PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME vs. BAITARANI GRAMYA BANK

PDF · subscribers
ITA/4/2018HC OrissaODHC01009554201801 December 2018Bench: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE K.R.MOHAPATRA9 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that a cross-objection is not maintainable in an appeal filed under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court relied on the Division Bench judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Jyoti Kumari vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax. The reasoning was that while Order 41 of the CPC, including Rule 22 (cross-objections), is applicable to first appeals (like those under Section 39 of the Arbitration Act), it is not automatically applicable to second appeals under Section 100 of the CPC. This is further reinforced by Order 42 read with Section 108 of the CPC. The Court noted that Section 260A of the Income Tax Act is more comparable to a second appeal under Section 100 CPC than a first appeal. Therefore, the principle that a cross-objection is not tenable in a second appeal under Section 100 CPC is even more applicable to an appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act. The Court acknowledged the principle of natural justice, which requires an opportunity to defend a benefit already obtained, but concluded that this does not override the statutory bar on maintainability. The cross-objection was dismissed as not maintainable. However, the main appeal (RSA No. 80/2018) was to be decided on merits.

What were the facts?

The case involves a Cross Objection filed by Smt. Kamala and others (Cross Objectors) against Kunha Malethaya (Respondent) in Regular Second Appeal (RSA) No. 80 of 2018. The Cross Objection was filed under Order 41 Rule 22 of the CPC. The appeal before the High Court was filed under Section 100 of the CPC, challenging a judgment and decree dated April 3, 2017, passed by the Principal District Judge, D.K. Mangaluru. This decree had allowed an appeal and set aside a judgment and decree dated November 30, 2015, passed in O.S. No. 32/2006 by the Prl. Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Bantwal, D.K. The core issue before the High Court was the maintainability of the cross-objection in a second appeal.

What were the issues?

1. Whether a cross-objection is maintainable in an appeal filed under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC)? Assessee (Cross Objectors) Contention: The Cross Objectors, relying on a judgment from the High Court of Rajasthan in Vijay Prakash vs. JankiBai, argued that a cross-objection is maintainable in a second appeal. Revenue (Respondent) Contention: The Respondent, relying on a Division Bench judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Jyoti Kumari vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, argued that a cross-objection is not maintainable in an appeal filed under Section 260(A) of the Income Tax Act, which is comparable to a second appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. The judgment cited by the respondent also discussed the maintainability of cross-objections in appeals under Section 39 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, and contrasted it with appeals under Section 100 of the CPC and Section 260A of the Income Tax Act.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 100,Section 260A,Section 108

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HC-KAR IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V SRISHANANDA RSA CROSS OBJECTION NO. 4 OF 2018 (SP) BETWEEN:

1.

SMT. KAMALA W/O. LATE. DEVU MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS

2.

HARISH S/O. LATE. DEVU MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS

3.

RUKMANYA MALEKUDIYA S/O. LATE. DEVU MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS

ALL ARE R/AT HERAJE HOUSE, KUNTHOOR VILLAGE, PUTTUR TALUK, D.K. DISTRICT - 574 261

4.

NEELAMMA W/O. GANAPA MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS R/AT MADHINA MANE, KOKKADA VILLAGE, BELTHANGADY TALUK, D.K. DISTRICT - 574 214

Digitally signed by R MANJUNATHA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HC-KAR

5.

PADMAVATHI W/O. JAYANTHA MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS R/AT SHISHILA COLONY HOUSE, SHISHILA VILLAGE AND POST, BELTHANGADY TALUK, D.K. DISTRICT PIN - 574 214

6.

SMT. DEJAMMA W/O. KRISHNA MALEKUDIYA, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS R/AT KAKKINJE VILLAGE AND POST, BELTHANGADY TALUK D.K. DISTRICT PIN - 574 214 …CROSS OBJECTORS (BY SRI. RAVISHANKAR SHASTRY G., ADVOCATE) AND:

KUNHA MALETHAYA S/O. DEVU MALETHAYA, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS R/AT HOSTHOTA, KANYANA VILLAGE AND POST BANTWAL TALUK D.K. DISRICT - 574 279 …RESPONDENT (BY SMT. PRATISHTA C.B., ADVOCATE FOR SRI. RUPA RON, ADVOCATE)

THIS RSA.CROB IN RSA 80/2018 FILED UNDER ORDER 41 RULE 22 OF CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DTD 03.04.2017 PASSED IN RA.NO.4/2016 ON THE FILE OF HC-KAR THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT JUDGE, D.K. MANGALURU, ALLOWING THE APPEAL AND SETTING ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DTD 30.11.2015 PASSED IN O.S.NO.32/2006 ON THE FILE OF THE PRL.SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, BANTWAL, D.K.

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V SRISHANANDA

ORAL ORDER

1.

Heard Sri. Ravishankar Shastry G., learned counsel for the appellants and Ms. Pratishta for Smt. Rupa Ron, learned counsel for the respondents. 2. This court has observed that whether a cross- objection would be maintainable in a appeal filed under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure by one of the parties. 3. In that regard, Sri. Ravishankar Shastry would place reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of HC-KAR Rajasthan in the case of Vijay Prakash versus JankiBai in SA No.72 of 1986, High Court of Madhya Pradesh, and submits that cross-objection is maintainable. 4. In response, Ms. Prathista, learned counsel for the respondents places reliance on the division bench judgment of this Court reported in 2010 SCC Online Karnataka 5147 in the case of Jyoti Kumari vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax. 5. This court has considered the relevant legal and factual aspects in both the cases. While Madhya Pradesh High Court was dealing with the Civil Appeal, Division Bench of this Court was dealing with an appeal filed under Section 260(A) of the Income Tax Act and has observed in paragraphs No.54 to 56 as under : 54. Though this judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of B. Subba Reddy cited supra had come in for examination again in the later judgment Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. International Security and Intelligence Agency Ltd. reported in (2004) 3 SCC 250 on which Sri Seshachala has placed reliance, we find that this HC-KAR judgment has only reiterated with regard to the nature of right for claiming a right of appeal as observed in para. 14, which is as under:

"14. Right of appeal is creature of statute. There is no inherent right of appeal. No appeal can be filed, heard or determined on merits unless the statute confers right on the appellant and power on the court to do so. Section 39 of the Act confers right to file appeal, in so far as the orders passed under this Act are concerned, only against such of the orders as fall within one or other of the descriptions given in clauses (i) to (vi) of sub-section (1) of section 39. Parliament has taken care to specifically exclude any other appeal being filed, against any order passed under the Act but not covered by clauses (i) to (vi) abovesaid, by inserting the expression `and from no others' in the text of sub-section (1). Clause (a) of section 41 extends applicability of all the provisions contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to (i)all proceedings before the court under the Act, and (ii) to all the appeals, under the Act. However, the applicability of such of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure shall be excluded as may be inconsistent with the provisions of the Act and/or of rules made thereunder. A bare reading of these provisions shows that in all the appeals filed under section 39, the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, would be applicable. This would include the applicability of Order 41 including the right to take any cross- HC-KAR objection under rule 22 thereof to appeals under section 39 of the Act."

and, therefore, having regard to the language of section 39 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, the Supreme Court ruled that section 39 being in the

nature of first appeal and with the provisions of Order 41 having been made applicable rule 22 of Order 41 was also attracted and applicable to an appeal under section 39 of the Act. However, in the present situation, we find such is not the case in so far as sub-section (7) of section 260A of the Act is concerned for the reason that the provisions of section 260A of the Act are more comparable to an appeal under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure rather an appeal under section 96 and even hearing in so far as the second appeal is concerned not all provisions of Order 41 are made automatically applicable to an appeal under section 100 both in terms of Order 42 read with section 108 of the Code of Civil Procedure and as the appeal being a creature of a statute, a cross-objection in terms of rule 22 being barred with an appeal until and unless there is express provision on settling the legal provisions one cannot hold that the implication or a right of cross- objection should be read into either the provisions of Order 42 read with sections 100 and 108 of the Code of Civil Procedure or under the provisions of sub - section (7) of section 260A of the Income-tax Act.

HC-KAR

55.

In so far as the Income-tax Act is concerned we say it is fortiori so for the reason that even while adopting the procedure as indicated in the Code of Civil Procedure for the purpose of disposal of a cross-objection the procedure is again made applicable in so far as, as far as may be, apply in the case of appeals under section 260A(1) and not in its entirety.

56.

As we have discussed above, if the cross-objection is not even tenable in a second appeal under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, it is more so in an appeal under section 260A of the Act. It is for this reason we reject the submission of Sri Shankar, learned counsel for the assessee, that the right of cross-appeal or the right to defend an order of the Tribunal to the extent it is in favour of the respondents and which is appealed against before this court in this appeal is available to the assessee on all grounds which may be otherwise available to either answer against the assessee in appeal by the Tribunal. However, we are aware that the principles of natural justice even otherwise, would require that if a person who has obtained some benefit or relief is to be deprived of that benefit or relief he should have an opportunity to defend that possession. The minimum that is expected in law and procedure is that a person is given an opportunity before being deprived of any benefit or relief which a person had already obtained.

HC-KAR

6.

Division Bench of this Court was of the considered opinion that a cross objection filed in an appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not maintainable. 7. As such, following Order: ORDER

(i) Cross-objection filed Smt. Kamala and others, who are the respondents in RSA No.80/2018, is hereby dismissed as not maintainable. (ii) However, the appeal in R.S.A. No.80/2018 shall be decided on merits along with R.S.A. No.1251/2018 and any other relief available to the present cross-objectors, it is kept open to be urged in accordance with law. (iii) Copy of this Order be made available to the R.S.A. Scrutiny/Pending branch to raise HC-KAR necessary objections in respect of pending cross- objections and intended cross-objections in future.

Sd/- (V SRISHANANDA) JUDGE

SNC List No.: 1 Sl No.: 0

More judgments on Section 100

All 31 judgments and leading authorities on Section 100 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →