CHINTAN GUVANTBHAI SHAH,SURAT vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 2(3)(6), SURAT

PDF · subscribers
ITA 744/SRT/2025Status: DisposedITAT Rajkot05 November 2026AY 2019-2013 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the issue raised in Ground No. 1 regarding the JAO issuing the notice and the FAO passing the assessment order is settled by the Gujarat High Court in Snehdham Trust (supra), which held that the notice under section 148 is not required to be issued in a faceless manner. Therefore, this ground of appeal is dismissed. Regarding Ground No. 2 & 3, the Tribunal found that while the assessee provided bank statements for the donation, mere banking transactions do not conclusively prove genuineness, especially given the revenue's reliance on search findings regarding RSP's alleged accommodation entries. However, the alleged modus operandi of the party does not automatically mean all donations were bogus. The Tribunal noted that the assessment order incorrectly stated no reply was filed by the assessee to the notice under section 142(1), whereas a reply dated 18.11.2024 was on record, which also demanded cross-examination. The Tribunal also observed that the non-compliance of the notice under section 133(6) by RSP cannot be held against the assessee without examining the assessee's transactions. The Tribunal acknowledged the decision in Pavan Anil Bakeri (supra) but stated that the present case must be examined on individual facts. Consequently, the issue of deduction under section 80GGC is restored to the AO for fresh verification and adjudication. The AO is directed to consider the assessee's submissions, examine bank transactions, and provide an opportunity for cross-examination. The grounds are allowed for statistical purposes.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Chintan Gunvantbhai Shah, filed an appeal before the ITAT, Surat Bench, against the order of the CIT(A) dated 13.05.2025, which upheld the assessment order dated 28.11.2024 passed by the Faceless Assessing Officer (FAO) under section 147 r.w.s. 144B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year 2019-20. The assessee, a salaried employee, had claimed a deduction of Rs. 2,50,000/- under section 80GGC for donations to the Rastriya Samajwadi Party (RSP), a registered unrecognized political party. Reassessment proceedings were initiated based on information from a search on 23 RUPPs, including RSP, indicating a scam involving bogus deductions. The FAO denied the deduction, which was upheld by the CIT(A). The assessee is aggrieved by these orders.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reassessment proceedings initiated under section 147 and the consequential order passed under section 147 r.w.s. 144B are bad in law, void-ab-initio, and liable to be quashed, given that the notice under section 148 was issued by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO) and the assessment order was completed by the Faceless Assessing Officer (FAO), contrary to the provisions of section 151A. 2. Whether the disallowance of deduction claimed under section 80GGC for Rs. 2,50,000/- is bad in law and void-ab-initio due to a violation of the principle of natural justice, as the AO relied on third-party statements without providing copies or allowing cross-examination. Assessee's Contentions: - Ground 1: The assessment is void because the notice under section 148 was issued by the JAO, but the assessment order was passed by the FAO, which is impermissible under section 151A. The assessee relied on decisions mentioned in their written submissions. - Ground 2 & 3: The disallowance is bad in law as copies of third-party statements were not provided, and cross-examination was denied, violating natural justice. The assessee requested copies of statements from RSP functionaries and cross-examination. Revenue's Contentions: - Ground 1: The issue is settled by the Gujarat High Court in Snehdham Trust Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax (2025) 181 taxmann.com 98 (Gujarat), which is against the assessee. - Ground 2 & 3: The AO relied on search material and issued a notice under section 133(6) to RSP, which was not complied with. A salaried employee cannot make such a high donation, making it unbelievable. Reliance was placed on ITAT, Ahmedabad in Pavan Anil Bakeri Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (2022) 142 taxmann.com 574 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) where a similar disallowance for donations to RSP was upheld.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 144B,Section 148,Section 151A,Section 143(2),Section 142(1),Section 80GGC,Section 133(6)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, SURAT BENCH, SURAT

Before: MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE & SHRI B.M. BIYANI

For Appellant: Shri Amar Shah, CA
For Respondent: Shri Ashish Kumar, Sr. DR
Hearing: 31.08.2026Pronounced: 05.11.2026

आदेश / O R D E R Per B.M. Biyani, A.M.: Feeling aggrieved by the order of first appeal dated 13.05.2025 passed by learned Commissioner of Income-Tax (Appeals)-NFAC, Delhi [“Ld. CIT(A)”], which in turn arises out of the assessment-order dated 28.11.2024 passed by learned Assessment Unit of Income-tax Department [“Ld. Faceless Assessing Officer/FAO”] u/s 147 r.w.s. 144B of Income-tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”] for Assessment-Year [“AY”] 2019-20, the assessee has filed this appeal.

2.

The background facts leading to present appeal are such that the assessee-individual, a salaried employee, submitted return of income of AY 2019-20 under consideration declaring a total income of Rs. 9,46,110/- after claiming deduction of Rs. 2,50,000/- u/s 80GGC on account of donation given to the Rastriya Samajwadi Party (RSP), a registered un- recognised political party (RUPP). The return so filed by assessee was assessed. Subsequently, the learned ITO, Ward-2(3)(6), Surat [“Ld. Jurisdictional Assessing Officer/JAO], taking into account information collected by tax authorities in a search u/s 132 conducted upon 23 RUPPs (including RSP) revealing that a scam was going on in the form of donations to political parties for claiming bogus deduction u/s 80GGC, issued notice dated 15.04.2023 u/s 148 [after completing the procedure of section 148A(d)] to re-open assessee’s u/s 147. In response, the assessee re-filed return repeating the original income of Rs. 9,46,110/-. Thereafter, the Ld. FAO issued statutory notices u/s 143(2)/142(1) to assessee and conducted faceless assessment proceedings. During proceedings, certain queries regarding the donation given by assessee to RSP and deduction claimed u/s 80GGC, were raised. In response, the assessee made submissions claiming that he had given genuine donations and claimed statutory deduction as allowable. However, the Ld. FAO rejected assessee’s submission and passed assessment-order dated 28.11.2024 u/s 147 r.w.s. 144B of the Act denying the deduction to assessee. Aggrieved, the assessee carried matter in first- appeal before Ld. CIT(A) and again made submissions. The Ld. CIT(A), however, rejected assessee’s submissions and dismissed asessee’s appeal with the result that no relief was granted to assessee. Now, the assessee has come before us in present appeal.

3.

The grounds raised by assessee are as under:

“1. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, Ld. AO erred in initiating the reassessment proceedings u/s.147 and consequential order passed u/s.147 rws 144 are bad in law as the notice u/s 148 was issued by Income Tax Officer, who is a Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO) and the assessment order is completed by Faceless Assessing Officer (FAO), which is not permitted as per provisions of section 151A and therefore entire proceeding are void-ab-initio and therefore consequential order are bad in law. 2. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, Ld. AO erred in making a disallowance of deduction claimed u/s 80GGC for a sum of Rs. 2,50,000/- on the basis of certain documents/statements recorded from third parties and in spite of repeated requests neither the copy of statements recorded is provided to the appellant nor any opportunity of cross examination was allowed to the appellant. This being in violation of principle of natural justice, the order passed is void ab initio and needs to be annulled. 3. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, Ld. AO erred in making a disallowance of deduction claimed u/s 80GGC for a sum of Rs. 2,50,000/- on the basis of certain documents/statements recorded from third parties and in spite of repeated requests neither the copy of statements recorded is provided to the appellant nor any opportunity of cross examination was allowed to the appellant. This being in violation of principle of natural justice, the order passed is void ab initio and needs to be annulled.” Ground No. 1: 4. In this ground, the assessee claims that the notice u/s 148 was issued by Ld. JAO whereas the final assessment-order u/s 147 r.w.s. 144B was passed by Ld. FAO, which is not permitted as per provisions of the Act and therefore the assessment-order is bad in law, liable to be quashed.

5.

Apropos to this ground, Ld. AR at first carried us to Pages 30, 34 and 38 of Paper-Book and demonstrated that the issuance of notice dated 29.03.2023 u/s 148A(b); passing of order dated 15.04.2023 u/s 148A(b); and the issuance of notice 15.04.2023 u/s 148; all these actions were done by Ld. JAO. However, the subsequent notice dated 11.11.2024 u/s 142(1) was issued by Ld. FAO; the assessee filed reply dated 18.11.2024 to the Ld. FAO; and ultimately the impugned assessment-order dated 28.11.2024 was also passed by Ld. FAO. According to Ld. AR/assessee, this is not permitted in law. In support, the Ld. AR has quoted certain decisions as mentioned on Pages 7 to 10 of his Written-Submission filed in Paper-Book.

6.

Per contra, Ld. DR for revenue relied upon the decision of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in Snehdham Trust Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax (2025) 181 taxmann.com 98 (Gujarat) and submitted that the issue raised by assessee stands settled by Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court against assessee, therefore the assessee’s ground is meritless and must be rejected.

7.

We have considered rival submissions of both sides. We re-produce below the relevant paras of Snehdham Trust (supra):

“28. So far as the issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act is concerned, after the information is collected through Risk Management Strategy formulated by the Board as referred to under Section 148 of the Act for issuance of notice, the case is allocated through automated allocation to the Assessing Officer. Therefore, the question arises as to who the Assessing Officer should be, whether the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer or the Assessing Officer of an assessment unit as per Section 144B of the Act. If we peruse Section 144B of the Act, there is no Assessing Officer as such, but it also only refers to the “assessment unit” which comprises of various Assessing Officers. If we peruse clause (i) of Sub-section (1) of Section 144B of the Act, it stipulates that the National Faceless Assessment Centre shall assign the case selected for the purpose of faceless assessment under Section 144B of the Act to a specific “assessment unit” through automated allocation system prior to selection of the case to be allocated to the specific assessment unit through automated allocation system and Section 144B of the Act has no role to play for the purpose of faceless assessment. 29. Therefore, if we read paragraph No.(3) of the Scheme, 2022, which refers to the issuance of the notice through automated allocation in accordance with the Risk Management Strategy formulated by the Board only. The contention on behalf of the petitioners that the issuance of notice also should be in a faceless manner is also required to be considered from the subsequent prefix after the words “and in faceless manner” which is further qualified by the words “to the extent provided in Section 144B of the Act with reference to making assessment or reassessment of total income or loss of assessee”. If we further analyse the provisions of Section 144B of the Act, it provides that National Faceless Assessment Centre shall intimate the assessee that assessment in his case shall be completed in accordance with the procedure laid down in Section 144B of the Act. Both the clauses (i) and (ii) of section 144B of the Act which have come into operation with effect from 01.04.2022 only refer to assessment proceedings and thereafter, from clause (iii) onwards, the procedeeings prescribed for assessment starts by referring to the issuance of notice under Sections 142(1) and 143(2) of the Act. Therefore, the procedure prescribed under Section 144B of the Act only refers to the faceless assessment and it nowhere provides for the notice to be issued under Section 148 of the Act in a faceless manner. Therefore, the words “and in faceless manner” as appears in the Scheme, 2022 is further qualified “to the extent provided in Section 144B of the Act with reference to making assessment or reassessment of total income or loss of the assessee”. A submission is also made that to the extent in Section 144B of the Act with reference to making assessment or reassessment would also include that the procedure which is prescribed for assessment or reassessment should also be applicable for issuance of the notice under Section 148 of the Act. Taking such contentions to its logical conclusion, it appears that if the procedure prescribed under Section 144B of the Act for assessment is to be applied also for the notice to be issued under Section 148 of the Act, then it would also lead that the provisions of Section 148A of the Act which provide for inquiry by the Assessing Officer and passing of order by the Assessing Officer to come to a prima-facie conclusion that whether it is a fit case to reopen is not available in the Scheme, 2022. If we read the Scheme literally as canvassed before us by learned advocates for both the sides, as it is unambiguous and plain in language, no further interpretation is required to be made by reading the provisions of Section 148A of Act in the Scheme, 2022. If the Scheme is also applied to the procedure prescribed under Section 148A of the Act, the same shall be altered by adding the procedure of discarding which is not intended by the legislature. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the decision of the Bombay High Court in case of Kairos Properties (P.) Ltd. (Supra) wherein, the Scheme, 2022 is also extended to the procedure prescribed in Section 148A of the Act, would amount to alter the Scheme, 2022 itself. 30. The Hon’ble Bombay High Court while considering the provisions of Section 148A of the Act has held that the scope of scheme as defined in paragraph No.3 by excluding the applicability of Section 148A of Act from the scope of the scheme would lead to an absolute absurdity and would amount to alter the Scheme. In such circumstances, we are with due respect not in agreement with the Bombay High Court to insert the provisions of Section 148A of the Act to be read in the scope of the scheme. Therefore, the logical conclusion which comes that if Section 148A of the Act is not part of the Scheme, 2022, then issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act by the Faceless Assessing Officer would be an empty formality because issuance of notice under Section 148 of Act is consequence of the order which is passed under Section 148A(d) of the Act. As held by the this Court in case of Talati and Talati LLP (Supra), the notice issued under Section 148 of the Act by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer in search cases is held to be a valid notice and would also justify our view that the notice under Section 148 of the Act has to be issued by the Assessing Officer who has passed the order under Section 148A(d) of the Act. If the notice is issued by the Faceless Assessing Officer under Section 148 of the Act on the basis of the order which has been passed by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer under Section 148A(d) of the Act, the same would result into absurdity. 31. Therefore, the logical conclusion which can be deduced from reading of the provisions of the Act together with the intention of the legislature and the Scheme, 2022, we are of the opinion that so far as issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act is concerned, the contention raised on behalf of the Revenue based upon the Office Memorandum of the Central Board of Direct Taxes dated 20th February, 2023 which is even considered by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court would be in line of the legislative intent so as to operate the two aspects separately, one by issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act by automated allocation and other by conducting assessment or reassessment proceedings under Section 147 of the Act in a faceless manner to the extent as provided under Section 144B of the Act. 32. In view of the above opinion, we are not analysing the judgments rendered by the various High Courts as the line of reasoning adopted by us is totally different than what is adopted by the various High Courts by interpreting the scope, intent and impact of Section 144B of the Act which has been come into statute book with effect from 01.04.2022. 33. In view of the foregoing reasons, so far as the issue, with regard to the challenge to the assumption of jurisdiction to issue the notice under Section 148 of the Act by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer, fails and the notices issued by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer under Section 148 of the Act after 01.04.2022 are held to be valid and legal.”

8.

Thus, the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court, after examining the provisions of sections 147, 148, 148A, 151A and 144B of the Act read with the “E-Assessment of Income Escaping Assessment Scheme, 2022”, held that the issuance of notice u/s 148 and conduct of re-assessment proceedings u/s 147 are two distinct aspects. It is further held that the JAO is competent to issue notice u/s 148 [after passing the order u/s 148A(d)] whereas the subsequent re-assessment proceedings are required to be conducted in a “faceless manner” in accordance with section 144B of the Act. Admittedly, in present case, the notice u/s 148 was issued by the Ld. JAO whereas the subsequent re-assessment proceedings were conducted by the Ld. FAO in a “faceless manner”, which has culminated into passing of the impugned assessment-order. Such a course of action is in conformity with the legal position laid down by the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court. Respectfully following the binding decision of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court, the jurisdictional objection raised by the assessee is not acceptable. Accordingly, the Ground No. 1 is dismissed.

Ground No. 2 & 3:

9.

In these grounds, the assessee challenges the merits of the deduction u/s 80GGC.

10.

Apropos to these grounds, the Ld. AR submitted as under:

(i) That, the assessee has given a genuine donation of Rs. 2,50,000/- through banking channel. The copy of bank statement reflecting the debit entry of donation given was filed to Ld. AO and also available at Page 270-271 of Paper-Book. The bank statement shows debit entry of Rs. 1,25,000/- on 06.12.2018 (+) debit entry of Rs. 1,25,000/- on 15.01.2019.

(ii) That, the bank statement of assessee clearly shows that there are credit entries only of salary income earned by assessee and the salary income has been separately offered for taxation. The bank a/c does not have any credit entry of any amount received back from RSP or any cash deposit having been made.

(iii) That, during assessment proceedings, the Ld. AO has provided copy of Appraisal Report to assessee but the assessee’s name is nowhere mentioned in the said report. Copy of Appraisal Report is filed at Page 62-200 of Paper-Book.

(iv) That, during assessment proceedings, the assessee made a specific request to Ld. AO to provide the statements of Ms. Sandhya Singh/ Mr. Bishwajeet Singh and Mr. Suryanath Chaturvedi, the functionaries of RSP whose statements have been relied by authorities for drawing conclusions against assessee, and to allow cross- examination of those persons. The assessee’s request letters dated 02.07.2024 and 31.10.2024 are available at Pages 50-61 of Paper- Book and the same are also re-produced by Ld. AO on Pages 5-7 and 17-22 of assessment-order. However, neither full statements have been provided nor cross-examination has been granted.

(v) That, the Ld. FAO has mentioned a wrong fact on Page No. 3 of assessment-order that no reply was filed by assessee in response to notice dated 11.11.2024 u/s 142(1). The correct fact is that the assessee filed reply dated 18.11.2024. Copies of e-filing acknowledgement and assessee’s reply-letter are available at Pages 204 to 206 of Paper-Book. In this reply-letter also, the assessee demanded cross-examination of Ms. Sandhya Singh/Mr. Bishwajeet Singh and Mr. Suryanath Chaturvedi.

(vi) That, the Ld. AO has mentioned in Point No. (1) of Para 4.5 of assessment-order that a notice dated 01.10.2024 u/s 133(6) was issued to the RSP but no information was furnished by RSP. Ld. AR submitted that it is not a responsibility of assessee to ensure compliance from RSP. The assessee does not have any control over RSP.

11.

Per contra, Ld. DR for revenue made following submissions:

(i) That, the Ld. AO has not only relied upon the search material but also issued notice u/s 133(6) to RSP. However, the notice so issued remained uncompiled with by RSP.

(ii) That, a salaried employee cannot give donations as high as Rs. 2,50,000/- to a political party. There is no benefit to assessee by making such a high donation. Hence, it is absolutely unbelievable that the assessee made donation.

(iii) Reliance is placed upon the decision of ITAT, Ahmedabad in Pavan Anil Bakeri Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (2022) 142 taxmann.com 574 (Ahmedabad – Trib.). Ld. DR submitted that in this decision, the ITAT has upheld the disallowance of deduction claimed by assessee qua the donation given to very same political party “RSP”.

12.

We have considered the rival submissions of both sides and perused the orders of the lower authorities as well as the material available on record to which our attention has been drawn. The issue before us is whether the assessee is entitled to deduction of Rs. 2,50,000/- u/s 80GGC in respect of donations claimed to have been made to Rastriya Samajwadi Party (RSP).

13.

We find that the assessee has furnished bank statements evidencing two payments of Rs. 1,25,000/- each, aggregating to Rs. 2,50,000/- claimed to have been made to the RSP. However, mere payment through banking channel does not, by itself, conclusively establish the genuineness of the donation or the entitlement to deduction u/s 80GGC, particularly when the Revenue relies upon search findings concerning the alleged accommodation- entry activities of the said political party. At the same time, the alleged modus operandi of the party, even if established, cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that every donation made to it was an accommodation entry. The assessee’s individual transactions and the material having a bearing thereon are required to be examined before drawing an adverse inference against the assessee. The contention of Ld. DR that a salaried person would not make a donation of this magnitude is a mere presumption, which cannot substitute evidence. Similarly, non-compliance of the notice u/s 133(6) by RSP cannot, by itself, be held against the assessee without examining the assessee’s own transactions. We also find that the assessment-order records that no reply was filed by the assessee to the notice dated 11.11.2024 u/s 142(1) whereas the assessee’s reply dated 18.11.2024 is available on record (Pages 204-206 of Paper-Book). The assessee has further pointed out that the Appraisal Report does not name the assessee and that its bank account shows no credits other than salary. Therefore, verification by Ld. AO is warranted.

14.

We have taken note of the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench in Pavan Anil Bakeri (supra), relied upon by Ld. DR, wherein the disallowance of deduction claimed for donations to the very same political party was upheld. The allowability of the claim in the present case has to be examined on the assessee’s individual facts and that decision cannot be applied mechanically without such examination.

15.

In view of the above, the issue is restored to the file of Ld. AO for fresh verification and adjudication of the claim u/s 80GGC in accordance with law. The Ld. AO shall consider the assessee’s entire submission including the aforesaid reply dated 18.11.2024 and the material in the Paper-Book judiciously, and shall examine the assessee’s bank transactions, including whether the donated amounts were received back by the assessee, directly or indirectly, in any manner. The Ld. AO shall also supply the material, if any, proposed to be relied upon against the assessee. Needless to say, the assessee shall be given adequate opportunity of being heard and the Ld. AO shall decide the matter on the basis of material on record and as per law. Accordingly, these grounds are allowed for statistical purposes.

16.

In result, this appeal is partly allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in open court on 05/11/2026

Sd/- Sd/- (SUCHITRA KAMBLE) (B.M. BIYANI) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Surat दिन ांक /Dated : 05/11/2026 Kishore/Sr. PS Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) (5) Departmental Representative (6) Guard File By order HEMA KISHORE Digitally signed by HEMA KISHORE JAKKA JAKKA Date: 2026.11.06 12:35:55 +05'30' UE COPYAssistant Registrar/Sr. PS Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Surat Bench, Surat

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →