COMMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. DR.BINOD BIHARI NAIK
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the Tribunal erred in upholding the disallowance of 1/6th of telephone and car expenses. The Court reasoned that while a company is a separate legal person, it cannot have personal expenses in the same way an individual does. Expenses incurred by a company, even if reimbursed to employees or directors, are considered part of the 'Cost to Company' (CTC) and are necessary for the company's business, especially before the introduction of fringe benefit tax. The AO's disallowance based on a lack of log books or detailed telephone bills for a company's car or telephone usage was considered cursory. The Court emphasized that if a company authorizes car use for employees, it's a facility, and such expenses are allowable in toto, provided they are approved by the competent authority and have a nexus with the company's business. The Tribunal's reliance on the Standard Chartered Bank judgment was deemed incorrect in this context. The appeal was allowed, and the Tribunal's impugned order was set aside.
What were the facts?
The appellant, M/s Raunaq International Ltd., is challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal) dated 07.10.2005. The Assessing Officer (AO) had made additions for previous Assessment Years (AY 1995-96 to AY 1999-2000) by disallowing 1/6th of telephone and car expenses, treating them as personal. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) had set aside these disallowances, and this finding was affirmed by the Tribunal in prior years. The appellant contends the Tribunal should have maintained consistency. The Tribunal, in its impugned order, relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Standard Chartered Bank, which the appellant argues is in a different context. The revenue argues the Tribunal's decision is based on a finding of fact and the appeal should be dismissed.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Tribunal erred in upholding the disallowance of 1/6th of telephone and car expenses, despite prior consistent rulings in favour of the assessee for multiple Assessment Years (AY 1995-96 to AY 1999-2000)? (Mixed question of law and fact, concerning Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's arguments: - The Tribunal should have maintained consistency with its previous orders for AY 1998-99 (dated 25.06.2004) and AY 1996-97 (dated 24.01.2005), as there were no factual differences. - The reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Standard Chartered Bank v. Directorate of Enforcement was misplaced as it was in a different context. - The AO was not justified in disallowing 1/6th of the expenses as they were incurred for the company's business. Revenue's arguments: - The Tribunal's decision was based on a finding of fact. - The AO had provided cogent reasoning for the disallowance, treating 1/6th of the expenses as personal due to lack of log books for car expenses and incomplete details for telephone expenses. - The appeal should be dismissed as it involves a finding of fact.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ITA 113/2006 Page 1 of 5
$~16 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Date of decision: 14th May, 2026 + ITA 113/2006
M/S RAUNAQ INTERNATIONAL LTD. .....Appellant Through: Dr. Shashwat Bajpai & Mr. Mayank Chaturvedi, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX I N .....Respondent Through: Mr. Vipul Agrawal SSC with Ms. Sakshi Shairwal, Mr. Akshat Singh, JSCs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR J U D G M E N T DINESH MEHTA, J. (ORAL)
Mr. Shashwat Bajpai, learned counsel for the appellant, at the outset submitted that there is a typographical/inadvertent error in the question framed vide order dated 23.01.2006, regarding club charges, inasmuch as the same had already been allowed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench ‘A’, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’) vide its order dated 07.10.2005. 2. Adverting to the other part of the question, namely disallowance of 1/6th of telephone expenses and car expenses, he submitted that the Assessing Officer had made such addition for previous Assessment Years (AY 1995-96 to AY 1999-2000), whereas the appeals filed for all those years, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) had set aside such Digitally Signed By:NAVEEN KUMAR Signing Date:19.05.2026 19:26:56 Signature Not Verified
ITA 113/2006 Page 2 of 5
disallowances and such finding had been affirmed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. 3. He submitted that the Tribunal was required to maintain consistency, more particularly, when there was no factual difference. In this regard, he invited Court's attention towards order dated 25.06.2004 passed by the Tribunal for AY 1998-99 and order dated 24.01.2005 for the AY 1996-97. 4. Learned counsel for the appellant took the Court through the impugned order of the Tribunal, more particularly, paragraph nos. 4 & 5 and submitted that the Tribunal has relied upon judgment of Hon’ble the Supreme Court rendered in the case of Standard Chartered Bank and Ors. v. Directorate of Enforcement and Ors. reported in [2005] 275 ITR 81 (SC), and argued that the same is in entirely different context, wherein Hon’ble the Supreme Court has observed that the company is a separate individual person. 5. Learned counsel argued that in any case, the Assessing Officer was not justified in disallowing 1/6th of the total expenses, which the company had incurred on telephone and towards car expenses. 6. Mr. Vipul Agarwal, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Department, on the other hand submitted that the Tribunal's decision is based on finding of fact and notwithstanding, a question has been framed and the same need not be answered and the appeal should be dismissed as the same involves a finding of fact. 7. He argued that the Assessing Officer in his assessment order dated 15.06.2001 has given cogent finding and reasoning and he has only Digitally Signed By:NAVEEN KUMAR Signing Date:19.05.2026 19:26:56 Signature Not Verified
