COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. O.N.G.C. AGENT OF WESTERN PETROLEUM
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court found merit in the Revenue's contention. It noted that the ITAT's decision was based on prior rulings that were themselves under challenge before the High Court. Given that the ITAT's order was based on judgments that were sub-judice, the High Court deemed it appropriate and in the interest of justice to allow the application. The Court directed the ITAT to draw a statement of facts and refer the question of law to the High Court for its decision. The principle here is that a tribunal's decision should not be based on precedents that are themselves under judicial review, especially when the same issue is being considered by a higher court.
What were the facts?
This case involves an application by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Revenue) to the High Court under Section 256(2) of the Income Tax Act. The Revenue is challenging the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's (ITAT) order dated March 26, 1998, which refused to refer a question of law to the High Court. The ITAT had dismissed the Revenue's appeals against orders of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) that had set aside assessments made by the Assessing Officer under Section 143(3) read with Section 263. The Revenue argued that the ITAT's reliance on previous decisions in similar cases involving ONGC was incorrect, especially since those decisions were themselves under challenge before the High Court.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) was justified in confirming the order of the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) who set aside the assessment made by the Assessing Officer under Section 143(3)/263? (Question of law and mixed fact and law, turning on Section 256(2) and Section 263). Assessee's contentions: The ITAT held that since the order passed by the Commissioner under Section 263, which led to the reassessment order, was cancelled, the subsequent order by the Assessing Officer could not be sustained. The ITAT relied on its previous decisions in similar cases involving ONGC (e.g., ITA No. 3405/Del/88 and ITA No. 3314/Del/88) where the Revenue's appeals were dismissed. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued that the ITAT's reliance on the cited judgments was flawed because those judgments were not accepted by the department and were themselves sub-judice before the High Court via applications under Section 256(1). Therefore, the present application under Section 256(2) should be allowed.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
COURT NO.2
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARANCHAL AT NAINITAL
INCOME TAX APPLICATION NO.404 OF 2001 (Old No. 152 of 1998)
Commissioner of Income Tax Meerut ……. Applicant
Versus
ONGC as agent of Western Petroleum Services, Dehradun
……. Opposite Party
Shri S.K. Posti, learned counsel for the applicant. Sri J.P. Joshi, learned counsel for the opp. party.
Dated: 21.11.2005
Coram: Hon’ble P.C. Verma, J.
Hon’ble J.C.S. Rawat, J.
This is an application under Section 256(2) of the Income Tax Act by the Revenue Department against the order of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal refusing refer the following question of law as framed in the application to this Court for its decision:-
“Whether on facts and in the circumstances of the case, Hon’ble ITAT was justified in confirming the order of Ld. CIT (A) who set aside the assessment made by the A.O. u/s 143(3)/263?”
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter will be referred to as the Tribunal) vide its order dated 26.03.1998 came to the conclusion that in their opinion, there was no referable question of law arose in the facts and circumstances of the case and accordingly the learned Tribunal declined to refer the same after relying on the judgment in Income Tax Appeal No.3405Del/88 in the case of ONGC as agent of ETPM, ITA No.3314/Del/88 in the case of ONGC as agent of M/S Schlvmberger Far East, whereby on the same facts and under the similar circumstances, the appeals of the
Revenue against orders of the learned CIT (Appeals) was dismissed. The facts of this case are identical as in ITA No.3405Del/88 and others and ITA No. No.3314/Del/88, therefore, the learned Tribunal dismissed the appeals. The application was moved by the Department of Revenue giving the statement of fact for which the reference of question was to be decided by the High Court. The learned Tribunal while deciding the appeal held that since the order passed by the Commissioner under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act on which re-assessement order was passed, stands cancelled, hence the order passed by the Assessing Authority in pursuance of the order passed by the Commissioner under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act cannot be sustained.
Learned counsel for the Revenue Department Sri S.K. Posti contended that the orders relied upon by the learned Tribunal have not been accepted by the department and an application under Section 256(1) of the Income Tax Act was filed and which was allowed by the learned Tribunal and the matter is at present sub-judiced by this Court, hence the present application is liable to be allowed. We find force in the contention of learned counsel for the Revenue Department. Since, the judgment of the Tribunal is sub-judiced in reference by this Court, therefore it would be just and proper and would be in the interest of justice to allow the application and to direct the Appellate Tribunal to draw a statement of facts and refer the question of law to this Court for its decision.
Hence, the application is allowed. The learned Tribunal is directed to refer the above statement of fact and record and above question of law to this Court for its decision.
(J.C.S. Rawat, J.)
(P.C. Verma, J.) Rajeev Dang
More judgments on Section 256(2)
- A.K. Exporters, Kolkata vs D.C.I.T., Circle - 32, KolkataITA 2286/KOL/2025[2013-2014]Status: Disposed10 Dec 2025AY 2013-2014
- A.K. Exporters, Kolkata vs D.C.I.T., Circle - 32, KolkataITA 2285/KOL/2025[2012-2013]Status: Disposed10 Dec 2025AY 2012-2013
- Hotel Ambassador vs The Deputy Commissioner of Income TaxWP(C)/29840/20176 Jul 2023
- Mfar Hotels and Resorts Private Ltd vs The Commissioner of Income TaxITA/17/201910 Oct 2022
- Mfar Hotels and Resorts Private Ltd vs The Commissioner of Income TaxITA/14/201910 Oct 2022
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S. Ashok Panda, Dhenkanal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax , CT And GST Circle, DhenkanalOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahadev Malik vs. Additional Commissioner, BhubaneswarOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Dillip Kumar Sethy vs. The Deputy Commissioner, CGST And Central ExciseOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- K Pushkara Rao vs. The State Of ApAndhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026
- M/S. Jayasundar Engg Works vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Andhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026