COMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. ORISSA COMPUTER ACAD
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that Condition No. 9 of the Notification dated 25.08.1994, which stated that all members of the staff would be treated as fresh entrants and placed at the bottom of the seniority list, related solely to the fixation of seniority and not to the fixation of pay. The Court found that Condition No. 7 of the same notification dealt with the pay scale of absorbed employees, stating that government scales would be permissible to them after the takeover. It clarified that the absorbed staff would be entitled to the government pay scales they were receiving at the time of takeover, thus protecting their pay. Therefore, the argument that Condition No. 9 was applicable for pay scale fixation was rejected as it did not pertain to pay fixation. The Court concluded that the learned Single Judge had rightly allowed the writ petitions for the fixation of pay at the time of the college's takeover. Consequently, the appeals filed by the State were dismissed.
What were the facts?
The appeals by the State of Himachal Pradesh and others challenge the High Court's decision to allow writ petitions filed by respondents who were lecturers in a private college taken over by the State. The respondents claimed entitlement to revised pay scales upon absorption, specifically the selection grade. The State contended that under Condition No. 9 of a notification dated 25.08.1994, absorbed staff were to be treated as fresh entrants, affecting their pay fixation. The respondents argued that Condition No. 7 of the same notification protected their pay scale at the time of absorption. The private college was receiving 95% grant-in-aid and was taken over by the State on 18.06.1997. The case was transferred to the High Court after the abolition of the Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the respondents, lecturers absorbed by the State after the takeover of their private college, are entitled to the revised pay scales, specifically the selection grade, based on their pay at the time of absorption? (Question of law and fact, concerning pay fixation upon absorption). Assessee's Contention (Respondents): The respondents argued that as per Clause 7 of the Notification dated 25.08.1994, their pay scale at the time of absorption was duly protected. They were entitled to the government pay scales applicable to their category after the takeover. Revenue's Contention (Appellants-State): The State contended that the learned Single Judge erred in allowing the writ petitions. They argued that Condition No. 9 of the Notification dated 25.08.1994 stipulated that absorbed staff should be treated as fresh entrants, which precluded them from being granted the disputed pay scales.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA ON THE 30th DAY OF JUNE, 2022 BEFORE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SABINA, & HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATYEN VAIDYA LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.135 of 2012 ALONGWITH CONNECTED MATTERS
Between:-
1.LPA No.135 of 2012:
STATE OF HP THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2 AND OTHERS.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.
HIMACHAL PRADESH UNIVERSITY, SUMMER HILL, SHIMLA, THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
MISS PREM LATA THAPAR, DAUGHTER OF LATE SH. CHANAN RAM, RESIDENT OF
VILLAGE & POST OFFICE AMB, DISTRICT UNA, PRESENTLY LECTURER IN SANSKRIT MAHARANA PARTAP GOVERNMENT COLLEGE AMB, DISTRICT UNA (H.P.). 1-A SMT. KUSUM LATA, WIDOW OF LATE SH. ANKUSH SHARMA, SON OF SH. PARTAP BHANU, VILLAGE BADERA, SUB TESHIL JOL, DISTRICT UNA, H.P., AT PRESENT VILLAGE ADARSHNAGAR AMB, TEHSIL AMB, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
(MR. SUNIL MOHAN GOEL, ADVOCATE)
2.LPA No.268 of 2012:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.
PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT COLLEGE DAULATPUR, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
MANORMA SHARMA, DAUGHTER OF SHRI YUDISTIR SHASHTRI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE AMB, TEHSIL AMB, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
….RESPONDENT
(NONE)
3.LPA No.278 of 2012:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
SHRI K.C. SOOD, SON OF SHRI S.L. SOOD, LECTURER IN ENGLISH, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE AMB, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
SHRI K.D. SHARMA, SON OF SHRI NAGINA RAM, LECTURER IN ECONOMICS, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE UNA, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
SHRI C.J. DOGRA, SON OF SH. BASANT RAM DOGRA, LECTURER IN MATHEMATIC, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE AMB, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
SHRI SUNIL DUTT SHARMA, SON OF SHRI SHYAM DUTT SHARMA, LECTURER IN PHYSICAL EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE AMB, DISTRICT UNA, H.P.
SHRI Y.P. MISHRA, SON OF SHRI JAYOTI SWARUP, LECTURER IN POLITICAL SCIENCE, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE, NADAUN, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
(NONE)
4.LPA No.299 of 2012:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171001.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
RAJ KUMAR KANWAR, SON OF SH. KEHAR SINGH, HOUSE NO.170-A, WARD-1, KRISHNA NAGAR, HAMIRPUR, PRESENTLY WORKING AS ASSISTANT PROFESSOR GOVERNMENT POST GRADUATE DEGREE COLLEGE HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.
SMT. KUSUM KALIA, DAUGHTER OF SHRI RAM NATH, LECTURER IN ENGLISH, GOVERNMENT COLLEGE NALAGARH, DISTRICT SOLAN, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
(BY MR. ANUP RATTAN, ADVOCATE)
5.LPA No.336 of 2012:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171001.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
DR. SUMAN KUMAR, SON OF SH. TARA CHAND, LOHNA PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA (HP), PRESENTLY POSTED AS LECTURER IN GOVERNMENT DEGREE COLLEGE PALAMPUR.
….RESPONDENT
(BY MR. VIKAS RAJPUT, ADVOCATE)
6.LPA No.64 of 2013:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171001.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
SH. GANESH NAND SHARMA, SON OF SH. BRAHMA NAND SHARMA, VILLAGE KANHOL, POST OFFICE DHIEMLA, TEHSIL KANDAGHAT, DISTRICT SOLAN, H.P.
SH. GURBACHAN SINGH THAKUR, SON F SH. SAHIB SINGH, VPO MALAN, TEHSIL &
DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P. 3. SHRI UTTAM CHAND, SON OF SHRI MADAN LAL, VILLAGE LOWER CHAUNDRA, P.O. CHAUNTRA, TEHSIL JOGINDERNAGAR, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.
SHRI DHAN SINGH, SON OF SH. GANUA SINGH, VILLAGE SULTANPUR BILONI, P.O. RAHIMKOT VIA DIBAI, DISTRICT BULANDSHAHAR, U.P.
SH. JAI SINGH, SON OF SHRI KULDEEP SINGH, VILLAGE KHABBAL, P.O. HAR, TEHSIL JAWALI, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SH. CHANDON ROY, SON OF SHRI GOPAL CHANDER ROY, VPO BAIJNATH, TEHSIL BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SH. MILAP CHAND, SON F SHRI WAZIR CHAND, VPO KANDI, TEHSIL PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SH. SANDEEP SOOD, SON OF SH. BANKA RAM SOOD, VPO BAIJNATH, TEHSIL BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI SHRUTI PARKASH, SON OF SH. KHAZANA RAM, VILLAGE JAMTHALA, POST OFFICE LADBHAROL, TEHSIL LADBHAROL, MANDI, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.
SH. RAJESH SOOD, SON OF SH. AMAR NATH SOOD, VPO RAJPUR, TEHSIL PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
HIMACHAL PRADESH UNIVERSITY, SUMMER HILL, SHIMLA, THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR.
….PROFORMA RESPONDENT
(MR. SUNIL MOHAN GOEL, ADVOCATE, FOR R-1 TO R-10)
7.LPA No.65 of 2013:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171001.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
SHRI R.S. RANDHWA, SON OF LATE SH. MAN SNGH RANDHWA, VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
MRS. INDU KAUL, DAUGHTER OF LATE SHRI MAKHAN LAL KAUL, VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI KULDEEP KUMAR SHARMA, SON OF SHRI OM
PARKASH SHARMA, HOUSE NO.153, HOUSING BOARD COLONY, BRINDABAN, PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P. 4. MRS. MEERU RANI, DAUGHTER OF SHRI BASANT LAL SHARMA, WIFE OF KULDIP KUMAR SHARMA, HOUSE NO.153, HOUSING BOARD COLONY, BRINDABAN, PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI SANDEEP MAHAJAN, SON OF SHRI RAVINDER KUMAR GUPTA, GIKA AIMA, PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI ASHOK KUMAR GOSWAMI, SON OF LATE SHRI JAGAN NATH, VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI ARUN KUMAR DIXIT, SON OF SHRI MADAN LAL, VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE GUGGA SALOH, TEHSIL PALAMPUR (VIA MARANDA), DISTT. KANGRA, H.P.
DR. ASHWANI VARSHNEY, SON OF SHRI OM PARKASH GUPTA, “VIMAL PLAZA”, 3/142, MARRIS ROAD, (MR. RENUKA HOSPITAL), ALIGARH-202002 (UP).
SHRI SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA, SON OF SH. MOOL RAJ, SAI NIWAS, KESAR BATH, NEAR CHOWDHARY HOSPITAL PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
DR. VEER PAL SINGH, SON OF SHRI DURGA PAL SINGH,
VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE GADRANA, DISTRICT ALIGARH, U.P. 11. DR. HARISH LAKHANPAL, SON OF SHRI PREM NATH LAKHANPAL, VILLAGE TUND, P.O. BHUGNARA, TEHSIL NURPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
MISS YOGINDRA KAPOOR, DAUGHTER OF SHRI MATHURA PRASAD MAHARAJA PALACE, OPPOSITE DEGREE COLLEGE BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
MISS RENUE KAUL, DAUGHTER OF LATE SHRI MAKHAN LAL KAUL, GILL NIWAS, VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
MRS. SATINDER DOHROO, DAUGHTER OF SH. MULAKH RAJ SHARMA, C/O SHRI SARBJIT K. DOHROO, TARAPARI, DOHROO KUNJ, BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
(BY MR. SUNIL MOHAN GOEL, ADVOCATE, FOR R-1 TO R-14)
HIMACHAL PRADESH UNIVERSITY THRUGH ITS REGISTRAR, SUMMER HILL, SHIMLA-171005 (H.P.).
….PROFORMA RESPONDENT
8.LPA No.69 of 2013:
STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH COMMISSIONER-CUM- SECRETARY (EDUCATION) TO
THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002. 2. DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171001.
….APPELLANTS
(BY MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATE GENERAL WITH MR. ASHWNI K. SHARMA, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
AND
SMT. SHASHI KIRAN ANGIRAS, WIFE OF DR. NH ANGIRAS, RESIDENT OF FRIENDS COLONY, OPPOSITE SPEM STATION, HOLTA, PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
DR. MANJU KAUSHAL, WIFE OF DR. R.K. VERMA, RESIDENT OF SAL-SHIRAM CLOTH HOUSE, MAIN BAZAAR, BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI SHIV BHARDWAJ, SON OF SHRI O.P. BHARDWAJ, RESIDENT OF BEHIND OLD INCOME TAX OFFICE, GHUGGAR, PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
SHRI RAKESH MAHAJAN, SON OF SHRI ROSHAN LAL GUPTA, C/O DEV GENERAL STORE, TIKA AIMA PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANRA, H.P.
SHRI ASHWANI NAYITAL, SON OF SHRI BAL KRISHAN NAYITAL, VILLAGE PANTEHAR, POST OFFICE
PATTI, TEHSIL PALAMPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P. 6. DR. MADAN GILL, SON OF LATE SHRI MEHTAP SINGH GILL, RESIDENT OF GILL NIWAS, NEAR PETRO PUMP, BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P.
DR. RAM CHAND VERMA, SON OF SHRI KANSHI RAM, RESIDENT OF CHAUHAN BUILDING, LAMBE LANE, TUTI KANDI, SHIMLA, AT PRESENT LECTURER GOVERNMENT POST GRADUATE COLLEGE, SOLAN, H.P.
….RESPONDENTS
(BY MR. SUNIL MOHAN GOEL, ADVOCATE)
__________________________________________________
These Letters Patent Appeals coming on for hearing this day, Hon’ble Mrs. Justice Sabina, delivered the following:
J U D G M E N T
Vide this order, above mentioned appeals would be disposed of, as they involve common issue/controversy. 2.
Appellants-State has filed the appeals challenging the orders passed by the learned Single Judge, whereby the writ petitions filed by the respondents were allowed.
Facts are stated from LPA No.135 of 2012, titled State of Himachal Pradesh & Others versus Prem Lata Thapar. 4.
Case of the respondent, in brief, was that the respondent was working as a Lecturer in privately managed National College Amb, since 4th September, 1974. The College was taken over by the Government of Himachal Pradesh vide Notification dated 27.06.1997 w.e.f. 18.06.1997. Twenty posts of various categories were created by Commission-cum- Secretary (Education) at the time of absorption of the staff and out of them, eleven posts were of Lecturers in the scale of Rs.2200-4000. Respondent was absorbed against one of the posts meant for Lecturer. Vide Notification dated 18.01.1999, the State had protected the pay of the Lecturers as on 27.06.1997. Respondent was getting pay scale of Rs.3700- 5700 at the time of her absorption and her basic pay scale which had been protected by the State was Rs.4450/-. However, at the time of revision of pay scales w.e.f. 01.01.1996, the Lecturers (College Cadre) were given the scale of Rs.8000-275-13500 with selection grade of Rs.12000-420- 18000. Since the respondent was getting the selection grade of Rs.3700-5700 on 18.06.1997, she was to be paid salary in the
revised scale (selection grade of Rs.12000-420-18000). However, the appellants-State had declined to give the said pay scale and consequently, respondent approached the erstwhile Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal at Shimla for redressal of her grievance. 5.
Appellants-State, in its reply, averred that the respondent had been given senior scale of Rs.3000-5000 w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and selection grade of Rs.3700-5700 w.e.f. 04.09.1990 and her pay was fixed at Rs.3,000/- and 3,700/-, respectively, as the erstwhile National College Amb, prior to its being taken over by the State, was under 95% Grant-in-Aid Scheme. The services of the respondent were taken over vide Notification dated 23.03.1998 w.e.f. 18.06.1997 in the pay scale of Rs.2200-4000 and she was drawing basic pay of Rs.4,450/- in the privately managed college prior to its being taken over by the State. The pay of the respondent was protected at Rs.4000+450 w.e.f. 27.06.1997 vide Notification dated 18.01.1999, subject to the condition that the pay of the Lecture may be protected in initial scale of Rs.2200-4000 and the portion of salary exceeding Rs.4000/- be treated as personal pay. Therefore, respondent was not entitled for senior selection scale of Rs.10000-15200 and 12000-18300.
After the abolition of the H.P. State Administrative Tribunal, the case was transferred to this Court. 7.
Learned Single Judge, vide impugned order, allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent. Hence, the Letters Patent Appeal by the State. 8.
Mr. Ashok Sharma, learned Advocate General, assisted by Mr. Ashwani K. Sharma, learned Additional Advocate General, has submitted that the learned Single Judge has erred in allowing the writ petitions. In fact, the respondents could not be granted the pay scale in dispute in view of Condition No.9 of Notification dated 25.08.1994. As per the said condition, the staff after absorption was to be treated as fresh entrant. 9.
Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, have opposed the appeals and have submitted that as per Clause 7 of Notification dated 25.08.1994, the pay scale drawn by the respondents at the time of absorption had been duly protected. 10.
Admittedly, in the present case, the respondents were working as Lecturers with a private College. The said College was getting 95% Grant-in-Aid. The private College was
taken over by the State w.e.f. 18.06.1997. Relevant Conditions No.7 & 9 of Notification dated 25.08.1994, read as under:- “(7) The services of only qualified teaching and non-teaching staff appointed one year earlier who fulfill, prescribed departmental recruitment and promotion rule conditions, prevalent at the time of taking over will be considered for taking over subject to the approval of the State Public Service Commission or Departmental Screening Committee from the date of taking over. The services of the Principal will be taken over only as Senior most lecturer of the college concerned subject to the above mentioned proviso. The Government scales in respect of the respective categories shall be permissible to them after the take over. (8) xxx
xxx
xxx (9) All members (including principal) of the staff will be treated as fresh entrants and they will be placed at the bottom of the seniority list, maintained in respect of Government employees in their respective cadre from the date of taking over, provided, in the case of Ministerial staff.”
11.
A perusal of the above conditions reveal that so far as Condition No.9 is concerned, the same relates to fixation of
seniority. As per the said condition, the absorbed staff of the private College would be treated as fresh entrant and would be placed at the bottom of seniority list maintained in respect of Government employees in their respective cadre. So far as Condition No.9 is concerned, the same does not refer to fixation of pay of the absorbed employees. 12.
Condition No.7 deals with the pay scale of the absorbed employees. A perusal of Condition No.7, reproduced above, shows that the Government scales in respect of the respective categories of the absorbed employees, shall be permissible to them after the take over. It has been clarified that the staff to be taken over in College, would be entitled to Government pay scales which the said staff had been getting at the time of take over. This shows that vide Condition No.7, the pay of the absorbed employees had been duly protected. Hence, the argument raised by the learned Advocate General to the effect that Condition No.9 was applicable for fixation of pay scale, is without any force as the Condition No.9 does not relate to pay fixation but it relates to fixation of seniority. Rather, it is Condition No.7 which deals with fixation of pay of the absorbed employees.
13.
In these circumstances, the learned Single Judge had rightly allowed the writ petitions filed by the respondents for fixation of their pay at the time of taking over of the College. No ground for interference is made out. 14.
Accordingly, all the appeals are dismissed. 15.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
( Sabina )
Judge
( Satyen Vaidya )
June 30, 2022
Judge (Yashwant)
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Basant Ballabh Punetha vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Satyavan vs. Commissioner Central Goods And Services Tax CommissionerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Deepak Kumar Daiya vs. State Of West Bengal And Ors.Calcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Pawan Kumar Rajgaria vs. State Of West BengalCalcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Mohammed Fazil vs. State Of ChhattisgarhChhattisgarh · 4 Nov 2026