COMNR.,OF INCOME TAX vs. TRISHNA REAL ESTATE

PDF · subscribers
ITA/173/2011HC OrissaODHC01038834201110 February 2022Bench: DR. JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR (CJ),MR. JUSTICE R.K.PATTANAIK3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the impugned order of the ITAT was based entirely on factual details and an analysis of the evidence and material produced before the AO and the ITAT. The Court found no illegality or infirmity in the ITAT's approach, considering its view to be plausible. Consequently, the Court was not satisfied that the ITAT's order called for interference. The substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and against the Department. The ITAT's deletion of the addition of Rs. 2,41,08,962/- was upheld.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Trishna Real Estate Pvt. Ltd., filed its income tax return for Assessment Year 2007-08, disclosing an income of Rs. 23,47,494/-. The Assessing Officer (AO) selected the return for scrutiny. The AO noted that the assessee's closing work in progress was Rs. 4,27,88,559/- and closing advances from customers were Rs. 11,78,41,329/-, an increase from Rs. 6,20,00,335/- in the previous year. The AO added Rs. 2,41,08,962/- to the assessee's income, stating the increase in advances was not properly explained with customer names and addresses. The CIT(A) dismissed the assessee's appeal. The assessee appealed to the ITAT. The ITAT, after reviewing the assessment folder, found that details were available to the AO. The ITAT noted that while previous AOs correlated details, the present AO did not, leading to the addition. The ITAT also found that the assessee provided details of cancelled bookings totalling Rs. 2.41 crores and, following the project completion method, deemed the addition unsustainable.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT was justified in deleting the additions made by the AO on account of unexplained investment when the assessee could not produce the relevant details in support of the claims? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's Contention: The ITAT was justified in deleting the additions because the relevant details were available to the Assessing Officer in the assessment folder, and previous AOs had been able to correlate these details. The ITAT also found that details of cancelled bookings, which offset the advances, were provided. Revenue's Contention: The ITAT was not justified in deleting the additions because the assessee could not produce the relevant details in support of the claims for the increase in advances.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Page 1 of 3 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

ITA No.173 of 2011

Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneswar

Appellant

Mr.T.K. Satpathy. Standing Counsel -versus- Trishna Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. Bhubaneswar

Respondent

CORAM: THE CHIEF JUSTICE

JUSTICE R.K.PATTANAIK

Order No.

ORDER 10.02.2022

3.

1. The present appeal arises from an order dated 25th August 2011 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack (ITAT) in ITA No.091/CTK/2011 for the Assessment Year (AY) 2007-08.

2.

While admitting this appeal on 3rd January, 2013, the following substantial question of law is framed for consideration.

(i) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned ITAT was justified in deleting the additions made by the A.O. on account of unexplained investment when the asseessee could not produce the relevant details in support of the claims.”

3.

The facts in brief are that the Respondent Assessee is a Real Estate Developer. He filed a return of income for the AY in question disclosing an income of Rs.23,47,494/-. His return

// 2 //

Page 2 of 3

was selected for scrutiny. The Assessing Officer (AO) in the assessment order dated 31st December, 2009 under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (IT Act) noted that the Assessee had disclosed details of closing project work in progress in the sum of Rs.4,27,88,559/-. The closing balance of advances received from the customers as as on 31st March, 2007 was Rs.11,78,41,329/- whereas the corresponding figure for 31st March, 2006 was Rs.6,20,00,335/-. According to the AO, the increase in advances was not properly explained by the Assessee by providing the names and addresses of the customers. Thus, the AO decided to add a sum of Rs.2,41,08,962/- to the taxable income of the Assessee.

4.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-II [CIT (A)] by order dated 10th November, 2010 dismissed the Assessee’s appeal. The Assessee thereafter went in appeal before the ITAT. The ITAT, during the course of hearing, called for the assessment folder and found that “details were available to the Assessing Officer as has been perused by us in assessment folder.” According to ITAT, while the previous AOs had been able to correlate the details available in the file with the figures submitted by the Assessee, the present AO was unable to do so and this has resulted in the erroneous addition of Rs.2.41 crores. Additionally, the ITAT found that the Assessee had submitted the details of the opening balance of the customers who had booked flats, shops in the Assessee’s premises but had later cancelled the same and this totalled Rs.2.41 crores. Since the Assessee was following the project completion method of accounting, the ITAT concluded that the above

// 3 //

Page 3 of 3

addition in the sum of Rs.2,41,08,962/- was unsustainable in law.

5.

Having heard Mr. Satpathy, learned Standing Counsel for the Department and Mr. P.R. Mohanty, learned counsel for the Respondent Assessee, the Court is of the view that the impugned order of the ITAT turns entirely on factual details and is based on an analysis of the evidence and material produced before the AO and the ITAT. The Court is unable to discern any illegality or infirmity of the approach of the ITAT. The view taken by the ITAT appears to be a plausible one. Consequently, the Court is not satisfied that the impugned order calls for interference.

6.

The question framed is accordingly answered in favour of the Appellant assessee and against the Department. The appeal is dismissed.

(Dr. S. Muralidhar) Chief Justice

(R.K. Pattanaik) Judge

KC Bisoi

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →