PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. SATYA NARAYAN GUPTA
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) correctly dismissed the revenue's appeal as not maintainable in view of CBDT Circular No. 17/2019. The Court noted that the Department was represented before the ITAT, and no ground was raised requiring the ITAT to decide the matter on merits in light of Clause 10(c) of Circular No. 3/2018. Crucially, the departmental representative before the ITAT made a concession that the tax effect in the appeal was less than the prescribed limits, which was recorded by the ITAT. The Court found that since this plea was not raised before the ITAT, the revenue could not be allowed to raise it in the present appeal. The Court concluded that the ITAT correctly acted upon the mandate of Circular No. 17/2019, and therefore, no substantial question of law arose for determination. The appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Sh. Satya Narayan Gupta, filed an income tax return for AY 2009-2010 declaring an income of Rs. 27,76,650. The assessment was completed at Rs. 27,96,650. Subsequently, the case was re-opened under Section 147 on March 14, 2016, based on an audit objection, alleging escapement of income amounting to Rs. 17,36,000 as long-term capital gain. A fresh assessment under Section 143(3)/147 was completed on December 15, 2016, adding Rs. 17,36,000. The CIT(A), by order dated August 16, 2019, partly allowed the appeal, directing the adoption of sale consideration at Rs. 47,82,000 instead of Rs. 63,76,000, granting relief of Rs. 15,94,000. The revenue appealed this order before the ITAT, which dismissed the revenue's appeal. The present appeal is filed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-1, Chandigarh, against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) erred in dismissing the revenue's appeal solely on the basis of CBDT Circular No. 17/2019, which enhanced the monetary limit for filing appeals to Rs. 50,00,000, without deciding the matter on merits? Assessee's Contention: The ITAT correctly dismissed the revenue's appeal as the tax effect was less than the enhanced monetary limit prescribed by CBDT Circular No. 17/2019. The assessee implicitly relies on the ITAT's decision. The ITAT's order was based on the concession made by the departmental representative before it that the tax effect was less than the prescribed limits. Revenue's Contention: The ITAT wrongly dismissed the appeal. The benefit of Circular No. 17/2019 could not be extended because Clause 10(c) of Circular No. 3/2018 of CBDT dated 11.7.2018 exempted cases where revenue audit objections had been accepted by the Department. Since an audit objection was raised in this case, the circular did not apply, and the ITAT should have decided the matter on merits.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
REPORTABLE/NON-REPORTABLE IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA ON THE 20th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2021 BEFORE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE TARLOK SINGH CHAUHAN & HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATYEN VAIDYA.
ITA NO. 13 of 2021
Between:- PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-1, CHANDIGARH.
…APPELLANT
(BY SH. VINAY KUTHIALA, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VANDANA KUTHIALA, ADVOCATE.)
AND SH. SATYA NARAYAN GUPTA, R/O CHAND BUILDING, HOSPITAL ROAD, DISTT. AND TEHSIL, SOLAN, H.P.
….RESPONDENT.
(SH. VISHAL MOHAN, ADVOCATE)
__________________________________________________________________
This appeal coming on for admission before notice this day, Hon’ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, delivered the following:
J U D G M E N T 2. By way of instant appeal, the appellant seeks to assail order dated 11.6.2020, passed by the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal (for short ‘ITAT’), Chandigarh in ITA No. 1455/Chd./2019. 3. Respondent herein, (for short ‘assessee’), declared Rs.27,76,650/- as income in the ITR filed for the A.Y. 2009-2010. Assessment u/s 143(3) of the Income Tax Act (for short ‘Act’) was completed on 29.9.2011 and income of the assessee was assessed at Rs.27,96,650/-. 4. Subsequently, objection was raised by the audit party and the case was re-opened u/s 147 of the Act on 14.3.2016 with the prior approval of Pr. CIT, Shimla, on the ground that income chargeable to tax amounting to Rs.17,36,000/- and any other income which subsequently comes to notice had escaped assessment for the A.Y. 2009-2010. 5. Notice under Section 148 of the Act was issued to assessee whereby he was required to explain as to why the long term capital gain of Rs.17,36,000/- be not added to his income already assessed u/s 143 (3) of the Act. 6. Fresh assessment under Section 143(3)/147 of the Act was completed on 15.12.2016 and the income was assessed at Rs.45,32,650/- by making addition of Rs.17,36,000/- on account of long term capital gain.
The assessee assailed the above said assessment order by filing an appeal before the CIT(A). Vide order dated 16.8.2019, CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal of the assessee on the issue of long term capital gain and directed the Assessing Officer to restrict the sale consideration to be adopted at Rs.47,82,000/- in place of Rs.63,76,000/-. Thus, the relief of Rs.15,94,000/- was given to the assessee. 8. The revenue challenged the order dated 16.8.2019 of the CIT(A) before the ITAT, Chandigarh. The appeal of the revenue was dismissed vide impugned order assailed in the instant appeal. 9. The grievance of the appellant herein, is that the ITAT, Chandigarh had wrongly proceeded to dismiss the appeal of the revenue solely on the basis of Circular No. 17/2019 issued by the CBDT whereby the monetary limit for filing the appeal by the Department before the ITAT was enhanced to Rs.50,00,000/-. As per appellant, the benefit of the above noted circular could not be made available to the assessee in the instant case, though, the liability of tax was much less than the prescribed limit of Rs.50,00,000/- for the reason that para 10 (c) of Circular No. 3/2018 of CBDT dated 11.7.2018 exempted those cases where revenue audit objection had been accepted by the Department. The
appellant contends that in the present case also the audit had raised objection and, as such, the CBDT Circular No. 17/2019 did not apply to the facts of the case and the ITAT had erred in not deciding the matter on merits. 10. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also gone through the records of the case. 11. The controversy can be summed up in narrow encompass. The issue for adjudication is whether the appellant can press into service the exemption Clause 10 (c) of Circular No. 3/2018 dated 11.7.2018 issued by the CBDT. 12. Perusal of impugned order passed by the ITAT reveals that it has taken into consideration the Circular No.17/2019 dated 8.8.2019 issued by the CBDT, which reads as under:
“Circular No. 17 of 2019
Date – 8th August, 2019
Further Enhancement of Monetary limits for filing of appeals by the Department before Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, High Courts and SLPs/appeals before Supreme Court – Amendment to Circular 3 of 2018 – Measures for reducing litigation.
Circular No. 3/2018 dated 11th July 2018 has been replaced by circular No. 17/2019 dated 8th August 2019 to enhance Monetary limits for filing of appeals by the Department before Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, High Courts and SLPs/appeals before Supreme Court for reducing litigation.
Appeals/SLPs in Income-tax matters Monetary Limit (Rs.) (Previous Limit) Monetary Limit (Rs.) (Revised Limit) Before Appellate Tribunal 20,00,000 50,00,000 Before High Court 50,00,000 1,00,00,000
Before Supreme Court 1,00,00,000 2,00,00,000
The Assessing Officer shall calculate the tax effect separately for every assessment year in respect of the disputed issues in the case of every assessee. If, in the case of an assessee, the disputed issues arise in more than one assessment year, appeal can be filed in respect of such assessment year or years in which the tax effect in respect of the disputed issues exceeds the monetary limit. No appeal shall be filed in respect of an assessment year or years in which the tax effect is less than the monetary limit.
Further, even in the case of composite order of any High court or appellate authority which involves more than one assessment year and common issues in more than one assessment year, no appeal shall be filed in respect of an assessment year or years in which the tax effect is less than the monetary limit.
In case where a composite order/judgment involves more than one assessee, each assessee shall be dealt with separately.”
It is not in dispute that the above noted Circular No. 17/2019 is extension of Circular No. 3/2018 issued by the CBDT whereby certain modifications have been made in the original circular especially in respect of enhancement of revision of monetary limits for appeals/SLPs in income tax matters. 14. It is evident from the impugned order that the Department was duly represented by its Additional CIT at the time of hearing of appeal before the ITAT, Chandigarh. No ground had been raised on behalf of the Department before the ITAT, Chandigarh requiring the said Tribunal to decide the matter on merits in view of Clause 10 (c) of the Circular No. 3/2018. To the contrary, the concession made by the departmental representative
before the ITAT to the effect that the tax effect in the appeal was less than the prescribed limits, stood recorded. 15. Once the Department had not raised the plea of applicability of Clause 10 (c) of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, it cannot be allowed to raise such plea in the present appeal. 16. The ITAT has correctly held the appeal before it to be not maintainable in view of clear mandate of Circular No. 17/2019. Same principle applies to the filing of present appeal. Hence, no substantial question of law arises for determination by this Court. 17. No other infirmity has been pointed out in the impugned order. 18. In the light of above discussion, we find no merit in the appeal and the same is dismissed, so also the pending application(s), if any.
(Tarlok Singh Chauhan)
Judge
20th September, 2021
(Satyen Vaidya)
(GR)
Judge
More judgments on Section 147
- S V D Promoters, Agra vs Income Tax Officer Ward 1(1)(2), AgraITA 325/AGR/2026[2015-16]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2015-16
- Suman Lata, Raipur vs Income Tax Officer-1(1), RaipurITA 800/RPR/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Naynaben Rasiklal Cholera, Rajkot vs ITO, Ward-1(2)(1), RajkotITA 1124/RJT/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2016-17
- Pakman International, Delhi vs ITO Ward 34(5), DelhiITA 7952/DEL/2026[2014-2015]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2014-2015
- Crystal Business System Limited (Earlier… vs DCIT, Circle 22(2), DelhiITA 6979/DEL/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Sri Vijoy Trading Company vs. The Commissioner Of Customs (Preventive)Gauhati · 9 Nov 2026
- Vijay Trading Company vs. The Commissioner Of Customs (Preventive), And 3 OrsGauhati · 9 Nov 2026
- K Pushkara Rao vs. The State Of ApAndhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026
- M/S. Jayasundar Engg Works vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Andhra Pradesh · 9 Nov 2026
- Nkg Infrastructure LTD. vs. Government Of Nct Of Delhi & Ors.Delhi · 6 Nov 2026