CCCA No.55 o{ 201i and CCCA No.72 of 2015 are :lisniissed confirmirrg tl::: impugned common judgm,:nt a;t j <lecree dated 19.O1 2r)t5 in O.S.No.77 of 2005 arrd O.Si No.27 of 2OO5 respe,:t ,,c ly on tl.re file of the learned Ll dditionril Chief Ju<lge , )ity Cii,ii Court at Secunderabad. _lorvever, in the circr_ r Ls tances of the case and <:onsirlt:ring the relationsl'rip o ::tween the parties, there sha_l L be rL; orrler as to costs. As a s r:<1ue1, miscellaneous applicationr; it. arr1. pending tn l;,r h the appeal suits, shall stand clos,,:rl. To //TRUE COPY// 1. The lAdditior.ra Chief Judge, City Civil Court, SecunderaLir:1 2. One CC to Sri t,.l.,.Waghray, Advocate [OPUC] 3. One CC tc Sri I ia'/inder Reddy Muppu, Advocate [OPUC] 4. Two CD Oopier Sd/ ( SRINIVASA RAO J(-)IN'- -REGISTRAR '=LD :,1.CTION OFFICER (vvith records) K +.

HIGH COURT DATED:2910312023 COMMON JUDGMEN T CCCA. Nos.55 and 7 2 ol 2015 DISMISSING THE I.1 PEALS WITHOUT COSTS. -''-:''- " -: . ,... - .c. i,r'f 0t t1 ,\\\\" N8 v .(- '\ r r:._:., ,f.:. \3 \v-3 s\

[ 3218 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF IMARCH TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.VENKATESHWARA REDOY c.c.c.A. NOS: 55 AND 72 0F 201s cccA NO.5s oF 2015: cccA NO.72 0F 201 5: !V.qd ^tf!e_[!gr Ahmed, S/o. Sye-d Khizar Ahmed Occ: Business Rt/o. ptor No.6, H.No.2/20/89, Maharaja Colony, Secunderabad. ...APPELLANT/ DEFENDANT Yg,!qll,"9 !,rrT eStg, S/o. Mohd Zia Baig, Rep. by his Generat power of Attornev Horoer, Mond. tia Baio rr, A_bdul ZiaBaig, s/o. (Late) Abdul sattar Baig, No.1_7_, 68/8, I I Ftoo r, Sa rojini bivi nora, s"iJn-ti'"iirr!l-'"'''' .RESPONDENT/ PLAINTIFF lV.qO -tf!e_[!qr Ahmed, S/o. Sye-d Khizar Ahmed Occ: Business Rfo. ptor No.6, H.No.2/20189, Maharaja Colony, Secunderabad. ...APPELLANT/ PLAINT|FF 1. S.mt_Begum Jani, Wo.late Syed Khizar Ahmed, Occ: Housewife, R/o.plot No. t 2. Gulshan-e-tobat, Sanjeevaiah Cooperative Societv, Sif n Viirrg"l' 2. Smt Shaeda Beg!m,. Wo.Abdul Zia Baig, Occ: Housewife, R/o.1 -7_68, M/s.Sattar Sons packaging pvt. Ltd., S.d.RoaO, Secunderibad. ' --' 3. SmtRuksana Begum, Wo.Or. Mohd. Raeesuddin, O"c: f-fousewife, Rl/o.Beside Pariwar Hotel, Station Road, Gulbarga, Xarnataii SiJG. 4 lnt!|ir*ula, BgO^um, Wo..Raefs tqbatk Occ: H6u;ewife, Ry;.Froil.ro.rZ, Gutshan-e-tqbat, Sanjeevaiah Cooperative Society, Sikh Village, ...RESPONDENT/ RESPONDENTS Appeal under section 96 of cpc against the common judgment and decree of the court of the I Additional chief Judge, city civil'court, Secunderabad in os No.27 & 77 o'f 2005. dated 19tO1t2O1S. oRDER: This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal, the Judgment and decree of the Lower court and the material papers in the

suit and upon hearinQ ll :) lrquments of Sri K.K.waghray, Advocat: rn brth cases for the Appe'ant and of Sr Favinder Reddy Muppu, Advocate for ti. Re;pondents in both cases. This Court doth Orler;rr ,i Cecree as follows : '1 That the Appezrr r iu ts in cccA No.55 0f 2015 and occA r,,t.71). of 2015 be and hereby drsn rssed confirming decree datr-.d I I /0 .l/201 5 in OS the impugned oommo-r jurjgment and No.77 of 2005 and r.)S No.2712005 respectivery on th' , f re of the learned r Additionar chief Judg:, citlr civir court, That there shall t;r no order as to costs of this appeals //TRUE COPYII Sd/-K [iIiINIVASA RAO JC [.,TJlEGtsTRAR (;L> SEC''IO\ OFFICER The lAdditional (.j ief Judge, City Civil Cou(, Secunderabad Two CD Copies x*,- To Kj

HIGH COURT DATED:29/03/2023 COMMON DECREE CCCA.Nos.55 and'12 o1 2O15 DISMISSING THE I\P )EIALS WITHOUT COSTS. b 25

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →