COMMNR. INCOME TAX vs. YUGAL TRANSPORT CO.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/37/2003HC OrissaODHC01000550200314 August 2018Bench: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE I.MAHANTY121 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the partnership was indeed dissolved, as evidenced by the admission and signature of K.N. Seshadri Iyengar on Ex.D-1, his reply to Subramanya Sastry, the statement of accounts, and his sworn testimony in a previous suit (O.S.No.186/56). The court found that Seshadri Iyengar's conduct, including withholding properties that fell to his share under Ex.P-1 and not approaching the court with clean hands, weakened his defense. The court also found that the allotment of properties during the dissolution of partnership was not a regular transfer requiring registration, and any deficit stamp duty had been made good. The compromise between the legal representatives of the plaintiff and defendant No.2 was accepted as it was based on facts and in accordance with law, without affecting Seshadri Iyengar's vested rights. The trial court's judgment and decree in both suits were found to be free from lapses, irregularities, or illegalities. The appeals were dismissed.

What were the facts?

These appeals arise from two original suits, O.S.No.284/1980 and O.S.No.601/1980, filed in the City Civil Court, Bangalore. O.S.No.284/1980 was filed by D. Subramanya Sastry against K.N. Seshadri Iyengar and K. Keshavachar, seeking declaration, injunction, and partition. O.S.No.601/1980 was filed by K.N. Seshadri Iyengar and K. Keshavachar against D. Subramanya Sastry, also concerning partnership dissolution and partition. The trial court decreed O.S.No.284/1980 and partly decreed O.S.No.601/1980, ordering division of agricultural land (item No.6) and rendition of accounts. The appeals challenge the judgment and decree dated July 31, 2002, passed by the XXXI Addl. City Civil Judge, Bangalore.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the partnership between the parties stood dissolved, and if so, whether the allotment of properties under the dissolution deed (Ex.P-1) was valid and required registration. The assessee (K.N. Seshadri Iyengar) contended that the partnership was not dissolved and needed to be effected afresh, and that the allotment of properties was not a regular transfer. The revenue (D. Subramanya Sastry) argued that the dissolution had already taken place and the allotment was a consequence thereof. 2. Whether the trial court correctly handled the partition of properties, particularly item No.6, and the rendition of accounts. The assessee argued that the suit was for dissolution and rendition of accounts, and that no schedule properties were mentioned in O.S.No.601/80. The revenue contended that O.S.No.284/80 was for declaration and injunction, not dissolution, and that dissolution was already over. 3. Whether the compromise between the legal representatives of the plaintiff and defendant No.2 in O.S.No.284/1980 was valid. The assessee's contention on this point is not explicitly recorded, but the trial court accepted the compromise.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 54 of CPC

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 10TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2021 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N.K.SUDHINDRARAO R.F.A.No.37/2003 C/W R.F.A.No.84/2003

IN R.F.A.No.37/2003:

BETWEEN:

1.

SRI. K. N. SESHADRI IYENGAR, S/O LATE K.P.S.NARAYANA IYENGAR, R/AT No.26, H.B.SAMAJ ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE – 560 027.

SINCE DEAD BY LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES

i). SRI. K. S. RAM PRASAD, S/O K. S. SESHADRI IYENGAR, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, No.26, H.B.SAMAJ ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE-560 004.

ii) SMT. K.S.VATHSALA, W/O DR.V.S.ACHAR, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, No.45, 12TH CROSS, WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE- 560 027.

iii) SMT. K. S. VASUDHA, W/O T.K. SRINIVASAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, No.43, 12TH CROSS, WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE-560 027.

...APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. JAYAVITTALA RAO KOLAR, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. C VINAY SWAMY, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1.

SRI. D. SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, S/O LATE D. AHOBALA SASTRY, R/AT No.2708, 1st MAIN, VANI VILAS MOHALLA, MYSORE-2. SINCE DEAD BY LRs.

i) SMT. S.PARVATHAMMA, W/O AHOBALA SASTRY, AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS, No.2708, 1st MAIN ROAD, VANI VILAS MOHALLA, MYSORE-2

ii) SRI. D .S. RAMAMURTHY, S/O D. S. SUBRAMANYA SASTRY,

SINCE DEAD BY LRs.

a) SMT. SHAMALA MURTHY, W/O D.S.RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS.

b) SRI. HARISH R DEVANGUNDI, S/O D.S.RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.

c) SMT. JYOTHI MURTHY, D/O D.S.RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,

ALL ARE RESIDING AT No.2708, 1ST MAIN ROAD, V.V.MOHALLA, MYSORE-2

iii) SRI. D. S. NARAHARI, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, No.2708, V.V.MOHALLA, MYSORE-2.

iv) DR. BHASKAR S DEVANAGONDI, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, No.309, OAKLAND DRIVE, ESSEXWILLE, MI 48732, U.S.A.

v) SRI. SRIDHAR S DEVANAGONDI, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, No.2886, ROGARIO COURT, SANJOSE, CA 95132, U.S.A.

vi) SRI. SHANKAR D SASTRY, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY No.2886, ROGARIO COURT SANJOSE, CA 95132, U.S.A.

vii) SMT. LEELA VENKATRATHNAM W/O VENKATRATHNAM, No.C7, IICT CAMPUS, TARANAKA, HYDERABAD-7.

viii) SMT. KAMALA THYAGARAJA, W/O THYAGARAJA, No.1-11-252/11 "GRUHA LAKSHMI" MOTILAL NAGAR, BEGUMPET P.O. HYDERABAD-16.

ix) SMT. RATNA PHANIRAJ, W/O PHANIRAJ, No.1, 5TH CROSS, JAYAMAHAL, NANDIDURGA ROAD, BANGALORE- 560 046.

2.

SRI. K. KESHAVACHAR, S/O RAMASWAMY IYENGAR, No.2709, 1ST MAIN ROAD, VANIVILAS MOHALLA, MYSORE.

SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS

i) SMT. INDIRA SRINIVAS, D/O K.KESHAVACHAR, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,

ii) SMT. LALITHA KRISHNAMACHAR,

SINCE DEAD BY HER LR's.

a) SRI. T.S.KRISHNAMACHAR, S/O LATE.T.SRINIVASACHAR, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,

b) DR. K. HARISH, S/O T.S.KRISHNAMACHAR, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS.

BOTH ARE R/AT No.2866, 13TH MAIN, 'E' BLOCK, SUBRAMANYA NAGAR, RAJAJINAGAR 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE- 560 021.

iii) SMT. MAYURA KRISHNAMURTHY, W/O SRI K.G.KRISHNA MURTHY, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/AT C/O DR.BHAGWAN MURTHY

No.B-5-2, REGIONAL ENGINEERING COLLEGE CAMPUS, WARANGAL, ANDHRA PRADESH.

iv) SMT. MANJULA RAMASWAMY W/O T.R.RANGASWAMY, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS, R/AT No.F-2, SUKASHAYA, No.118, PAMPAMAHAKAVI ROAD, SHANKARPURAM, BANGALORE - 560 004.

v) SMT.VASUMATHI PADMANABHAN, W/O SRI C.G.A.PADMANABHAN, AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, R/AT No.1270, 1ST BLOCK, 4TH MAIN, BEL L/O, VIDYARANYAPURA, BANGALORE - 560 097.

vi) SMT. HARINI NARAYAN, W/O SRI T.S.NARAYAN, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, R/AT No.2709, 1ST MAIN ROAD, VANIVILASPURAM, MYSORE-570 002.

3.

SRI. K. S. SRIDHRAN, S/O LATE SEDHADRI IYENGAR, No.16, 17TH MAIN, 4TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE- 560 011.

SINCE DEAD BY HIS LEGAL REPESENTATIVES

a) SMT. RAMAMANI SRIDHARAN, W/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.

b) SRI. K. S. BADRINATH,

S/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS.

c) SRI.K. S. SRIKANTH, S/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS.

ALL ARE RESIDING AT No.16, 17TH MAIN, 4TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE- 560 011.

4.

SMT. K. S. VANI, W/O DR K R SRIDHARAN, No.510, TYPE 5, IIT, KANPUR-208 016.

SINCE DEAD BY HER LR'S

a) DR.M.R.SREEDHARAN, H/O LATE K.S.VANI, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,

b) MASTER VALLABH SREEDHARAN, S/O LATE K.S.VANI, AGED ABOUT 16 YEARS, REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND NATURAL GUARDIAN DR.M.R.SREEDHARAN,

BOTH ARE R/AT No.510, TYPE 5 QUARTERS, IIT, KANPUR-208 016.

...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI H.R. ANANTHAKRISHNA MURTHY, ADVOCATE FOR R1(4-6) & R1(9), R2(1), R2(2)(a & b) AND R2(3-6). SRI G S NATARAJAN, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1(3); R1(1), R1(2)(a), R1(2 (b), R1(2(c)), R-1(7), R-1(8), R3(a), R-3(b), R-3(c), R4(a) R-4 (b) ARE SERVED)

THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 31.7.2002 PASSED IN O.S.No.284/1980 ON THE FILE OF THE XXXI ADDL. CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BANGALORE, DECREEING THE SUIT FOR DECLARATION, PERMANENT INJUNCTION AND PARTITION.

IN R.F.A.No.84/2003:

BETWEEN:

1.

SRI. K. N. SESHADRI IYENGAR, S/O LATE K.P.S.NARAYANA IYENGAR, SINCE DEAD BY LRs.

i) SMT. K.S.VATHSALA, W/O DR.V.S ACHAR, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, No.45, 12TH CROSS, WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE- 560 027.

ii) SMT. K. S. SUDHA, W/O P.K. SRINIVASAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, No.8-A, NANDA DEVI ANUSHAKTHI NAGAR B A R C, BOMBAY.

iii) SRI. K. S. RAM PRASAD, S/O K. S. SESHADRI IYENGAR, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, No.26, H.B.SAMAJ ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE-560 004.

...APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. JAYAVITTALA RAO KOLAR, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI T S MAHABALESHWARA, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1.

SRI. D. SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, S/O LATE D. AHOBALA SASTRY, R/AT No.2708, 1ST MAIN, VANI VILAS MOHALLA, MYSORE-2.

SINCE DEAD BY L Rs.

i) SMT. S.PARVATHAMMA, W/O AHOBALA SASTRY AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS No.2708, 1ST MAIN ROAD VANI VILAS MOHALLA MYSORE-2.

ii) SRI D .S. RAMAMURTHY, S/O D. S. SUBRAMANYA SASTRY,

SINCE DEAD BY L Rs.

a) SMT.SHAMALA MURTHY, W/O D.S.RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS.

b) SRI. HARISH R DEVANGUNDI, S/O D.S RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.

c) SMT. JYOTHI MURTHY, D/O D.S. RAMAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS.

ALL ARE RESIDING AT No.2708, 1ST MAIN ROAD, V.V.MOHALLA, MYSORE-2.

iii) SRI. D. S. NARAHARI,

S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, No.2708, 1ST MAIN ROAD, V.V.MOHALLA, MYSORE-2.

iv) DR. BHASKAR S DEVANAGONDI, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, MAJOR, No.309, OAKLAND DRIVE, ESSEXWILLE, MI 48732, U.S.A.

v) SRI. SRIDHAR S. DEVANAGONDI, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, MAJOR, No.2886, ROGARIO COURT, SANJOSE, CA 95132, U.S.A.

vi) SRI SHANKAR D. SASTRY, S/O D.SUBRAMANYA SASTRY, MAJOR, No.2886, ROGARIO COURT, SANJOSE, CA 95132, U.S.A.

vii) SMT. LEELA VENKATRATHNAM, W/O VENKATRATHNAM, MAJOR, No.C7, IICT CAMPUS, TARANAKA, HYDERABAD-7.

viii) SMT. KAMALA THYAGARAJA, W/O THYAGARAJA, MAJOR, No.1-11-252/1 "GRUHA LAKSHMI" MOTILAL NAGAR, BEGUMPET P.O. HYDERABAD - 560 016.

ix) SMT. RATNA PHANIRAJ, W/O PHANIRAJ, MAJOR, No.1, 5TH CROSS, JAYAMAHAL, NANDIDURGA ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 046.

2.

SRI. K. KESHAVACHAR, S/O RAMASWAMY IYENGAR,

No.2709, 1ST MAIN ROAD, VANIVILAS MOHALLA, MYSORE.

SINCE DEAD BY HIS L.Rs.

i) SMT. INDIRA SRINIVAS, D/O K. KESHAVACHAR, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS.

ii) SMT. LALITHA KRISHNAMACHAR,

AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS.

SINCE DEAD BY HER L Rs.

a) SRI. T.S.KRISHNAMACHAR, S/O LATE T.SRINIVASACHAR, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS.

b) DR. K. HARISH, S/O T.S.KRISHNAMACHAR, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS.

BOTH ARE RESIDING AT No.2866, 13TH MAIN, 'E' BLOCK, SUBRAMANYA NAGAR, RAJAJINAGAR 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE - 560 021.

iii) SMT. MAYURA KRISHNAMURTHY, W/O K.G.KRISHNA MURTHY, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/AT C/O DR.BHAGWAN MURTHY, NO.B-5-2, REGIONAL ENGINEERING COLLEGE CAMPUS, WARANGAL, ANDHRAPRADESH.

iv) SMT. MANJULA RAMASWAMY W/O T.R.RANGASWAMY, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,

R/AT No.F-2, SUKASHAYA, No.118, PAMPAMAHAKAVI ROAD, SHANKARPURAM, BANGALORE-4.

v) SMT.VASUMATHI PADMANABH, W/O C.G.A.PADMANABHAN, AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, R/AT No.1270, 1ST BLOCK, 4TH MAIN, BEL L/O, VIDYARANYAPURA, BANGALORE-97.

vi) SMT. HARINI NARAYAN, W/O T.S.NARAYAN, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, R/AT No.2709, 1ST MAIN ROAD, VANIVILASPURAM, MYSORE-570 002.

3.

SRI. K. S. SRIDHRAN, S/O LATE SESHADRI IYENGAR, No.16, 17TH MAIN, 4TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE- 560 011.

SINCE DEAD BY HIS L.Rs.

a) SMT. RAMAMANI SRIDHARAN, W/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.

b) SRI. K. S. BADRINATH, S/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS.

c) SRI.K. S. SRIKANTH, S/O LATE K.S.SRIDHARAN, AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS,

ALL ARE RESIDING AT No.16, 17TH MAIN,

4TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-11.

4.

SMT.K S VANI W/O DR. K R SRIDHARAN,

SINCE DEAD BY HER L.Rs.

a) DR.M.R.SREEDHARAN, H/O LATE K.S.VANI, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,

b) MASTER VALLABH SREEDHARAN, S/O LATE K.S.VANI, AGED ABOUT 16 YEARS, REP. BY HIS FATHER AND NATURAL GUARDIAN DR.M.R.SREEDHARAN.

BOTH ARE RESIDING AT No.510, TYPE 5 QUARTERS, IIT KANPUR-208 016.

NOTE: AS. L.R’S OF K.S.SRISHARAN 2ND L.R’S OF SHESHADRI IYENGAR AND L.R’S SMT. K.S.VANI,THE IVTH L.R’S OF K.N.SESHADRI IYENGAR HAVE NO SUBSISTING INTEREST IN THE SUIT SCHEDULE PROPERTIES AND AS THEY HAVE NOT JOINED THE APPELLANTS IN FILING THE APPEAL THEY HAVE BEEN MADE PARTY RESPONDENTS..AWON. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. H.R. ANANTHA KRISHNAMURTHY, ADVOCATE FOR C/R-1, SRI. G.S. NATARAJAN, ADVOCATE FOR LRs OF R-2)

THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 31.7.2002 PASSED IN O.S.No.601/1980 ON THE FILE OF THE XXXI

ADDL. CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BANGALORE, DECREEING THE SUIT FOR DISSOLUTION OF PARTNERSHIP.

THESE APPEALS BEING HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT COMING ON FOR DICTATION THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

These are the two appeals directed against Judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.284/1980 and O.S.No.601/1980 dated 31.7.2002 by the learned XXXI Additional City Civil Judge, Bengaluru. Interconnection between the suits and appeals is mentioned in the following table: Sl.No. RFA NO. O.S.NO. RESULT 1. 37/2003 Filed by K.N.Seshadri Iyengar- defendant No.1 284/1980 (old No.13/1972) Filed on 10.01.1972 by D.Subramanya Sastry Suit decreed 2. 84/2003 Filed by K.N.Seshadri Iyengar- plaintiff 601/1980 (earlier No.29/73 and 309/1974) Filed on 17.02.1973 by K.N.Seshadri Iyengar Suit partly decreed

2.

In order to avoid confusion, it is also necessary to mention parties to the original suit as under: In O.S.No.284/1980: Plaintiff D.Subramanya Shastry S/o Late D.Ahobala Shastry, dead and hence represented by legal representatives.

Defendant No.1 Sri.K.N.Seshadri Iyengar son of late K.P.S. Narayan Iyengar, defendant No.2- Sri.Keshavachar son of late K.Ramamurthy Iyengar, since both the parties are dead they are represented by their legal representatives.

In O.S.No.601/1980: Plaintiff No.1-Sri.K.N.Seshadri Iyengar son of late K.P.S. Narayan Iyengar, Plaintiff No.2- Sri.Keshavachar son of late K.Ramamurthy Iyengar, dead represented by legal representatives. Defendant- Sri. D.Subramanya Shastry S/o. Late D.Ahobala Shastry, since dead represented by legal representatives.

3.

In both the cases learned Trial Judge disposed of the matter through a common Judgment dated 31.7.2002.

4.

In order to avoid confusion, repetition and overlapping, parties are addressed in accordance with their status and rankings as stood by them before the Trial Court. Further considering the similar nature of cases, in majority of places reference of parties is made with reference to first suit filed by D.Subramanya Shastry in O.S.No.284/1980 (O.S.No.13/1972).

5.

Original Suit in O.S.No.284/1980, the relief sought by the plaintiff and the schedule properties are as under:

Relief sought in O.S.No.284/80

"a. for declaring that the plaintiff is the owner of items 1 to 5 of the plaint schedule and that the

defendants have no manner of right, title or interest in any of the said items 1 to 5.

b. for permanent injunction restraining the first defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession and enjoyment of the items 4 and 5 of the plaint schedule;

c. for partition of plaintiff's 1/3rd share in item No.6 of the plaint schedule;

d. for a direction to the second defendant who is in management of item No.6 of plaint schedule to render account of the income derived from item No.6.

e. for direction to the second defendant to deliver the plaintiff's share in item No.6.

f. for costs and such other reliefs, to which plaintiff may be found entitled."

Schedule properties: "1. Premises bearing No.2708, situate in first Main Road, Vani Vilas Mohalla, Mysore-2, Bounded as follows:-

East by: House No.2707, belonging to the 1st Defendant

West by: House No.bearing No.2709 belonging to the 2nd Defendant.

North by: Conservancy Lane.

South by: First Main Road.

2.

Premises bearing No.2836, situated in 11th cross, built on site No.60, Vani Vilas Mohalla, Mysore, bounded as follows:-

East by : Conservancy Lane West by : 11th Cross Road North by : Gururajachar's House South by : Jagadeeshwaraswami's House.

3.

Vacant site bearing No.6. In this site a portion to the west acquired by the Mysore City Improvement trust Board for the formation of a road. In lieu of the acquisition made in this site, another site to the west of the road so formed has been granted to the plaintiff and this is now re-alignment of site No.6 was made. The site allotted to the west of the Road is site No.107 and there remaining portion of site No.6, after acquisition, has been assigned site No.47.

Boundaries of realiged Site No.47.

East by : Bannayantap Road West by : Newly formed service Road North by : by Site No.5 South by : Private property.

Boundaries of realigned Site No.107:

East by : Service Road West by : Conservancy Lane & private

Property North by : Private Property South by : Private Property.

4.

Vacant Site No.(Municipal) 214 (Trust Board No.215). Situate in 11th Cross, Wilson Gardens, Bangalore city.

Bounded as follows:-

East by : Site No.215 belonging to the Plaintiff (this bears Trust board No.216). West by : Site No.213 (Trust Board

No.214) belonging to the first

defendant. North by : 11th Cross Road South by : Private Property.

5.

Vacant site bearing Municipal No.215(Trust Board No.216). Situate 11th Cross, Wilson Gardens, Bangalore City. Bounded as follows:-

East by : Private Property West by : Site bearing Municipal No.214(Trust board No.215) belonging to the Plaintiff. North by : 11th Cross Road. South by : Private property.

6.

Survey number 130, 131, 78, 81, 148, 159, 160 and 161 situate in Cheluve Arasana Koppalu, Pandavpura Taluk, Mandya District measuring 15 acres and B guntas, Bounded as follows:-

Survey Numbers 159, 160,161.

East by : Paddy field of Deve Gowda

Hombalamma. West by : Paddy field of Madiah, Mariappa

Etc. North by : Raya Maduve. South by :

Survey numbers:148

East by : Hombalamma's Lands West by : Raya Maduve and Boraiah's Wet

Land North by : Basave Gowda's Wet Lands. South by : Mariappa's Wet Lands.

Survey Nos.78 and 81:

East by : Melu Gowda's wet land West by : Devamma Subba Gowda's Lands North by : Sy.No.148. South by : Old Channel and passage.

(Including Garden Land with trees)

East by : Made Gowda's Lands West by : Deve Gowda's Lands North by : Old Nala and Passage South by : Kolli Halli."

6.

Similarly in O.S.No.601/1980 the relief sought by the plaintiff is as under:

a. For dissolution of the firm 'The Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company, Mysore."

b. For rendition of accounts relating to the firm,

c. Costs of the suit and other reliefs."

7.

For the sake of convenience in reading O.S.No.284/1980 is also referred as suit filed by D.Subramanya Sastry and O.S.No.601/1980 is also referred as suit filed by Sheshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar.

8.

The substance of the suit filed in O.S.No.284/1980 by Subramanya Sastry is as under:

The plaintiff namely D.Subramanya Sastry and defendants 1 and 2 namely Sheshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar entered into partnership during the year 1939-40 in the name and style of "Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company (MICC)" and it was registered under the provisions of the Indian Partnership Act 1932. The date of registration being 22.2.1939. Three sites were acquired at Vanivilas Mohalla, Mysore for use and occupation of the

partners and they had intention to treat the partners as the owners of the said properties.

9.

The construction of the houses over the said three sites were completed during the year 1941 and each of the partners occupied their respective houses on the day of Vijayadashami in the year 1941. The house numbers are 2707, 2708 and 2709. The plaint speaks about further acquisition as well. Thus site bearing No.53 at Vanivilas Mohalla, Ontikoppal, Mysore was acquired and outhouse was constructed and it was assigned Municipal No.2709/2.

10.

Site No.60 belonged to one K.P.Gundappa who is stated to be an overseer and house was constructed on the same. However, the said Gundappa did not prefer to buy the house, hence the partnership firm purchased the entire property in site No.60 from him on 7.6.1943.

11.

The site Nos.6 and 8 at New Santhepete Extension, Mysore were allotted by Mysore City Improvement Trust Board and subsequently site No.6 was converted into Site No.47 and 107. Similarly site No.8 was converted to site No.49 and 109. Another site in Chamarajanagar and Lakshmipuram, Mysore also were acquired. Seven sites bearing Municipal Nos.211, 212, 213, 214, 215, 196 and 240 at Wilson Garden, Bangalore were acquired by the partners. In addition to the above immovable properties 15 acres and 8 guntas of wet land at Cheluve Arasana Koppalu Chinnakurali Hobli, French Rocks now called Pandavapura Taluk, Mandya District.

12.

The said firm was dissolved on 11.5.1947 and the properties were distributed among the partners. The only property that was kept open was wet land of 15 acres and 08 guntas at Cheluve

Arasana Koppalu Chinnakurali Hobli, Franch Rocks now called Pandavapura Taluk, Mandya District.

13.

The dissolution of partnership that was effected on 11.5.1947 was reduced to writing on 17.1.1948 (Marked as Ex.P1). Thus, according to the plaintiff the distribution of the firm properties were acted upon.

14.

The plaintiff claims that by virtue of said arrangement he became the full owner of the following items: "Item No.1: House No.2708, 1st Main Road, Vanivillas Mohalla, Mysore.

Item No.2: House No.2836, built on site No.60, 11th Cross, Vanivillas Mohalla, Mysore.

Item No.3: Site No.47 and 107 and site No.49 and 109 at New Santhepete Extension, Mysore.

Item No.4: Site No.214, Wilson Garden, Bengaluru

Item No.5: Site No.215, Wilson Garden, Bengaluru

Item No.6: 1/3rd share in 15 acres and 8 guntas."

15.

Insofar as the landed property at Cheluve Arasana Koppalu Chinnakurali Hobli, French Rocks now called Pandavapura Taluk, Mandya District, the partners continued to be in joint possession and enjoyment. However, defendant No.2 was entrusted with management of care taking in respect of item No.6. Thus, the plaintiff claims that the defendants do not have any right over the said item Nos.1 to 5 of the suit schedule properties.

16.

The plaintiff further claims that despite the said fact, the defendants started writing letters to the local authority in the matter of khatha and other entries pertaining to schedule properties and also developed hostile attitude in respect of the same against the plaintiff. The plaintiff, thus sought the relief as stated above against the defendants.

17.

The defendants filed their common written statement. They claim that the properties stand in the name of the firm as they are acquired for the firm. It is claimed that the sites at Mysore were acquired for partners and with an intention of each partner entering the house as owners.

18.

Defendant No.2 however contended that out of the shares of money drawn from the firm he purchased site No.53, built an outhouse thereon which bears Municipal No.2709/2 and it is his absolute property.

19.

Insofar as the purchasing rights of K.P.Gundappa is concerned, the purchase of the property from K.P.Gundappa is accepted. However, the reason was that he already had a house and not in a position to buy the said property.

20.

Insofar as the site Nos.6 and 8 are concerned, they are contended to have been purchased by defendant No.2 in a public auction.

21.

Insofar as seven sites at Wilson Garden, Bengaluru are concerned, they were acquired by defendant No.1 in the year 1940 as individual owner and the firm was formed in February 1939. It is also contended that the plaintiff was not a partner of the previously existed firm as the very partnership deed stated the assets of the previous firm were taken over by the new firm. The plaintiff was never the partner of the previous firm to be entitled for the assets of the firm.

22.

It is their further contention that the plaintiff has not contributed funds to the partnership firm till the date of filing of the written statement. It is also contended that the plaintiff himself has drawn the

amount of Rs.50,000/- more than the defendant No.1 from the partnership account and it is overdrawing.

23.

The property standing jointly at Cheluve Arasana Koppalu Chinnakurali Hobli, French Rocks now called Pandavapura Taluk, Mandya District to the extent of 15 acres and 08 guntas is admitted to be joint property of the partners.

24.

It is insofar as dissolution of partnership dated 11.5.1947, the contention of the defendants is that the said document is nothing but a draft and it has not out come of the intention of the parties as it did not reflect free hand transaction. Further, there were no properties as stated in paragraph No.11 in the plaint. Document dated 17.1.1948 is not a reflection of intention of the parties, it was never acted upon, infructuous and not acceptable. Further, the provisions of the Registration Act are not complied

as the documents claimed is under Registration. It was the plaintiff who prevailed upon the defendants for signature to be made on the draft.

25.

The plaintiff was stated to be in the possession of books and accounts of the firm till 1948 but misused the same. Defendant No.1 was never consulted, amounts were allowed by the bank to be withdrawn by the plaintiff indiscriminately. The plaintiff did not allow the approval of interest on the amount belonging to firm on the bank. The defendants also make a mention of original suit No.186/1966 wherein the plaintiff was defendant and in the said suit the Court held that the said document was inadmissible for want of proper stamp duty and registration.

26.

In so far as the site in Chamarajanagar is concerned, it was sold by defendant No.1. The claim

of the ownership of the property No.2836 by the plaintiff is denied. Claim of plaintiff over properties bearing item Nos.1 to 5 is denied. Thus, the above pleadings relate to the claim and contention of plaintiff and the defendants who incidentally are stated to be the partners of Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company. The plaintiffs also has filed supplementary pleadings.

27.

In the next suit is O.S.No.601/80 filed by Sri.K.N.Seshadri Iyengar and Sri.Keshavachar against Sri.D.Subramanya Sastry. The relief sought by the plaintiff is as under: a. For dissolution of the firm 'The Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company, Mysore."

b. For rendition of accounts relating to the firm,

c. Costs of the suit and other reliefs."

28.

The plaintiffs in the subsequent suit claim that the business was jointly carried on by the

plaintiffs and the defendant and the defendant was employee under the plaintiff No.1 as such he was taken to confidence and also was agreed to take him as partner in the partnership firm by the partners to the partnership firm.

29.

The defendant entered into partnership on 4.1.1939 for the purpose of carrying on public and private engineering contract in the State of Mysore and elsewhere and further agreed that the principal place to be at Mysore.

30.

It was also agreed that the business should run in the name and style of "Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company(MICC)". According to the terms, it was agreed that the Subscribed Capital should be Rs.30,000/- and that each partners should contribute equally. The plaintiffs carried on the business jointly and prior to the said date Rs.90,000/-

was subscribed as their contribution towards capital of the firm. However, defendant did not contribute. Further, the capital invested by each of the partners should carry interest of 8% per annum. Books of accounts to be maintained at principal place and each terms were incorporated in said agreement and partnership dated 4.1.1939 and under the said terms and conditions, partnership came into existence. The contract works were distributed in different places and the accounts were maintained separately in respect of each of the contract. The defendant was incharge of accounts as stated above and likewise, the plaintiffs also were in possession of the respective records.

31.

In the course of business, some properties were purchased out of their own funds and some were purchased out of the funds of the firm. The properties purchased by the plaintiffs out of their own funds

stand in the their names and those purchased out of the funds of the firm stand in the name of the firm or jointly in the name of the partners. When the business was in progress the plaintiffs, defendant and others started a company viz., "United Engineering Corporation Limited, Bangalore" to carry on business on bigger scale with a view to finalize the affairs they decided to take stock of the firm "Mysore irrigation and Construction Company". The defendant who was in the possession of all the books of accounts of the firm promised to scrutinize and get the accounts audited and keep the Statements and Balance Sheet ready. Hence, during May 1947 defendant prepared only Statement of Accounts and represented that he had prepared it in accordance with the books of accounts. The defendant enjoyed the absolute confidence of the plaintiffs. The plaintiff No.2 was residing in Mysore and the plaintiff No.1 at Bangalore

and because of the understanding to wind up the affairs of the firm and preparation of Statement of Account, the defendant prepared a draft of the deed of dissolution and took the same to the plaintiff No.1 at Bangalore on 17.5.1948 and represented that he had scrutinized and prepared the draft assuring that it represents the true state of affairs of the firm and presented it for signature of the plaintiff. The original document to remain with the plaintiff No.1 after signature of plaintiff No.2. The plaintiff No.1 made the signature believing the defendant and the statements made by him. The defendant approached plaintiff No.2 at Mysore on same day and represented that plaintiff No.1 has approved the draft and affixed the signature and the plaintiff No.2 followed the suit of plaintiff No.1. Thus the signatures were affixed on the deed in believing bonafide the defendant. It is also claimed that they have specifically agreed to the

representation made by the defendant to the plaintiff No.1 the senior most partner, later it turns out to be false. The plaintiff No.2 on the very next day addressed a letter dated 18.1.1948 to the defendant pointing out the omissions and wrong entries and the circumstances under which he had been made to subscribe his signature. Thus the document dated 17.1.1948 was not intended by the parties and the same was denied and it could not have taken effect and did not affect the status quo ante. The said document dated 17.1.1948 is invalid, illegal and not enforceable and also contravenes the provisions of Transfer of Property Act.

32.

The plaintiffs also claim that earlier the defendant filed a suit in O.S.No.13/1972, later it was renumbered as O.S.No.284/1980 and his claim in the said suit is contrary to the document dated 17.1.1948

and there is no dispute in so far as nature of properties and regarding joint status of ownership.

33.

The written statement is filed by the defendant denying the plaint averments and the claim made by the plaintiffs to reiterate the contention of the document dated 17.1.1948. The said partnership firm "Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company" was dissolved and they were assigned to "United Engineering Corporation Limited, Bangalore." The partnership was dissolved and accounts were entrusted to one R.K.Rama Rao, Accountant for finalizing whose services had been assigned to United Engineering Corporation Limited, Bangalore. Deed of dissolution was properly prepared by one Sri.M.Seshadri, Advocate Mysore and there were certain corrections by the plaintiff No.1 and it became final.

34.

Regarding the acquisition of properties, defendant reiterates plaint averments made by him in the capacity of plaintiff in O.S.No.284/80.

35.

The learned trial Judge based on the above pleadings and contentions of the parties in both the suits framed the following issues: Issues in O.S.No.284/1980

"1. Whether the plaintiff proves that the sites in question were acquired with the avowed intention that the 3 partners should be regarded as owners of one site?

2.

Whether the 3 partners occupied the houses constructed therein a individual owners and whether the plaintiff has become the owner of suit item No.1?

3.

Whether the suit item No.2 was purchased by the partnership firm towards the costs of construction due from K.Gundappa, the owners by paying the site value?

4.

Whether the suit item No.6 the agricultural lands were enjoyed by the 3 partners of the firm after the dissolution of the firm, as tenants-in-common?

5.

Whether under the document dated 17.01.1948 all the immovable properties of the

firm were divided amongst the 3 partners reserving suit item No.6 for the common enjoyment of all the 3 partners?

6.

Whether the defendants prove that the document dated 17.01.1948 is not acted upon and it is an unfructuous document?

7.

Whether the suit item No.3 is the partnership property or the property of the 2nd defendant?

8.

Whether the suit item No.4 and 5 are the properties of the firm or the separate properties 1st defendant acquired in his individual capacity?

9.

Whether the 2nd defendant is liable to render accounts in respect of the suit item No.6?

10.

Whether the suit is barred by limitation?

11.

Whether the defendants prove that in respect of items 3, 4 and 5 their possession is adverse to the right of the plaintiff?

12.

Whether the Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit for reasons stated in paras 25 and 26 of the written statement?

13.

Whether the plaintiff is not entitled to declaration sought for reasons stated in para 24 of the written statement?

14.

To what relief if any is plaintiff entitled?"

Issues in O.S.No.601/1980

"1. Whether the plaintiff executed the document of dissolution Dt.17.10.1948 in the circumstances pleaded by them in the plaint?

2.

Whether the plaintiffs prove that the document Dt.17.01.1948 was not final and was not intended to be acted upon?

3.

Whether the document Dt.17.1.1948 is invalid for the reasons stated in para B of the plaint?

4.

Whether the defendant proves that the Firm has been dissolved as and from 21.05.1947?

5.

Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the dissolution of the Firm?

6.

Whether defendant is liable to render accounts?

7.

Whether the suit is barred by limitation?

8.

What order?"

36.

Learned trial Judge was accommodated with oral evidence of PW-1 D.Subramanya Shastry and documentary evidence of Exhibits P-1 to P-144 and oral evidence of DW-1 K.N.Seshadri Iyengar and DW-2 N Narayana and documentary evidence of Exhibits D-1 to D-85. Upon conclusion of trial, learned

trial Judge answered issue Nos.1 to 5 and 9 in the affirmative, issue Nos.6, 10, 11 and 13 in the negative and issue No.8 holding that suit item Nos.4 and 5 are the properties of the firm in O.S.No.284/80 and also answered issue Nos.1 to 3 and 5 in the negative, issue No.4 in the affirmative, issue No.6 partly in the affirmative in O.S No.601/80 and as per final order decreed O.S.No.284/80 and partly decreed O.S.No.601/80. Operative portion of the same is as under: ORDER

O.S.No.284/1980 is decreed.

O.S.No.601/1980 is partly decreed.

The Legal Representatives of the deceased plaintiff in O.S.No.284/1980 are hereby declared to be the owners of items No.1 to 5 of the plaint schedule.

The defendants are restrained by means of Permanent Injunction from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession and enjoyment of suit items No.4 and 5.

It is further declared that the Legal Representatives of the deceased plaintiff are together entitled to 1/3rd share in suit item 6, which comprises agricultural lands. The partition of the said land shall be effected in accordance with section 54 of CPC.

Since under the terms of the compromise petition filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of CPC, the Legal Representatives of the deceased plaintiff have not opted for accounting of the income derived by the deceased second defendant, there will be no direction for taking of accounts regarding the income in respect of the suit item No.6.

The Legal representatives of the deceased plaintiff shall be entitled for partition and separate possession of 1/3rd share in suit item No.6 upon allotment of partnership.

In O.S.No.601/1980 the Legal Representatives of the deceased Subramanya Sastry shall render accounts regarding the movables of the erstwhile firm as mentioned inE.x.P.1. On the examination of accounts, the rights and liabilities of the parties in respect of the such movables shall be finally determined.

Under the circumstances of the cost, the parties are directed to bear their costs:

Original judgment shall be kept in O.S.No.284/1980 and the copy of the judgment shall be kept in O.S.No.601/1980."

37.

Being aggrieved by the said Judgment and decree, K.N.Seshadri Iyanger (dead by LRs) who is defendant No.1 in O.S.284/80 and plaintiff in O.S.No.601/80 presented these appeals.

38.

Learned Senior counsel Sri.Jayavittala Rao Kolar appearing for appellants submitted that the dissolution of partnership deed marked at Ex.P17 is not binding and was not acted upon the appellants. The Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company

(MICC) acquired the properties morefully admitted in the written statement of Defendant No.1. Item No.4 and 5 consists of two sites in Wilson Garden, Bangalore, which are the separate properties of defendant No.1 which has no nexus.

39.

It is further submitted that the intermediary transaction or sharing of the properties of the partnership cannot take away the separate

rights of defendant No.1 in respect of the said properties. It is also submitted that defendant No.1 Sheshadri Iyengar had even made settlement of the said items of properties. It is further submitted that claiming of absolute ownership in respect of item No.1 to 5 of the schedule properties by the plaintiff does not arise as the legal dissolution of the partnership firm has not taken place. There was no reason for the Trial Court to hold that 3 sites at Mysore were purchased by the firm with the intention of partners should be regarded as the owners of the properties. The finding of the learned Trial Judge in holding that the document dated 17.11.1948 was acted upon, despite the overwhelming evidence to show that the said document marked as Ex.P17 is an honest and did not reflect the real intention of the parties and the plaintiff has taken unfair advantage of a draft that was a proposal which has not attained finality. The learned

Trial Judge erred in holding the properties particularly Item no.3 as partnership property and recognizing the dissolution as claimed by the plaintiffs even the claim of dissolution and allotment of properties is neither illegal nor unsuitable and there is no reason to the said effect.

40.

Again the learned trial Judge erred in granting injunction in respect of item No.4 and 5 of the suit schedule. The said finding is not based on the facts and evidence. There were clinching evidence in the form of documents and also oral testimony to show that item Nos.4 and 5 are the self acquired properties of Mr.K.N.Sheshadri Iyengar the defendant No.1., and remained under his ownership and possession. The sale consideration for the said properties at Wilson Garden was duly paid by the said Sheshadri Iyengar.

41.

The principles of possession and ownership in respect of vacant site are ignored by the trial court. The possession of the property at Bangalore by Sheshadri Iyengar was admitted by the plaintiff and the other defendant but the finding goes against the very admission. Learned Trial Judge failed in not recognizing the hostile title and possession of defendant No.1 and he should have held to have perfected the title by adverse possession in accordance with the principle laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court.

42.

The non payment of prescribed stamp duty and compulsory registration of dissolution deed in accordance with provisions of the Registration Act effects the document of dissolution and it cannot be relied for the purpose of adjudication of rights, whether creation or extension in accordance with the said unregistered deed.

43.

The timing of questioning and claiming by the plaintiff is nearly after 24 years and thus by itself shows that such claim is barred by limitation and has no legal efficacy. Even in the earlier proceedings in OS.No.186/1956 filed by Thiruvanachar the Court held that the dissolution of partnership deed cannot be considered for reckoning dissolution as required stamp duty was not paid and registration in accordance with the Registration Act was not effected.

44.

The suit for declaration of title and injunction by the plaintiff in respect of item Nos.1 to 5 should invariably have been filed within 3 years from 1948 as per Article 58 of the Limitation Act. The loosing of possession by the plaintiff and exclusive user of the same by defendants has not at all been considered by the Trial Court. In so far as the Plaintiff and defendant No.2 are concerned both are dead and

represented by legal heirs. The plaintiff and defendant No.2 Keshavachar are dead and are represented by the legal representatives. They entered into compromise and filed the application of compromise before the Court. The said compromise apparently is self explanatory regarding the collusion between the said parties and ought not have been accepted by the Trial Court on the other hand it should have been rejected as it prejudices the rights of the first defendant regarding his pleadings and admission of the plaintiff and the defendant no.2.

46.

The Trial Judge failed to take note of the fact that though the defendant No.1 was not party to the said compromise the said arrangement ought not have been considered in the light or prejudice that was caused to legal interest of the defendant No.1. The legal representatives of the plaintiff and the defendant No.2 apparently have no knowledge about

the state of affairs regarding the partnership properties and the way of dissolution or distribution. Thus even otherwise the application was filed in contravention with the law relating to partnership and statutory rights of the defendant No.1. The admissible documents were not considered and inadmissible documents were taken into consideration.

47.

Insofar as RFA.No.84/2003 is concerned, it is directed against the judgment and decree passed in OS No.29/1973 (old number) O.S.No.601/1980 dated 31.07.2002. The said suit was filed seeking dissolution of partnership (for the first time and rendition of accounts).

48.

Insofar as O.S.No.284/1980 filed by Subramanya Shastry was decreed and O.S.No.601/80 was partly decreed and the legal representatives of the deceased Subramanya Shastry were ordered to

render accounts. The operative of judgment is morefully as stated above.

49.

In this connection, it is necessary to note that 'C' file pertaining to RFA No.84/2003 was reported destroyed on 17.8.2015. Further, RFA No.84/2003 was dismissed for non prosecution on 16.1.2006.

50.

Meanwhile, the 'C' file and connected record in RFA No.84/2003 was ordered to be destroyed on 17.8.2015. However the appeal memorandum or appeal in RFA No.84/2003 and impugned Judgment in O.S.No.601/1980 (old No.29/1973) available in the paper book and also in the certified copy of the common judgment dated 31.07.2002. Hence, the destruction of records does not cause material impact on disposal of the matter.

51.

Thus, learned counsel for appellants submit that the said suit was filed seeking dissolution and rendition of accounts considering the assertions and denials of the parties regarding dissolution and non dissolution of the partnership firm.

52.

Learned counsel Sri.Anantha Krishnamurthy for respondent No.2- plaintiff in O.S.No.284/1980 (old No.13/1970) submitted that the partnership among the plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1 and 2 was formed in the year 1937 and registered during 1939 and it is not disputed. The very object of the said partnership is to engage in public and private works morefully connected to construction of building, installation of road and related is also not disputed. Though the partnership came into existence in the year 1937 it was registered on 22.02.1939. The partnership firm took the assignment of construction

and other works of public and private nature at Mysore, Chamarajanagar and other places.

53.

So far as the acquisition of properties are concerned there is no dispute in so far as major portions of the properties being acquired by the firm. Even the defendant No.1- Seshadri Iyengar asserted item Nos.4 and 5 of the suit schedule properties to be his exclusive properties and there is no assertion regarding his exclusive ownership in respect of the properties at Mysore or Chamarajanagar.

54.

Learned counsel also submits that in so far as landed property to the extent of 15 acres 08 guntas of wet land at Pandavapura Mandya District previously known as Cheluve Arasana Koppalu is concerned the parties are not at issue regarding the joint rights of the plaintiff and Defendant Nos.1 and 2.

55.

Insofar as compromise is concerned, learned counsel submits that under Order 23 Rule 1 when the compromise is lawful there is no embargo for the Court to accept the same. Moreover, the said compromise was entered into between the legal heirs of plaintiff Subramanya Shastry and the legal heirs of Keshavachar, defendant No.2. Insofar as item No.6 the agricultural land of 15 acres 08 guntas at Pandavapura is concerned, the learned Trial Judge was right in recognizing 1/3rd undivided rights in favour of each of the partners. However, the said partners even after the dissolution of the partnership firm are entitled to immovable properties which is yet to be divided by metes and bounds.

56.

Apart from the immovable properties, movable properties are concerned whether in the form of cash, deposits or debts payable are invariably to be available to the parties. However, in this connection

there being compromise between the plaintiff and legal representatives of defendant No.2 learned counsel submits that the contention of defendant No.2 is that holder of the books of accounts and also the custodian of records was answerable to the amounts received by the firm and those amount which was in the custody of the firm. Thus by virtue of the said compromise being accepted by the Court it did not ordered for rendition of accounts.

57.

Learned counsel further submits that in the light of claim and contention of the parties and the documents available on record dictum laid down by various judgment the suit of the plaintiff-Subramanya Sastry was rightly decreed and in so far as immovable properties are concerned, the firm was dissolved properly and the legal status of partners was disrupted in respect of partnership firm and its business and in so far as the immovable property at

Pandavapura is concerned, the partners continue to have undivided 1/3rd share apart from that there is no relationship of partnership or firm or partnership properties between the partners.

58.

In the context and circumstances of the case, coming into existence of partnership in the name and style of "Mysore Irrigation Construction and Company" during the year 1937 is not disputed. The prime contention between the plaintiff and defendant No.1-K.N.Seshadri Iyengar is regarding the legal status of partnership firm. According to plaintiff D Subramanaya Shastry it came to an end under Ex.P-1-Deed of Dissolution. However, it is denied by defendant Nos.1 and 2. The compromise was entered into between legal representatives of plaintiff and defendant No.2 -Keshavachar.

59.

Plaintiff Subramanya Shastry and defendant No.1 -Seshadri Iyengar and defendant No.2 Keshavachar in the first suit all are dead and they are represented by their Legal heirs/legal representatives. The compromise before the Court is stated to be partial as it was entered into between the plaintiff and defendant No.2. However, compromise is opposed by defendant No.1. Registration of partnership was not compulsory, when the business was entered into in such nature. However the domain of the case is not in relation to dissecting registration or the effects of non registration. Partnership Act came into force in 1932. There was no impediment for the parties to enter into a partnership business regarding construction works as mentioned in the name itself. The firm is stated to have engaged in constructing public and private works and the parties have gone on record stating that

different projects and assignment were undertaken and cleared by them in various places including Mysore, Chamarajanagar etc.,

60.

The properties were claimed to have been acquired by the partners from funds of partnership. In this connection there is difference between parties to the effect that item No.4 and 5 is claimed to have been acquired by defendant No.1-Mr. Sheshadri Iyengar. However, plaintiff Subramanya Shastry claimed all property including Item Nos.4 and 5 belonged to firm. However partnership was dissolved under Ex.P1 dated 17.1.1948.

61.

Regarding the said document the controversy between the parties is to the effect that it was a draft and did not see the light of the day according to defendant No.1. He further contends that a draft document was being shown to the

partners and that the plaintiff prevailed upon the signatures of the defendants and they were made. Apart from the draft nature of the said document it did not step further and the said document did not carry the intention of the parties nor the said document saw the light of the day and the said document did not undergo the required legal formalities of a regular dissolution of partnership deed on a prescribed stamp paper and being registered in accordance with the provision of the Registration Act.

62.

Now between the parties as stated above contractual relationship of partnership is not disputed. In this connection it is necessary to mention that law of partnership is nothing but extension of law of agency.

63.

`Partnership' is defined under Section 4 of Indian Partnership Act as "relation between persons

who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all". Section 14 of the said Act deals with the properties of firm which reads as under: "14. The property of the firm.—Subject to contract between the partners, the property of the firm includes all property and rights and interests in property originally brought into the stock of the firm, or acquired, by purchase or otherwise, by or for the firm, or for the purposes and in the course of business of the firm, and includes also the goodwill of the business. Unless the contrary intention appears, property and rights and interests in property acquired with money belonging to the firm are deemed to have been acquired for the firm."

64.

It is not uncommon that partnership is also compared to that of Joint Hindu Family with their own similarities and differences. The effect of partnership is analyzed with the representation that individually a person is called 'partner' and collectively 'firm'. There are different kinds of partnership such as partnership for particular project, period, when both are not

specifically stated partnership at will and related. Insofar as the nature of partnership in this case is concerned it is construction activities. Incidentally properties are acquired by the firm as stated not only the construction materials or equipments or other related but also purchased the residential sites and also construction were made on the said properties and

purchase of sites at Vanivilas Mohalla, Ontikoppal, Santhepete in Mysore, Chamarajanagar and Wilson Garden, Bangalore. The other aspects which come in between are regarding limit of drawings, properties being maintained by defendant No.1 at Bangalore thereafter each of partners incurring expenditure regarding maintenance, payment of tax and thereafter reimbursement of the said amount by the firm.

65.

RFA No.37/2003 is filed by the appellant- K.N.Seshadri Iyengar against the judgment and decree dated 31.7.2002 passed in O.S.No.284/1980 by the XXXI Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore, decreeing the suit for declaration, permanent injunction and partition.

66.

RFA No.84/2003 is filed by the appellant- K.N.Seshadri Iyengar against the judgment and decree dated 31.7.2002 passed in O.S.No.601/1980 by the XXXI Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore, decreeing the suit for dissolution of partnership.

67.

Insofar as the oral evidence of the parties are concerned, plaintiff has reiterated plaint averments in his evidence. He is subjected to cross examination. His prime assertion in the suit is to the effect that the partnership was formed in the year 1937 however, it was registered during 1939 i.e., on

22-02-1939. At the same time, the scheme for dissolution was made during the year 1947 and was given a final shape and came into force under Ex.P1 dated 17-01-1948. Thus, according to the plaintiff, the partnership does not exist any more with reference to immoveable properties except the land at Cheluve Arasana Koppalu. It is the contention of the defendant No.2 that the fact of dissolution of the partnership is a programme concept and it came to an end in the year 1948.

68.

The allocation of shares in the form of respective properties were made under Ex.P1, for which all the three partners are parties. It is in this connection, the defendant No.1-K.N. Sheshadri Iyengar contended that the properties at item Nos.4 and 5 sites at Wilson garden, Bangalore, were never the properties of partnership and they were his self

acquired properties and he has made settlement in favour of his children.

69.

So far as the other properties forming part of the suit schedule are concerned, it is the contention of defendant No.1-K.N. Sheshadri Iyengar that they are yet to be settled. It is in this connection, parties are having a material assertions and denial. Defendant No.2 also contended that after the dissolution of partnership in the year 1948, each partner has dealt with the said properties according to their volition. To name them, property bearing No.2707 house at VV Mohalla was mortgaged by K.N.Sheshadri Iyengar in favour of one P.M.Chennabasavanna son of P.Mallanna on 18-8-1965 for Rs.3,300/-. Similarly, defendant No.1 sold the site at Chamarajanagar to N.Nagarajaiah son of S.Narayan. Similarly,

Lakshmipuram site was sold to Athmaram Sadhur on 18-11-1969 for consideration of Rs.10,000/-.

70.

It is also claimed by the plaintiff that the defendant No.1-K.N. Sheshadri Iyengar has stated in his examination that K. Keshavachar/defendant No.2 purchased three sites in Mysore on behalf of the firm in Ontikoppal area. Further it is also stated that three partners occupied the respective houses at Mysore. It is also elicited from his evidence that out of capital investment and advances made by him and K.Keshavachar, three sites in Ontikoppal, one in Santhepet and 8 sites in Wilson garden extension, Bangalore were purchased.

71.

Learned counsel for defendant No.2 relies on the said version of K.N.Sheshadri Iyengar which is contrary to his claim in respect of item Nos. 4 and 5. It is also contended that, it is Mr. K.N.Sheshadri

Iyengar has asserted that there was no individual and exclusive right in respect of the property.

72.

Defendant No.1-K.N. Sheshadri Iyengar and defendant No.2-K. Keshavachar, in written statement at para- 3 stated that out of the funds drawn against defendant No.2-K. Keshavachar, he purchased item No.3 built in out house No.2709/2. At this juncture, it is necessary to mention both the claims and defence by the parties overlap to some extent insofar as the identity or reckoning of the properties are concerned. However, the compromise was entered into between the legal heirs of plaintiff- Subramanya Sastry and defendant No.2 – K.Keshavachar.

73.

At this stage, it is necessary to examine Ex.P1. It is the copy of the dissolution of partnership dated 17-01-1948 among:

(1) K.N. Sheshadri Iyengar son of Mr. Kalkunte Narayana Iyengar, residing at No.22, 1st Cross Road, Gavipuram Extension, Bangalore City;

(2) Kalkunte Keshavachar son of Kalkunte Ramaswamy Iyengar, residing at No.2709, 1st Main Road, Vanivilas Mohalla, Mysore City and

(3) Devanagondi Subramhanya Sastry, son of Devanagondi Ahobala Sastry, residing at No.2707, 1st Main Road, Vanivilas Mohalla, Mysore city.

74.

They resigned as partners of the firm “The Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company” which carried on the business till 11th May 1947 at Mysore and other places. It further reads that the partners took the decision to dissolve the partnership and took inventory of the assets on 11-05-1947 and divided and apportioned the assets in accordance with a list thereon and thus, the shares were considered and properties were allocated. They were prepared in

triplicate and are given to each of the partners. The said document further reads that the immoveable assets of partnership including builtup structures stated above were taken into consideration with reference to their value. Their identification is done as under:

“AND WHEREAS the immoveable assets of the partnership consisting of premises No. 2707 with out house No.2707/1, valuing rupees eighteen thousand six hundreden fifty (Rs.18,650/-), 2708 with out house No.2708/1 valuing rupees Nineteen thousand two hundreden fifty (Rs.19,250/) and 2709 with out house No.2709/1 valuing rupees Nineteen thousand eight hundreden fifty (Rs.19,850/-) and 2709/2 in site No.52 situate in the1st main road, Vanivilas Mohalla (Vontikoppal) Mysore valuing at rupees Ten thousand (Rs.10,000/-) and premises No.2836 in Block III Vanivilas Mohalla, Mysore valuing rupees Fie thousand and five hundred (Rs.5,500/-); Site No.6 in New Santhepet Extension, Mysore City valuing Rupees Four thousand and one hundred

(Rs.4,100/-); Site No.E (No.7) in Lakshmipuram Extension, Mysore City valuing rupees Seven thousand and three hundred (Rs.7,300/-) Silk Filature site at Chamaraja Nagar together with Masonry foundations, valuing rupees Twelve Thousand (Rs.12,000/-); Sites Nos. 212, 213, 214 at Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City valuing rupees Three thousand four hundreden forty one (Rs.3,441/-); Site Nos. 197 and 242 in Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City, valuing rupees one thousand four hundreden ninety eight (Rs.1,498/-); and sit Nos. 215 and 216 situated in Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City valuing rupees one thousand five hundreden fifty four (Rs.1,554/-); site No. 8 in New Santhepet Extension, Mysore City valuing rupees three thousand five hundred (Rs.3,500/-) and wet lands of the aggregate area of 15 acres and 8 guntas comprising Survey Nos. 78,81,131,148, 159, 160 and 161... Cheluve Urs Koppal and Aralu Koppal Jamabandi, Chinnakurali Hobli, French rocks Taluk, Mandya District valuing rupees Seventeen thousand (Rs.17,000/-) were all acquired mostly in the individual

names of such of the partners then available at the spot out of partnerships assets and for the benefit of the Partnership .......”

75.

The concluding para in page No.2 states the Firm is dissolved which reads as under:

“NOW THIS DEED WITNESSETH that the Partnership styled “THE MYSORE IRRIGATION AND CONSTRUCTION COMPANY” is and has been dissolved as from 11-05-1947 subject only to the final winding up after division and apportionment of the assets and liabilities yet to be ascertained, realised and apportioned and detailed in the triplicate lists executed by the partners on 11-5-1947 and this day as specified in the preamble by the Partners on 11-5-1947 and this day as specified in the preamble above and the Partners above named further hereby declare that if any items of their assets are left out of this deed, or the lists as above by inadvertence or ignorance they agree to divide and appropriate them in equal shares hereafter.”

76.

The allotment of properties with reference to each share were mentioned in Ex.P1 which reads as under:

“........Premises Nos. 2707 with 2707/1 situated in the First Main Road, Vanivilas Mohalla, Mysore, Site No.8 in New Santhepet Extension, Mysore; Site No.E(No.7) situated in the Lakshmipuram Extension, Mysore City; the Silk Filature Factory site at Chamarajanagar standing in the name of Mr.K.N.Seshadri Iyengar; and sites Nos. 212, 213 and 214 at the Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City were assigned to the share of the first of the above partners—viz., Mr. K.N. Seshadri Iyengar;

Premises Nos. 2709 with 2709/1 in site No.52 and 2709/2 in site No.53 (in Block IV A, Vani vilas Mohalla Extension) in the 1st Main Road, Vanivilas Mohalla Extension, Mysore and sites Nos. 197 and 242 situated in the Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City were assigned to the share of the second of the Partners above named – Viz., Mr. K. Keshavachar; and

Premises Nos. 2708 with 2708/1 in the 1st Main Road, Vanivilas Mohalla Extension, Mysore, Premises No.2836 in Block III Vanivilas Mohalla Extension, Mysore, site No.6 in New Santhepet Extension, Mysore and Site Nos. 215 and 216 in the Wilson Gardens Extension, Bangalore City were assigned to the share of the third of the Partners above named – viz., Mr. D. Subramhanya Sastry; and

The wet lands of the aggregate area of 15 acres and 8 guntas comprising survey Nos. 78,81, 131,148,159, 160 and 161 near Cheluve Urs Koppal and Aralu Koppal Jama Bandi, Chinna Kurli Hobli, French Rocks Taluk, Mandya District were agreed to be enjoyed jointly by all the Partners dividing only the annual income therefrom equally amongst them, till such time as they decide jointly to sell or divide them and each of the Partners has assumed and obtained exclusive and absolute possession and enjoyment of his share of the assets as above.

77.

Insofar as the allocation or allotment of properties situated at Pandavapura is concerned, no specific appropriation of property at Pandavapura is mentioned. However, the said land and property is admitted to be the property of partnership and there is consensus among the parties to share in equal ratio. Moreover, insofar as joint nature of land and property at Pandavapura is concerned, it is measuring 15 acres 08 guntas.

78.

Thus, the pleading of the parties are concerned, the bone of contention is that plaintiff claim the dissolution of partnership is foregone conclusion. Defendant No.1 contends that his properties i.e., item Nos.4 and 5 are included in the schedule and insofar as other properties are concerned, they are to be divided and the deed of dissolution is redundant and nonest.

79.

Thus, on the whole context and circumstances of the case, it is against plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1 and 2 the contest went on, but it ended in compromise between plaintiff and defendant No.2. However, defendant No.1 is not a party to the compromise and rather opposed the same. In the result the claim of the plaintiff is endorsed by defendant No.2.

80.

There are six items of the suit schedule immovable properties and other disputed area is regarding rendition of the accounts of MICC.

81.

Ex.P4, Ex.P5, Ex.P8, Ex.P9 and Ex.P35 and Ex.D5 are the documents maintained by the partners regarding the suit schedule properties. However, it is to be noted that the acquisition of the properties are not disputed nor there is any dispute between the partners and the third parties. The bone of the

contention is restricted among the parties and the persons claiming under them. Thus adjudication of the matter in the present proceedings would be between the parties to suit and the persons claiming under them respectively.

82.

Another aspect to be considered herein is the effect of compromise between the legal representatives of plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry and the defendant No.2-Keshavachar. Thus he literally goes along with the plaintiff regarding the stand taken in respect of the title and the possession of the suit schedule properties and also rendition of accounts. Under these circumstances the defendant No.2 invariably endorse the existence of the partnership as per Ex.P2-Partnership deed dated 04.01.1939 and Ex.P1-dissolution partnership deed. This is concerned to the first suit filed by D.Subramanya Shastry in O.S.No.284/1980.

83.

Thus concurrence from the side of the defendant No.2-Keshavachar (his legal heirs came on record) in the fag end of the trial on 02.11.1999. In this connection it is necessary to mention under Order XXII Rule 3 of Code of Civil Procedure which is as under :- "Procedure in case of death of one of several plaintiffs or of sole plaintiff.- (1) Where one of two or more plaintiffs dies and the right to sue does not survive to the surviving plaintiff or plaintiffs alone, or a sole plaintiff or sole surviving plaintiff does and the right to sue survives, the Court, on an application made in that behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased plaintiff to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit.

(2) Where within the time limited by law no application is made under sub-rule (1) the suit shall abate so far as the deceased plaintiff is concerned, and, on the application of the defendant, the Court may award to him the costs which he may have incurred in defending the suit, to be recovered form the estate of the deceased plaintiff.

84.

The learned trial Judge found the compromise lawful and accepted the same at the time of the disposal of the suit as could be seen in the judgment. There was a serious opposition by the defendant No.1-Sheshadri Iyengar (legal representatives) for the said compromise.

85.

As stated above the formation of the partnership in the year 1937 reducing the same into writing in the year 1939 is not disputed. Both are governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932. The difference between the parties would be highlighted as under :- 1. The plaintiff-Subramanya Shastri claim that entire properties mentioned in the schedule items No.1 to 6 remain partnership properties irrespective of being acquired by only the partner and also relies on dissolution deed-Ex.P1 wherein the shares are allotted. The schedule properties fell to the share of plaintiff D Subramanaya Shastry and 1/3 share in item No.6.

2.

The dissolution of the partnership is strongly disputed and denied by the defendant No.1. Incidentally the defendant No.2 also denied the claim of the plaintiff wherein both the defendants contended that dissolution of the partnership had not taken place and it is very much intact.

86.

Further contention of the both defendants that Ex.D1 was draft and that document was not intended to be acted upon. It never represented the intention of the parties. The said document is not acceptable as it is not in accordance with law and it is neither duly stamped as per the Stamp Act nor registered under the provision of the Indian Registration Act-1970. Further contentions of the defendant that the items No.4 and 5 the sites at Wilson Garden, Bengaluru, exclusively belongings to defendant No.1. Further contended that three house properties in Mysore were intended to be occupied by

the partners as the owners. Thus they contended that they are also not the properties of the partnership firm. Further the account of the firm were not settled. In so far as item No.6 of the suit schedule property is concerned it is agricultural lands to the extent of 15 acres 8 guntas situated at Pandavapura Village, Mandya District. There is no difference between either of the parties either confirming same as joint properties of the partners and only difference in this connection would be the plaintiff said that property was reserved for distribution among all the partners. Regard being had to the fact that partition was effected in respect of other properties as sought by the plaintiff.

87.

In the first suit the plaintiff D Subramanya Shastry claims that declaration of the ownership over the items No.1 to 5 of the suit schedule properties and against the defendants No.1 and 2 and permanent

injunction to restrain the defendants from interfering with his peaceful possession and enjoyment and for declaration of 1/3rd share in item No.6 and the rendition of accounts in connection with the item No.6 of the suit schedule properties. It is in this connection by virtue of the compromise defendant No.2 has endorsed and agreed with the claim of the plaintiff and that compromise is accepted by the Trial Court and the suit is decreed as prayed by the plaintiff and the defendant No.2.

88.

Defendant No.1 therein contended that collusion between plaintiff and the defendant No.2 and assert that it is fact for convenience and he is not bound by such compromise.

89.

In so far as adjudication of the matter is concerned, it is not voting process so as to contend

how many claim and how many denial. It is the legal process and the merits and the justification recognized by the law which are to be considered. In this process though the contentions between the plaintiff and the defendant No.1 bring point regarding the dissolution of the partnership, sharing of the properties and the rendition of accounts. To simplify, the bone of contention that item No.6 which is landed property is not disputed and all three partners namely Subramanya Shastry, Seshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar all of them are holding 1/3rd share. It is accepted by all of them irrespective of the existence of the partnership or dissolution of partnership, it is declared to be partnership properties.

90.

The learned Trial Judge has observed various documents, the letters and the deposition representing the claim and the contentions of the

parties. Among them the following are worth mentioning: 1. The first contention of the defendant No.1-Sheshadri Iyengar, defendant No.2- Keshavachar is that plaintiff misrepresented them and obtained signature on Ex.P1 and their signatures do not represent their intention.

2.

Ex.P9 is letter dated 14.09.1947, the substance of the said letter is that defendant No.1-Seshadri Iyengar is stated to have been instructed to defendant No.2-Keshavachar to prepare draft of the partnership deed and he expresses further that he seen draft sent by Keshavachar, before putting the same on the stamp paper. He has also expresses opinion that it may not be necessary to consult the advocate as he apprehended advocate may charge heavy sum.

91.

Ex.P10 is another letter dated: 18.09.1947 written by defendant No.1-Seshadri Iyengar to the plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry. The writer defendant

No.1-Seshadri Iyengar reminded Keshavachar to prepare draft. Ex.P11 is the another letter dated: 22.09.1947 addressed to Subramanya Shastry wherein Sheshadri Iyengar writes to the plaintiff- Subramanya Shastry with regard to equalization of the share and opined that they need not change agreed arrangement and he has bought a site plan from the Trust Board. The plan issued by Trust Board does not contain serial number. In this connection he would go to Trust board office and collect the numbers. Further Ex.P71 is letter addressed to the plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry by Seshadri Iyengar by requesting to prepare the draft partition deed. Ex.P72 is another letter by the defendant No.1-Seshadri Iyengar to the plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry wherein it is expressed by Seshadri Iyengar that registration of the partnership deed may attract the stamp duty Rupees 7 and 8 Anas (at this juncture it is necessary

mentioned one rupee note issued by the Government of India was considered equivalent to 16 anas). In this connection Seshadri Iyengar is stated to have mentioned registration of the partnership deed may attract expenditure of rupees 7-8-0 anas. In this letter he states that properties are in the name of firm and if it is in the individual name the stamp will be on 2/3rd share and 1/3rd being exempted. He has also mentioned that the partition deed is already executed.

92.

Ex.P73 is another letter dated 21.01.1948 written by the defendant No.1 to the plaintiff and there is reference about the existence of the deed of dissolution. At this juncture it is necessary to consider the fact of filing of the suit by one Thirumalachar against Seshadri Iyengar and others wherein the dissolution deed was also the subject matter

discussed and defendant No.1-Seshadri Iyengar gave evidence in the said suit as defendant.

93.

The Ex.P64 and Ex.P65 marked as rough statement of account. Ex.P121 marked in O.S.No.284/80 which is the deposition of K.N.Seshadri Iyengar in O.S.No.186/1956. Ex.D1 is document which was shown to Seshadri Iyengar in that suit. He admits the document as Ex.D15. All the corrections in it are in his handwriting. He admits that there was a draft before D-1 was finally made. Thus Seshadri Iyengar stated that before preparing Ex.D1 there was a draft and he has made correction also. Ex.P17 in the present litigation was previously stated to have been marked as Ex.P144.

94.

Ex.P-143 is the letter dated 29.10.47 addressed to defendant No.1 Seshadri Iyengar and is

written by plaintiff –Subramanya Sastry. The points that are highlighted in the said letter are as under: The partnership that existed is stated to have been expired and possibilities of dispute. In the said connection they are put at rest by executing a formal and legally tenable document. He has enclosed the draft prepared by lawyer as himself could not do so for the reason of not knowing the legal formalities. The request is made to Seshadri Iyengar to consider the draft and suggest amendment if desired by addressee Seshadri Iyengar within a week so that a final document be engrossed on a requisite stamp paper and to get it registered as decided earlier. The amount received by each of them subsequent to 11.05.47 or any of them separately has to be apportioned and adjusted in accordance with the draft.

This letter was received by Seshadri Iyengar. This is replied by Seshadri Iyengar and communicated to

Mr.Subramanya Sastry. The features of the reply to Ex.P.143 are as under: The reply states that Seshadri Iyengar has gone through the draft. He refers to second paragraph in the draft where the mistakes are to be corrected and there shall not be accusation by one against the other to maintain friendly spirit. Mr.Iyengar expresses his anxiety about Mr.Subramanya Sastry not disclosing all the points in the draft and also work out for corrections if any and hope lawyer would agree for the same. A collection amount of Rs.10,000/- is also mentioned which is stated to have been collected in place of Rs.9,000/-. He also mentioned the scheme regarding distribution of assets as under:

1.

Equalization of money drawn by each of the partners before and after 11.5.47. 2. In respect of the liabilities preparation of statement would be better, to avoid all the cost

in Schedule A of the draft in order to reduce the stamp duty.

95.

It is also made clear in the reply to ascertain regarding the requirement of registration or whether it would be enough to have three copies. Seshadri Iyengar concludes the reply by stating that he has to go to Mysore to carryout certain formalities after hearing from Mr.Subramanya Sastry (plaintiff). He also expresses about health problem for the previous two days. It is in this connection draft of dissolution of partnership marked as Ex.P-144 was prepared by Mr.Subramanya Sastry-Plaintiff and sent to defendant No.1 - Seshadri Iyengar. It is after this transaction the litigation or the dispute appeared to have cropped up. Ex.P70 reply notice dated 9.2.54 sent by Seshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar defendant No.1 and 2 respectively to the notice dated 24/25-1- 1954.

96.

The trial Judge has observed that there is no mentionregarding flaws in consent or misrepresentation played by plaintiff in obtaining the signature on Ex.P-1 or the signatures were made by the defendants out of the confidence reposed in Subramanya Sastry -plaintiff. Ex.P-1 states that the partnership was dissolved and assets were appropriated. The memorandum of dissolution of partnership is dated 17.1.48 and learned trial Judge finds that if there was any defect or irregularity they would have floated at the time when the dissolution was effected.

97.

The next appreciation of evidence by the learned trial Judge is also regarding the consequences of non-registration of dissolution of partnership. In this connection he refers the

decision reported in AIR 1966 SC 1300 – Addanki Narayanappa and another Vs Bhaskara Krishnappa.

The relevant portion of the karar reads thus : "As disputes have arisen in our family regarding partition, it is not possible to carry on the business or to make investment in future. Moreover, you yourself have undertaken to discharge some of the debts payable by us in the coastal parts in connection with our private business. Therefore, from this day onwards we have closed the joint business. So, from this day onwards, we have given up (our) share in the machine etc., and in the business, and we have made over the same to you alone completely by way of adjustment. You yourself shall carry on the business without ourselves having anything to do with the profit and loss. Here for, you have given up to us the property forming our Venkatasubbayya's share which you have purchased and delivered possession of the same to us even previously. In case you want to execute and deliver a proper document in respect of the share which we have given up to you, we shall at your own expense, execute and deliver a document registered."

This document on its face shows that the partnership business had come to an end and that the Addanki family had given up their share in the "machine etc., in the business" and had made it over to the Bhaskara family. It also recites the fact that the Addanki family had already received certain property which was purchased by the partnership presumably as that family's share in the partnership assets. The argument advanced by Mr. Alladi

Kuppuswami is that since the partnership assets. included immovable property and the document records relinquishment by the members of the Addanki family of their interest in those assets, this document was compulsorily registrable under s. 17(1)(c) of the Registration Act and that as it was not registered it is inadmissible in evidence to prove the dissolution of the partnership as well as the settlement of accounts.

6.

We may also refer to the decision of a Full Bench in Ajudhia Pershad Ram Pershad v. Sham Sunder & Ors.(3) in which Cornelius J., has discussed most of the decisions we have earlier referred to in addition to several others a id reached the conclusion that while a partnership is in existence no partner can point to any ,part of the assets of the partnership as belonging to him alone. After examining the relevant provisions of the Act, the learned judge observed "These sections require that the debts and liabilities should first be met out of the firm property and there.

(1) I.L.R. 55 Mad. 72. (2) A.I.R. 1939 Mad. 884.

(3) A.I.R. 1947 Lah. 13.

after the assets should be applied in rateable payment to each partner of what is due to him firstly on account of advances as distinguished from capital and, secondly on amount of capital, the residue, if any, being divided rateably among all the partners. It is obvious that the Act contemplates complete liquidation of the assets of the partnership as a preliminary to the settlement of accounts between partners upon

dissolution of the firm and it will, therefore, be correct to say that, for the purposes of the Indian Partnership Act, and irrespective of any mutual agreement between the partners, the share of each partner is, in the words of Lindley : "his proportion of the partnership assets after they have been all realised and converted into money, and all the partnership debts and liabilities have been paid and discharged.

B. The next Judgment is (1995) 3 SCC 205 – Gangadhar Madhavrao Bidwai Vs Hanmantharao Vyankataro Mungale - Head Note - Registration Act, 1908 -Ss,17 and 19 - Unregistered deed of dissolution of partnership - Evidentiary value -Appellant and respondent constituting partnership -Land purchased by respondent alone- Deed indicating that the land was in joint ownership of both the partners - Held, on facts, the property at the time of dissolution of partnership was partnership property and therefore the deed of dissolution was not required to be registered and the recital therein admissible in evidence even in absence of registration -Partnership Act, 1932, S.42.

98.

The learned trial Judge considered the scope of registration of a deed of dissolution of partnership and relied on the decision reported in 1995 (3) SCC 205 wherein the Apex Court held that property at the time of dissolution of firm was

partnership property therefore dissolution did not require registration. Infact said provision of law is applied to the deed of dissolution Ex.P-1. It is in this connection position similar to a Joint Hindu Family is to be considered. Whenever a joint family carries on the business the male members are also considered as the well accepted nomenclature as coparcener. In this connection coparcener possesses and enjoy the joint family properties irrespective of the records and entries regarding the ownership of properties of partnership are held in name of a particular member. It is under this notion no difference is found between a partner and a firm. Individually called a partner collectively a firm. As stated above, the law of partnership is 'extension of law of agency' wherein partners are both agent and principal. It is in this connection partnership is held in common by all the partners and does not fall under Section 5 of the

Transfer of Property Act and learned trial Judge has placed reliance on the said principle. This dissolution deed Ex.P-1 incidentally also came up for discussion in earlier proceedings O.S.186/1956. Seshadri Iyengar in his deposition before the Munsiff in O.S.No.186/56 has gone on record has acknowledged the existence of dissolution of partnership deed. In the present proceedings earlier the deed of dissolution of partnership dated 17.1.48 the learned trial Judge did not allow the document to be admitted in evidence upon objection made by defendant - Seshadri Iyengar. Against said order of rejection Subramanya Sastry- plaintiff went in civil revision in C.R.P.No.3249/1979 before the High Court of Karnataka. The said revision petition was allowed and trial court was directed to allow the document received in evidence subject to objection of defendant. In the said connection in the year 1979 the trial court while recording the evidence

allowed the document to be marked as Ex.P-1. It is in this connection plaintiff was directed to pay the duty and penalty of Rs.137.50 ps. This document is seriously objected by defendant either for treating it as a valid piece of evidence or relying on the content.

99.

In the deposition marked as Ex.P-121 which is the deposition of Seshadri Iyengar in O.S.No.186/56 it is stated that he has admitted the acquisition of seven sites at Bengaluru for MICC- Mysore Irrigation Construction Company. The learned trial Judge has extracted a portion of the deposition. “In October 1946 United Engineering Corporation was formed, with us 3 partners of M.I.C.C.... On behalf of M.I.C.C. I had purchased some sites in Bangalore. There are 7 plots and these are in my possession eversince they have been taken”.

“The 3 houses built by us, we meant for each one of us. It is true that the house occupied by me was exclusively meant for met. The same was true for others. At the time of Ex.D.1, it was understood that the properties i.e., houses-

should go to the persons in whose possession they were”.

“Para 16: I was a partner of M/s.Mysore Irrigation and Construction Company which was a partnership firm. Mr.K.Keshavachar, the 23nd defendant and the plaintiff Mr.D.Subramanya Sastry were the other partners.

Para 17: Mr.Keshavachar purchased 3 sites at Mysore on behalf of the firm. The sites were in Vontikoppal area. At the time of purchase of the sites at Mysore, the intention was that they should belong to the firm. There was then no intention that the person purchasing the sites should be then owner thereof. We built houses on the sites. The houses consisted of main houses and out-houses. The houses were municipal numbers. The main numbers 2707, 2708, 2709. All the houses belong to our firm. The out houses were given sub numbers in the same numbers.”

“It is true that I have deposed in O.S.No.186 of 1956 on 15.09.1960 thus: the 3 houses built by us were meant for each one of us. It is true that the houses occupied by me was exclusively meant for me. The same was true of others”. It is true that I have stated in the same deposition thus: “At the time DI, it was understood that the properties i.e., the houses –should go to the person in whose possession they were. Ex.D.1 in O.S.No.186/56 is marked as Ex.P.1 in this suit subject to arguments being addressed in that behalf”.

“Our firm owns 7 houses in Mysore (3 houses with 3 out houses and a house). These were

constructed in 1941 and these stand in the name of M.E.C. I am paying the assessment and municipal taxes on behalf of our firm and from out of the funds of my firm. These houses are in the joint enjoyment and ownership of we these partners........Out firm has acquired 15 acres of wet land in 1943. These are in the name of our firm. These are in the joint enjoyment of us the partners. The sale deed in our favour is executed by Channaiah..... I am managing this land property. I have been collecting rent and I have been paying the assessment.

“6. The said deed in regard to one of the houses was executed by K.P.Gundappa on 21.02.1943.....We have purchased 2 plots in Mysore from the Trust Board. The Trust Board had executed Ex.P.29 and 30 in my favour on behalf of my firm”.

100.

As a contesting defendant- Keshavachar the defendant No.2 has stated at page 5 of Ex.P.122 as follows: "Our firm owns 7 houses in Mysore (three houses with 3 out houses and a house). These were constructed in 1941 and these stand in the name of M.E.C. I am paying the assessment and municipal taxes on behalf of our firm and from out of the funds of my firm. These houses are in the joint enjoyment and ownership of we these partners...... Out firm has acquired 15 acres of wet land in 1943. These are in the name of our firm. These are

in the joint enjoyment of us the partners. The sale deed in our favour is executed by Channaiah..... I am managing this landed property. I have been collecting rent and I have been paying the assessment.

"6. The said deed in regard to one of the houses was executed by K.P.Gundappa on 21.2.1943.... We have purchased two plots in Mysore from the Trust Board. The Trust Board had executed Ex.P.29 and 30 in my favour on behalf of my firm".

101.

The learned trial Judge has also extracted portion of deposition of Seshadri Iyengar before the Court Commissioner on 1.8.86 as under: “Out of the capital investment and advances made by him and Keshavachar, 3 sites in Ontikoppal, one in Lakshmipuram, Mysore & 3 sites in southpete, Mysore and 8 sites in Wilson Garden were purchased.”

O.S.No.186/56 (Old No.256/53) Sheshadri Iyengar had deposed before the court as per Ex.P.121 `A’ as follows:

“On behalf of M.I.C.C. I had purchased some sites in Bangalore”.

102.

Subsequent to 1948 according to plaintiff the schedule properties at item No.1 to 5 became

separate properties of plaintiff and he is entitled for declaration of title over the same. As a plaintiff in any suit he is seeking declaration of title which is opposed by defendant No.1. As stated above, the initial unity between defendant No.1 and 2 at the time of issuing reply notice or filing written statement did not last long. On the other hand when defendant No.2 and plaintiff represented by legal representatives entered into compromise wherein defendant No.2 conceded the claim of the plaintiff. The existence of the property is not disputed. The outcome of the suit would be binding between the parties or persons claiming under them. Because the acquisition of properties is asserted, but the only difference is, defendant No.1 claims items 4 and 5 of the schedule properties were separate properties and thus the schedule has not been properly described and includes separate properties of defendant No.1. Which voice

was endorsed by defendant No.2 in the beginning however coordination did not last long and through the compromise the legal representatives of defendant No.2 went on record against defendant No.1. Thus, the first phase of difference is regarding the dissolution of partnership and allotment of properties in accordance with Ex.P-1 dated 17.1.48 which are as under: "Premises No.2707 along with outhouse 2707/1 valued at Rs.18,650/-;

Premises 2708 along with outhouse 2708/1 valued at Rs.19,250/- ;

Premises 2709 along with outhouse 2709/1 valued at 19,850/-;

Premises 2709/2 at Oontikoppalu, Mysuru valued at Rs.10,000/- and Rs.5,500/-;

Site No.6 in new Santhepet extension, Mysuru city value Rs.4,000 and 100;

Site No.7, Lakshmipuram Extension, Mysuru city valued at Rs.7,300/- ;

Silkfilature site at Chamarajnagar together with

masonry foundation valued at Rs.12,000/-;

Site Nos.212, 213, 214 at Wilson Garden Extension valued at Rs.3,441/-;

Site No.197 and 242 at Wilson Garden Extension valued at Rs.,1498/-;

Site Nos.215, 216 situate at Wilson Garden Extension valued at Rs.1,554/-;

Site No.8 Santhepet extension, Mysuru city Rs.3,500/-

Wet lands to the extent 15 acres 08 guntas at Cheluve Arasana Koppalu village, Chinnakurali Hobli, Pandavapura, Mandya Valued at Rs.17,000/-."

103.

It is mentioned that all the said properties were acquired in individual names of partners out of the partnership fund. Then allotment of properties to each of the partners is shown as per division dated 11.05.47 which are as under: "Premises No.2707 with 2707/1 situated at Vani Vilas Mohalla, Mysuru;

Site No.8, New Santhepet Extension, Mysuru; Site No.E (7) situated at Laxmipuram Extension, Mysuru;

Silkfilature at Chamarajanagar standing in the name of Seshadri Iyengar and site

Nos.212, 213, 214, Wilson Garden, Bengaluru are assigned to the share of 1st partner namely Seshadri Iyengar;

Premises No.2709 with 2709/1 in site No.52 and 2709/2 in site No.53 block 4A Vanivilas Mohalla Extension, Mysuru. Site nos.197 and 242 situated at Wilson Garden Extension, Bengaluru assigned to second partner namely Keshavachar.

Premises No.2708 with 2708/1 in the first main Road, Vanivilas extension, Mysuru.

Premises in block 3, Vanivilas extension, Mysuru.

Site No.3 in new Santhepet extension, Mysuru, Site No.216 in the Wilson Garden extension was assigned to the third partner Subramanya Sastry."

104.

The wet lands of the aggregate area of 15 acres and 08 guntas comprising survey Nos. 78,81, 131, 148, 159, 160 and 161 near Cheluve Arasana Koppal and Aralu Koppal Jama Bandi, Chinna Kurli Hobli, French Rocks Taluk, Pandavapura, Mandya District were agreed to be enjoyed jointly by all the Partners dividing only the annual income therefrom

100

equally amongst them till such time as they decide jointly to sell or divide them and each of the partners has assumed and obtained exclusive and absolute possession and enjoyment and possession being available for division, needless to state it is 1/3rd.

105.

Section 14 of the Partnership Act is as under: "14. Subject to contract between the partners, the property of the firm includes all property and rights and interests in property originally brought into the stock of the firm, or acquired, by purchase or otherwise, by or for the firm, or for the purposes and in the course of business of the firm, and includes also the goodwill of the business.

Unless the contrary intention appears, property and rights and interests in property acquired with money belonging to the firm are deemed to have been acquired for the firm."

106.

Contrary to the status of a Registered Company, the partner and the Firm are inseparable. As stated above, individually he is 'partner' and

101

collectively 'Firm'. The property of the firm consists of the rights and interests of the properties owned by the Firm, subsequent acquisition by purchase or otherwise in the course of the existence of the Firm. It does not mean that the separate property of the partner ipso facto becomes the property of the firm. The principle is laid down in 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 594 (SC) by the Apex Court in this regard, wherein it is held that property exclusively belonging to a person does not become the property of the partnership firm merely because it is used for the purpose of the business if there is an agreement. Such property shall become property of the partnership firm.

107.

The properties are acquired and even disposed off like any other individual or a Firm. The acid test to determine would be, whether the consideration was moved from the Firm's account or the properties were acquired in the name of the Firm;

102

whether the properties were invested or brought to the Firm as capital. Also those properties which were acquired in this connection, though a partnership is distinguished from a Joint Hindu family, we may also come across the example wherein the partnership also formed by the Joint Hindu Family.

108.

In the present case, it is not division of the Joint Hindu family. Partners and their terms and conditions are in terms of the partnership deed that was admittedly created. When the partnership firm goes into dissolution, the properties of the firm has to be apportioned to satisfy in chronology giving preference to outside liabilities. In other words, the table according to which the creditors, outside liabilities, loan borrowed from the partners other than capital and thereafter the ratiable apportionment of the capital and if excess is available for sharing among

103

the partners in accordance with the ratio agreed upon by them. In this connection, it is necessary to mention that creation and existence and carrying on the business among the parties is an admitted factor and already there is no cash or credit transaction lending or borrowing loan by and from respectively in this behalf.

109.

It is in this connection, partners' liability is regarded as unlimited unlike that of a share holder wherein the share of the partner is insufficient to meet the liability, they have the personal liability to the extent of their shares. When the business relation as partners come to an end between the partners and the firm which happens at the time of retirement or death or vacancy in the office of a firm. However, dissolution of partnership comes to an end when the very business of the Firm and the relationship of the

104

partners among all of them except one come to an end. It is under the said circumstances, the settlement of account would come to picture.

110.

The provisions regarding dissolution of the partnership are mentioned under Section 39, 40, 41 42 and 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932. The said provisions read as under:

"39. Dissolution of a firm.—The dissolution of partnership between all the partners of a firm is called the ‘dissolution of the firm’.

40.

Dissolution by agreement.—A firm may be dissolved with the consent of all the partners or in accordance with a contract between the partners.

41.

Compulsory dissolution.—A firm is dissolved,—

(a) by the adjudication of all the partners or of all the partners but one as insolvent, or

(b) by the happening of any event which makes it unlawful for the business of the firm to be carried on or for the partners to carry it on in partnership:

Provided that, where more than one separate adventure or undertaking is carried on by the firm the illegality of one or more shall not of itself cause the dissolution of the firm in respect of its lawful adventures and undertakings.

105

42.

Dissolution on the happening of certain contingencies.—Subject to contract between the partners a firm is dissolved,—

(a) if constituted for a fixed term, by the expiry of that term;

(b) if constituted to carry out one or more adventures or undertakings, by the completion thereof;

(c) by the death of a partner; and

(d) by the adjudication of a partner as an insolvent.

43.

Dissolution by notice of partnership at will.—

(1) Where the partnership is at will, the firm may be dissolved by any partner giving notice in writing to all the other partners of his intention to dissolve the firm.

(2) The firm is dissolved as from the date mentioned in the notice as the date of dissolution or, if no date is so mentioned, as from the date of the communication of the notice."

111.

Now, the question is regarding the dissolution of partnership. Dissolution of partnership is asserted by Subramanya Shastry and denied in the beginning both by the first defendant-Seshadri Iyengar and the second defendant-Keshavachar.

106

However, through compromise plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry and Keshavachar reached consensus and second defendant-Keshavachar endorses the stands of the plaintiff-Subramanya Shastry. However, the said compromise as stated above is seriously objected and disputed by defendant No.1-Seshadri Iyengar among several grounds including that the compromise was effected by the legal representatives of both the plaintiff and defendant No.2 that too long after the death of the plaintiff and defendant No.2. Further, the legal representatives had no knowledge of what they were doing and how compromise was taken up or could be possible. There is always a boundary line between the property of the partners and that of the firm. As stated earlier, there is no bar for a partner to hold a separate property. In other words, Apples cannot be mixed with Oranges. However, the property acquired whether in the name of a partner or

107

in the name of the firm becomes a property of a partnership, if the consideration is from the partnership firm or the consensus at the time of purchase of the said property among the partners was to treat as Firm's property and at the same time, the partners have treated the said property as belonging to firm and also where income from such property is shared among all the partners. It is in this connection, the treatment of a partnership is considered at par with a joint family wherein the property earned from the properties of the partners and those properties which are acquired from the firm are treated as firm's property.

112.

Applying this principle, the question would be, whether sharing of the property of the firm at the time of dissolution of the partnership is a transfer? In this connection Section 5 of the Transfer of

108

Property Act, 1882 is worth mentioning which reads as under: "5. In the following sections "transfer of property" means an act by which a living person conveys property, in present or in future, to one or more other living persons, or to himself, (or to himself) and one or more other living persons; and "to transfer property" is to perform such act.

[In this section "living persons" includes a company or association or body of individuals, whether incorporated or not, but nothing herein contained shall affect any law for the time being in force relating to transfer of property to or by companies, associations or bodies of individuals.]"

113.

The term conveying of property under the definition means the property conveyed for the first time of the transferor. Insofar as the partnership property is concerned, each partner will be having an undivided interest in the entire partnership property and the share which he gets at the time of dissolution is in consideration of his common interest in all the partnership properties and it does not get it for the

109

first time or shall be considered as previously he owned the property. It is in the common interest which has taken place in Joint Hindu family.

114.

Further contention between the parties is question of registration. It is contended by the learned counsel for defendant No.1 even Ex.P1 fails in law as it is not duly registered.

115.

It was contended that whenever an immovable property belonging to partnership firm is allotted to a partner by virtue of dissolution of the firm, it attracts the stamp duty under the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 also should be duly registered in accordance with the Registration Act.

116.

In this connection, the appellant-defendant No.1 relied upon the following citations: 1. AIR 1964 SC 358 -State of Uttar Pradesh Vs Singhara Singh and others

110

(1993) 1 SC 589 - S.V.Chandra Pandian and others Vs S.V.Sivalinga Nadar and others wherein, the relevant para reads as under:

[Registration Act, 1908-S.17(1)-On dissolution of partnership, distribution of residue among partners after settlement of accounts in terms of S.48 of Partnership Act is to be treated as distribution of moveable property and does not result in partition, transfer or extinguishment of interest so as to attract S.17-Arbitration award directing dissolution of partnership firm and providing for distribution of residue or surplus properties of the dissolved firm among partners after settlement of accounts not required to be registered under S.17(1)-In the circumstances, challenge to the award under S.30 of the arbitration Act on ground of non-registration not sustainable-Partnership Act, 1932, S.48- Arbitration Act, 1940, S.30-Income Tax Act, 1961, Ss.2(47) and 45(4).

Partnership Act, 1932-S.48(b)(iv)-Entire property whether brought in by the partners on constitution of the partnership or acquired in course of business of the partnership would constitute property of the firm-During property- But after dissolution and settlement of accounts, partners entitled to proportionate share in residue of the property-Such residue is treated as moveable property being money representing the value of the property- Therefore, when the residue is distributed by allocating any property to a partner proportionately to his share, no partition or transfer takes place not is there any extinguishment of interest of other partners in

111

the allocated property-Income Tax Act, 1961, Ss.45(4) and 2(47).

Incidentally, the principle underlined in the said decision that arbitration award directing dissolution of partnership firm and providing distribution of the residue or surplus properties of the dissolved firm among the partners after settlement of accounts not required to be registered under Section 17(1). It is to be mentioned here that the dissolution deed must have been registered. Because in the light of Section 39 of the Partnership Act, the allotment of the properties to the shares of the partners would arise only when all the liabilities are cleared. 3. (1998)3 SCC 410 - Central Bureau of Investigation Vs V.C.Shukla and others, wherein the relevant para reads as under:

A. Evidence Act, 1872-S.34-Ingredients of - Two parts of the section explained-"Entries in books of account regularly kept in course of business"-Expressions "books of accounts", "course of business" and "regularly kept"- Meaning and import of -Ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning should be ascribed-

112

Words and phases-Interpretation of Statutes- Basic Rules-Plain meaning-Ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning should be given when neither the context nor any principle of construction calls for a restrictive meaning

B. Evidence Act, 1872-S.34-Jain Hawala diaries-Entries in Jain note books-Held on facts, admissible under S.34-But file containing loose sheets of papers not 'book' and hence entries therein not admissible under S.34 - Jain Hawala Diaries case

C. Evidence Act, 1872-S.34-Books of account "regularly kept"-Whether the books regularly kept, held, depends on the nature of the occupation-System of accounting and contemporaneity in making entries may both differ - Making of entries may both differ- Making of entries at or about the time of the transaction not the test in any case - Further held, by which system the books are regularly kept affects their probative value and not their admissibility as a relevant fact under S.34.

D. Evidence Act, 1872-S.34-Rationale of - Entries in books of account-Probative value- "such statements shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability"- Entries even if relevant are only corroborative evidence-Independent evidence as to trustworthiness of those entries necessary to fasten the liability-Held on facts, entries made in the Jain hawala diaries though admissible under S.34 but truthfulness thereof not proved by any independent evidence

113

E. Words and phases-"Book"-Meaning of - Spiral note book/pad included but not loose sheets.

4.

AIR 1977 Karnataka 173 -Syed Rasool and others Vs Mohammed Moulana, wherein, the relevant para reads as under:

A. Specific Relief Act (1963), S.31-Prayer for cancellation when unnecessary - redemption suit-Mortgagor alleging sale deed executed by him in favour of mortgagee to be invalid-Suit maintainable without prayer for cancelling the deed.

B. Evidence Act (1872), S.92-Oral evidence Admissibility of - Plaintiff alleging certain sale-deed to be sham-Oral evidence is admissible to prove intention.

5.

AIR 1969 SC 1118 - Rani Bai Vs Yadunandan Ram and another:

Civil P.C.(1980), O.23, Rr.1 and 3-C, a trespasser, dispossessing A in possession of land in lieu of maintenance-Suit for declaration of right and possession by A joining B as co- plaintiff-B compromising with C applying for withdrawal of suit-Court cannot dismiss the suit of A on the basis of the application. Misc.Appeal No.22 of 1962, D/-17-9-1962 (MP), Reversed.

6.

Civil.A.No.2631 of 2003 decided on 02.04.2003 -

114

117.

Learned counsel for respondent-plaintiff also relied upon the following decisions: 1. (1995)3 SCC 205 -Gangadhar Madhav Rao Bidwai dead by LRs Vs Hanumantharao Vyakantarao Mungale

(1993) 1 SCC 589 cited supra

118.

The list of properties as seen from Ex.P1 which were shown as the subject matter for dissolution and there is no denial of the existence of the said properties. However, in respect of the suit schedule properties are concerned, defendant No.1 raises objection to the claim of the plaintiff or exclusive right over item Nos.1 to 5 of properties.

119.

As already stated that two original suits, re-numbered considering the latest O.S.No.284/1980 filed by Subramanya Shastry against Seshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar decreed on 31.07.2002. The next suit O.S.No.601/1980 filed by K.N.Sheshadri Iyengar

115

S/o Narayanan and Keshavachar S/o Ramaswamy Iyengar came to be decreed in part, wherein the division of item No.6 agricultural land was ordered to be effected equally in the form of share to the respective branches of the partners namely Subramanya Shastry, Seshadri Iyengar and Keshavachar and rendition of accounts is not considered by virtue of the documents between the plaintiff and defendant No.2. Of course, there is no dispute among the parties in respect of item No.6 of the schedule property wherein 1/3rd share to each of them is agreed upon.

120.

Insofar as registration or paying stamp duty of dissolution of partnership is concerned, as already observed, it is not a regular transfer and allotment of properties during dissolution of partnership is not transfer for effecting the dissolution

116

and allotment of immovable properties on a stamp paper requiring registration. Deficit stamp duty is already made good as stated above.

121.

Thus the contention of defendant No.1 Seshadri Iyengar that the dissolution had not taken place of the partnership it can never be accepted by virtue of his own admission and signature on Ex.D-1 letter written to Subramanya Sastry and reply sent by Subramanya Sastry and statement of account plus preliminary arrangement, his evidence regarding preparation of draft and preparation of final document. His admission in evidence by sworn testimony in O.S.No.186/56 filed by one Thirumalachar strongly and reconcilably go against the pleadings and contentions of Seshadri Iyengar as a defendant. Similarly withholding of properties that fell to his share under Ex.P-1 in the suit filed by him in

117

O.S.No.601/80 tells his conduct that he did not approach the court with clean hands either as defendant in O.S.No.284/80 or as a plaintiff in O.S.No.601/80. His defence as a defendant fails. His pleadings as a plaintiff in O.S.No.601/80 also fails as the same is devoid of merits.

122.

Another development in the case is that whether in Joint family or firm total number of properties are to be presented for partition or dissolution as the case may be. Insofar as O.S.No.280/80 is concerned Subramanya Sastry filed a suit for declaration and injunction and it is not for dissolution of partnership. As a matter of fact, he has claimed that dissolution of partnership is already over and he sought declaration of properties allotted to him in the form of Item Nos.4 and 5. But the major difference in O.S.No.284/80 and O.S.No.601/80 is

118

that in the later suit Seshadri Iyengar the plaintiff therein had sought for dissolution of partnership firm and rendition of accounts. Incidentally, no schedule properties are mentioned in the suit. It is to be remembered that in the light of the earlier suit and pleadings of the parties it is regarding the ownership of immovable properties, assertions and denials had taken place. But the contention of Seshadri Iyengar as defendant No.1 in the connected case is plaintiff in O.S.No.601/80 is partnership is not dissolved and has to be effected afresh. In such a case no property under the schedule is mentioned thus it is a substantial lapse. Further on perusal of dissolution deed Ex.P-1 there are certain several properties which have fallen to the share of plaintiff Subramanya Sastry equally certain other properties to Seshadri Iyengar and certain other properties to defendant No.2- Keshavachar. Incidentally, Seshadri Iyengar in the

119

capacity of plaintiff never whispered about the properties fell to his share or ownership which is considered as a withholding of the fact which is established. Neither he says other properties are left out nor volunteers or those properties are in the hotchpot. In other words, he wants to avoid breaking of shares allotted to him under dissolution of partnership and lay hand upon the share of Subramanya Sastry which is neither proper nor appreciable. Further, the suit is not for reopening the earlier division.

123.

Compromise between legal representatives of plaintiff and defendant No.2-Keshavachar is accepted by trial court and on perusal of the entire pleadings, circumstances and materials, I do not find any reason to reject the compromise which is based on facts and in accordance with law as no vested right

120

of Seshadri Iyengar the first defendant therein is taken up.

124.

Insofar as O.S.No.601/80 filed by Seshadri Iyengar is concerned, trial court decreed the share of 1/6th landed property which is item No.6 in O.S.No.280/80 not mentioned in the schedule of O.S.No.601/80. In this connection item No.6 landed property at Pandavapura to the extent of 15 acres 8 guntas of wet land agreed is to be jointly belonged to partners namely Subramanya Sastry, Seshadri Iyengar, Kesahvachar and their 1/3rd share is kept in tact by the trial court which is open for partition as per Section 54 of CPC.

125.

On complete marshalling of the records available including pleadings, evidence, documents and submissions made by learned counsel appearing

121

for the parties, I am of the sincere and firm view that there are no lapses, irregularities or illegalities in Judgment and decree passed by the trial court in both the suits and they do not call for interference. Appeals are devoid of merits and are liable to be dismissed.

Accordingly, appeals filed by Seshadri Iyengar are hereby dismissed. No orders as to cost.

Sd/- JUDGE

AKV/HD/tsn*/SBN

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →