M/S SOMA TRG JOINT VENTURE vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

PDF · subscribers
ITA/34/2013HC J&KJKHC02001832201315 September 2017Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.S.WALIA4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the appeals filed by the Revenue. The Court noted that while the Revenue sought to rely on the Supreme Court's decision in New Noble Educational Society, the Supreme Court itself had clarified in paragraph 88 of that judgment that the decision would operate prospectively. This clarification meant that the Revenue could not take advantage of the changed legal position for the assessment years in question. Consequently, the Court was not inclined to frame the question urged by the Revenue and proceeded to dismiss the appeals. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeals, with no decision on the merits of the exemption claim itself for the period under review.

What were the facts?

The Revenue filed these appeals challenging orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for Assessment Years (AYs) 2007-08 to 2012-13. The assessee, Sikhya ‘O’ Anusandhan, which had registration under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, claimed exemption under Section 11 for its charitable activity of imparting education. The Assessing Officer (AO) denied exemption, alleging the assessee charged substantial fees for profit and made payments to 'interested persons'. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] and the ITAT allowed the exemption, holding that capital expenditure on infrastructure was permissible application of income under Section 11(1)(a) and relying on various Supreme Court and High Court decisions.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal were justified in allowing the benefit of exemption under Section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to the Respondent-Assessee? (Question of law) Assessee's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions made by the assessee before the High Court. However, it is implied that the assessee supported the findings of the CIT(A) and ITAT. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue argued that the CIT(A) and ITAT were not justified in allowing the exemption under Section 11. The Revenue drew the Court's attention to the Supreme Court's recent decision in New Noble Educational Society v. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, which took a different view from earlier precedents relied upon by the ITAT, such as Aditanar Educational Institution, Pinegrove International Charitable Trust, American Hotel and Lodging Association, and Queen’s Education Society. The Revenue sought to rely on this new ruling.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 11,Section 11(1)(a),Section 12AA

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Cited by 6 judgments on BharatTax

See all citing judgments →

Counted from the text of the judgments hosted here. Most recent first.

Page 1 of 4

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

ITA Nos.32, 33 & 34 of 2013 And ITA No.17 of 2015 and ITA No.37 of 2018

Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneswar (In ITA Nos. 32, 33 & 34 of 2013 and ITA No.17 of 2015) Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions), Hyderabad (In ITA No.37 of 2018) …. Appellants Mr. Radheshyam Chimanka, Senior Standing Counsel along with Mr. Avinash Kedia, Junior Standing Counsel for the Revenue Department -versus- Sikhya ‘O’ Anusandhan …. Respondent Mr. Siddhartha Ray, Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. K. K. Sahoo, Advocate

CORAM: THE CHIEF JUSTICE JUSTICE M.S. RAMAN

ORDER 03.01.2023 Order No.

Dr. S. Muralidhar, CJ. 06. 1. These appeals by the Revenue are directed against individual orders passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack (ITAT) in the corresponding appeals by the Revenue through the DCIT (Exemption) before the ITAT against the Respondent-Assessee for the Assessment Years (AYs) 2007-08 till 2012-13.

Page 2 of 4

2.

The common question sought to be urged by the Revenue in these appeals is whether the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] as well as the ITAT were justified in allowing the benefit of exemption under Section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (Act) to the Respondent-Assessee? 3. For the various AYs in question, in the returns filed by the Respondent-Assessee, which were picked up for scrutiny by the Assessing Officer (AO), the Assessee had purportedly shown the excess of income over expenditure which had been transferred to its capital account. The Respondent-Assessee having been granted registration under Section 12 AA of the Act, claimed exemption under Section 11 of the Act on the basis that it was carrying on the charitable activity of imparting education. While denying the said exemption, the AO came to the conclusion that the Assessee had been charging substantial fees from the students with a view to making profit and that the imparting of education was for commercial motive and for making payments to ‘interested persons.’ 4. The CIT (A) came to the conclusion, following the decision of the Supreme Court of India in S. RM. M. CT. M. Tiruppani Trust v. CIT (1998) 230 ITR 636, that capital expenditure was also considered as an application of the profits of the entity and that expenditure incurred on the creation of infrastructure and building was permissible expenditure under Section 11(1)(a) of the Act. Reference was also made to the decision of the Delhi High Court in St. Lawrenence Educational Society v. CIT (2010) 197 Taxman 504 (Del.) and the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court

Page 3 of 4

in Pinegrove International Charitable Trust v. Union of India (2010) 327 ITR 73 (P & H). Reference was again made to the decision of the Supreme Court of India in Aditanar Educational Institution v. Additional CIT (1997) 224 ITR 310 (SC). 5. In the impugned order, the ITAT has concurred with the CIT(A) and that the conclusion was based on the various decisions of the Supreme Court of India. 6. At this stage, Mr. Radheshyam Chimanka, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Revenue Department drew the attention of the Court to the recent decision of the Supreme Court of India in New Noble Educational Society v. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax 1, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1458 where a Larger Bench of three Hon’ble Judges of the Supreme Court has taken a different view from the one expressed in Aditanar Educational Institution (supra), Pinegrove International Charitable Trust (supra) and American Hotel and Lodging Association v. Central Board of Direct Taxes, (2008) 10 SCC 509 and Queen’s Education Society v. Commissioner of Income Tax, (2015) 8 SCC 47, all of which have been relied upon by the ITAT in the instant case. 7. However, this Court notes that in New Noble Educational Society (supra), the Supreme Court in para 88 of the said judgment clarified that “since the present judgment has departed from the previous rulings regarding the meaning of the term ‘solely’, in order to avoid disruption, and to give time to institutions likely to be affected to make appropriate changes and adjustments, it would be in the larger interests of society that the present judgment operates

Page 4 of 4

hereafter. As a result, it is hereby directed that the law declared in the present judgment shall operate prospectively.” 8. In view of the above clarification of the Supreme Court, the Revenue cannot take advantage of the changed legal position as a result of the decision in New Noble Educational Society (supra). 9. As a result, this Court is not inclined to frame the question urged by the Revenue in these appeals. The appeals are accordingly dismissed.

(Dr. S. Muralidhar) Chief Justice

(M.S. Raman) Judge M. Panda

More judgments on Section 11

All 7,784 judgments and leading authorities on Section 11 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →