COMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. NALCO
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court ordered the disposal of all the listed matters without prejudice to the rights of the parties subsisting as on date. This decision was made considering the peculiar circumstances, the lack of effort by counsel to list these matters, and the fact that keeping them pending would serve no useful purpose. Parties were granted liberty to seek revival of these cases if any cause still survived. They could reconstruct the record or file fresh petitions to protect any surviving interests. Miscellaneous applications were also closed, and no costs were awarded. The court acknowledged that some cases were transferred to other High Courts or had been disposed of earlier.
What were the facts?
The High Court of Andhra Pradesh was presented with a note from its Registry concerning approximately 1330 cases erroneously reflected as pending in its Live Server Database. A verification exercise revealed that 735 cases were disposed of before 2019, while details for the remaining 595 cases were not available on the erstwhile common High Court server. The Registry sought directions to mark these cases as disposed of. The court noted that out of the 595 cases, 142 were Division Bench matters and 453 were Single Bench matters. Specific instances were highlighted where cases were transferred, disposed of, or were being considered by another High Court.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the cases listed as pending in the High Court Live Server Database, for which details are not available on the erstwhile common High Court server, should be marked as disposed of. (Question of procedure) 2. Whether the remaining 595 cases should be listed before the Court for passing necessary orders. (Question of procedure) Assessee's Contentions: Not recorded. Revenue's Contentions: The Registry's note, supported by specific submissions from counsel regarding transferred, disposed of, or pending cases in other jurisdictions, indicated that many of these cases were no longer actively pending before this High Court.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
APHC010262851995
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
Appeal Suit No. 406 of 1995 along with Bench Sr.Nos:- 61 to 202 [3552] Appeal Suit Nos. 2401 of 1996; 147, 429 of 1998; 2264, 2493 of 1999; 2235, 2331, 2432, 2487, 2503, 2553, 2611, 3679, 3680, 3681 of 2000; 205, 206, 209, 210, 211, 212, 213, 268, 271, 356, 402, 1013, 1055, 1056, 1057, 1058, 1059, 1769, 2951, 2952 of 2001; 298, 944, 1359, 1489, 1797, 16526, 60459, 76507, 89297, 94165, 104439 of 2002; 161, 896, 1016, 1274, 2653, 2701, 4079 of 2003; 237, 330, 761, 3812, 4510 of 2004; 483 of 2007; Civil Revision Petition Nos.972, 1500 of 2007; 4108 of 2008; Contempt Case No.1264 of 1999; Public Interest Litigation Nos.140, 322 of 2012; 222 of 2014; Land Acquisition Appeal Suit Nos.961, 6251, 7787 of 2005; 220, 651 of 2006; 258 of 2007; Special Appeal Nos.43437, 43441 of 2003; Transfer Appeal No.469 of 1999; Writ Petition Nos. 5062, 8850, 9133 of 1997; 27778 of 1998; 8939, 11417, 12646 of 1999; 17376, 22099 of 2000; 1057, 3822, 13830, 17480, 27105 of 2001; 8395, 17455, 20069, 21194, 21948 of 2002; 143, 3703, 12129 of 2003; 309, 1127, 1231, 1318, 2582, 2682, 14329 of 2004; 86809 of 2007; 26018 of 2008; 21820 of 2010; 8478, 31390 of 2011; 4554, 16915 of 2012; 9951, 27420, 30058, 38267 of 2013; 9462, 12355, 14091, 41075, 41337 of 2015; 4374, 10350, 25486, 26969, 44647 of 2016; 1645, 12636, 27965, 28025, 28055, 31786, 31788, 39115, 41717, 45281 of 2017; 4928, 18726 of 2018; Income Tax Tribunal Appeal Nos.347 of 2011; 245, 295, 448 of 2012;
Appeal Suit No. 406 of 1995 Secretary, A.P.Housing Board & another
...Appellant Vs. G. Chennamma ...Respondent ********** Advocate for Appellant: Mrs. S. Pranathi, Ld. Special Government Pleader appearing vice The Advocate General Advocate for Respondent: -
2 HCJ & CGRJ AS_406_1995 & batch
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN DATE : 30th December, 2025. P C :
The Registry has placed a note before us wherein it is stated that after completion of the affixture of QR codes to all available cases in the Posting, Filing, and English Records Sections, it was found that approximately 1330 cases are still reflected as pending in the High Court Live Server Database. 2. A list of such cases has been prepared, which is now listed before us. 3. From a reading of the note, it can be seen that the Registry conducted a comprehensive verification exercise by cross-checking the relevant data with records available on the erstwhile common High Court server and upon verification, it is stated, it was found that 735 cases had since been disposed of prior to the year 2019, while the details of the remaining 595 cases are not available on the said server, and that these cases continue to be erroneously reflected as pending in the present High Court database, although they may have been disposed of by the erstwhile common High Court prior to 2019. 4. It is in those circumstances that the Registry in the note sought appropriate directions to take steps to mark the cases of all categories, listed in Annexure-I to the note, as disposed of in the Live Server Database and further that the Registrar (Judicial) be permitted to list the remaining 595 cases before the Court for purpose of passing necessary orders.
3 HCJ & CGRJ AS_406_1995 & batch
It can be seen that out of the 595 cases, 142 cases are Division Bench matters, whereas the remaining 453 are pertaining to the Single Bench. 6. Counsel for the petitioner in Writ Petition No.4374 of 2016 submits that the matter was last listed before the High Court in the year 2018, when the Rejoinder affidavit had been filed by the petitioner and that it was not listed thereafter. She has no further instructions in the matter. 7. Insofar as Writ Petition No.10350 of 2016 is concerned, counsel for the petitioner would submit that pursuant to the orders of the Supreme Court passed in Transfer Petition (s) (Civil) Nos.820-829 of 2016, dated 18.08.2017, Writ Petition bearing No.10350 of 2016 was transferred to the Delhi High Court and is stated to have been currently pending before the said Court. 8. The statement made by learned counsel for the petitioner appearing in W.P.No.10350 of 2016, therefore, supports the note of the Registry. 9. In regard to Writ Petition No.2582 of 2004, learned Government Pleader for Services II, makes a statement that the Writ Petition had since been disposed of by virtue of order dated 13.02.2004. 10. Counsel appearing for the petitioner in Writ Petition No. 25486 of 2016 states that the matter is currently being considered by the Telangana High Court and that it is not rendered infructuous. Be that as it may, in any case, Writ Petition No.25486 of 2016, for that reason, needs to be deleted from the list of pending cases before this Court.
4 HCJ & CGRJ AS_406_1995 & batch
Be that as it may, considering the peculiar circumstances of these cases, and considering the fact that there has been no effort made by any of the counsel to have these matters listed, there would be no useful purpose served by keeping these matters in a state of pendency. We, accordingly, order the disposal of all these matters, without prejudice to the rights of the parties subsisting as on date, by granting liberty to them to seek revival of these cases. In case any cause still survives, it would be open to the parties to either reconstruct the record or file fresh petitions, with a view to protecting any interest that may still survive in that regard.
Miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall also stand closed. No costs.
DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ.
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J. SSN
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Shashibhusan Moharana vs. The Superintendent Of CGST And Central Excise, DhenkanalOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Paramount Tea Marketing PVT. LTD. vs. Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 4 Nov 2026
- Md. Junaid vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Sanjeevini Health Care vs. M/S.Vijayalakshmi And AssociatesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Trilok Chandra vs. State Tax OfficerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026