DIRECTOR INCOME TAX vs. DOLPHIN DRILLING PVT LTD
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court allowed the revision, setting aside the orders of the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Joint Commissioner (Appeal), and the Assessing Authority. The Court found merit in the assessee's argument that the best judgment assessment for the assessment year 1999-2000 was made on the basis of pure conjectures and lacked a reasonable foundation. The significant disparity between the assessed turnover for 1999-2000 (Rs. 32,25,000/-) and the preceding year 1998-1999 (Rs. 4,50,000/-) without any apparent justification or consideration of relevant factors like passenger traffic, indicated arbitrariness. The Court relied on the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in *Kachwala Gems* and *Shri S.M. Hasan*, emphasizing that best judgment assessments must be grounded in reasonable estimates rather than speculation. The matter was remitted back to the Assessing Authority for re-assessment in line with the Court's observations.
What were the facts?
The revisionist, owner of Roadways Canteen, challenged the order dated 09.11.2011 of the Commercial Tax Tribunal, which upheld the order of the Joint Commissioner (Appeal) dismissing the assessee's first appeal. The first appeal had confirmed the assessment order dated 28.01.2002 by the Assessing Authority. During an inspection, the assessee failed to produce documents for sales and purchases. The Assessing Authority, using best judgment, fixed the turnover for assessment year 1999-2000 at Rs. 32,25,000/- with a tax liability of Rs. 1,55,875/-. The assessee had not previously argued that the best judgment assessment was arbitrary. The High Court noted the assessment for the previous year (1998-1999) was Rs. 4,50,000/- with a tax of Rs. 22,100/-.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the best judgment assessment for the assessment year 1999-2000, which determined the taxable turnover at Rs. 32,25,000/- and tax liability at Rs. 1,55,875/-, was made on a reasonable basis or on arbitrary grounds, considering the assessment for the preceding year was significantly lower. Assessee's contention: The learned Senior Counsel argued that the best judgment assessment must be based on a reasonable basis and not arbitrary discretion. He highlighted that the assessment for the previous year (1998-1999) was Rs. 4,50,000/- taxable sales with Rs. 22,100/- tax, making the jump to Rs. 32,25,000/- in the subsequent year unreasonable and based on pure conjectures. The Assessing Authority failed to consider factors like passenger flow to estimate sales. The assessee relied on Supreme Court judgments in *Kachwala Gems, Jaipur vs. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Jaipur* and *Shri S.M. Hasan, S.T.O. Jhansi & another vs. M/s New Gramphone House, Jhansi* to argue that best judgment assessment requires an intelligent, well-grounded estimate, not speculation. Revenue's contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the respondent (revenue).
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Commercial Tax Revision No. 2 of 2012
Tariq Bilal
...….Revisionist -Versus-
Commissioner, Commercial Tax Uttarakhand
.......Respondent
Present:
Mr. Arvind Vashistha, the learned Senior Advocate assisted by Mr.
Imran Ali Khan, the learned counsel for the revisionist.
Ms. Puja Banga, the learned Brief Holder for the respondent.
Date of hearing : 11.03.2022
Coram: Sri S.K. Mishra, ACJ.
Sri R.C. Khulbe, J. Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties, this Court made the following judgment:
By virtue of filing of this revision, the revisionist, being the owner of Roadways Canteen at Gandhi Road, Dehradun, has assailed the order dated 09.11.2011, passed by the learned Commercial Tax Tribunal, Uttarakhand Division Bench, Dehradun in Second Appeal No. 141/20-2011 (1999-2000 Provincial) confirming the order passed by the Joint Commissioner (Appeal)-II Commercial Tax, Uttarakhand, Mukhyalaya, Dehradun in First Appeal No. 580 of 2003 (1999-2000 Provincial) whereby the first appeal has been dismissed confirming the assessment order dated 28.01.2002 passed by the Assessing Authority.
It is apparent from the records that the business premises of the revisionist was inspected by the Assessing Authority, and, as the revisionist could not produce any document regarding sale and purchase of Page No. 1 of 5
merchandise , food stock etc., he, by using his best judgment fixed turnover as follows:-
Sale of self cooked food, tea, breakfast Rs. 25,00000 5% 1,25,000/- 2. Taxable purchased food grains without forms Rs. 60,000/- 4% 24,000/- 3. Taxable purchases of Kirana, Besan, Refined-oil etc. from unregistered dealers. Rs. 1,00,000/- 5% 5,000/- 4. Purchases of Paneer from unregistered dealer Rs. 25,000/- 7.5% 1,875/-
Taxable turnover of sales & purchases Rs. 32,25,000/-
1,55,875/-
Therefore, he determined the taxable turnover of sales and purchases as Rs. 32,25000/- and the tax liability as Rs. 1,55,875/-. Though, it was not argued by the revisionist at any stage like the first appellate or second appellate stage that the best judgment of the Assessing Authority is based on whims and caprices.
We are inclined to entertain the argument advanced by Mr. Arvind Vashistha, learned Senior Advocate that the best judgment has to be on a reasonable basis and not on the basis of arbitrary use of discretion.
In this connection we take note of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kachwala Gems, Jaipur vs. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Jaipur, (2007) 12 SCC 761, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that it is well settled that in a best judgment assessment there is always a certain degree of guesswork. No doubt the authorities concerned, the Hon’ble Supreme Court further Page No. 2 of 5
held, should try to make an honest and fair estimate of the income even in a best judgment assessment, and should not act totally arbitrarily, but there is necessarily some amount of guesswork involved in a best judgment assessment, and it is the assessee himself who is to blame as he did not submit proper accounts.
In that reported judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that there is no arbitrariness in that case on the part of the Income Tax Authority.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shri S.M. Hasan, S.T.O. Jhansi & another vs. M/s New Gramphone House, Jhansi, (1976) 4 SCC 854, has held that for a best judgment assessment, concerned authorities should not made it on speculative and fanciful grounds but on reasonable guess, since, the best judgment assessment does not negate the exercise of judgment on the part of officer. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that a tax officer, who makes a best judgment assessment should make an intelligent well grounded estimate rather than launch upon pure surmises.
Applying these ratios to the case in hand, the learned Senior Advocate appearing for the revisionist very eloquently placed that the same authority having assessment for the previous year i.e. 1998-1999 has assessed the liability as follows:-
Sale of self cooked food, tea, breakfast Rs. 4,00,000/- 5% 20,000/- 2. Taxable purchases Rs. 40,000/- 4% 1,600/- Page No. 3 of 5
food grains without forms 3. Taxable purchases of Kirana, Besan, Refined-oil etc. from unregistered dealers. Rs. 10,000/- 5% 500/- 4. Sale Milk & curd (Non- taxable) Rs. 50,000/-
Exempt
Gross sales Rs. 5,00,000/-
Taxable Sales Rs. 4,50,000/-
22,100/-
Thus, from the record it is apparent that the Assessing Authority on the basis of best judgment has assessed the taxable sales of the said canteen i.e. Roadways Canteen at Gandhi Road, Dehradun owned and operated by present revisionist to be Rs. 4,50,000/- and the tax imposed is Rs. 22,100/- but it stands to no reason why on the next year i.e. 1999-2000, he came to the conclusion by using the concept of best judgment the taxable turnover of sales and purchase Rs. 32,25,000/-.
Mr. Arvind Vashishtha, the learned Senior Counsel is correct in his submission that the said assessment has been made on the basis of pure conjectures, as the Assessing Authority has not even taken into the total flow of the passengers to the particular terminal to assess what could have been the total sale of the canteen i.e. per day, per month and per year.
In that view of the matter, we are of the opinion that the best assessment concept as applied to the assessment year 1999-2000 is incorrect.
In that view of the matter, we are of the opinion that the revision is meritorious one, and the same is Page No. 4 of 5
allowed. The order dated 09.11.2011 passed by the learned Commercial Tax Tribunal Uttarakhand Division Bench, Dehradun, order dated 21.01.2011 passed by the Joint Commissioner (Appeal)- II Commercial Tax, Uttarakhand, Mukhyalaya, Dehradun and order dated 28.01.2002 passed by the Assessing Authority are hereby set-aside. The matter is remitted back to the Assessing Authority for re-assessment in the line of the observations made by us in the preceding paragraphs.
(Ramesh Chandra Khulbe, J.)
(Sanjaya Kumar Mishra, ACJ.)
PV Page No. 5 of 5
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Distributory Committee vs. The Deputy Assistant Commissioner 1Andhra Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- Smt. T.Leela vs. The State Of Andhra PradeshAndhra Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- Divikolu Subba Rao vs. The State Of Andhra PradeshAndhra Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Delhi Tools vs. The Commissioner CGST & Anr.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Priyanshi Enterprises vs. Principal Commissioner Of CGST Delhi North And Ors.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026