ITA 113/2006 Page 3 of 5
disallowed 1/6th of the contentious expenses, treating them to be of a personal nature, as the assessee had neither maintained log book in respect of car expenses nor had it given complete details of the telephone expenses. 8. Heard learned counsel for the parties. 9. It is not in dispute that the addition of this nature made in the assessment orders of AY 1995-96 to AY 1999-2000, had been set aside by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and orders of the first appellate authorities had been affirmed by the Tribunal. 10. Such being the position, according to us, the Tribunal ought to have maintained consistency, unless there was a striking change in the facts. On perusal of the impugned order dated 07.10.2005 passed by the Tribunal, we find that the only new thing which had come to the notice or knowledge of the Tribunal was, the judgement of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in the case of Standard Chartered Bank (supra). 11. According to us, nothing can be deduced, so far as the moot question of disallowance of the expenses in question are concerned. 12. It is true that a company is a separate legal person, but simply because a company can be said or considered to be a person, it does not necessarily mean that its expenses are required to be disallowed for being personal in nature. 13. An Assessing Officer can be justified in disallowing a part of the expenditure treating them to be of personal nature in the case of an individual assessee, because when an individual uses his car or telephone, there is found to be an element of personal use but in case of a company, Digitally Signed By:NAVEEN KUMAR Signing Date:19.05.2026 19:26:56 Signature Not Verified
ITA 113/2006 Page 4 of 5
despite being a person, there cannot be any personal expenses of a company. 14. Even if expenses are borne by the company are reimbursed to the employees or even Directors, it will be treated to be a part of the complete package given to those employees, as a need of company’s business. Therefore, such expenses duly approved by the Competent Authority are required to be allowed in toto. Because, until the concept of fringe benefits was introduced, every penny spent by a company, or amount spent by the employees (subject ofcourse to the limits prescribed in the Companies Act or other laws) was allowable. 15. The Tribunal has, therefore, erred, in understanding the true import of the concept of a company being a person. Disallowance can be made only in the event when there is a finding that the amount spent was of personal nature, having no nexus with company’s business. 16. So far as the findings recorded by the Assessing Officer are concerned, the same is cursory. In case, a company’s car is provided to the Directors or the employees, the company is not required to maintain a log book nor is the Assessing Officer supposed to go into the log book and dissect, which journey was of employee’s personal nature and which was for the affairs of the company. 17. If the company authorizes the employees to use the car for personal use, then it is a facility provided to such employee and all such expenses are treated as CTC (Cost to Company). 18. Similar is the position, when it comes to telephone expenses. We are, therefore, of the considered opinion that the Tribunal has erred in upholding Digitally Signed By:NAVEEN KUMAR Signing Date:19.05.2026 19:26:56 Signature Not Verified
ITA 113/2006 Page 5 of 5
the disallowance of 1/6th of the telephone expenses and car expenses. 19. The appeal is, therefore, allowed. Impugned order passed by the Tribunal dated 07.10.2005 is set aside. The question is answered in favour of the appellant-assessee. 20. Consequence to follow.
(DINESH MEHTA) JUDGE
(VINOD KUMAR) JUDGE MAY 14, 2026/nk Digitally Signed By:NAVEEN KUMAR Signing Date:19.05.2026 19:26:56 Signature Not Verified
More judgments on Section 37
- Lowes India Private Limited, Bangalore vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1245/BANG/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax… vs Pureways Infra Pvt. Ltd. (Earlier Known As…ITA 114/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax… vs Pureways Infra Pvt. Ltd. (Earlier Known As…ITA 113/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Pureways Infra Private Limited, New Delhi vs DCIT Central Circle-30, New DelhiITA 7361/DEL/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Pureways Infra Private Limited, New Delhi vs DCIT Central Circle-30, New DelhiITA 7338/DEL/2025[2019-20]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
Latest GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Puran Singh Fartyal vs. Khushal SinghUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Rama Gupta Construction vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Abhay Kumar Sharma vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Sunita Pandey vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026
- Ashutosh Gupta vs. The Commissioner Central Goods And Services TaxUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026